Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU over boyfriends birthday?

213 replies

didntgetagift · 13/09/2023 21:40

My boyfriend and I are together a year next month so this year was our first valentines and birthdays.

We returned from holiday early last week and his birthday was last Sunday. Prior to the holiday, he told me to save my money and wait until we were home and settled before buying any presents. Now I know I didn’t mishear him because he said it more than once.

He said that he expects me to spend a minimum of £200 on him because that was his budget and specifically requested an outdoor pop-up tent and JBL speaker equating to the budget.

Based on boyfriends advice, this would mean anything I order wouldn’t arrive on time for the Sunday.

I literally started a new job where I am paid monthly and after the holiday and paying other bills, I have £30 to do me until payday and my boyfriend is completely aware of this. Sunday came and he was incredibly disappointed there were no gifts (I did bring him to the beach and paid for dinner).

I would never expect him to take care of me financially but despite knowing how strapped I am until payday, he hasn’t offered to pay for anything and instead keeps making jokes about how poor I am. He even tried to give me £5 as a joke so I couldn’t say he ‘wasn’t a good boyfriend who didn’t get me anything’…

Here’s my issue. My birthday was in June and without sounding materialistic I was incredibly disappointed with my presents and know my boyfriend completely cheaped out yet set a minimum budget for his presents.

He bought me a pair of Crocs (in the wrong size), Yankee Candles (Christmas scents), and a reed diffuser. On top of this, we went for a meal tasting (8 courses) that was £80 per person (in total £160) and my boyfriend is including the total £160 toward the money he spent on me. Now, when I take anyone out for dinner, I only factor in their portion towards total cost and completely ignore my own because that’s money I spent on myself and not them. Isn’t this normal?

Before anyone presumes I went googling the prices… My boyfriend left the delivery slips in the bags (presents weren’t wrapped and they were handed to me in packaging they arrived in) and a lot of the items were heavily discounted compared to their normal retail price.

I know it’s not what a person spends but the thought that counts, but when I tally what my boyfriend spent it was roughly £130!

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Davros · 27/09/2023 14:30

24 and this is your first adult relationship, you sound sweet but naive and vulnerable. You've been homed in on by a 30 year old, it's not just about age but also your lack of experience that has attracted him if you ask me. Sending friends £5 vouchers also sounds sweet and naive but a bit weird.

BlaBlaBlaHa · 27/09/2023 13:33

Just say you can't afford to spend that amount. End of. If he kids off, then dump him

chaosmaker · 21/09/2023 13:45

Is the money stuff generational?

Dreamstate · 15/09/2023 11:57

So young and your first relationship so you have no idea what a good healthy relationship should be like. I'd be leaving him and dating more people quite frankly. Some might be worse but some will be miles better.

I just don't understand at your age why you insist on staying in something that isn't great for you but its your prerogative.

Mari9999 · 15/09/2023 11:17

@didntgetagift
So many people budget for various aspects of their lives, why should gift giving not be an aspect around which you budget?

I think that your relationship has not reached a stage where co-mingling of funds or even the sharing of information about financial resources is necessarily appropriate or indicated.

If you are going to be spending Xmas together, you might focus more on how you are going to spend the time together and each decide separately on gift giving for each other. within your individual budgets and resources.

Pixiedust1234 · 15/09/2023 10:57

He understood and said he wasn’t being serious about the minimum budget and genuinely felt awful about it. He basically said that I know him “well enough” to know what to take with a pinch of salt. He said he knows his presents will arrive when they do and not to worry.

So he's still expecting his presents then. Nothing about save your money so you have a buffer, or that he shouldn't have asked for expensive gifts? And did you notice that nice little twist he did to make this all your fault? I bet you didn't.

I repeat. He's not a good one.

billy1966 · 15/09/2023 10:56

He's shown himself to be mean, tight, and manipulative.

He has said you should know when he's joking, but also that ye are only getting to know each other?

Which is it?

Major backtracking because you have spoken directly to just how cheap and mean he is.

Mean goes to the core of a persons character and influences every thought and action.

Mean people are always trying to get one over, be ahead, come out on top of you.

THAT is who he is.

Fair enough if your relationship bar is low and you feel you want to accept that, but be clear that is who he has shown himself to be, and you are now fully aware of this fact.

Women with self esteem would dump him as this characteristic gives them instant ICK and they know they deserve better.

But good luck.

ImustLearn2Cook · 15/09/2023 10:47

Ok, he has successfully backtracked. You have decided to give him the benefit of the doubt. That is entirely your decision to make. People can tell you to LTB, but it is entirely up to you to make that decision.

Just keep in mind to maintain self respect and healthy boundaries. Recognise red flags and try to make the right decision for you. I wish you luck and good will for your future.

IndysMamaRex · 15/09/2023 10:00

There are red flags all over your post OP. Girl you can/deserve better! :/ get rid.

and it’s not about the presents etc it’s about his attitude & self-centred childish crap. I don’t like the mocking you over finances while putting pressure on you to live up to his budget. And by the sounds of it he wouldn’t do the same for your either financially or emotionally. He’s sounds like a scrounger

FictionalCharacter · 15/09/2023 10:00

Please re-think this idea you have that gift giving is your "love language" and that you're making people happy. I promise you that sending £5 to friends is an odd thing to do and that you're not "giving them joy" as you think. They probably accept graciously but wish you wouldn't do it.

didntgetagift · 15/09/2023 08:41

I’d prefer a nice night or spa break away than a gift I won’t appreciate, and I know I’d only love that quality time together more than anything gift. I’m happy that we did agree on it.

I’m aware based on this post our relationship does sound transactional, and that’s the last thing I want for this or any relationship I have. As a result of that, that’s why I suggested no Christmas presents but time away together or doing something instead.

OP posts:
VioletPickles · 15/09/2023 08:37

All sounds very transactional. Where’s the joy?!

readsalotgirl63 · 15/09/2023 08:37

It really, really doesn't matter if he is happy with this - it only matters if YOU are happy with this

I still can't believe that he would specify a budget even as a joke/ in jest and that would make me very wary if you were my daughter.

didntgetagift · 15/09/2023 08:13

To clarify, I gave the £5 back but I did keep the £20. Nothing is or has been forgotten! I just needed time to process and take everyone’s responses into account. It’s the first time I’ve ever been told by anyone to essentially LTB. In terms of not discussing with family or friends, from reading other MN’s posts, I was always under the impression that you “shouldn’t air your dirty laundry”.

So I thought long and hard, and decided to speak directly with him about it. I told him due to my current financial situation, I’m not in a position to buy both gifts requested and he will have to forego one. I also brought up the minimum budget and told him about how much financial pressure that put on me, but also how greedy and selfish it came across. He understood and said he wasn’t being serious about the minimum budget and genuinely felt awful about it. He basically said that I know him “well enough” to know what to take with a pinch of salt. He said he knows his presents will arrive when they do and not to worry.

And I went a step further and clarified we would not be exchanging Christmas presents this year. When he asked why, I did bring up my birthday presents and how I personally felt he cheaped out and that the meal voucher should not have been included as part of my overall present because it was an experience shared together. He tried to reason his gifts and explain how there was thought behind them, but apologized for “cheaping” out and getting things wrong i.e. shoe size. He said we were still only getting to know each other and that stage and he wasn’t overly familiar with what I liked.

**In replacement of the Christmas gifts, I did suggest we put money together and go away for either a night or spa break instead. He was happy with this.

OP posts:
SoRainbowRhythms · 14/09/2023 21:34

hellohelp · 14/09/2023 19:52

Theres a change of tune in your posts since he sent you £25 and a nice text. It's like you've forgotten he has treated you badly and made you feel shit enough to post

My thoughts exactly. A manipulative 25 notes and all is forgiven!

Sennelier1 · 14/09/2023 21:24

@didntgetagift so......you will only see him again if and when you have some money to buy him the gifts he's expecting? Darling girl, will you please say this out loud? Again? Once more? Okay, let me spell this for you : you will never ever be happy with him. So run. Run fast.

Catastrophejane · 14/09/2023 20:04

I’d LTB purely for the Yankee candles

Girliegurl · 14/09/2023 19:57

RUN.....run for the hills!
Seriously, why are you standing for this entitled bullsh*t?
At 30 he should know better and sounds like he's trying to pull the wool over your eyes and taking advantage of your naivety good nature!

hellohelp · 14/09/2023 19:52

Theres a change of tune in your posts since he sent you £25 and a nice text. It's like you've forgotten he has treated you badly and made you feel shit enough to post

Hesma · 14/09/2023 18:49

You sound as bad as each other 🤷‍♀️

Mookie81 · 14/09/2023 18:47

didntgetagift · 13/09/2023 22:22

I have considered financing the items on Very and paying back immediately when paid so there’d be no interest applied but it comes to over £200 for the speaker and pop-up tent. Even if I did this, they wouldn’t come for another week or two.

I already told him I probably won’t meet him this week as I have no money and he said that we could have a weekend of “free fun” but I’d feel so restricted not having funds to get a coffee or lunch as I pleased and be relying on him.

I know I’m probably going to avoid him until I’m paid again and have his presents to avoid feeling guilty or bad.

I have considered financing the items on Very and paying back immediately when paid so there’d be no interest applied but it comes to over £200 for the speaker and pop-up tent. Even if I did this, they wouldn’t come for another week or two.
Don't be so fucking stupid! Yup need to work on your boundaries.

aSofaNearYou · 14/09/2023 18:44

OP none of your responses have addressed the main issue, which is how awful it is for somebody to set others a "minimum budget" of what to spend on them. Giving gifts to people who are polite and appreciate them, yeah, sure, but can you seriously condone his attitude here?

didntgetagift · 14/09/2023 18:09

Honestly in terms of sex, I have a higher sex drive and want it more than my boyfriend so in reference to the free fun it is highly unlikely he means sex. He probably means a movie night, board games, or a game of cards (activites we generally do) and a nice walk somewhere. I wouldn’t mind this at all but I would feel restricted not having excess money to spend and I wouldn’t ask for a coffee either, apart of me just wished he had the initiative to say “this weekends on me”!

OP posts:
didntgetagift · 14/09/2023 18:06

Crocs were probably my summer choice of shoe and my old job was pretty relaxed on work wear so I often wore them to work as they’re the comfiest shoe I own! I did mention wanting a specific colour and he did buy them for me so there was thought behind it.

As for candles, I always light candles but I hate Yankee! Typically I’d buy hand craft candles or there’s a local cafe we go to that sells some amazing scents I’d buy. He noticed me constantly smelling these and I think that’s where he got the idea to buy the candles from. I know in theory it was thoughtful but he definitely cheaped out by buying Christmas scented ones that were a fraction of the price of one of the candles I’d buy from that cafe.

OP posts:
didntgetagift · 14/09/2023 17:59

Hi All!

My boyfriend recently completed a masters and is working in retail at the moment. Up until I transitioned to this job last week, we were both earning £24,500 without bonuses or commission but I am now on £29,000 therefore earning more.

As we don’t live together or have any shared finances, we don’t really discuss our salaries or monthly income frequently because it doesn’t effect us together.

In terms of sending my friends £5, this is to friends who I no longer live beside and is more a token to say I am thinking of you and please enjoy your morning coffee on me. With friends who do live nearby and I meet more often, we rotate who pays for the coffee.

I understand some people have an issue with gift giving as a love language and I completely comprehend that. If I see something albeit small or big and it is within my current means, I will often pick it up regardless of my relationship to that person (only close friends or immediate family). I never gift give to buy people’s love! I grew up in a low earning working class family so often presents were only received at birthdays or Christmas and I like to be able to now give back to my family and friends. For me, I love giving someone a gift and seeing how happy it may make them.

Now, someone mentioned the small gifts I do give my partner he probably could care less about and I don’t completely disagree with this. Some of the small gifts I have given him sit in the spare room unopened but he keeps the wrapping paper and little notes so I know some of the gesture is appreciated.

His ears must have been burning as he sent me £20 this morning to buy myself a nice coffee and lunch at work. I know it’s not a lot considering I’m broke as chips until the 25th but I did appreciate this and find it thoughtful. He has sent me £15 once before to buy a coffee and lunch.

It goes without say that I do have a lot to think about. I will try read all the replies once I’m sat down with a cup of tea!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread