Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK has become awful?

815 replies

ma1formed · 13/09/2023 20:26

I can't pinpoint when, but it feels like everything that was once pretty good is now quite awful

So expensive
No doctors
Uni costs for kids insane
Terrible rent / can't buy a house
Everyone seems quite unpleasant or racist

Is it just me?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Alexandra2001 · 14/09/2023 12:44

DownNative · 14/09/2023 12:36

The OPs question is "AIBU to think the UK has become awful?".

The answer to that is no as we can see from the 2023 Best Countries rankings.

Their question is about the UK as a whole AND overall, but NOT about how people feel at the anecdotal, individual level.

As for your individual level concern vis a vis quality of life, the UK ranking in 2022 Best Countries was.....8th.

It's 9th in 2023.

So, in global terms the UK has experienced SOME decline. But NOT to the extent of "awful" as in the OPs thread title....🤦‍♂️

Edited

You keep clinging to the overall but this wasn't a survey done of british peoples views was it? and if you look at the things that matter, such as Quality of life, the UK from your own link, is not good at all.

What matters is peoples lived experiences and when it comes to soooo many things, its shite.. Roads, GP appts, NHS waiting lists, Schools, council services.. all in decline.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 12:36

Ilikeicecream · 14/09/2023 10:39

Even if UK is better than other countries, public are noticing decline in their quality of lives.

If you lose your job and you have less disposable income as a family and make no efforts to find another, should your kids be ok in decline in the way they were living because there are families doing worse than you? What matters is you are used to certain standards and when rhey decline, it impacts you.

The OPs question is "AIBU to think the UK has become awful?".

The answer to that is no as we can see from the 2023 Best Countries rankings.

Their question is about the UK as a whole AND overall, but NOT about how people feel at the anecdotal, individual level.

As for your individual level concern vis a vis quality of life, the UK ranking in 2022 Best Countries was.....8th.

It's 9th in 2023.

So, in global terms the UK has experienced SOME decline. But NOT to the extent of "awful" as in the OPs thread title....🤦‍♂️

BloodyHellKen · 14/09/2023 12:21

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 14/09/2023 10:13

@BloodyHellKen so have the tories done a good job ? That’s the crux of the matter. Individually you’re doing great, but what about the rest of the country ?
Brexit going well ? NHS functioning half decently, likewise schools, criminal justice system ? Surely any intelligent person votes on a government’s record.
Too many folk on here live a nice sheltered existence in the home counties or prosperous market towns and really haven’t got a clue what it’s like anywhere else.

No, the crux of the matter based on the OPs original question is 'has the UK become awful' and I answered that.

The OP didn't state a timeline or political reason for the perceived awfulness to have happened so I'm using my lifetime of 50 odd years as it's the only experience I have and as I said up thread IMO there have been peaks and troughs (and different governments).

If the OP wanted to garner public opinion on if the Tory govt had managed the country well over the last x number of years she should have asked that instead, and possibly put the post in the politics thread as well.

Tambatamba · 14/09/2023 12:20

The reality is that Covid broke the NHS, because the Tories stripped and stripped and stripped it to nothing.

Tambatamba · 14/09/2023 12:19

Teddleshon · 14/09/2023 12:13

I dread to think what the financial position of the country would be like now following the £400bn or so spent on covid if it hadn’t been for austerity.

😂😂 yeah right

Teddleshon · 14/09/2023 12:13

I dread to think what the financial position of the country would be like now following the £400bn or so spent on covid if it hadn’t been for austerity.

Feebleexcuses · 14/09/2023 12:13

I feel that people feel they are losing their sense of individual cultural identity but don't have an understanding of why. This manifests as racism.

Angrycat2768 · 14/09/2023 12:11

Alexandra2001 · 14/09/2023 12:00

I think a lot of the UKs problems are to do with Austerity and Brexit...

What happens when we neglect the mtce on our houses?

What happens when we snub our neighbours?

Irony is no one in govt really believes in brexit

I agree with this. Covid caused many more problems, partly because austerity meant that we had little to no resilience in services and then had to buy stuff and fix things in am emergency situation . I don't think we are more racist than many countries in Europe ( although I think if we implement PR we will get to see just how many people vote for a hard/far right party). I do think this is a country run for the old. I don't think my children will have a future here, and am encouraging them to broaden their horizons.

LuluBlakey1 · 14/09/2023 12:06

bombastix · 14/09/2023 08:39

All you can hope for is that the Tory Party are flattened at the next election. Sorting this out is the work of a decade at least.

It is the work of a generation- not a decade. 25-30 years. It's about re-establishing a culture in this country that is based on:
Treating the environment and nature with respect- animals and waterways and land and the air we breathe.
Teaching the next generation how to parent children properly- poor parenting is a huge part of our problems.
Everyone well enough to should contribute to our communities. Everyone- run a local sports club, coach at one, volunteer for a charity, participate in clean-ups of beaches, parks etc- whatever it is. It should be part of our psyche that we do that.
We should run community classes/groups in things that encourage togetherness and mental well-being as well as teaching skills- art, crafts, fitness, walking, decorating, dressmaking, a MFL, sewing, camping, cycle maintainance and safety, gardening/growing/
allotments (anything) Can't have an allotment anywhere where we live because waiting list is 5 years- we need more.
Making people pay their way- through fair taxation (we all should pay more and those earning the most and big business should pay much more).
Reducing the 'benefits' culture that exists. Benefits should never be a choice as a way of living- it is now for far too many.
Being much more interventionist about what we allow to be imported and what we allow industries to produce. At the minute we allow any old shit to be imported and any old shit to be produced. Plastic tat and complete rubbish that ends up dumped and in landfill.
Removing the drain of public monies into private industries. There are things that should be nationalised to protect our standards and ensure funding is spent improving standards and not stripped out as profit. Adult social care, nurseries, all education, health care, dentistry, power, water.
Financial regulation of companies should be much stricter.
There should be absolutely no tax benefit to being rich, and nowhere to hide wealth.
There should be a wealth tax on property, paid annually instead of council tax. 0.5% of a property's value annually- with single person discount remaining in place.
Inheritance tax MUST be paid. Up the starting point to £1 million but on anything above it must be paid by everyone. It is currently paid by very few.
Jobs should not come with perks outside of a salary. People should pay their way.
Salaries paid to CEOs should be limited. It's disgusting what we pay hospital managers.
If we want decent public services, we have to find ways of paying for them.
Company accounts and pay outs to shareholders should be regulated. No shareholders should be allowed to strip money from employees pension funds.
Get rid of 'fast food'. It is nothing but a health issue and a pollutant of our environment.
Grow food. Why do we import apples? We can grow our own apples but we don't. We fly them in from round the world. We grew the best apples in the world and a huge range.It is capable of being a big industry. But we are too lazy to pick them.
We need standards in workmanship- they are shit. There are no real apprenticeships where young people are taught high quality skills. Brickie apprentices follow idle, sloppy builders around who can't be bothered to teach them skills. Same with most trades. There was a time our building standards were envied - not now.
Give up the idea that going to university is the be-all for everyone. It osn't. Most people would be much better off learning the skills we need to improve our future- in new power industries for example, market gardening, environmental protection,

Limit shit university courses- 'forensic science', 'sports science', 'cosmetology'. Waste of time.
Lower the grades required for medicine- the teenagers I have taught who would have been excellent Drs but got 2 As and a B at A level and didn't get in had other skills - with people- that many who do qualify don't have. They would have coped academically with support- universities need to provide tailored academic and study support to medics to help more qualify.
Do a deal for medicine, nursing, teaching - no tuition fees but you work full-time in this country for 10 years from the date you fully qualify or you pay your fees back.
Reduce the number of cars built- noone needs a new car every year or two years. It's environmentally damaging to produce so many.
The rich need to expect to make less wealth. That's the bottom line. At the minute we are all, and our environment, exploited by the most wealthy making money from us and from the state and not doing everything they can to contribute.

1dayatatime · 14/09/2023 12:04

@csiaddict

"Not to mention the postal service. There was a time when first class post meant delivered next day, and didn't cost the earth"

+++

I thought about this the other day after reading that a soldier in the trenches in France in WW1 could post a letter from the front and know that their loved one would receive it the next day.

Now if they managed to achieve this over a 100 years ago in a war zone being shelled, across bombed out terrain then over the Channel and then on to an address anywhere in the UK and all for free then things must have gotten really really crap since then!

Alexandra2001 · 14/09/2023 12:00

I think a lot of the UKs problems are to do with Austerity and Brexit...

What happens when we neglect the mtce on our houses?

What happens when we snub our neighbours?

Irony is no one in govt really believes in brexit

PinkRiceKrispies · 14/09/2023 11:57

We are one of the most tolerant countries in the world. I almost feel like we have to be apologetic about our culture and traditions to make way for others.

Tambatamba · 14/09/2023 11:48

ma1formed · 14/09/2023 11:40

Regards the racism thing, I'm not saying other countries don't have worse problems; I'm saying the UK has become more racist.

We're Jewish for example and have personally experienced three hate crimes in our family the past two years after having none at all in the previous 3 decades. One by an actual self declared Nazi, one by a school child fgs, and one by a woman on a bus.

I think that hate / slide to neo nazism and general hate has been a direct result of our politics as well as the normalisation of characters like Lozza, Farage or even Trump. I think people are being radicalised to hate.

I also think a vast proportion of people unashamedly hold xenophobic views since Brexit, and that our media has been egging this on. We have almost glamourised it.

The entire attitude has gone downhill from where I'm standing, and the "free speech" brigade at times devolve into "hate speech". Our own politicians (Labour included) seem to egg this on.

Since Farage radicalised the nation, our politicians seem too scared to call a bigot a bigot. Probably because a lot of them are bigots themselves, but also because they worked out that poking hate is vote winner.

I'm really disappointed in England to be honest.

I'm sorry to hear about what you've been through. Brexit has emboldened a lot of people to openly be the bigots they are I think.

ma1formed · 14/09/2023 11:40

Regards the racism thing, I'm not saying other countries don't have worse problems; I'm saying the UK has become more racist.

We're Jewish for example and have personally experienced three hate crimes in our family the past two years after having none at all in the previous 3 decades. One by an actual self declared Nazi, one by a school child fgs, and one by a woman on a bus.

I think that hate / slide to neo nazism and general hate has been a direct result of our politics as well as the normalisation of characters like Lozza, Farage or even Trump. I think people are being radicalised to hate.

I also think a vast proportion of people unashamedly hold xenophobic views since Brexit, and that our media has been egging this on. We have almost glamourised it.

The entire attitude has gone downhill from where I'm standing, and the "free speech" brigade at times devolve into "hate speech". Our own politicians (Labour included) seem to egg this on.

Since Farage radicalised the nation, our politicians seem too scared to call a bigot a bigot. Probably because a lot of them are bigots themselves, but also because they worked out that poking hate is vote winner.

I'm really disappointed in England to be honest.

OP posts:
Tambatamba · 14/09/2023 11:25

No it's not just you but this is what happens when you have a Tory government for 13+ years.

Ilikeicecream · 14/09/2023 11:24

barbieofswanlake · 14/09/2023 08:52

Have you lived outside of the U.K.? Racism exists but not anything like on the scale of many other countries. Try being of Egyptian descent (and assumed to be Muslim) in France. On all your other points I agree. But actually the U.K. is a very inclusive and tolerant country. The reason people think it's not is conversely because of our heightened awareness and concern compared to places where people just accept, or don't even notice

As a brown person, I agree with you about the overall inclusiveness in UK. For last 2 years, I live in one of the top 3 countries in Wharton article and find UK more inclusive despite being poorer and with strained public services compared to where I live. I really hope situation improves there.

H34th · 14/09/2023 11:24

I'll add the teenagers dressed in black with masks, riding scooters on pavements, thieving in shops, intimidating the more vulnerable, and doing whatever they fancy with police looking the other way.

Not sure it's a new thing, but I do see more of them.

YouHaveAnArse · 14/09/2023 11:19

It's quite telling that none of the younger staff at my or DH,s workplaces now are living in flatshares having moved from elsewhere in the country - they are all people who grew up locally and are able to live with family and commute in. It's terrible for social mobility.

YouHaveAnArse · 14/09/2023 11:17

BloodyHellKen · 14/09/2023 10:03

In answer to your question Op, no I personally don't think the UK has become awful. Don't get me wrong there are lots of things I will change when I'm in charge, but generally things are okay in my family/friends and those things that aren't okay (illness/death) can't really be blamed on the govt.

So expensive - it's expensive everywhere
No doctors - this is not uniform over the whole country and has been an issue for decade in cities
Uni costs for kids insane - I agree with this and this is one of the things I would change.
Terrible rent / can't buy a house - this is not a new thing
Everyone seems quite unpleasant or racist - this is bollocks, everyone is not unpleasant or racist. IME most people are quite decent.

Maybe you are feeling like this because of your stage in life and the normal ups and downs of an economy?

For example things were very bad for me 25-30 years ago when I was starting out, then they got better, then really good and then worse for us about 10-15 years ago when the children were much smaller, we still had a mortgage and no savings, lots of stress.

Now we are more comfortable so things are better and I worry less about the things in your list.

Bidding wars/ "guide price" appearing on rental ads is not something that's always been the case. People are being expected to pay 6 or 12 months upfront to get a rental now, even if they earn 30x the monthly rent, even if they provide references and 3m bank statements. Properties are poorly maintained and mouldy as it's assumed renters will just put up with it and if they don't then they shouldn't be so entitled to expect to live in the same city they work in. It's significantly worse than when we were last looking a decade ago and it's making it ever harder for people to save up for their own homes, so people are flatsharing into their 30s and 40s and praying the rent doesn't go up.

LuluBlakey1 · 14/09/2023 11:12

Yirk · 14/09/2023 07:40

An oldie here and to me apart from covid the biggest shift in the behaviour and personality of people came about with the internet/ social media.

^^ This. Completely agree.

ma1formed · 14/09/2023 11:08

I find it surprising that a number of people on this thread think it's fine, or compare it to twenty years ago.

It feels so starkly different to me.

Even to my parents.

OP posts:
Eleganz · 14/09/2023 10:42

It is exactly what you'd expect it to be after 13 years of Conservative government in Westminster. Yet lots of people still keep voting for them.

Bearpawk · 14/09/2023 10:40

Yep - my formerly beautiful city feels like a shithole. Bins constantly overflowing, rubbish everywhere, weeds everywhere on pavements, homeless people everywhere, potholes not fixed. Yet council tax and parking permits have skyrocketed.
Impossible to get a docs appt and wait times are ridiculous for routine surgery etc. have been affected by this myself recently.
Anti social behaviour is off the charts and nowhere for kids to go.

FabFitFifties · 14/09/2023 10:40

As a nurse, I dread having to be hospitalised, or having to attend A/E after my last experience, and really, really hope, if I live to old age, I don't need care. I'm retiring early, because I don't even trust them with my pension, and considering the vast amount of unpaid hours I've done and still do, I want to be sure I at least see some of it! I'm lucky I have a pension of course - I worry even more for people reliant on state pension.

Ilikeicecream · 14/09/2023 10:39

DownNative · 14/09/2023 08:22

Only 6 EU countries are above the UK for quality of life with all the rest below us.

And just two non-EU countries above us.

In other words, the UK is still Top 10 in Europe for quality of life with most of Europe below. Including Republic of Ireland, France, Spain & Italy!

Top 10 Overall & Top 10 Europe plus Top 15 for global quality of life.

We can celebrate what we do well whilst acknowledging what we'd like to improve. It's not a False Dilemma scenario, you know. 🤦‍♂️

Even if UK is better than other countries, public are noticing decline in their quality of lives.

If you lose your job and you have less disposable income as a family and make no efforts to find another, should your kids be ok in decline in the way they were living because there are families doing worse than you? What matters is you are used to certain standards and when rhey decline, it impacts you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread