Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK has become awful?

815 replies

ma1formed · 13/09/2023 20:26

I can't pinpoint when, but it feels like everything that was once pretty good is now quite awful

So expensive
No doctors
Uni costs for kids insane
Terrible rent / can't buy a house
Everyone seems quite unpleasant or racist

Is it just me?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
givemeasunnyday · 14/09/2023 21:05

Australia's system is awful in my opinion. They pay hugely more than we do and only get basic coverage if not. Their insurance costs can be eye watering. Even those insured are often bankrupted by medical expenses as the insurer won't cover it or they are offered sub standard care if they can't afford to pay. I've read heartbreaking stories. Not as bad as America, but in my opinion awful.

Are you being serious? I know a lot of people who live in Australia - not one of them has ever complained about their health system, and it is a lot more efficient than the NHS appears to be.

Seychal · 14/09/2023 21:01

LuluBlakey1 · 14/09/2023 12:06

It is the work of a generation- not a decade. 25-30 years. It's about re-establishing a culture in this country that is based on:
Treating the environment and nature with respect- animals and waterways and land and the air we breathe.
Teaching the next generation how to parent children properly- poor parenting is a huge part of our problems.
Everyone well enough to should contribute to our communities. Everyone- run a local sports club, coach at one, volunteer for a charity, participate in clean-ups of beaches, parks etc- whatever it is. It should be part of our psyche that we do that.
We should run community classes/groups in things that encourage togetherness and mental well-being as well as teaching skills- art, crafts, fitness, walking, decorating, dressmaking, a MFL, sewing, camping, cycle maintainance and safety, gardening/growing/
allotments (anything) Can't have an allotment anywhere where we live because waiting list is 5 years- we need more.
Making people pay their way- through fair taxation (we all should pay more and those earning the most and big business should pay much more).
Reducing the 'benefits' culture that exists. Benefits should never be a choice as a way of living- it is now for far too many.
Being much more interventionist about what we allow to be imported and what we allow industries to produce. At the minute we allow any old shit to be imported and any old shit to be produced. Plastic tat and complete rubbish that ends up dumped and in landfill.
Removing the drain of public monies into private industries. There are things that should be nationalised to protect our standards and ensure funding is spent improving standards and not stripped out as profit. Adult social care, nurseries, all education, health care, dentistry, power, water.
Financial regulation of companies should be much stricter.
There should be absolutely no tax benefit to being rich, and nowhere to hide wealth.
There should be a wealth tax on property, paid annually instead of council tax. 0.5% of a property's value annually- with single person discount remaining in place.
Inheritance tax MUST be paid. Up the starting point to £1 million but on anything above it must be paid by everyone. It is currently paid by very few.
Jobs should not come with perks outside of a salary. People should pay their way.
Salaries paid to CEOs should be limited. It's disgusting what we pay hospital managers.
If we want decent public services, we have to find ways of paying for them.
Company accounts and pay outs to shareholders should be regulated. No shareholders should be allowed to strip money from employees pension funds.
Get rid of 'fast food'. It is nothing but a health issue and a pollutant of our environment.
Grow food. Why do we import apples? We can grow our own apples but we don't. We fly them in from round the world. We grew the best apples in the world and a huge range.It is capable of being a big industry. But we are too lazy to pick them.
We need standards in workmanship- they are shit. There are no real apprenticeships where young people are taught high quality skills. Brickie apprentices follow idle, sloppy builders around who can't be bothered to teach them skills. Same with most trades. There was a time our building standards were envied - not now.
Give up the idea that going to university is the be-all for everyone. It osn't. Most people would be much better off learning the skills we need to improve our future- in new power industries for example, market gardening, environmental protection,

Limit shit university courses- 'forensic science', 'sports science', 'cosmetology'. Waste of time.
Lower the grades required for medicine- the teenagers I have taught who would have been excellent Drs but got 2 As and a B at A level and didn't get in had other skills - with people- that many who do qualify don't have. They would have coped academically with support- universities need to provide tailored academic and study support to medics to help more qualify.
Do a deal for medicine, nursing, teaching - no tuition fees but you work full-time in this country for 10 years from the date you fully qualify or you pay your fees back.
Reduce the number of cars built- noone needs a new car every year or two years. It's environmentally damaging to produce so many.
The rich need to expect to make less wealth. That's the bottom line. At the minute we are all, and our environment, exploited by the most wealthy making money from us and from the state and not doing everything they can to contribute.

A fantastic post again. Thank you. ⭐

Seychal · 14/09/2023 20:55

ginandtonicwithlimes · 14/09/2023 09:14

They would be considered wealthy in Hull.

That was my point. Try being as opposed to try living.

givemeasunnyday · 14/09/2023 20:47

Alexandra2001 · 14/09/2023 12:44

You keep clinging to the overall but this wasn't a survey done of british peoples views was it? and if you look at the things that matter, such as Quality of life, the UK from your own link, is not good at all.

What matters is peoples lived experiences and when it comes to soooo many things, its shite.. Roads, GP appts, NHS waiting lists, Schools, council services.. all in decline.

I don't actually live in the UK, but have been following this with interest.

However, while I can't comment regarding the OP's question I just wanted to say that I agree with this. So many on MN spend so much time looking for survey results/statistics to prove their point, and people's lived experiences are just shrugged off as being meaningless. I have NEVER, in my whole 64 years, been asked my opinion in any survey, and nor have any of my friends, so I have not a lot of faith in the end result of these. When a vast majority of average people are complaining about something that means a lot more to me than a 'best country to live in' type ranking. A poster on MN once threw 'facts' at me about my own country which were completely erroneous - just because something is published does not make it true. I can't help but wonder if this is part of the ills of the world - ordinary people are ignored because their views are no longer relevant as 'facts/figures' are seen as the absolute truth, and people spend far too much time assembling them rather than actually speaking to people about their issues instead of asking a few yes/no questions.

TeenLifeMum · 14/09/2023 20:39

@YouHaveAnArse nope, council likely to declare bankruptcy and dh 2 week wait cancer referral still not through since early July. I just like to focus on the positives more than the negatives I can’t change.

cheapest 3 bed house to rent is £1300 (which is nuts).

DownNative · 14/09/2023 18:42

Ilikeicecream · 14/09/2023 13:04

Their question is about the UK as a whole AND overall, but NOT about how people feel at the anecdotal, individual level.

What is an overall country if you remove the experience of vast majority of people living there?

The OPs question is "AIBU to think the UK has become awful?".

While I agree awful is a strong word, but becoming awful in the context of OP, is UK deteriorating.

You must be in a very comfortable position, maybe a landowner or just prefer to be in denial.

UK had declined in the rating you mentioned. And has managed to stay in top10 because it did very well on criterias like power, cultural attractiveness, these parameters are not as important to an average Joe. Access to good healthcare, education, decent wages to afford decent lifestyle, safety and clean air and water are more important. Just a few days ago, Liverpool Council declared itself bankrupt 🙄

I said at the anecdotal, individual. That means people's perception of how things appear to them.

Anecdotes such as throughout the thread aren't reliable indicators as to whether a country is declining or the reverse.

That's why studies such as the aforementioned rankings hold weight with methodology made clear.

The UK declined SLIGHTLY in the rankings I provided between 2022 and 2023. I note you did not refer to entrepreneurship which the authors stated is how governments spread wealth to the citizens. UK ranked 4th in that. Agility and Social Purpose are also important to citizens - 13th and 15th respectively.

Whichever way you cut it, the UK ranks higher than most of the World and most Europe on individual metrics such as entrepreneurship, cultural power, agility and social purpose, etc. Gives us an overall 9th ranking.

Basically, a lot of anecdotes in the thread are out of step with rankings of countries. People are more likely to post about problems than successes on forums such as this one as well.

Answer is still no to OPs question. 🤷‍♂️

Teddleshon · 14/09/2023 18:29

Totally agree with your final line @Maatandosiris . I’m an Aussie and am so grateful to be able to live in the UK.

Maatandosiris · 14/09/2023 18:04

Well I look at it differently

most people are really nice

the Uk is substantially less racist than many other countries

we have a free at point of use healthcare system - needs a massive shake up though but still better than many other countries

Uni costs are a lot more affordable than many countries and we have some of the best education establishments in the world

Housing costs would be better if we cut down the increase in population, many countries have the same issue.

inflation has hit world wide

on top of that we have fantastic countryside and coasts, incredibly interesting history

Good job opportunities

Relatively good standard of living

A broad range of culture on tap, much of it is free

Our temperate climate means we don’t suffer tropical diseases, but can grow a wide range of food

We have good education opportunities for children

we have freedom we don’t risk being shot for saying we don’t agree with the government

The UK is an amazing place to live. Every day people risk their lives to get here.

It isn’t just you, it’s become fashionable to slag off the UK.

But living here, your one of the luckiest people in the world.

User135644 · 14/09/2023 17:48

anotherside · 13/09/2023 22:17

@StarDolphins

Labour will be in next & things won’t improve

The Labour Party as an electoral force has been dead for decades. The choice we have is Tory or Tory lite. Tory economics or Tory economics (lite). Neither Tory nor Tory lite are the answer - which is why the best countries to live in Europe largely abstain from governments as right wing as the Tories.

FPTP voting doesn't help.

The Tories feel comfortable self imploding (now, mid-90s) when the alternative is a very centrist and moderate Labour government that aren't actually going to change much. If Corbyn or even Ed Milliband was Labour leader promising radical change they'd be holding it together and the right wing press would be rallying round them and slaughtering Labour. As it is they'll be able to stomach Starmer, who wouldn't be out of place as a Conservative PM (albeit in the Cameron mould).

We need PR.

User135644 · 14/09/2023 17:45

bombastix · 13/09/2023 22:21

Went to lunch party reunion at the weekend. Well heeled people. The bile at the Tories was everywhere. It wasn't about tax it was about how shit they had been and are.

10 years ago it was nowhere near so anti. A mix of opinions. Now it's something like middle class rage.

It's a Tory country. England loves its Tories and is a nation of cap doffers.

Problem is after the Tories have been in for 10-15 years they realise everything has gone to shit and want them out. But they'll vote them back again, just not next election.

verdantverdure · 14/09/2023 16:45

The man we saw bellowing racist abuse at the woman behind the newsagent counter was a well spoken white haired OAP in a fairisle sweater and drove a nice car with a sticker about donkeys and ponies on it. He had also double parked, blocking one lane of the small country road, instead of pulling in.

I expect he looked nice when he wasn't frothing.

YouHaveAnArse · 14/09/2023 16:30

"This morning a couple threw a pile of fast food stuff from their car window in Seaton Delaval. They were mid 30s I'd say, driving an old black Range Rover, she was orange faced, he had a shaved head. Both had tattooed arms. What's going on with adults who behave like that?"

While I agree with you about the littering being vile behaviour, what's with the detailed description of their appearance?

verdantverdure · 14/09/2023 16:27

Ringpeace · 14/09/2023 16:15

Deluded.

I lived in Germany for a long time. I'm still a frequent visitor.

For the most part Germany is doing far better than the UK and the 'public realm' is in a much better state.

German towns and cities are in the main far less run down than their British counterparts.

From what I understand the German government has put money into infrastructure such as future-proofing the energy sector to benefit the
German people and the German economy in the long run.

The current U.K. government just gives our country's money to their mates and we have nothing to show for it.

My husband works across Europe and he and his mates go to the Nurburgring every year to race, and he says the infrastructure contrast with the U.K. is possibly the strongest in Germany. (Although he also has complimentary comments about Austrian, Swiss and Italian public transport.)

Ringpeace · 14/09/2023 16:15

Deluded.

I lived in Germany for a long time. I'm still a frequent visitor.

For the most part Germany is doing far better than the UK and the 'public realm' is in a much better state.

German towns and cities are in the main far less run down than their British counterparts.

BloodyHellKen · 14/09/2023 16:07

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 14/09/2023 14:41

@BloodyHellKen telling that you didn’t answer the question did you ?
And surely the OP meant now.
Why are you policing where the OP posts her thread ? Everyone knows AIBU and chat get the most footfall. Many PP are quite happy to attribute blame to the current shower for the decline of the UK not just me.

I did answer the question.

The OP asked if I thought the UK had become awful and I said from my experience (over 50+ years) things go up and down and that I agreed with some things in her list, but not others.

Just because I didn't drag politics into it and give the answer you would like to read to support your own bias doesn't mean my opinion is any less valid.

Lazyusername · 14/09/2023 16:05

I feel as though things have deteriorated massively in the last few decades and I have a couple of comments on factors I feel have added to this.
One is that the "contract" has been broken for younger people (I'm talking 40 and under); the expectation that they will earn a good wage, own a home and do better than their parents has been dashed. So some have stopped caring or feeling that they have a societal responsibility and some are resentful of older people - the respect has gone.
This has led to things like quiet quitting. I was reading a thread on MN a while back where people were saying, "Who else here is getting away with skiving/doing half-arsed job?" The comments were quite eye-opening with people happy to say they were being paid but were not working and thinking it was really funny. The thing is, people are happy to admit this, but then they are angry when the service they get from the GP, Council or NHS is half-arsed as well because other people are doing it too.

And the Government, our representatives, are exactly the same.

It reminds me of something John Lennon said,
“The government will fix everything; it is all government’s fault; shake your fists at the government’. Well, we are the government. The people are the government, and the people have the power.”

The calibre of people we now have in Government is reflected in the calibre of people and the behaviour we now see accepted around us every day. Go to Japan and see how people show care and respect for each other and take pride in their jobs. I remember this attitude in the UK from when I was a child; the doctor feeling pleased to come to your home and help you, the police being proud of keeping their local area crime-free and so on.
This is what I think we have lost and I don't know how we can ever get it back.

toadasoda · 14/09/2023 15:59

I'm sorry about your experiences @LuluBlakey1 I don't know much about the race element but sadly I think misogyny exists everywhere. I'd be interested to know if there is anywhere on this earth where it doesn't?? Its actually depressing when you think about it.

verdantverdure · 14/09/2023 15:58

My friend emigrated to Australia about 15 years ago and she always says I'd hate it there because of the casual racism.

She came back to the U.K. this summer during Stop The Boats and read the papers, spoke to all the elderly rellies.

She now thinks it's nastier here if anything.

LuluBlakey1 · 14/09/2023 15:41

toadasoda · 14/09/2023 13:58

Can't comment as I don't live in UK but just wanted to say I think British people on here can be a bit hard on themselves! UK to me is a very tolerant place and most people are polite and friendly. Im generalising hugely obviously but basing this on my experience of being there and those I've met elsewhere.

It really isn't a very tolerant place. It is certainly not tolerant of sexual equality and women face misogyny every day - often habitual low level stuff but every day, sometimes much nastier abusive stuff including comments about appearance, sexualised behaviours like inappropriate touching, men who talk down to women and belittle them, who pigeonhole them, exclude them from decision-making at work, have it in their minds they will have children so don't consider them for promotions. It os continual. And that's without the extreme and- the violence. 95%+ of domestic violence is male against female. Stranger violence against women is almost 100% male. Sexual violence not related to a previous relationship os 99% male to female.

The UK is a racist country- casual racism is continual. I hear it every single day. Assumptions made, ingrained beliefs and attitudes. Then there is much more discriminatory or violent racism. It's certainly not all white against other cultures, it's culture vs culture and often involves religion between some groups. I have never felt as intimidated in my life as I do in Wembley in London. We have a family member who lives there and , if I visit alone, I am often the only white woman on the station and the way black men treat me is horrible. I have been scared by it. In shops people speak wholly in Indian or Middle-Eastern languages and will just ignore a white woman. I have seen young asian men in their 20s in groups following and making sexual remarks to teenage white girls who are alone, on one occasion following her in a car and trying to persuade her to get into it.

I am lucky in that I live in the north-east in a well-off little community by the sea. One of the benefits of being ignored by our government is there is less change here but what I do see here is insularity and ignorant behaviour most often from 20-40 year olds who can be just awful- gobby, loud, shouting about what they want, rude to others, dire parenting from groups of them, wasteful, no sense of decency- of course I'm not talking about everyone, not even a majority but lots. This morning a couple threw a pile of fast food stuff from their car window in Seaton Delaval. They were mid 30s I'd say, driving an old black Range Rover, she was orange faced, he had a shaved head. Both had tattooed arms. What's going on with adults who behave like that?
I'd leave the UK if we had a choice but DH won't leave PIL. I think he would have 10 years ago but I wouldn't leave my mam then. Soon we'll be too old. I'd go to Canada or New Zealand .

beAsensible1 · 14/09/2023 15:34

ma1formed · 14/09/2023 12:55

"Tolerant" of what?

I am always puzzled by this statement. We're Jews. I'm not sure why anyone is called on to tolerate anything

right.
what is there to tolerate about different ethnicities existing on the same bit of rock as you. get a grip.

The existence of different ethnicities is not a personal affront to you.

jgw1 · 14/09/2023 15:30

If anyone would like evidence of how awful the attitudes to other humans are in the UK, take a look at the latest small boats thread.

Teddleshon · 14/09/2023 15:18

All essential and urgent medical care is free or low cost in Australia. Dentistry is not included if you are over 18 (which may account for at least some of the bankruptcy figures). In the UK NHS dentistry is almost non existent now.

Incidentally, that bankruptcy statistic may sound shocking but there are around 10,000 personal bankruptcies a year in Australia so if it is correct then 1,000 a year are apparently due to medical bills. Last year in the UK hundreds of thousands people died while on NHS waiting lists which are now stretching up to 7 years. And of course people are bankrupted in the UK by medical/care costs too.

ma1formed · 14/09/2023 14:58

10% of bankruptcy in Australia is from medical bills. Fuck what the OECD says. That's nightmarish.

OP posts:
Charlotteowensdodgydad · 14/09/2023 14:41

@BloodyHellKen telling that you didn’t answer the question did you ?
And surely the OP meant now.
Why are you policing where the OP posts her thread ? Everyone knows AIBU and chat get the most footfall. Many PP are quite happy to attribute blame to the current shower for the decline of the UK not just me.

Kendodd · 14/09/2023 14:38

With regard the state of the UK, for the last 50 years, we have mostly had a Tory government. I was trying to think if they've done anything that has actually really benefited the people. I was chatting to somebody today and couldn't think of anything.

Council houses sold and not replaced
Sale of publicly owned services and utilities
Vigorously opposing the creation of the NHS
Largely responsible for Brexit
The Poll Tax
They even opposed Labour banning the production of torture equipment in the UK in the 1990s arguing that it was good for business.

That's just off the top of my head.

This isn't to say Labour have been perfect, far from it.

PPI was a terrible idea (although actually started by the Tories)
The Iraq war (wholeheartedly supported by the Tories)
I'm sure loads of other stuff.

The Tories though, do seem to have just looted the country and sold everything to the lowest bidder every chance they get though. And Labour have done public good, setting up the NHS and state pension for example. They also seem to have historically been ahead on equality legislation, equal pay etc.

One good thing I do want to give credit to the Tories for though is the Good Friday Agreement (although it was cross party).