Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
fiddlesticksandotherwords · 15/09/2023 13:39

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 16:18

Well actually eight generations away. The example you give is like saying, my Great Great Great Great Granny spoke to the Great Great Grandson who's Dad went up chimneys as a boy.

My dad was born in 1922. So no, not eight generations. One.

Callmesleepy · 15/09/2023 13:22

I left school in 2010 and definitely learnt about slavery. I didn't do history GCSE so it would have been y7-9. I remember learning about it in quite a nuanced way as clearly an absolutely appalling thing and one that a lot of people worked very hard to combat including both Harriet Tubman and William Wilberforce. I think we also touched on the Irish famine in the context of Cromwell and am pretty sure India was discussed at some points although that may have been due to the school being predominantly Asian. I definitely learnt about castes somewhere.

The thing that drives my nervousness around the current way things are presented is that it seems really divisive. We've seen this happen before - I've seen the argument that racism as it stands today was pushed to prevent the indentured servants and slaves teaming up against the people oppressing then both. What I'm seeing currently seems to present all black people as victims and all white people as aggressors which ignores intersectionality and context. The nuances matter.

From my education I'd say the best thing we can teach children is how to understand how nations operate and how to see where they're being manipulated. By all means touch on all sorts of topics and pick a few key ones to explore in greater depth to properly understand the patterns so they can apply them to other situations. It's not like world leaders are inventing wholly new methods, they're just applying old ones differently.

GodessOfThunder · 15/09/2023 12:56

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 11:36

Hobbi
Your relentless whataboutery is akin to insisting we teach that the 15th century Ottoman conquest of Bosnia and Herzegovina is equally relevant as WWII to British children.

Relentless?* *😀He he!

The OP includes the phrase 'part of everyone's culture'. Therefore it's not whataboutery to suggest OP takes a comprehensive, broadly historical and international view. They didn't say 'part of UK culture' - or are you suggesting that's what is implied? If that's the case, no wonder there's misunderstanding.

What puzzles me is that when I was at school in the 70s we were taught the evils of slavery (both at my private prep school and later at state secondary). I well remember having a lesson on the famous plan of a slave ship, showing the people crammed in. We learned all about the triangular trade, the way the trade winds facilitated it, the sugar, tea and later, cotton etc. and links to the Industrial Revolution. Also, the Manchester Cotton Famine and the way the workers supported the American slaves' cause. Plus, of course, the abolitionist movement.

I just don't get why anyone has suddenly been taken by surprise by this. It's not something that's been covered up - it was very much on the educational agenda in my day. Has it dropped off in recent years? It's the pretence that it's been covered up in some way that I find completely crazy. No, it hasn't - what point are people trying to make here? Nothing I've recently read on the subject has been new to me, yet there's a strong implication that somehow 'now it can be told'. Is it something that's happened since the National Curriculum was introduced? Feel free to enlighten me.

My initial post defined “everyone” as “everyone in Britain”, so, no, not the everyone everywhere across all time interpretation you have suggested. It also referred to specifically transatlantic slavery and the British Empire.

You wrote “I just don't get why anyone has suddenly been taken by surprise by this.”

My response:

Educational coverage (and more importantly what people actually remember today) across the past few decades has been patchy. Some know a lot less than others.

In the past decade we have developed a greater understanding that slavery and imperialism weren’t just things that happened overseas and only involved a small number of elite slave/ship owners and abolitionists. We now understand slave owners were more diverse and numerous, plus we know more about connections to institutions.

Before, there was a sense that the story of slavery and its effect on Black people ended with abolition. Today, we have a better understanding that the prejudices nurtured by slavery and empire continue to create injustice today.

The population of Britain has become more diverse. Empire and slavery are directly resonant for more people.

We live in a more globalised world where Britain’s global history has become, rightly more resonant.

All this sadly, has all been interpreted by some conservative minded people as some woke/BLM activist/lefties/minority/American types are deliberately kicking off about what we all already know in order to manipulate us to accept their unreasonable demands.

One argument made several times on this thread has been been “but what about telling the history of oppressed white people”. There are collectively thousands of books; industrial and living museums; exhibitions; films; plays; dramas; documentaries and so on dealing with this topic. Some people “feel” slavery and empire related history, that has been produced recently, is dominating (or in danger of doing so) over their preferred narratives. This however, is because the brain is primed to notice what’s new and different. It’s not a reflection of reality as a visit to any local museum will illustrate.

OP posts:
MCOut · 15/09/2023 12:35

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 12:00

user9630721458 · Today 11:46

No, not just Wilberforce, although we did cover him - and the support he got from people such as Wedgwood (Am I a not a Man and a Brother?) etc.

At primary level and at my grammar school in the 70s we did a lot about slavery and were left in no doubt of its evils (I'm talking the T-A slave trade here). Also its links to British industrialism and, as I said, the Cotton Famine in ....I think the 1860s? In those far-off days, TV was not dumbed down and there were plenty of documentaries about slavery too. I don't think it was on the exam syllabuses but in what is now called KS1, 2 and 3 we certainly learned about it.

Also, at university doing Eng Lit, it was discussed in relation to Jane Austen (Mansfield Park and Sir Thomas Bertram's Jamaican estates) and Austen's portrayal of him as morally dubious (his slave ownership being a hint of this).

I just object to the suggestion that it's been somehow covered up and that any of it should be a surprise to us. I'm old, but what on earth have educationalists been doing if all this really is news to subsequent generations? I've discussed it with my contemporaries and they also were taught about it in school.

We older people might feel a bit patronised and don't feel we need to 'educate outselves' thank you! Honestly, don't judge us all by modern dumbed-down educational and broadcasting standards.

My understanding is that this has never been the norm. Lots of my generation haven’t learned it at all as teaching about slavery was at the school’s discretion. I’m not even sure there’s ever been an optional module on India come to think of it.

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 12:25

@MCOut

👏🏻

MCOut · 15/09/2023 12:22

mids2019 · 15/09/2023 06:50

@MCOut

Aren't you illustrating the point that you can't separate the teaching of slavery from race? It seems the motivation of teaching about slavery is not purely for academic awareness but to support an anti-racism agenda. I certainly do not agree with racism but should we not at least be honest behind the motivation behind increased teaching of this subject?

I think what a lot of players are suggesting is that slavery is contextualized with the lo we of the white working class poor at these times (which was grim) and therefore the historical sufferings of one race do not utterly surmount those of the other.

I think the thing to be avoided in the teaching of such subjects that there should be any sense of shame in being of any race and we should not feel shame about our country.

There are racial discrepancies in a number of areas within the country and they do need addressing. I actually think it doesn't help the anti-racism cause to highlight historical wrongs to a huge extent as that leads to resentment amongst than white working class who feel their culture and history is being displaced (rightly or wrongly).

An over focus on one side of a racial divide I think leads to a sense of grievance on the other.

I actually think there is an argument to suggest the major dividing line in British society is that of class and there should be unity in combating an overall system that rewards elites.

I think we have crossed wires. The whole point of having a more inclusive is history curriculum is for the purpose of anti-racism. I am happy to unashamedly shout this off the rooftops.

The entire argument that teaching should be apolitical is ridiculous tbh. There has never been a time that education has not been ideologically motivated. For example democracy is a value British education is formally required to impart. This is just arguing that education should be allowed to continuously exclude poc to maintain a feeling of white superiority.

We agree partially with regards to white guilt. I mentioned it previously and it truly angers me. It shouldn’t be indulged because it doesn’t affect life outcomes. Imagine if I said we shouldn’t teach about working class reform because it might make rich people feel bad.

White guilt is tedious, self indulgent and useless. It stands in the way of progress, derails all conversations and is damaging to poc because it centres white people in the same way everything else does. It’s so self centred the amount of people who look at how disparities affect poc people and still walk away thinking that their feelings are what drives calls for change.

Empathy and an appreciation for the contributions of all races is the goal. Not shame, not guilt. While learning slavery you end up coming across hurtful material about black people so it’s equally uncomfortable for everyone. Uncomfortable but necessary. It’s also not all doom and gloom. There are some really positive moments between races that also don’t get taught.

I don’t feel that it’s my responsibility to try and combat white guilt and I honestly don’t think it’s something that POC can achieve. I’ve found white people in general will receive information like this better from other white people. We can agree that they’re not responsible for things they did not do. We can make it clear that there are many positive contributions that Britain has given to the World. We can support the English football team right beside them. It will not make a blind bit of difference.

I managed to be taught about slavery and not dislike white people, so I’m confident that white children can be taught about it without feeling unnecessary self loathing. Similarly, I managed to be taught about working-class reform which has little to do with my people and walked away with empathy for the British working class. Asking white children to do the same is not asking much. It’s not like slavery alone would take up more than 6 lessons. We are talking about changing/ adapting only about 25% of the curriculum to be more inclusive. Any curriculum will still be heavily focused on the white British.

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 12:16

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 12:03

Hobbi · Today 11:55

I refer you to my reply to user above, and rest my case.

But Hobbi - I don't know your age, but you come over as very patronising and arrogant.

Thank you very much; it's great when knowing something in an academic field defines you as arrogant. Sums up modern England and its contempt for experts. I suspect we're of similar age. You brought up Sumerians and Mesopotamia - that's arrant whataboutery. You continue to define the transatlantic slave trade as an isolated historical phenomenon. You don't seem to want to confront its importance to contemporary British life. I don't believe you are an uneducated person so can only assume you have your own reasons for wilfully ignoring the arguments presented and constructing cliched straw men as an alternative. Seems a shame as no one is calling for guilt or blame but whatever...

user9630721458 · 15/09/2023 12:07

@CoffeeCantata Yes, I get the impression that it isn't taught in so much depth in schools now. It would be well covered in English Lit and History at HE level I expect. I may be wrong. I think education needs to look at a less Britain centric view, including learning about figures like Olaudah Equiano and resistance like the Haiti revolution,

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 12:03

Hobbi · Today 11:55

I refer you to my reply to user above, and rest my case.

But Hobbi - I don't know your age, but you come over as very patronising and arrogant.

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 12:00

user9630721458 · Today 11:46

No, not just Wilberforce, although we did cover him - and the support he got from people such as Wedgwood (Am I a not a Man and a Brother?) etc.

At primary level and at my grammar school in the 70s we did a lot about slavery and were left in no doubt of its evils (I'm talking the T-A slave trade here). Also its links to British industrialism and, as I said, the Cotton Famine in ....I think the 1860s? In those far-off days, TV was not dumbed down and there were plenty of documentaries about slavery too. I don't think it was on the exam syllabuses but in what is now called KS1, 2 and 3 we certainly learned about it.

Also, at university doing Eng Lit, it was discussed in relation to Jane Austen (Mansfield Park and Sir Thomas Bertram's Jamaican estates) and Austen's portrayal of him as morally dubious (his slave ownership being a hint of this).

I just object to the suggestion that it's been somehow covered up and that any of it should be a surprise to us. I'm old, but what on earth have educationalists been doing if all this really is news to subsequent generations? I've discussed it with my contemporaries and they also were taught about it in school.

We older people might feel a bit patronised and don't feel we need to 'educate outselves' thank you! Honestly, don't judge us all by modern dumbed-down educational and broadcasting standards.

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 11:55

@CoffeeCantata

I wouldn't dream of attempting to enlighten you, your 40 year memory of learning about the slave trade at prep school is obviously the gold standard in understanding how historical events are relevant to contemporary issues. As for what you're missing, the OP is making the important point that British life has been drastically shaped around the impact of the slave trade and that teaching about it could possibly include an acknowledgment of that, rather than just as information about an historical event. And yes, the whataboutery has been relentless, as it always is. I suppose 'all lives matter' as well. The OP has stressed it's not about blame or guilt, yet folk on here still act like they're simultaneously guilty while also falsely accused.

user9630721458 · 15/09/2023 11:46

@CoffeeCantata I don't think we covered it at school in the 80s. I only got to study in depth in Higher Ed! Would be good to hear from more recent students if it's covered in schools/colleges. And is it the sort of contextualised, rounded coverage you studied, or is it just a bit on Will Wilberforce?

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 11:36

Hobbi
Your relentless whataboutery is akin to insisting we teach that the 15th century Ottoman conquest of Bosnia and Herzegovina is equally relevant as WWII to British children.

Relentless?* *😀He he!

The OP includes the phrase 'part of everyone's culture'. Therefore it's not whataboutery to suggest OP takes a comprehensive, broadly historical and international view. They didn't say 'part of UK culture' - or are you suggesting that's what is implied? If that's the case, no wonder there's misunderstanding.

What puzzles me is that when I was at school in the 70s we were taught the evils of slavery (both at my private prep school and later at state secondary). I well remember having a lesson on the famous plan of a slave ship, showing the people crammed in. We learned all about the triangular trade, the way the trade winds facilitated it, the sugar, tea and later, cotton etc. and links to the Industrial Revolution. Also, the Manchester Cotton Famine and the way the workers supported the American slaves' cause. Plus, of course, the abolitionist movement.

I just don't get why anyone has suddenly been taken by surprise by this. It's not something that's been covered up - it was very much on the educational agenda in my day. Has it dropped off in recent years? It's the pretence that it's been covered up in some way that I find completely crazy. No, it hasn't - what point are people trying to make here? Nothing I've recently read on the subject has been new to me, yet there's a strong implication that somehow 'now it can be told'. Is it something that's happened since the National Curriculum was introduced? Feel free to enlighten me.

LeaderBee · 15/09/2023 11:29

Newusername1273 · 15/09/2023 10:44

But you can also argue industrialisation benefited everyone globally. The technology, once invented, was exported pretty quickly and that's without the huge improvement in workers rights, living conditions, water quality, sanitation, health care etc.

"Cheap" (slave) labour facilitates change. Look at any of the big empires and what underpins them all? Cheap/slave labour. The exploitation of defeated enemies, the trading of children, and the othering of people not of their kind.

It is why we still see it happening now with the developing nations or at its worst in China. Slavery is evil but it will never stop while small dick energy runs the world.

I don't follow your point?

Of course it affected people globally, it created a foreign market for the goods which were produced and shifted favour to the goods producing countries, making Britain even more economically powerful - on the flip side, it created a disparity of wealth between ourselves and the goods consuming countries.

I was giving an example how the common man benefit from the slave trade, whether or not industrialisation affected everyone globally it is at least partially a result of the slave trade that it even happened.

greengreengrass25 · 15/09/2023 11:14

Yes so our modern day society also benefited from their exploitation

Newusername1273 · 15/09/2023 11:12

user9630721458 · 15/09/2023 11:05

You have only to look at Blake or any of the radicals at the time to conclude the IR was pretty terrible for the working classes. Enclosure acts drove them off land into cities, children and adults were forced into cities, living in slums, working in factories with no working rights and blamed for poverty as a moral failing. If things improved you'd have to consider the fight of the working classes in unions, in protests such as the Peterloo Massacre, and the huge effort after WWII to equalise society. Yes the IR produced the middle classes, but there were many who existed beneath that.

Exactly.

You have two sides: one of significant, and disgusting levels of oppression and exploitation. The other of invention, creativity, and social reform.

The two go hand in hand and need teaching simultaneously.

user9630721458 · 15/09/2023 11:05

You have only to look at Blake or any of the radicals at the time to conclude the IR was pretty terrible for the working classes. Enclosure acts drove them off land into cities, children and adults were forced into cities, living in slums, working in factories with no working rights and blamed for poverty as a moral failing. If things improved you'd have to consider the fight of the working classes in unions, in protests such as the Peterloo Massacre, and the huge effort after WWII to equalise society. Yes the IR produced the middle classes, but there were many who existed beneath that.

Newusername1273 · 15/09/2023 10:44

LeaderBee · 15/09/2023 10:33

The less nobly born people might not have benefitted from slavery immediately, but the huge amounts of money that slavery added to the economy will have given the capital necessary to fund research into medicine and STEM fields which eventually would result in breakthroughts that the "common man" would use in every day life, maybe not immediately, but perhaps 5, 10, 20, years later.

The industrial revolution was in part facilitated by money from the slave trade and the ability for products to be mass produced and produced cheaply, meaning EVERYONE could afford them

Mass production lowered the costs of much needed tools, clothes and other household items for the common (That is, nonaristocratic) people, which allowed them to save money for other things and to build personal wealth.

Edited

But you can also argue industrialisation benefited everyone globally. The technology, once invented, was exported pretty quickly and that's without the huge improvement in workers rights, living conditions, water quality, sanitation, health care etc.

"Cheap" (slave) labour facilitates change. Look at any of the big empires and what underpins them all? Cheap/slave labour. The exploitation of defeated enemies, the trading of children, and the othering of people not of their kind.

It is why we still see it happening now with the developing nations or at its worst in China. Slavery is evil but it will never stop while small dick energy runs the world.

greengreengrass25 · 15/09/2023 10:42

A lot of the Scottish aristocracy also played a part in slavery

LeaderBee · 15/09/2023 10:33

Coyoacan · 15/09/2023 04:38

I so disagree. As you say that aristocratic family benefitted, but how did other less nobly born people benefit.

I personally still have problems reading Jane Austen because the young men at the gambling tables, for example, were often gambling with the money from their estates in Ireland and/or their plantations in Jamaica.

But the English working class were not exactly living the high life

The less nobly born people might not have benefitted from slavery immediately, but the huge amounts of money that slavery added to the economy will have given the capital necessary to fund research into medicine and STEM fields which eventually would result in breakthroughts that the "common man" would use in every day life, maybe not immediately, but perhaps 5, 10, 20, years later.

The industrial revolution was in part facilitated by money from the slave trade and the ability for products to be mass produced and produced cheaply, meaning EVERYONE could afford them

Mass production lowered the costs of much needed tools, clothes and other household items for the common (That is, nonaristocratic) people, which allowed them to save money for other things and to build personal wealth.

greengreengrass25 · 15/09/2023 10:05

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 09:10

Yes, OP, but only if ALL known slavery is included, and not just that connected with the British trans-Atlantic slave trade.

You'd need to state that all advanced civilisations from the early Near-Eastern cultures (Sumerians, Mespotamians) to the Egyptians, Greeks, Romans to name but a few, depended on slaves.

We have less information about other areas, but we know for sure that the North African states (Barbary) used and traded in slaves and that Sub-Saharan African peoples had slaves themselves and also facilitated the Trans-Atlantic trade.

As long as it's put in context, and not made out that the British were some kind of evil freaks of history, then fine.

And I agree that people need to focus on modern slavery - all those using recreational drugs, for example, are participating in slavery, but (as with the tea an sugar consumers of 18th century England) are they prepared to face up to it?

It was taught in textbooks at one point in Y8 history that the Middle Eastern slave masters were somehow good as the slaves could buy their freedom and were taken in wars but only the Europeans were bad

Really balanced view

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 09:25

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 09:10

Yes, OP, but only if ALL known slavery is included, and not just that connected with the British trans-Atlantic slave trade.

You'd need to state that all advanced civilisations from the early Near-Eastern cultures (Sumerians, Mespotamians) to the Egyptians, Greeks, Romans to name but a few, depended on slaves.

We have less information about other areas, but we know for sure that the North African states (Barbary) used and traded in slaves and that Sub-Saharan African peoples had slaves themselves and also facilitated the Trans-Atlantic trade.

As long as it's put in context, and not made out that the British were some kind of evil freaks of history, then fine.

And I agree that people need to focus on modern slavery - all those using recreational drugs, for example, are participating in slavery, but (as with the tea an sugar consumers of 18th century England) are they prepared to face up to it?

Please read the OP. The transatlantic slave trade has a continuous connection to and influence on modern British life and culture. Your relentless whataboutery is akin to insisting we teach that the 15th century Ottoman conquest of Bosnia and Herzegovina is equally relevant as WWII to British children.

GodessOfThunder · 15/09/2023 09:21

CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 09:10

Yes, OP, but only if ALL known slavery is included, and not just that connected with the British trans-Atlantic slave trade.

You'd need to state that all advanced civilisations from the early Near-Eastern cultures (Sumerians, Mespotamians) to the Egyptians, Greeks, Romans to name but a few, depended on slaves.

We have less information about other areas, but we know for sure that the North African states (Barbary) used and traded in slaves and that Sub-Saharan African peoples had slaves themselves and also facilitated the Trans-Atlantic trade.

As long as it's put in context, and not made out that the British were some kind of evil freaks of history, then fine.

And I agree that people need to focus on modern slavery - all those using recreational drugs, for example, are participating in slavery, but (as with the tea an sugar consumers of 18th century England) are they prepared to face up to it?

What do you worry will happen if all this context isn’t provided?

OP posts:
CoffeeCantata · 15/09/2023 09:10

Yes, OP, but only if ALL known slavery is included, and not just that connected with the British trans-Atlantic slave trade.

You'd need to state that all advanced civilisations from the early Near-Eastern cultures (Sumerians, Mespotamians) to the Egyptians, Greeks, Romans to name but a few, depended on slaves.

We have less information about other areas, but we know for sure that the North African states (Barbary) used and traded in slaves and that Sub-Saharan African peoples had slaves themselves and also facilitated the Trans-Atlantic trade.

As long as it's put in context, and not made out that the British were some kind of evil freaks of history, then fine.

And I agree that people need to focus on modern slavery - all those using recreational drugs, for example, are participating in slavery, but (as with the tea an sugar consumers of 18th century England) are they prepared to face up to it?

GodessOfThunder · 15/09/2023 08:31

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/09/2023 08:12

We're four pages in and certain posters are still pretending it isn't taught. It has been part of the UK curriculum for over 40 years.
Is the confusion that the US doesn't teach and acknowledge it appropriately? Or is it because as an early poster said some people don't 'feel' as though its taught so their feelings trump the facts?
In which case it's back to the question of how people's understanding and knowledge should be manifested to appease or acknowledge those who 'feel' overlooked. I asked that question pages back.
But it isn't whataboutery to say there are parts of British history that are deliberately overlooked and haven't ever been in the curriculum because tbh England still benefits every day and does not want to reckon with that part of its past and present (Scotland, Ireland, India, GRT - are just a few).

No confusion here.

Not every child studies slavery at GCSE or A level.

Earlier exposure is fairly lightweight (at least in my direct experience as a pupil and a parent).

It’s not true that every adult under 40 was taught about slavery at school in substantive way.

There are very many adults who lack knowledge as evidenced on this thread, and hold prejudiced views as a consequence.

Empire (the thread isn’t just about slavery) is less taught, yet it’s impossible to understand the multicultural globally connected Britain of today without knowing something of its history.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread