Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
IvorTheEngineDriver · 15/09/2023 17:46

In the immortal words of the late Adge Cutler "I weren't there, so I don't care."

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:41

Middlelanehogger · 15/09/2023 17:36

The fact that most of the people who go on about how we need to apologise for historical transatlantic slavery are also enthusiastically in favour of "sex workers" with no acknowledgement of the horrors TODAY of sex trafficking particularly grinds my gears!

Do you have any proof of this strange and illogical allegation about “most people”?

Seems extraordinary.

CallumDansTransitVan · 15/09/2023 17:40

MasterBeth · 15/09/2023 17:20

why certain ethnicities do better than others is anyones guess

Guess what?

Some people have thought about it a little bit harder than you have, and their conclusions are a bit more thorough than just "anyone's guess":

https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=report+on+educational+achievement+across+ethnicities+uk&hl=en&as_sdt=0&as_vis=1&oi=scholart

Edited

Perhaps you could link one which shows students from equally poor backgrounds and how their attainment reflects compared to other students.
As example. Take students from Moss Side Manchester, Glasgow East & Peckham. Do White students in any of these areas regularly do considerably better than their POC counterparts?

MoxieFox
Nail hit firmly on the head there. Poverty is the number one reason for poor diet & low education attainment. That isn't a Black only thing. No matter how much you wish it was.

Middlelanehogger · 15/09/2023 17:36

The fact that most of the people who go on about how we need to apologise for historical transatlantic slavery are also enthusiastically in favour of "sex workers" with no acknowledgement of the horrors TODAY of sex trafficking particularly grinds my gears!

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:35

Rubyupbeat · 15/09/2023 17:28

Why don't people show as much passion over modern day slavery? There is more slavery now than at any other time in history, this includes babies and small children, black, white and Asian. Yes historic slavery was awful, but if everyone fought and protested about the slavery of today, something may get done, even in a small way.

First, people do. Second, no there is not more slavery now than at any other time in history after you adjust for how many billions more people are alive now. Thirdly, things are getting done about it. I’m shocked that someone who professes to be concerned about modern slavery isn’t aware of the extensive international pressure and funding of anti-slavery law enforcement has been and is being done worldwide to combat it.

Middlelanehogger · 15/09/2023 17:33

I actually agree that slavery and colonialism are exceptionally poorly understood today.

The emphasis on slavery and colonialism as "historical" and particularly in reference to transatlantic slavery in the 1700s and colonialism in Africa in the 1800s, and its teaching as "bad stuff that bad people did for the sake of being bad", is the primary cause of the misconceptions.

A proper understanding of slavery and colonialism would include grappling with the economic forces and contemporary rationalisations that resulted in these setups - and would help us recognise it in different forms today. China doesn't have any colonies on paper - but are its operations in Africa are essentially extractive colonial projects just without the settler aspect? How should we think about loans from the IMF? Did any countries do colonialism "better" or "worse" and why? What modern forms of indentured labour are acceptable (prisons) or not (taking maids' passports away)?

Wailing about how Edward so-and-so from 1785 inherited a bit of cash from the plantations is utterly useless in terms of helping us address modern challenges and ethical questions.

CallumDansTransitVan · 15/09/2023 17:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rubyupbeat · 15/09/2023 17:28

Why don't people show as much passion over modern day slavery? There is more slavery now than at any other time in history, this includes babies and small children, black, white and Asian. Yes historic slavery was awful, but if everyone fought and protested about the slavery of today, something may get done, even in a small way.

MasterBeth · 15/09/2023 17:20

why certain ethnicities do better than others is anyones guess

Guess what?

Some people have thought about it a little bit harder than you have, and their conclusions are a bit more thorough than just "anyone's guess":

https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=report+on+educational+achievement+across+ethnicities+uk&hl=en&as_sdt=0&as_vis=1&oi=scholart

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:19

@MCOut you are wasting your time with TransitVan as their posts are full of denial that institutional racism exists in our society.

As Ibram X. Kendi said,
”This denial of racism is the heartbeat of racism. Where there is suffering from racist policies, there are denials that those policies are racist. The beat of denial sounds the same across time and space”

The allegory of the red and pink flowers might help transitvan understand better that different ethnicities do not have the same opportunities and that poverty is the #1 factor causing the poor diet that then causes health inequalities such as obesity, diabetes, rickets, etc.
https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/confronting-racism-denial-using-stories-to-communicate-across-divides

A picture of a door with the word 'Closed' on it and text below that reads "Racism structures Open/Closed signs on our society.

Confronting racism denial: using stories to communicate across divides

Professor Camara Phyllis Jones believes that allegorical stories can help initiate conversations about systemic racism and its complexities.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/confronting-racism-denial-using-stories-to-communicate-across-divides

CallumDansTransitVan · 15/09/2023 17:06

MCOut · 15/09/2023 05:35

Ok so we can distill your points down to overall Black people are simply incompetent & lazy and white people are just superior. No different from the ideas perpetuated in slavery. This is why teaching inclusive British history is important. These racist views are pervasive and enduring but hopefully generations to come will have empathy and more balanced views so they make fairer decisions.

Your first point is irrelevant because individual characteristics are controlled to control job, level and qualifications. This phenomenon is seen at all levels and typically large organisations who conduct ethnicity pay gap reviews have pay bands but do not negotiate salaries at graduate levels. Most of these organisations are upfront about having a problem.

Regarding maternal deaths, if this were the case you would expect more proportionate levels. More like 1.6, not 4 times more likely. Again, the NHS is upfront about having a problem.

Recently you’ve been posting threads about the black community to encourage abuse in the guise of debate. Just pointing this out so other poc can decide whether to engage. Had I noticed prior I would have written you off as it’s less a case of apathy or an unconsidered viewpoint and more active conscious anti blackness.

You come from a place in which I highly doubt you've spent any meaningful time with black people. I’m assuming from your initial post you’ve received little if any formal education with regards to black people, you have no lived experience as a black person. Yet are happy to make unqualified statements on a public forum to influence people who will make decisions which affect poc.

You asked me those questions. I gave you well founded answers.

No matter your colour, age or gender:
If you stack shelfs in Tesco you get the same wages.
If you drive a truck for Eddie Stobart you get the same wages.
If you work as a nurse, you get the same wages as same band and role.

There is documented evidence of certain health conditions being more prevalent in certain ethnicities.
There is documented evidence of higher levels of obesity in certain ethnicities.
There is documented evidence of poor diet within certain ethnicities.

Colleges and Universities give everyone the opportunity to educate themselves. why certain ethnicities do better than others is anyones guess. But in most cases is likely down to the student.

Now, not one of those statements are racist, So I ask you not to call me one.

LeaderBee · 15/09/2023 16:35

Coyoacan · 15/09/2023 15:31

@LeaderBee

So you believe in the long-disproved trickle-down theory of economics.

If you have evidence to present to the contrary i'd be willing to see it.

MCOut · 15/09/2023 16:07

@narniabusiness

Thanks for sharing this. It’s very interesting to see.

@GodessOfThunder

Most are non statutory though. Now I think teachers who work in schools which serve poc demographics will teach accordingly but I highly doubt most will choose to teach these options when faced with more European centric and perhaps more familiar choices. It feels like lip service.

Coyoacan · 15/09/2023 15:31

@LeaderBee

So you believe in the long-disproved trickle-down theory of economics.

Abitofalark · 15/09/2023 14:57

I meant to reply to Myguineapig.

Abitofalark · 15/09/2023 14:53

Those two things you mention are abstractions - it was part of a longterm broader system of oppressive conditions of land tenure, poverty, status and rights etc. Yes, grain was available but exported while people were dying. There wasn't just 'the famine' - it is called The Great Famine or The Great Hunger - as there were many lesser famines or crises. There is a lot of history to it and relatively few will know it in England just as little is generally known or remembered about many other histories.

GodessOfThunder · 15/09/2023 14:40

narniabusiness · 15/09/2023 14:33

I decided to have a look at what the History curriculum is for History in secondary school at KS3, which is prior to GCSE, so should give a good idea of what subjects are covered in school at the moment.

So the curriculum is below and I've highlighted the subjects which have appeared on this thread.

The development of Church, state and society in Medieval Britain 1066-1509 Examples (non-statutory) This could include:
 the Norman Conquest  Christendom, the importance of religion and the Crusades
 the struggle between Church and crown
 Magna Carta and the emergence of Parliament
 the English campaigns to conquer Wales and Scotland up to 1314
 society, economy and culture: for example, feudalism, religion in daily life (parishes, monasteries, abbeys), farming, trade and towns (especially the wool trade), art, architecture and literature
 the Black Death and its social and economic impact
 the Peasants’ Revolt
 the Hundred Years War
 the Wars of the Roses; Henry VII and attempts to restore stability

The development of Church, state and society in Britain 1509-1745
Examples (non-statutory) This could include:
 Renaissance and Reformation in Europe
 the English Reformation and Counter Reformation (Henry VIII to Mary I)
 the Elizabethan religious settlement and conflict with Catholics (including Scotland, Spain and Ireland)
the first colony in America and first contact with India
 the causes and events of the civil wars throughout Britain
 the Interregnum (including Cromwell in Ireland)
 the Restoration, ‘Glorious Revolution’ and power of Parliament
 the Act of Union of 1707, the Hanoverian succession and the Jacobite rebellions of 1715 and 1745
 society, economy and culture across the period: for example, work and leisure in town and country, religion and superstition in daily life, theatre, art, music and literature

Ideas, political power, industry and empire: Britain, 1745-1901
Examples (non-statutory) This could include:
 the Enlightenment in Europe and Britain, with links back to 17th-Century thinkers and scientists and the founding of the Royal Society
Britain’s transatlantic slave trade: its effects and its eventual abolition
 the Seven Years War and The American War of Independence
 the French Revolutionary wars
 Britain as the first industrial nation – the impact on society
 party politics, extension of the franchise and social reform
 the development of the British Empire with a depth study (for example, of India)
 Ireland and Home Rule
 Darwin’s ‘On The Origin of Species’

Challenges for Britain, Europe and the wider world 1901 to the present day
In addition to studying the Holocaust, this could include: Examples (non-statutory)
 women’s suffrage
 the First World War and the Peace Settlement
 the inter-war years: the Great Depression and the rise of dictators
 the Second World War and the wartime leadership of Winston Churchill
 the creation of the Welfare State
 Indian independence and end of Empire
 social, cultural and technological change in post-war British society
 Britain’s place in the world since 1945

A local history study
Examples (non-statutory)
 a depth study linked to one of the British areas of study listed above
 a study over time, testing how far sites in their locality reflect aspects of national history (some sites may predate 1066)

The study of an aspect or theme in British history that consolidates and extends pupils’ chronological knowledge from before 1066 Examples (non-statutory)
 the changing nature of political power in Britain, traced through selective case studies from the Iron Age to the present
 Britain’s changing landscape from the Iron Age to the present
 a study of an aspect of social history, such as the impact through time of the migration of people to, from and within the British Isles
 a study in depth into a significant turning point: for example, the Neolithic Revolution

At least one study of a significant society or issue in world history and its interconnections with other world developments [for example, Mughal India 1526-1857; China’s Qing dynasty1644-1911; Changing Russian empires c.1800-1989; USA in the 20th Century].

That’s good to see. Sadly a lot of older people lack this knowledge and some are resistant or unreceptive to engaging with it in museums etc.

OP posts:
narniabusiness · 15/09/2023 14:33

I decided to have a look at what the History curriculum is for History in secondary school at KS3, which is prior to GCSE, so should give a good idea of what subjects are covered in school at the moment.

So the curriculum is below and I've highlighted the subjects which have appeared on this thread.

The development of Church, state and society in Medieval Britain 1066-1509 Examples (non-statutory) This could include:
 the Norman Conquest  Christendom, the importance of religion and the Crusades
 the struggle between Church and crown
 Magna Carta and the emergence of Parliament
 the English campaigns to conquer Wales and Scotland up to 1314
 society, economy and culture: for example, feudalism, religion in daily life (parishes, monasteries, abbeys), farming, trade and towns (especially the wool trade), art, architecture and literature
 the Black Death and its social and economic impact
 the Peasants’ Revolt
 the Hundred Years War
 the Wars of the Roses; Henry VII and attempts to restore stability

The development of Church, state and society in Britain 1509-1745
Examples (non-statutory) This could include:
 Renaissance and Reformation in Europe
 the English Reformation and Counter Reformation (Henry VIII to Mary I)
 the Elizabethan religious settlement and conflict with Catholics (including Scotland, Spain and Ireland)
the first colony in America and first contact with India
 the causes and events of the civil wars throughout Britain
 the Interregnum (including Cromwell in Ireland)
 the Restoration, ‘Glorious Revolution’ and power of Parliament
 the Act of Union of 1707, the Hanoverian succession and the Jacobite rebellions of 1715 and 1745
 society, economy and culture across the period: for example, work and leisure in town and country, religion and superstition in daily life, theatre, art, music and literature

Ideas, political power, industry and empire: Britain, 1745-1901
Examples (non-statutory) This could include:
 the Enlightenment in Europe and Britain, with links back to 17th-Century thinkers and scientists and the founding of the Royal Society
Britain’s transatlantic slave trade: its effects and its eventual abolition
 the Seven Years War and The American War of Independence
 the French Revolutionary wars
 Britain as the first industrial nation – the impact on society
 party politics, extension of the franchise and social reform
 the development of the British Empire with a depth study (for example, of India)
 Ireland and Home Rule
 Darwin’s ‘On The Origin of Species’

Challenges for Britain, Europe and the wider world 1901 to the present day
In addition to studying the Holocaust, this could include: Examples (non-statutory)
 women’s suffrage
 the First World War and the Peace Settlement
 the inter-war years: the Great Depression and the rise of dictators
 the Second World War and the wartime leadership of Winston Churchill
 the creation of the Welfare State
 Indian independence and end of Empire
 social, cultural and technological change in post-war British society
 Britain’s place in the world since 1945

A local history study
Examples (non-statutory)
 a depth study linked to one of the British areas of study listed above
 a study over time, testing how far sites in their locality reflect aspects of national history (some sites may predate 1066)

The study of an aspect or theme in British history that consolidates and extends pupils’ chronological knowledge from before 1066 Examples (non-statutory)
 the changing nature of political power in Britain, traced through selective case studies from the Iron Age to the present
 Britain’s changing landscape from the Iron Age to the present
 a study of an aspect of social history, such as the impact through time of the migration of people to, from and within the British Isles
 a study in depth into a significant turning point: for example, the Neolithic Revolution

At least one study of a significant society or issue in world history and its interconnections with other world developments [for example, Mughal India 1526-1857; China’s Qing dynasty1644-1911; Changing Russian empires c.1800-1989; USA in the 20th Century].

GodessOfThunder · 15/09/2023 14:26

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 13:52

Careful, won't be long before someone will respond to you insisting that the Irish be grateful for the British and all that they did for their country.

Great point.

OP posts:
MyGuineaPigIsInnocent41 · 15/09/2023 14:16

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 13:52

Careful, won't be long before someone will respond to you insisting that the Irish be grateful for the British and all that they did for their country.

They will just have to eat Biscuit then!

Callmesleepy · 15/09/2023 14:08

@nonheme yes but, again, very multicultural school in London so I'm not sure it was standard. We did some of the good bits of colonialism as well but it was predominantly presented as negative which I think is fair. I'm still not totally clear on the power interface between the government and the east India company despite doing my own research as much of the information available has a serious spin on it.

@Hobbi yes it was an addendum to the first famine. Again, some nuance on the good of Cromwell's new model army and his impact on the class system vs how he acted in Ireland. I think the famine should be prioritised now as it's the same mass movement of people due to manmade situations we'll see with climate change.

I keep coming back to the importance of being able to challenge what we're told and knowing how to research ourselves as crucial rather than necessarily depth on specific topics. We need history to inform how we act today.

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 13:52

MyGuineaPigIsInnocent41 · 15/09/2023 13:49

History should definitely teach an unbiased view of each side, as it were. I'm shocked that I myself , as someone who did history at both GCSE and A Level and to this day still enjoy reading historical books, was taught so little about the history of Ireland, and my ignorance drilling this subject is pretty bad. For so long I assumed the Potato famine was just about bugs eating the crops, I had no idea that the British has basically refused the Irish access to food they could have as part of their control.

And to think that only a few decades ago, Irish people had difficulties renting accomodation. Paddy jokes are still widely considered acceptable, though thankfully less so.

Careful, won't be long before someone will respond to you insisting that the Irish be grateful for the British and all that they did for their country.

Hobbi · 15/09/2023 13:50

@Callmesleepy

There was famine and plague in Ireland while Cromwell engaged in his genocide but 'the famine' was much later. He did, however, portray the Irish as lazy, brutal and subhuman and therefore deserving of their treatment. Word for word and image for image, this was replicated to justify the transatlantic slave trade. Much of what we now describe as racist language and tropes originated in Cromwell's tactics in Ireland. This is another reason that this particular slave trade is of particular importance to our culture, despite apologists claiming it's equivalent to Ancient Rome or Carthage or some such nonsense.

MyGuineaPigIsInnocent41 · 15/09/2023 13:49

History should definitely teach an unbiased view of each side, as it were. I'm shocked that I myself , as someone who did history at both GCSE and A Level and to this day still enjoy reading historical books, was taught so little about the history of Ireland, and my ignorance drilling this subject is pretty bad. For so long I assumed the Potato famine was just about bugs eating the crops, I had no idea that the British has basically refused the Irish access to food they could have as part of their control.

And to think that only a few decades ago, Irish people had difficulties renting accomodation. Paddy jokes are still widely considered acceptable, though thankfully less so.

nonheme · 15/09/2023 13:44

Callmesleepy · 15/09/2023 13:22

I left school in 2010 and definitely learnt about slavery. I didn't do history GCSE so it would have been y7-9. I remember learning about it in quite a nuanced way as clearly an absolutely appalling thing and one that a lot of people worked very hard to combat including both Harriet Tubman and William Wilberforce. I think we also touched on the Irish famine in the context of Cromwell and am pretty sure India was discussed at some points although that may have been due to the school being predominantly Asian. I definitely learnt about castes somewhere.

The thing that drives my nervousness around the current way things are presented is that it seems really divisive. We've seen this happen before - I've seen the argument that racism as it stands today was pushed to prevent the indentured servants and slaves teaming up against the people oppressing then both. What I'm seeing currently seems to present all black people as victims and all white people as aggressors which ignores intersectionality and context. The nuances matter.

From my education I'd say the best thing we can teach children is how to understand how nations operate and how to see where they're being manipulated. By all means touch on all sorts of topics and pick a few key ones to explore in greater depth to properly understand the patterns so they can apply them to other situations. It's not like world leaders are inventing wholly new methods, they're just applying old ones differently.

Did you learn about the colonies and what happened there? It seems a large part of history does not exist in British curriculum.