Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
mids2019 · 14/09/2023 00:03

@Chickenkeev

I agree unambiguously that slavery was wrong and should be taught as such. However care has to be taken to not suggest it is a historical wrong that the current generation of white children need to be guilty of.

I think there is a difference in stating 'slavery is wrong' and 'slavery is wrong and is the root of racial division today so giving justification for ideas such as positive discrimination to right past wrongs'

all history is important but I just happen to think that those that advocate a more pronounced teaching of slavery aren't entirely not motivated by politics.

Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 23:57

AlexandriasWindmill · 13/09/2023 23:49

I don't understand why there is a perception people in the UK don't know about slavery and colonialism. They've always been a large part of the curriculum. I was taught about it in primary school and high school. Same for our DCs.
Unlike the British history in Ireland which hasn't ever been properly taught and acknowledged. Or the ongoing institutional racism against Gypsy, Roma and Traveller - which is never taught or addressed.

It 'feels' like people don't get it there. And having met a history teacher who hadn't a breeze, it seems it's not impossible. When it comes to NI and people don't know what they're on about, it's very (very!) annoying.

AlexandriasWindmill · 13/09/2023 23:49

I don't understand why there is a perception people in the UK don't know about slavery and colonialism. They've always been a large part of the curriculum. I was taught about it in primary school and high school. Same for our DCs.
Unlike the British history in Ireland which hasn't ever been properly taught and acknowledged. Or the ongoing institutional racism against Gypsy, Roma and Traveller - which is never taught or addressed.

Isleofdeer · 13/09/2023 23:48

Jasperdale · 13/09/2023 22:21

I feel not one jot of guilt over whatever my ancestors may or may not have done, as I didn’t do it! I have heard people who think we should be groveling and apologizing till kingdom come when we have personally done nothing wrong. It’s history, people were treated terribly (and still are in some places )and we should learn from it and move on if there is nothing we can actually do about it now.

Okay...but do you consider all the advantages you still enjoy today - and which came about because of the Empire - when you decide that you're not personally responsible for anything?
Of course you can do nothing about the past, but you can change the present.
No need at all to apologise - but are you willing to empty your museums?
To pay back the millions and millions (in todays money) to the countries your ancestors stole from? Because the past is past of course, no need to feel guilty about things you can't change, but you can influence the present and future.
You are responsible for that.

Scarfweather · 13/09/2023 23:42

ruby1957 · 13/09/2023 23:10

I doubt that these signs were that prevalent in the 1980s!
They were a symptom of 1950s attitudes in SOME cities in the UK.

I’m giving MY experience of growing up in the 1980s and the signs were in numerous places in my town. I made no comment on the UK as a whole.
If you’re doubting it, then I guess you didn’t live it? Enjoy your ignorance.

Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 23:42

mids2019 · 13/09/2023 23:37

Is there an argument to say history should be taught in an apolitical way such that the way history is taught does not manifestly promote a political view point? For instance focusing on the history of industrial action unduly may promote union leaders as heroic and therefore engender left leaning thoughts on student's minds?

I think given the (relative) recency of slavery in historical terms we need to be careful about how much prominence we give it in British schools especially if it is implicitly used to suggest that black poor children may have a greater right to social injustice than white poor children as they can trace the roots of their current poverty to the historical reverberations of slavery?

I agree with the OP but I think thought needs to given to how the knowledge of slavery is taken by children of different races and how it moulds their political and current social.perspectives. I do not feel white children should feel shame and black children should nurture grievance from historica!.events.

I think you're correct, but to a point. I don't think slavery or naziism should be taught without outright criticism of them. Some things are just wrong and should be labelled as such.

Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 23:39

Orders76 · 13/09/2023 23:30

Love that other Irish people got here before me.
We could start by utterly changing English history teaching. I believe its still very sympathetic to Cromwell and kings before him who fecked with our chieftain system. Loosing our population, our language etc......

I find it so strange that modern, relevant history seems to be a bit ignored, but kings from a million years ago are seemingly important. I really don't get it!

mids2019 · 13/09/2023 23:37

Is there an argument to say history should be taught in an apolitical way such that the way history is taught does not manifestly promote a political view point? For instance focusing on the history of industrial action unduly may promote union leaders as heroic and therefore engender left leaning thoughts on student's minds?

I think given the (relative) recency of slavery in historical terms we need to be careful about how much prominence we give it in British schools especially if it is implicitly used to suggest that black poor children may have a greater right to social injustice than white poor children as they can trace the roots of their current poverty to the historical reverberations of slavery?

I agree with the OP but I think thought needs to given to how the knowledge of slavery is taken by children of different races and how it moulds their political and current social.perspectives. I do not feel white children should feel shame and black children should nurture grievance from historica!.events.

Orders76 · 13/09/2023 23:30

Love that other Irish people got here before me.
We could start by utterly changing English history teaching. I believe its still very sympathetic to Cromwell and kings before him who fecked with our chieftain system. Loosing our population, our language etc......

Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 23:20

DuesToTheDirt · 13/09/2023 23:10

I wasn’t taught about slavery of any type, not even the colonisation of the Irish at school. It’s wrong.

There frankly isn't time to teach the whole of history at school. I am always reading on here the many things that apparently should be taught in school - slavery, the Holocaust, the Romans, the Tudors, the Irish situation, the Scottish Clearances, WWI, WWII, the Cold War, the Civil War, the British Empire, the Industrial Revolution. And that's just for starters. School should give us some critical thinking skills, a few basics that are essential for a functioning life, such as maths and literacy, and methods for learning - the rest is up to us.

Can you please not refer to it as 'the Irish situation'? It's history, it's not a 'situation'. It certainly wasn't for us anyway.

mids2019 · 13/09/2023 23:13

@GodessOfThunder

I agree with your post in that slavery should be taught as a significant part of history in a balanced factual way.

However we should not make teaching of history a platform for perpetuating grievance for which there is definitely potential. In the US the teaching of slavery does have direct political ramifications so if we are looking at history purely academically and not as a political tool we need to be careful.

How many that want a fuller role of slavery in our school curricula would adhere to concepts like 'white privilege ' for example and want to use this subject to act as a platform to highlight current racial injustice with all its contemporary political focus?

I am not disputing that history should not be taught as accurately as possible but ðo we question the motives of those who wish changes in the portrayal of history? Is history as an academic discipline all they are concerned about?

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 23:12

Lantyslee · 13/09/2023 19:54

I've just been reading the thread about the Roman Empire (how often do you think about it?) and the level of interest and enthusiasm is really interesting. People seem to view it positively. I guess the colonised and enslaved Britons might have felt differently though.

It made me wonder how long has to pass after the fall of an Empire for people in a formerly colonised country to feel personally disconnected from it and simply view it as an interesting part of their country's history.

It’s an interesting question. I’ve thought about it too.

Perhaps at least as long as there aren’t lingering injustices as a consequence.

OP posts:
Glowie · 13/09/2023 23:12

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 22:49

Be proud of whatever you like, but personally I reserve my pride for my own accomplishments, not those of a bunch of people the vast majority of whom I’m not even related to, who lived several centuries ago.

Edited

If you don't care what people are proud of, then why did you bring it up?

DuesToTheDirt · 13/09/2023 23:10

I wasn’t taught about slavery of any type, not even the colonisation of the Irish at school. It’s wrong.

There frankly isn't time to teach the whole of history at school. I am always reading on here the many things that apparently should be taught in school - slavery, the Holocaust, the Romans, the Tudors, the Irish situation, the Scottish Clearances, WWI, WWII, the Cold War, the Civil War, the British Empire, the Industrial Revolution. And that's just for starters. School should give us some critical thinking skills, a few basics that are essential for a functioning life, such as maths and literacy, and methods for learning - the rest is up to us.

ruby1957 · 13/09/2023 23:10

Scarfweather · 13/09/2023 22:28

Ok, I’ll say it - I agree with your sentiments OP, but as a white person of extremely downtrodden Irish heritage and growing up in the 1980s with the ‘no Irish, no dogs, no blacks’ signs in local buildings, I feel what I describe as a kind of kinship to those with ancestors affected by slavery….but that seems to not be allowed because I’m ‘white’.
I wasn’t taught about slavery of any type, not even the colonisation of the Irish at school. It’s wrong.

I doubt that these signs were that prevalent in the 1980s!
They were a symptom of 1950s attitudes in SOME cities in the UK.

molotovcupcakes · 13/09/2023 23:04

I think many do. The industrial revolution was possible because of colonisation and slavery.

If this is true then why didn’t it happen in the other continents that also had slavery at that time?
I do get your point that the colonies were a kind of trading block for raw materials which may have made them cheaper but all countries trade goods with each other.
Industrialisation in other countries such as Singapore have not included colonisation or slavery so why do you think it was necessary for the development of industrialisation in the UK?

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 23:02

Scarfweather · 13/09/2023 22:28

Ok, I’ll say it - I agree with your sentiments OP, but as a white person of extremely downtrodden Irish heritage and growing up in the 1980s with the ‘no Irish, no dogs, no blacks’ signs in local buildings, I feel what I describe as a kind of kinship to those with ancestors affected by slavery….but that seems to not be allowed because I’m ‘white’.
I wasn’t taught about slavery of any type, not even the colonisation of the Irish at school. It’s wrong.

I personally have no issue with your feelings, in fact anything that can help us understand and empathise with others can only be a good thing.

OP posts:
JuvenileEmu · 13/09/2023 23:02

Spendonsend · 13/09/2023 22:41

I'm perfectly able to be concerned about modern slavery and support attempts to tackle it, and cope with learning about historic slavery and empire at the same time.

So what are you doing about modern slavery?

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 23:01

Jasperdale · 13/09/2023 22:21

I feel not one jot of guilt over whatever my ancestors may or may not have done, as I didn’t do it! I have heard people who think we should be groveling and apologizing till kingdom come when we have personally done nothing wrong. It’s history, people were treated terribly (and still are in some places )and we should learn from it and move on if there is nothing we can actually do about it now.

If this is addressed at me, I specifically said no one needs to feel guilty about events other people participated in in the past.

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 23:00

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 22:57

I’m glad they exist and support that, but their accomplishments aren’t mine to be proud of. I’d rather give them respect and gratitude than make them a source of my own unearned pride.

Fair enough (and a lovely way of espressing that!)

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 13/09/2023 23:00

Family have lived in the West country for centuries.
One ancestor took part in the Monmouth rebellion in 1685. Barbadosed by judge Jefferies at the bloody assizes. That is sent to the West Indies to be a slave.
As you say sugar, tobacco, cotton all farmed by slaves.

As pointed out by this poster, the English ruling class used working class English people as slaves and indentured labourers too, often alongside West African slaves.

The descendants of the working poor in the UK are also still affected by a long term legacy of historical poor treatment. Even today, the heirs of the slave-owning, mill and mine owning class are significantly taller than the working class population.

Working class history in the UK is almost entirely ignored. How many schoolchildren know as much about the Peterloo Massacre or the Irish famines as they do about the Tudor monarchs?

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 22:57

Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 22:54

But would you not be proud of UN Peacekeepers for example? I would be for sure. (My own accomplishments being abysmal and all that ;))

I’m glad they exist and support that, but their accomplishments aren’t mine to be proud of. I’d rather give them respect and gratitude than make them a source of my own unearned pride.

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 13/09/2023 22:54

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 22:49

Be proud of whatever you like, but personally I reserve my pride for my own accomplishments, not those of a bunch of people the vast majority of whom I’m not even related to, who lived several centuries ago.

Edited

But would you not be proud of UN Peacekeepers for example? I would be for sure. (My own accomplishments being abysmal and all that ;))

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 22:53

changeme4this · 13/09/2023 22:49

Whose version of ''history'' do we take as being accurate? Several people can witness a car accident, but all will have their version of events...

I'm watching a local club honour past and current active members, but they have completely left out the names of the inaugural local members who started the club and with less resources than the current day. Several current active members know of course, but that would mean the focus shifts...

I also agree with a previous poster who said let's concern ourselves with the current day slave trade which include the trade of children. Let's do something about those wrongs while we can, rather than pearl clutch about the doings of the past, of which we cannot change.

History is always an ongoing debate. But we seem to accept a version (or a number of versions) as being accurate enough to be used to create plenty history books, documentaries, museums and educational materials. So, I don’t see this as a stumbling block.

History in education and academia is about what happened, why and how in the past not moral balance sheets judged by today’s standards.

OP posts:
GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 22:49

Glowie · 13/09/2023 22:32

It would be difficult to be proud of a future event, so I'm afraid we're stuck with past ones. Every nation/group/person since the dawn of time has done bad things, with slavery being a perennial feature across the world.

Also, I don't believe you, especially with regards to the 'shame' bit, since that is clearly what you're trying to achieve here. Why do you care what I or anybody else is proud of?

The British are allowed to be proud of their heritage and the achievements of their ancestors.

Consider the magnitude of the fact that Britain and the Empire succeeded in drawing a pretty good line under something that had been occuring for thousands of years.
This is also something to be proud of, and since my taxes have gone towards paying for it, perhaps you'll even allow that.

Be proud of whatever you like, but personally I reserve my pride for my own accomplishments, not those of a bunch of people the vast majority of whom I’m not even related to, who lived several centuries ago.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread