Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
WandaWonder · 14/09/2023 07:56

ntmdino · 14/09/2023 07:54

Well, it would seem a little odd for current events to be taught in a history class, wouldn't it?

Why? there is modern history but there is also discussions in history about comparing life now and in the past? it is not all teachers sitting in the front of the classroom droning on about back in the day

ProfessorLayton1 · 14/09/2023 07:55

For me it is not just the wealth disparity , there are so many instances you as a POC are viewed as inferior and discriminated against.
This is because of colonialism and the mentality of one race being superior to other. I completely understand that we have come a long way but it is still not good enough from my point of view.

India was one of the richest country when British empire came to India and they were the poorest when they left. Economic growth of Britain was phenomenal during this time.

Colonialism and its effect - good and bad needs to be taught in schools and it doesn't even get mentioned!

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 07:55

What is fascinating is that often certain groups try to weaponise discussions about slavery and colonialism to pit discriminated groups against each other. Reading this thread you can see the groups that consistently suffer - minorities, women, the poor. Those groups 'fighting' amongst themselves only benefits the wealthy and influential. It's standard 'divide and conquer'. We should all be working together to raise each other's voices and histories.

The absences in history education are where countries/governments feel vulnerable and are still reliant on those groups' exploitation. In the UK that isn't slavery or penal colonies. It's Ireland. It's religious discrimination. It's Gypsy, Roma and Travellers (GRT). It's also women. It's why the current MRA pushback against women's rights is combined with a push to 're-educate'. The battles women thought they had won are being lost at speed - the aggressors need a curriculum that pushes their new agenda and pushes out the history of suffragettes, women's liberation, etc.

ntmdino · 14/09/2023 07:54

WandaWonder · 14/09/2023 07:49

So you don't want speaking of slavery today, you want to pick and choose which bits of history of focus on why? does speaking of modern slavery make you feel threatened?

Well, it would seem a little odd for current events to be taught in a history class, wouldn't it?

WandaWonder · 14/09/2023 07:49

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 07:45

That’s the equivalent of saying “there’s war in Ukraine, so let’s stop studying World War 2”. I’ll assume you don’t agree with that statement, so why make a similar one about past slavery?

Ask yourself what are your motivations for wanting to silence this aspect of the past? It must make you feel threatened in some way.

So you don't want speaking of slavery today, you want to pick and choose which bits of history of focus on why? does speaking of modern slavery make you feel threatened?

Seashellies · 14/09/2023 07:49

That's not to say people could know more but that's the same for any topic surely?

Seashellies · 14/09/2023 07:48

Wilberforce and abolition is traditionally one of the few aspects of slavery many British people have already heard of. It suited elites to propagate this narrative.

I disagree with this, most people not just here but globally have no clue this is what happened and its hardly ever mentioned when this topic comes up on social media etc. I don't agree people aren't aware of our involvement in slavery overall though, I've never met anyone ignorant to it and I grew up on a sink estate and don't hang around solely with enlightened historians or whatever.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 14/09/2023 07:48

Is it? Think my ancestors were too busy trying to eke a living to feed their families.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 07:45

hattie43 · 13/09/2023 21:36

Slavery is going on today . Far better to focus on that .

That’s the equivalent of saying “there’s war in Ukraine, so let’s stop studying World War 2”. I’ll assume you don’t agree with that statement, so why make a similar one about past slavery?

Ask yourself what are your motivations for wanting to silence this aspect of the past? It must make you feel threatened in some way.

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 14/09/2023 07:43

WWII was part of German's history but no I don't think the German people of today have to take the blame, same as anyone from where Genghis Kahn roamed, what about the Romans?

and what do you want people to do about it?

DameWhiskers · 14/09/2023 07:40

@AlexandriasWindmill

iirc we were taught about Australia in the context of penal colonies, forced emigration of DCs from minority and vulnerable British communities, and on the impact on indigenous peoples in Australia. We were also taught about the legacy of ongoing discrimination and land grabs.
What does the Australian curriculum teach about the genocide, displacement and continued discrimination against indigenous peoples? Does it teach it at primary and high school level? In politics or history?

Does Australia teach about the sentencing and crimes that could lead to being exiled? And the ongoing search by families from impoverished, vulnerable and minority groups in Britain whose DCs were sent to Australia without their consent? If those issues are widely known it should help the families here who are still campaigning around those issues and still trying to trace family DCs who were taken.

The curriculum here has changed greatly over time. I wasn't taught a great deal of any of these things as a child of the 70s and 80s. Now, kids have much First Nations history embedded in their curriculums from very early on. I wouldn't suggest they learn much about British children sent to Australia without consent - they learn much more about Australia's indigenous Stolen Generation, where children of indigenous families were forcibly removed by the Government and sent to Children's Homes (where many were abused) or the homes of white people. I only learned about this at university, so I'm pleased things are changing there.

They do learn, in passing I suppose, about the types of crimes that sent people here.

The genocide and ongoing discrimination and racism of First Nations people is taught more at high school level, but not deeply enough, IMO.

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 07:28

It's important to talk about the past to learn from it. Modern slavery and human trafficking needs to be addressed too. It shouldn't be an 'either/or'.
There is a throughline but modern slavery and human trafficking are incredibly complex. It's more akin to organised crime and perpetuated by criminal networks than governments. Although imo all governments tacitly condone it by not closing down known companies that benefit eg Pornhub.
Most victims of trafficking (over 60%) are women and DCs. Most perpetrators (over 60%) are men. No-one ever cares as much about stopping an issue when it mainly affects women and DCs. There is always a lack of political will to police crimes against women and VAWG.

Orders76 · 14/09/2023 07:26

Chickeev in Ireland these things are relevant as they entirely changed the country as it is today.

JamSandle · 14/09/2023 07:17

Slavery is at its height today. There are more slaves today than there have ever been. Sometimes we talk about the past too much and not about today.

Whats the point talking about slavery if we aren't doing anything about modern slavery?

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 07:17

DameWhiskers · 14/09/2023 04:42

@Newusername1273

And this is where the nuance comes in... not every bit of colonisation was done without the consent of the people/governments. A significant number were happy to cooperate with the British.

I'd be interested to know what - if anything - is on the curriculum regarding British colonialism in Australia. That was essentially genocide for the indigenous peoples, and slavery. I live on a documented colonial massacre site. Those killed, including women and children, were hunted down as it was thought they has stolen food from a landowner. After the event, it turned out they hadn't. These sorts of events were not isolated.

c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/map.php

These people had no opportunity to consent.

iirc we were taught about Australia in the context of penal colonies, forced emigration of DCs from minority and vulnerable British communities, and on the impact on indigenous peoples in Australia. We were also taught about the legacy of ongoing discrimination and land grabs.
What does the Australian curriculum teach about the genocide, displacement and continued discrimination against indigenous peoples? Does it teach it at primary and high school level? In politics or history?
Does Australia teach about the sentencing and crimes that could lead to being exiled? And the ongoing search by families from impoverished, vulnerable and minority groups in Britain whose DCs were sent to Australia without their consent? If those issues are widely known it should help the families here who are still campaigning around those issues and still trying to trace family DCs who were taken.

Appleontherocks · 14/09/2023 06:55

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 19:48

I can’t speak about the specific exhibitions you went to as you haven’t named them. But, I think it’s a question of balance. Wilberforce and abolition is traditionally one of the few aspects of slavery many British people have already heard of. It suited elites to propagate this narrative.

Recent exhibitions however, have rightly placed more focus on new knowledge and the victims, of which 3.1 million were transported by Britain. If I went to a Holocaust museum I would find it odd if it focussed too much on those who liberated the camps vs the victims.

Edited

Great thread OP. Unfortunately, I'm too scared to read the comments.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 06:50

Precipice · 13/09/2023 20:00

Who is "everyone" or "everyone in Britain"? This appears to include people whose own family histories were based in another place, which was not necessarily either the perpetrator or victim of colonialism and the slave trade. Everyone living in Britain now lives in a country which has the legacy of the British Empire, but if you/your family moved here in the 21st century or late in the 20th, it's not necessarily your history.

Is it the history of people from Eastern Europe, for example? There are now lots of Poles and Ukrainians living in the UK. Ukraine has a history of oppression from Russia and from Poland, and of Tatar slave raids abducting people into slavery in the Ottoman Empire, or if we go back further there are the Mongols and even the "slave/Slav" link, but not specifically a history of colonialism outside of Europe or of transatlantic slavery.

Sharing the same reply as I gave to another commenter making a similar point:

Just to clarify, I don’t mean “everyone” in a strictly genealogical sense. Anyone living in Britain becomes part of British society. Slavery and colonialism are important aspects of that society’s history.

OP posts:
GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 06:29

Jeffjefftyjeff · 13/09/2023 18:11

Could help to make it a bit real for people rather than abstract ‘we all benefitted’: eg My family moved to Liverpool in the 1800s and opened a shop. They almost certainly moved because of the increased prosperity of the city. Slavery significantly contributed to this.

…..But I think a lot of people in the Uk today have very different histories (another part of my family was exiled from another country for religious reasons; another left their original country because of civil war). We need to be careful about presuming everyone traces back to the same sorts of things as the majority

I agree, but just to clarify I don’t mean “everyone” in strictly a genealogical sense. Anyone living in Britain becomes part of British society, and slavery and colonialism are important aspects of that society’s history.

OP posts:
DameWhiskers · 14/09/2023 04:42

@Newusername1273

And this is where the nuance comes in... not every bit of colonisation was done without the consent of the people/governments. A significant number were happy to cooperate with the British.

I'd be interested to know what - if anything - is on the curriculum regarding British colonialism in Australia. That was essentially genocide for the indigenous peoples, and slavery. I live on a documented colonial massacre site. Those killed, including women and children, were hunted down as it was thought they has stolen food from a landowner. After the event, it turned out they hadn't. These sorts of events were not isolated.

c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/colonialmassacres/map.php

These people had no opportunity to consent.

Coyoacan · 14/09/2023 04:22

The conditions of the English working class during the first half of the 19th century were absolutely appalling. Five-year-old children going down the mines and suchlike. It is horrible to then blame their descendents for slavery,

A contemporary writer was of the opinion that slaves were better off than factory workers because they cost their owners money, like a good horse, and it was bad business not to look after one's investment, whereas when a factory worker or a miner died, there were plenty more where they came from.

MCOut · 14/09/2023 01:57

molotovcupcakes · 13/09/2023 23:04

I think many do. The industrial revolution was possible because of colonisation and slavery.

If this is true then why didn’t it happen in the other continents that also had slavery at that time?
I do get your point that the colonies were a kind of trading block for raw materials which may have made them cheaper but all countries trade goods with each other.
Industrialisation in other countries such as Singapore have not included colonisation or slavery so why do you think it was necessary for the development of industrialisation in the UK?

Not all places develop in the same way and for the same reasons. I don’t think you can compare development of Britain with places like Singapore, South Korea and China. They had favourable access to mature foreign markets and significant foreign investment. Add to that, that their development was by design whereas the Industrial Revolution was a more “natural” process.

The Industrial Revolution wouldn’t have been possible as it was without slavery but no one is arguing there weren’t other factors which made Britain unique. That doesn’t change the fact that slave wealth drove the creation of factories and both before and after the slave trade ended sugar and particularly cotton still relied on raw materials from slave holding nations.

MCOut · 14/09/2023 00:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ooo your racism is really showing here. So to be clear you as a white person are the adult but black people are children?

Very interesting as infantilisation was often used as a justification for slavery. Black people were though of as a child race and it was argued that it was the duty of white people to subjugate.

It’s funny how according to you, slavery had little impact in Britain but yet in 2023 it is clear you have been socialised to feel the same way about us. Such is the enduring legacy of the slave trade.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 00:34

Black history month is a different matter though. So so much stuff there. So much awful treatment of black people. I can't really comment as am not black. But i do get annoyed when Irish history is dismissed.

mids2019 · 14/09/2023 00:26

@Chickenkeev ,

Yes I agree understanding is important and we certainly shouldn't hide the past. I think slavery should be taught in a manner though that does lead to understanding as you say and not to blame.

The problem with ideas such as black history month is it ties history to a race and as such gives one race a certain privilege to its contents. If you have a white history month of course that would be viewed as racist. The overall point being that history should be taught so that horrors of the past aren't repeated but it shouldn't be used as weapon in racial politcs.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 00:12

mids2019 · 14/09/2023 00:03

@Chickenkeev

I agree unambiguously that slavery was wrong and should be taught as such. However care has to be taken to not suggest it is a historical wrong that the current generation of white children need to be guilty of.

I think there is a difference in stating 'slavery is wrong' and 'slavery is wrong and is the root of racial division today so giving justification for ideas such as positive discrimination to right past wrongs'

all history is important but I just happen to think that those that advocate a more pronounced teaching of slavery aren't entirely not motivated by politics.

I absolutely agree that people shouldn't be held to account for the wrongs of those that went before them, but i do think it's a moral imperative to make them understand. It's an unfair burden tbf but very important all the same. The wounds for the victims are still raw. In general, understanding is a positive thing. (Sorry, sounds a bit pontificatey again!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread