Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 12:09

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:51

What needs to also be understood is how the world made Britain.

Hence this thread.

I'm not sure that is the main issue tbh.

Most people (if not all) do understand that 'the world made Britain' and actually that is simplistic in itself - England is not Britain and the English colonised the Celtic nations before, during and after they looked overseas. But yy at a basic level, everyone in Britain (regardless of their personal, family past) benefits from Britain's past to a greater or lesser extent.

The issue arises in how others (usually external to the UK ) want that 'understanding' to be manifested. And how much energy, time, resources and finances should be directed to 'manifesting' that understanding.

This thread is about to be inundated with the usual trolls pushing their own agendas. Which is unfortunate because the discussion has been interesting and thoughtful.

But part of the problem with these discussions happening on social media is that the loudest, most aggressive voices become the ones trying to demand that 'understanding' is manifested in a way that pleases them. Despite the fact they are completely unaware of the school curriculum or/and the local disadvantaged and vulnerable communities that suffered to build the 'Empire'.

My friend's Irish gran was taken away from her family as a child to work in an Englishman's home as a servant - where she was abused. My DH's family had DCs taken and sent to Australia. Any reckoning has to be nuanced enough to recognise and hold all those injustices imo. Does that mean reparations? Does it mean government acknowledgement? Does it mean special museums dedicated to all the vulnerable and oppressed? I think those are the answers we need to work on. Otherwise nothing is learnt, and we're always at the mercy of the most ignorant.

TreadLight · 14/09/2023 12:05

@Dotjones "When slavery was legal in Britain most people didn't have a vote and had no say over policy."

Slavery in England was abolished by the Normans. There hasn't been slavery in England for nearly a thousand years, and back then pretty much no-one had a vote. The country was ruled by an absolute monarch.

The colonies were different, but they were allowed a great deal of freedom in how they set themselves up and were governed. And with that gift of freedom in administration came abhorrent practices like slavery. Maybe England/Britain should have exercised more control over the colonial governments and there are strong arguments both for and against this level of imperial control.

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 12:02

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 11:56

Yes. I'm not a sociologist but my understanding is that society is there to set up a series of laws, opportunities and cultural practices to protect the welfare of the individuals. This will by its very nature include expansion.

I’d add in “elite” before individuals as most societies are hierarchical and not egalitarian. The elites set up society and then run/manipulate it to preserve their position at the top with most of the wealth and all the power.

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 12:00

FloorWipes · 14/09/2023 11:46

Neither modern not historic slavery negates the other but I'm not sure how one can decide that the correct measure for how bad slavery is to consider it on a per capita rather than an absolute number basis. That sort of thinking is very grim in its own way!

Of course it’s the correct way to determine how prevalent slavery is. You can’t say that slavery is at a peak or it’s height without making the numbers of slaves from 200 or 2,000 years directly comparable to the numbers of slaves today. The only way to do that is to adjust for the difference in total population.

Modern day slavery has a wider definition than the historic chattel slavery so it would be prudent to take that into account as well when comparing them.

In addition, not all forced labour/unfree labour is slavery. Conscription into the armed forces is unfree/forced labour but it is not slavery. The same with convict labour- also a type of unfree labour but it is not slavery.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 11:56

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:35

Does “society” have some sort of pre-determined universal purpose?

Yes. I'm not a sociologist but my understanding is that society is there to set up a series of laws, opportunities and cultural practices to protect the welfare of the individuals. This will by its very nature include expansion.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 11:54

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:51

What needs to also be understood is how the world made Britain.

Hence this thread.

Yes and that series helps someway with understanding it.

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 11:52

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:39

Haiti and Denmark also got in there before Britain. Yes, there are differences, but, as you say, we should not so ready to congratulate ourselves.

Edited

Yes, as did the Mughal Empire, Korea, Japan and others.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:51

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 11:06

Niall Fergusons documentary is interesting viewing (if a little outdated now) and is essentially his book in TV format.

What needs to also be understood is how the world made Britain.

Hence this thread.

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 14/09/2023 11:46

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 11:35

I really dislike this factoid, it is estimated that there are more (illegally kept) slaves today than ever before because the planet has 7 billion people. It’s a meaningless statistic and doesn’t mean slavery is at its height today.

When you look at it on a per capita basis, as in what % of the global population is enslaved, slavery is the lowest it has ever been.

Neither modern not historic slavery negates the other but I'm not sure how one can decide that the correct measure for how bad slavery is to consider it on a per capita rather than an absolute number basis. That sort of thinking is very grim in its own way!

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 11:45

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:35

Does “society” have some sort of pre-determined universal purpose?

This is a bit waffly so apologies. But i would say yes, it does. It's the social contract. 'Society' is a form of control. But for the greater good. A good type of control. As i said, waffly :)

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:39

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 11:18

but when hugely important events like the abolition of slavery for the first time in human history are omitted from the teaching (or only briefly mentioned in passing)

Careful. The British were not the first “in human history” to abolish slavery. That honour belongs to Emperor Wang Mang of the Xin Dynasty in 9 AD. Unfortunately he was assassinated by his nobles who didn’t like losing their slaves in 23 AD and slavery came back.

They were the first to abolish the transatlantic slave trade, and then to free the slaves from that specific trade. Not so big an accomplishment when you look at the timeline of slavery being abolished globally.

Haiti and Denmark also got in there before Britain. Yes, there are differences, but, as you say, we should not so ready to congratulate ourselves.

OP posts:
GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 11:35

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 08:14

The term coloniser is so loaded. Every single civilisation in history has been a coloniser. Even within the nation's we went and colonised the various groups of people's were in fighting and land grabbing amongst themselves, it's the very purpose of a society - to expand and succeed. An uncomfortable truth perhaps?

Does “society” have some sort of pre-determined universal purpose?

OP posts:
MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 11:35

JamSandle · 14/09/2023 07:17

Slavery is at its height today. There are more slaves today than there have ever been. Sometimes we talk about the past too much and not about today.

Whats the point talking about slavery if we aren't doing anything about modern slavery?

I really dislike this factoid, it is estimated that there are more (illegally kept) slaves today than ever before because the planet has 7 billion people. It’s a meaningless statistic and doesn’t mean slavery is at its height today.

When you look at it on a per capita basis, as in what % of the global population is enslaved, slavery is the lowest it has ever been.

Dizzybelle · 14/09/2023 11:33

Glowie · 14/09/2023 11:15

Calm down, I think you've been imbibing too many modern white guilt stories. We didn't rock up and hunt down the slaves ourselves.

We can look back now and say it was awful but at the time it was a thing that everybody did. We are not immune: Britons have been enslaved by the Italians, as well as being conquered and subjugated by various other parties.

Also consider that we also brought a lot of innovation, culture, and advancement to these places. It can't have been all bad, else they would have all left when they had the chance.

Good grief! And this comment is why we precisely need to teach our children the true, objective, history of our country, the good and the bad. But it seems that the “bad” is being ignored and/or downplayed. Scary.

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 11:28

FloorWipes · 14/09/2023 08:55

Agree it shouldn't be an either or.

However I don't think it's correct to suggest that modern slavery is a different sort of phenomenon, and more akin to organised crime. That just reduces the modern slavery definition to a particular subset of circumstances, when it is actually a broader phenomenon. And supposedly about 3.9 million people today are victims of actual state sponsored forced labour.

I'm sure during the transatlantic slave trade people did say various things that I think I'm seeing people say here about modern slavery such as "it's complicated", "I'm not responsible", "There's not much I can do about it".

I think that modern slavery reflects ongoing colonialism and analysing past colonialism illuminates that. However a problem I witness is that the legacy is often reduced to "white people do bad things and should stop and repent" which contains plenty of truth but actually is an argument that is now quite actively employed to obscure the reality of today's problems and even to prevent white people from taking action. We need to think about who is really benefiting from that. Colonialism past and present does not only break down along racial lines at all - however this is a tool being used to divide us and to prevent from seeing the world as it is now, so that we can't change it.

There's a massive leap from 'it's complicated' to 'there's not much I can do about it'. That wasn't the implication of my post at all.
There is a throughline to modern slavery (as my post said) but it is more complicated to police a myriad of different networks rather than campaigning against one or two governments. That's a logistical fact. It doesn't negate that the campaigning needs to happen. It doesn't negate that people with the same vulnerabilities will always be the ones targeted. It doesn't negate that certain organisations (whether they be corporate or governmental) are currently benefitting from modern slavery.

MasterBeth · 14/09/2023 11:27

it's wrong to blame ordinary people for slavery or claim that they still benefit from it.

"Blame", for me, is a strange and loaded concept in this debate. Ordinary British people then weren't to blame for slavery. Ordinary British people now aren't to blame for what happened in the past.

But...

Britain through its colonial invasions, with slavery as a big part of that (free labour - even notwithstanding the degradation and cruelty involved), became a global superpower. The national infrastructure, global status and economic power that we all enjoy now was built off the back of Empire. British Empire-builders stripped countries and continents of their natural resources. British slavers stripped them of their people.

You don't have to have someone to blame to note that British society benefitted economically from slavery and many structural global inequalities were built from it.

Of course, there are also many ordinary British people whose ancestors were bought and sold, beaten and raped, transported across the world for the financial gain of British millionaires whose names still adorn fine buildings and businesses and whose statues still stand in our city centres and town squares.

There is absolutely a psychological and physical toll of the legacy of slavery that hangs around today.

MotherofPearl · 14/09/2023 11:20

Most of us have benefitted very little from slavery - just a few who owned plantations and took part in the trade.

This is simply not true.

Transatlantic Slavery and its aftermath had a profound effect on all parts of British society, and Britain's economic, political and cultural institutions. If you are interested, you could take a look at some of the findings of the UCL Legacies of Slavery project I linked to earlier.

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 11:18

but when hugely important events like the abolition of slavery for the first time in human history are omitted from the teaching (or only briefly mentioned in passing)

Careful. The British were not the first “in human history” to abolish slavery. That honour belongs to Emperor Wang Mang of the Xin Dynasty in 9 AD. Unfortunately he was assassinated by his nobles who didn’t like losing their slaves in 23 AD and slavery came back.

They were the first to abolish the transatlantic slave trade, and then to free the slaves from that specific trade. Not so big an accomplishment when you look at the timeline of slavery being abolished globally.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 11:17

Yet again you're arguing for why it should be taught as its own separate topic area. The contentious nature of The Troubles is exactly why it should be taught. Kids need to know not everything can be resolved easily, that the knock on effect from decision A is XYZ.

Glowie · 14/09/2023 11:15

Dizzybelle · 14/09/2023 10:59

Yes, the will to “explore”, the incredible “time and logistics” to colonise and enslave so many millions of people. to colonise, to plunder the nations they were “exploring”, to enslave and force - into a life of subjugation, all of those millions of people, generation after generation, living in servitude for glory of king/queen and country. All the atrocities all the suffering caused by this “exploration”.

Yes, it’s astounding what such a tiny country had achieved, in terms of empire. . We should know more about this part of our history, but the majority of people really truly don’t know the truth about empire, because if we really did no one would ever actually have any kind of pride about that era of our history.

Calm down, I think you've been imbibing too many modern white guilt stories. We didn't rock up and hunt down the slaves ourselves.

We can look back now and say it was awful but at the time it was a thing that everybody did. We are not immune: Britons have been enslaved by the Italians, as well as being conquered and subjugated by various other parties.

Also consider that we also brought a lot of innovation, culture, and advancement to these places. It can't have been all bad, else they would have all left when they had the chance.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 11:11

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 10:58

You've successfully argued for why it should be taught in schools. Think of the critical thinking skills kids would learn about when discussing all the intricacies of Irish history and The Troubles. It absolutely is relevant and essential for our children to learn about this for exactly the reasons you argue it's not.

No, not until Northern Ireland's people themselves have formed a consensus on the Troubles.

Perceptions elsewhere can have a significant impact here. This is especially true with Americans of Irish descent, especially those who funded NORAID.

But this is a thread about colonialism and the Troubles was not about colonialism or anti-imperialism even if the Provos liked to present themselves in that manner. The statistics tell us approximately 1,000 or so of those killed by the Provos were from Northern Ireland.

So this wasn't an anti-imperialist situation. It was an internal problem within NI where Republicans especially disagreed with the principle of partition plus consent. It took them 78 years to FINALLY accept NI has a right to be separate from the Republic and a right to decide its own fate. That was always British policy which appears in Sunningdale, Anglo-Irish Agreement and the Belfast Agreement. I think it's in the Anglo-Irish Treaty as well.

The Troubles is not appropriate vis a vis colonialism and slavery.

Lazyusername · 14/09/2023 11:04

I agree this is a good thread with people sharing information. I have learned from reading people's comments. It is interesting to see the connection between my Nan (who I mentioned previously and who worked in the mills) and the cotton pickers. I am very open to learning more about slavery and the British Empire and hearing and understanding how this still affects people today. My perception is that many people feel the same and that it's just that there's this bit of indignation that it seems some people want people like my Nan to be held responsible for things they could have had no influence over whatsoever, having been victims themselves. To me this is a class issue; the poor were abused and still are; the poor had no power and still have none, both here in the UK and elsewhere.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 11:02

@DownNative he has a mahoosive wiki entry!

Dotjones · 14/09/2023 11:02

When slavery was legal in Britain most people didn't have a vote and had no say over policy. It's true we should celebrate Britain's role in slavery and how we ended a global tradition of slavery that went back many thousand years (at least since the last ice age). But it's wrong to blame ordinary people for slavery or claim that they still benefit from it.

We should also remember that Britain itself is a victim of colonization and slavery. The Romans, the Vikings, the Germanic people and the Normans all conquered some or all of the island and used slaves. After the Norman conquest peasants might not technically have been enslaved, but couldn't move around freely or leave to work for another landowner without their current employer's permission - slavery in effect if not name.

It's also important to note that the "classic" slave trade era relied heavily on African cooperation. African tribes had long embraced the tradition of slavery, inter-tribal conflict often leading to enslavement for the losers. When the Europeans arrived to expand the slave industry they were always reliant on local African expertise in acquiring slaves inland and transporting them alive to the coast.

Too often the story goes "Britain bad, Africa good" when that's very much not the case. Slavery has been part of the human experience for a long time, probably its entire existence, and even after Britain was instrumental in ending the slave trade it still exists - there are more slaves today than at any point of history.