Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 17:44

Wsmi · 14/09/2023 17:37

Has anyone figured out what point this thread is trying to make. It’s just a rambling lecture.

It's a discussion. And a rare type that hasn't descended into people abusing each other despite sensitive subject matter. These discussions are valuable. And, don't like it, don't read it. Nobody is forcing you to.

Wsmi · 14/09/2023 17:37

Has anyone figured out what point this thread is trying to make. It’s just a rambling lecture.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 17:25

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 17:22

Well happy birthday from Scotland. A place so rough the only thing to colonise us was midges! 😂

We've been colonised by midges too, i'm destroyed with the fookers altogether!

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 17:22

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 17:18

@CallumDansTransitVan true but ROI citizens would have decent enough protections too. I'm veering into waffly territory again now (soz!). But, indulge me, it's my birthday ;)

Well happy birthday from Scotland. A place so rough the only thing to colonise us was midges! 😂

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 17:21

LeaderBee · 14/09/2023 15:55

What a lot of people don't realise is that a lot of the african tribesmen who became slaves were rounded up and sold by their own people to the Europeans... and was infact going on for centuries prior to "the white man" even setting foot on the continent. Saying slavery is solely the fault of the British Empire and Colonialism is just pure ignorance.

Has anyone said that though on this thread?

I explicitly acknowledged the role of Africans few pages ago.

This point needs to be part of any account of slavery, but it’s important to also understand that Europeans incentivised and expanded the existing trade. They also introduced a greater degree of brutality and ownership over enslaved people.

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 17:18

@CallumDansTransitVan true but ROI citizens would have decent enough protections too. I'm veering into waffly territory again now (soz!). But, indulge me, it's my birthday ;)

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 17:09

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 16:33

But the consequences are still felt in a very real way. NI is current affairs. Whether it's as a result of colonisation, idk. But, whatever it was, the aftereffects (sp!?! ffs) are there.

Your correct Northern Ireland is current. In recent years progress has obviously been made to find peace between both sides. As has previously been said, we have to be very careful not to create a new generation of hatred by digging up the sins of the past. The background of it all is something for those in Ireland to teach their young. But to do it in such a way as that neither 'side' was beyond reproach.

Also appreciate that being a British Dependent Territory or Colony also comes with the protections the UK can offer. Recent examples would be the Falklands or Spains behaviour towards Gibraltar.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 16:33

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 16:09

How about putting a reallity check into this thread. In Secondary School History was/is taught as a compulsory subject for around two years. It then becomes a choice subject for the student. In those first two years there is obviously a lot of histoy to cover.

There is no way the full nuances of any part of history can be explored fully, nor their interactions with other parts.

Sadly I think the transatlantic slavery issue is being used and promoted presently by people with their own agenda. Especially when the subject of reparations often crop up in the subject.

I personally feel that 200 years after an event, nobody can claim to be persecuted by it. Eight Generations have passed with the opportunity to improve the family history. At some point the reason for where a person is has to become their own problem.

But the consequences are still felt in a very real way. NI is current affairs. Whether it's as a result of colonisation, idk. But, whatever it was, the aftereffects (sp!?! ffs) are there.

MasterBeth · 14/09/2023 16:22

LeaderBee · 14/09/2023 15:55

What a lot of people don't realise is that a lot of the african tribesmen who became slaves were rounded up and sold by their own people to the Europeans... and was infact going on for centuries prior to "the white man" even setting foot on the continent. Saying slavery is solely the fault of the British Empire and Colonialism is just pure ignorance.

Who is saying slavery is solely the fault of the British Empire and colonialism?

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 16:18

fiddlesticksandotherwords · 14/09/2023 13:43

No, but on the other hand, there are millions of people alive today who are older than me and could have had a conversation with them.

It is just a sobering thought that something so appalling that we think of as happening so long ago, is only actually a generation or so away.

Well actually eight generations away. The example you give is like saying, my Great Great Great Great Granny spoke to the Great Great Grandson who's Dad went up chimneys as a boy.

Spendonsend · 14/09/2023 16:17

Slavery may be 200 years on, but the de-colonising/end of empire is much more recent and well within living memory. The OP was about both.

Coyoacan · 14/09/2023 16:11

I encourage you to read the diaries of Thomas Thistlewood

I just looked up the Wikipedia entry for that monster, who apparently was typical of his caste. I haven't the stomach for reading his diaries.

Throughout history and across different cultures there have been different types of slavery, of which the most brutal was chattel slavery, the type implemented in the Americas.

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 16:09

How about putting a reallity check into this thread. In Secondary School History was/is taught as a compulsory subject for around two years. It then becomes a choice subject for the student. In those first two years there is obviously a lot of histoy to cover.

There is no way the full nuances of any part of history can be explored fully, nor their interactions with other parts.

Sadly I think the transatlantic slavery issue is being used and promoted presently by people with their own agenda. Especially when the subject of reparations often crop up in the subject.

I personally feel that 200 years after an event, nobody can claim to be persecuted by it. Eight Generations have passed with the opportunity to improve the family history. At some point the reason for where a person is has to become their own problem.

LeaderBee · 14/09/2023 15:55

What a lot of people don't realise is that a lot of the african tribesmen who became slaves were rounded up and sold by their own people to the Europeans... and was infact going on for centuries prior to "the white man" even setting foot on the continent. Saying slavery is solely the fault of the British Empire and Colonialism is just pure ignorance.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 14/09/2023 15:52

In the country I live in, a combination of factors are leading to ever louder voices on both sides (descendants of the colonised and of the colonisers) as one seeks to maintain the status quo and ideally revert to the good ole days of supremacy and the other seeks reparations and a level playing field. Contention often descends into violence and deeper entrenchment on both sides. Change comes in fits and starts, and isn't linear. Progress isn't always progress. I think this is a pattern that repeats and has repeated wherever there has been colonisation (and slavery - one cannot exist without the other).

I've begun to wonder whether we should look at this from a different perspective, that of who the colonisers tend to be and why they tend to colonise. Across the millenia and across the board, at its core slavery and colonisation is the exploitation of the many weak in order to satisfy the greed of a few, who are mostly men in search of power. It's a specific psychology that not only wants more but NEEDS more. To BE the subjogator and amasser of the greatest wealth is often what gives the coloniser and the slave owner their identity. It fulfils their need for supremacy.

Any type of despot - a dictator, a billionaire owner of an online shopping forum paying its workers less than a living wage, a human trafficker, a slave trader, a nation in search of global supremacy by every available means - and those who admire them and support them in their quest for despotic supremacy, has a specific type of humanity. They have always existed and, imo, for as long as there is humanity they will always exist. To understand slavery, colonialism, empire, is to understand human behaviour. You can't have one without the other.

Peacelily001 · 14/09/2023 15:47

Scarfweather · 13/09/2023 23:42

I’m giving MY experience of growing up in the 1980s and the signs were in numerous places in my town. I made no comment on the UK as a whole.
If you’re doubting it, then I guess you didn’t live it? Enjoy your ignorance.

My mother ‘lived it’ as a young Irish woman of 16 in London in the late 1950s.
If she’d seen such ignorance in the 1980s she’d have ripped the perpetrator a new one.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 15:30

@DownNative if you do start a thread, please tag me. It's v interesting!

Dizzybelle · 14/09/2023 15:00

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 13:40

I doubt anyone who has mentioned Ireland on this thread are 'from elsewhere and with no real interest'. You're rather aggressively trying to close down a discussion point that evolved because of the gaps in the UK school curriculum. History cannot, and should never be, ringfenced as only suitable for 'certain' people to read or write. Oral histories have a place. These tussles have to take place now. Saying it 'is inappropriate at this point in time' is the way that the elite have consistently rewritten history, obscured abuses and silenced certain voices. The process is important. When people stay silent and wait - they find the official 'history' has already been carved by others elsewhere with their own agendas.

Excellent post! Spot on.

MCOut · 14/09/2023 14:48

@Newusername1273 I’m genuinely curious, which countries are you referring to?

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 14:45

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 14:24

Your point was about why you felt Irish history can't be taught. My point was about the way South Africa was approached in the UK curriculum. It wasn't about whether South Africa was an example of colonialism or not.
I think you'd really benefit from starting your own thread because the discussion you're trying to have isn't the one that was taking place here and it's going to end up derailing this thread. I'm not going to reply to you again because I don't want to derail this discussion. But if you link to your new thread, I will join you there.

I agree. I'm disengaging from them too because I'm really enjoying this thread. I feel they're showboating and derailing rather than engaging in meaningful discussion

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 14:37

Coyoacan · 14/09/2023 14:25

Also consider that we also brought a lot of innovation, culture, and advancement to these places. It can't have been all bad, else they would have all left when they had the chance.

Whao, just whao. Your ignorance is appalling, but that has always been the way with racists and chauvinists.

You haven't heard about the high cultural acheivements of other countries because you are incurious, not because they didn't happen.

Timbuktu has been home to one of the largest libraries in the world for well over a thousand years. The astronomy of the Mayans and Aztecs was way more advanced than it was in Europe when these cultures met. Etc. etc.

The uncomfortable truth though is that a lot of nations welcomed being taken over (not just by the British) because it made social and financial sense to do so.

The reason the British (and to some degree Dutch) Empire was so successful in its growth was because it didn't stick to one type of colonisation, it adapted to each country it went to. Some were taken by force, others through diplomacy, some through trade. Portuguese colonised by settling and integrating/intermarrying with the locals. Spanish went in and decimated populations through disease and warfare.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 14:29

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 14:24

Your point was about why you felt Irish history can't be taught. My point was about the way South Africa was approached in the UK curriculum. It wasn't about whether South Africa was an example of colonialism or not.
I think you'd really benefit from starting your own thread because the discussion you're trying to have isn't the one that was taking place here and it's going to end up derailing this thread. I'm not going to reply to you again because I don't want to derail this discussion. But if you link to your new thread, I will join you there.

No, my point was that Northern Ireland Troubles shouldn't be taught in schools. Especially NOT in the context of colonialism.

Irish history, on the other hand, is very, very broad! I didn't advocate that various parts of that history shouldn't be taught as I'm sure you'll realise when you read back. Indeed, other aspects of this history fits this thread, e.g. Niall of the Nine, Irish colonialisation of Scotland, etc.

The UK approached South Africa differently because there was majority consensus there. And it fits in this thread's topic of colonialism and slavery.

Coyoacan · 14/09/2023 14:25

Also consider that we also brought a lot of innovation, culture, and advancement to these places. It can't have been all bad, else they would have all left when they had the chance.

Whao, just whao. Your ignorance is appalling, but that has always been the way with racists and chauvinists.

You haven't heard about the high cultural acheivements of other countries because you are incurious, not because they didn't happen.

Timbuktu has been home to one of the largest libraries in the world for well over a thousand years. The astronomy of the Mayans and Aztecs was way more advanced than it was in Europe when these cultures met. Etc. etc.

AlexandriasWindmill · 14/09/2023 14:24

DownNative · 14/09/2023 14:08

You're cherrypicking and misrepresenting what I've said.

I'm specifically referencing the Troubles which was and is NOT an anti-imperialist/colonialism conflict at all. The very fact it has been mentioned in this thread shows those who've done this do not understand the origins or what it's based on.

The origin goes back to 1880s when Nationalism and Unionism first emerged. It was comparative with the rise of nationalism across Europe. By the 1920s, the question was on self-determination which again was comparative with the European experience.

But the Troubles itself wasn't a case of colonisers v anti-colonisers by any means. It IS very inappropriate to shoehorn it into a thread about colonialism and slavery.

The history that IS more relevant to colonialism and slavery is early Irish attempts to conquer other lands and colonise them. The most successful of these was obviously Scotland whose name means "Land of the Irish". Before the arrival of the Irish, it was populated by the Picts with a Pictish language and known as Pictland.

St Patrick is the most famous person taken by the Irish as a slave today. There were others.

A rather more inconvenient fact and relevant to the thread is the role of the Irish in the British Empire. Along with the Scots, the Irish spread the Empire further than the English managed to. These two groups were famed for their fighting skills and made up a bigger proportion of the British Army since 1600s or so than other parts of the UK did.

It was an Irishman from Down who burnt down the White House too.

But the Troubles history itself was not part of this. Especially since history is not one long unbroken chain of causation. History ebbs and flows. One historical event doesn't necessarily impact on another.

Attached is Professor Walker explaining most of the above. He noted the same with Unionism, but I can't find my screenshot of this just now.

The difference with the example of South Africa given is there was majority consensus there since that society was hugely imbalanced. Northern Ireland is very significantly different from it as we never had majority to that degree and our peace pacification process is very different to theirs as a result.

South Africa was an example of colonialism. Northern Ireland was not.

Your point was about why you felt Irish history can't be taught. My point was about the way South Africa was approached in the UK curriculum. It wasn't about whether South Africa was an example of colonialism or not.
I think you'd really benefit from starting your own thread because the discussion you're trying to have isn't the one that was taking place here and it's going to end up derailing this thread. I'm not going to reply to you again because I don't want to derail this discussion. But if you link to your new thread, I will join you there.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 14:20

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 14:01

You do not get to dictate what does and doesn't get to be taught based on your own personal sensitivities. History is dark and disgusting (see the aforementioned ThistlewoodDiaries if you really want to have your stomach churned). To understand and prevent repetition of history it needs to be taught, objectively, without agenda, without misplaced anger or compassion.

Ireland is lived history. My history, your history. The ramifications of Irish history are still coming to light through Brexit. Absolutely it must be a core part of our curriculum. We would be doing BOTH factions in NI an injustice to do otherwise.

Not my personal sensitivities, but Northern Ireland's own. The latest issue is political Interference in PSNI by Provisional Sinn Fein. The propaganda of the peace pushed by both governments is slowly unravelling as we speak.

Brexit isn't doing that except as people outside NI believed it had been resolved due to the propaganda of the peace itself.

The Troubles isn't an example of colonialism based conflict by any means and doesn't belong in this area of discussion at all. That's the reality. It belongs in discussions of nationalisms and 20th century self-determination politics instead.

There's a reason why Irish Studies has been a thing I universities since 1998. Professor Liam Kennedy has an interesting graph concerning this area.

For the foreseeable, NI Troubles history will remain University level study. Far too complicated to be taught in schools by teachers. University lecturers are better equipped for that job.

Meantime, I recommend Professor Brian Walker's book as a good place to start. He's very even-handed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread