Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:38

Clymene · 14/09/2023 21:26

You could do a quick canter through vikings, romans etc.

In my experience of teenagers (including me), making history relatable is the key to making it interesting. If you bring it back to modern 20th century Britain, that is going to be every kid in the room who has parents/grandparents born in the 20th century.

Getting grandparents in to talk about their lived experience is amazing if it's possible. The kids love it.

Personally I would favour a lot more focus on the history of modern Britain. It’s inclusive and has direct and immediate relevance for understanding today. It is also good for critical thinking; if kids understand much in our culture today wasn’t “inevitable” or “natural”, but constructed, this helps them to recognise their own agency and that things can be changed.

Sure, the Saxons, for instance, are interesting. But they would be rather low on my list of priorities in comparison to more recent history.

On that note, it’s interesting how some conservatives seem to favour the Tudors being on the curriculum. I suspect the tales of separating from a European entity (Catholicism), taking up Protestantism and founding the CofE, stories of memorable monarchs, beating the Spanish and establishing the germs of empire, all appeal to that mindset. It’s also not likely to imbue kids with much of a critique of today.

OP posts:
user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:34

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:15

For the purposes of this discussion I conceive ‘British’ as anyone with British Citizenship or residency, or who identifies as such. This encompasses any ethnicity, race etc.

Edited

Well OK. But one should be mindful that the history of British people of colour, and of those of mixed descent is going to be different to the history of British people who trace their ancestry back to the Norman conquest, for instance. When talking collectively about the history and actions of the British it's important to differentiate.

MasterBeth · 14/09/2023 21:27

Wsmi · 14/09/2023 17:37

Has anyone figured out what point this thread is trying to make. It’s just a rambling lecture.

A thread doesn't make a point. It's a discussion of different points of view.

Maybe you hadn't realised, but each different box is a contribution from a different person. Look - your contribution shows up in its own little box, too.

Clymene · 14/09/2023 21:26

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:11

How did we get to the multicultural Britain we are lucky to have today would be a good starting point.

we are an island nation that was invaded many times before 1066. Combine that with our naval and history of trade where would you even begin on such a vast topic? I love the idea of having a "Making of Modern Britain" class though.

You could do a quick canter through vikings, romans etc.

In my experience of teenagers (including me), making history relatable is the key to making it interesting. If you bring it back to modern 20th century Britain, that is going to be every kid in the room who has parents/grandparents born in the 20th century.

Getting grandparents in to talk about their lived experience is amazing if it's possible. The kids love it.

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 21:21

MCOut · 14/09/2023 19:06

I gather from your comment that you don’t think institutional racism exists. Could you explain then how black people have caused themselves to have more negative outcomes in health, education and employment?

So for example when you look at published ethnicity pay gaps they almost always show that there is an ethnicity wage gap even when you control individual characteristics (eg occupation & education) between black and white workers. What do you think black people have done to cause that?

Or what have black women done to cause ourselves to be 4 times more likely to die when giving birth?

When going into university having previously attained similar grades why are black students performing worse than their peers? Despite the fact that some groups are more likely to go to university.

A White Man or Black Man doing the same job get the same pay. The only time there would be a difference is in roles where candidates are sought after eg due to skills etc. This would be down to how that person negotiated their pay.

Regarding health. Levels of obesity, diabetes,& heart disease are all found in higher levels in Black people. Combine this with diet and possibly less exercise taken that will account for increased issues. Bit like us Scots.

Why some Black students don't do well at further education is likely down to the student themself.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:15

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:07

@GodessOfThunder Not to be pedantic, but I would rather it was called Britain's history, which recognises not all British people are British ethnicity only.

For the purposes of this discussion I conceive ‘British’ as anyone with British Citizenship or residency, or who identifies as such. This encompasses any ethnicity, race etc.

OP posts:
Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:11

How did we get to the multicultural Britain we are lucky to have today would be a good starting point.

we are an island nation that was invaded many times before 1066. Combine that with our naval and history of trade where would you even begin on such a vast topic? I love the idea of having a "Making of Modern Britain" class though.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:09

Clymene · 14/09/2023 20:50

If you focused on 20th century history, you could cover loads of this. You could do the two world wars, Windrush, the Troubles, and cover colonialism, slavery, Kenyan Asians and other migratory patterns on the way.

How did we get to the multicultural Britain we are lucky to have today would be a good starting point.

Agree. Something like “The Making of Modern Britain”. I’d also stick a topic in there about economic and social change - from pre-war to the welfare state/social democracy to neoliberalism.

OP posts:
Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:08

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:07

@GodessOfThunder Not to be pedantic, but I would rather it was called Britain's history, which recognises not all British people are British ethnicity only.

What is British ethnicity by your definition then? We are a proudly multicultural nation.

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:07

@GodessOfThunder Not to be pedantic, but I would rather it was called Britain's history, which recognises not all British people are British ethnicity only.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:01

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 20:58

I think you paint a rather overly rosy picture of protectorates. Many of these arrangements were the result of gunboat diplomacy, or the spoils of treaties, with the local population having limitations on their autonomy.

I don’t think whether the empire was “good” or “bad” or not, or how how “bad” it was compared to other empires, should be a focus. Credible historians don’t concern themselves with this. What is more important is understanding what happened, how and why and what its legacy is today.

I don't disagree with you at all.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 20:58

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 20:36

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_protectorate

British Protectorates are an example of where diplomacy rather than warfare brought nation's on board. We offered protection (which given the state of the world and small nations never knowing if they would be speaking French, Portuguese, Spanish or Dutch from one week to the next was no small incentive). They gave us strategic points in the ocean from which we could base out navy, handy for a seafaring nation always at war in the oceans. But there were downsides to this system too - they ran their course and we outstayed our welcome in many cases.

There was a UN conference in the 60s that made all empire nations hand back their colonies. We'd already granted many of ours independence and gave it to many more after this conference. Other nations weren't so keen to hand theirs back.

I think it's why I get annoyed why in popular culture Britain is called the big bad guy of colonialism - we weren't exactly the good guys but there were far worse options than the British, and this is how we became a global superpower.

If you are going to teach this topic you can't teach it just focusing on Britain. You need the geopolitical situation, you need the build up, you need to analyse maps and military history and trade routes and diplomacy and so much more.

I think you paint a rather overly rosy picture of protectorates. Many of these arrangements were the result of gunboat diplomacy, or the spoils of treaties, with the local population having limitations on their autonomy.

I don’t think whether the empire was “good” or “bad” or not, or how how “bad” it was compared to other empires, should be a focus. Credible historians don’t concern themselves with this. What is more important is understanding what happened, how and why and what its legacy is today.

OP posts:
Clymene · 14/09/2023 20:50

If you focused on 20th century history, you could cover loads of this. You could do the two world wars, Windrush, the Troubles, and cover colonialism, slavery, Kenyan Asians and other migratory patterns on the way.

How did we get to the multicultural Britain we are lucky to have today would be a good starting point.

ProfessorLayton1 · 14/09/2023 20:46

I don't know the answer to this, does any one think that Britain is seen as a big bad guy of colonialism because a lot of current problems in different parts of the world could be traced to some of the dubious decisions made by Britain?

Partition of India / Pakistan
Sykes Picot line
Balfour declaration

I am sure people from these regions may have reasons to be more than annoyed.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 20:37

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 20:35

It's important to teach about it but there are other aspects of history that also need teaching and all of them are only going to get limited time in schools. It's a matter of priorities, drop the English civil war or world war 1 and 2 to give more time to slavery discussions. We help out at a museum and its sad to see so many young people who have little idea of what the second world war was or any of the conflict that came after. History teaching seems in some ways to be a popularity contest with people pushing their own interests and excluding so much.

Kids now are the first generation without a direct link to WW1 and 2 though. It's not relevant to them like it was to us where we quizzed grandparents about what they did in the war. It's another generation or 2 on from that now.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 20:36

MCOut · 14/09/2023 14:48

@Newusername1273 I’m genuinely curious, which countries are you referring to?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_protectorate

British Protectorates are an example of where diplomacy rather than warfare brought nation's on board. We offered protection (which given the state of the world and small nations never knowing if they would be speaking French, Portuguese, Spanish or Dutch from one week to the next was no small incentive). They gave us strategic points in the ocean from which we could base out navy, handy for a seafaring nation always at war in the oceans. But there were downsides to this system too - they ran their course and we outstayed our welcome in many cases.

There was a UN conference in the 60s that made all empire nations hand back their colonies. We'd already granted many of ours independence and gave it to many more after this conference. Other nations weren't so keen to hand theirs back.

I think it's why I get annoyed why in popular culture Britain is called the big bad guy of colonialism - we weren't exactly the good guys but there were far worse options than the British, and this is how we became a global superpower.

If you are going to teach this topic you can't teach it just focusing on Britain. You need the geopolitical situation, you need the build up, you need to analyse maps and military history and trade routes and diplomacy and so much more.

British protectorate - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_protectorate

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 20:35

It's important to teach about it but there are other aspects of history that also need teaching and all of them are only going to get limited time in schools. It's a matter of priorities, drop the English civil war or world war 1 and 2 to give more time to slavery discussions. We help out at a museum and its sad to see so many young people who have little idea of what the second world war was or any of the conflict that came after. History teaching seems in some ways to be a popularity contest with people pushing their own interests and excluding so much.

narniabusiness · 14/09/2023 20:28

Indeed - without colonialism it’s unlikely Britain would be such a diverse society

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 20:18

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 19:15

HRTFT - but not all British are of pure British ethnicity. Half my family came from an ex-colony of the British Empire, the other half were Welsh with a bit of French. But I am British. I'm in favour of Colonial history and Slavery being openly taught and discussed, but I think it's simplistic to say it's British people's history. There must be many British people of mixed ethnicity who find that a little muddled and mildly offensive.

Just to clarify I don’t mean “everyone” in strictly a genealogical sense. Anyone living in Britain becomes part of British society, and slavery and colonialism are important aspects of that society’s history.

OP posts:
MCOut · 14/09/2023 19:50

@DownNative Personally I think 1 or 2 topics a key stage of colonial history alongside other British history is doable. It doesn’t necessarily all have to be doom and gloom. The purpose would not be to make anyone feel bad but foster empathy and get rid of some of these pervasive stereotypes.

Even introducing positive poc achievements in other lessons would be great. Maybe some non-European literature, art or music again alongside British works. Anything at all that doesn’t leave children with the impression that all poc are stupid, lazy and incapable.

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 19:15

HRTFT - but not all British are of pure British ethnicity. Half my family came from an ex-colony of the British Empire, the other half were Welsh with a bit of French. But I am British. I'm in favour of Colonial history and Slavery being openly taught and discussed, but I think it's simplistic to say it's British people's history. There must be many British people of mixed ethnicity who find that a little muddled and mildly offensive.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 19:13

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 16:09

How about putting a reallity check into this thread. In Secondary School History was/is taught as a compulsory subject for around two years. It then becomes a choice subject for the student. In those first two years there is obviously a lot of histoy to cover.

There is no way the full nuances of any part of history can be explored fully, nor their interactions with other parts.

Sadly I think the transatlantic slavery issue is being used and promoted presently by people with their own agenda. Especially when the subject of reparations often crop up in the subject.

I personally feel that 200 years after an event, nobody can claim to be persecuted by it. Eight Generations have passed with the opportunity to improve the family history. At some point the reason for where a person is has to become their own problem.

Yes, good point about secondary schools only having a short period of time with which to teach history.

Does anyone want history to be compulsory throughout secondary education? All 5 years?

The subject of the British Empire can be taught in schools, but can it be dealt with quite comprehensively?

I'm not too sure on that, especially as you cannot explain how the British Empire began without a comparative study of other European Empires. After, they didn't really develop fully independent of each other.

For the first I think 150 years of the Atlantic Slave Trade, Portugal dominated it. Other European States saw how wealthy Portugal was becoming and developed their own empires. If I remember correctly, Portugal was also the first European power to trade with Japan who were very isolationist in the 1600s.

Whilst empires of old such as all the European ones and even Asian empires are a thing of the past in the sense of forced expansion of territory, the 21st Century equivalent is globalisation of business. The United States is, arguably, a kind of empire today. In a sense, empire hasn't gone away. Its simply involved.

Whether we like it or not, there is a strong correlation between successful economies and military might. China is a good example of this plus it operates similarly to the USA in terms of using business to spread its influence, e.g. Africa. It is poised to become the new super power. Other examples in the past include British, Portuguese, Spanish and Dutch empires.

MCOut · 14/09/2023 19:06

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 16:09

How about putting a reallity check into this thread. In Secondary School History was/is taught as a compulsory subject for around two years. It then becomes a choice subject for the student. In those first two years there is obviously a lot of histoy to cover.

There is no way the full nuances of any part of history can be explored fully, nor their interactions with other parts.

Sadly I think the transatlantic slavery issue is being used and promoted presently by people with their own agenda. Especially when the subject of reparations often crop up in the subject.

I personally feel that 200 years after an event, nobody can claim to be persecuted by it. Eight Generations have passed with the opportunity to improve the family history. At some point the reason for where a person is has to become their own problem.

I gather from your comment that you don’t think institutional racism exists. Could you explain then how black people have caused themselves to have more negative outcomes in health, education and employment?

So for example when you look at published ethnicity pay gaps they almost always show that there is an ethnicity wage gap even when you control individual characteristics (eg occupation & education) between black and white workers. What do you think black people have done to cause that?

Or what have black women done to cause ourselves to be 4 times more likely to die when giving birth?

When going into university having previously attained similar grades why are black students performing worse than their peers? Despite the fact that some groups are more likely to go to university.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 18:58

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 14:45

I agree. I'm disengaging from them too because I'm really enjoying this thread. I feel they're showboating and derailing rather than engaging in meaningful discussion

It was YOU who was using the Troubles as an example of colonialism well before I entered the discussion.

I saw your post and responded. Had you not brought the Troubles into a discussion on colonialism, I wouldn't even mentioned it.

But you brought it in as did some others when it wasn't a colonial based conflict. So it makes no sense to use it. Simple as that.

DownNative · 14/09/2023 18:53

Coyoacan · 14/09/2023 13:50

The island itself wasn't a colony, but an integral part of the UK. Same applies to Northern Ireland where the conflict wasn't anti-imperialist/colonialism

People who live in a sovereign state are taught the history of their country, while people who live in a colony are taught the history of the country that rules them.

When I was growing up in Belfast, we were not taught Irish history, we were taught the history of the kings and queens of England.

When I was in school East Belfast, we WERE taught about Irish history. More specifically, the Famine, 1880s emergence Unionism & Nationalism, 1912 Ulster Covenant, 1916 Easter Rising, Government of Ireland Act 1920 and partition.

Definitely weren't taught about Scottish or English Monarchs in secondary school in my time.

We learnt about Northern Ireland's role in WW2, e.g. training base for Normandy landings, important for strategic reasons during Battle of The Atlantic.

So, I'm afraid what you said doesn't gel with what my generation was learning in history classes.

And I'm far from old!