Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slavery and Colonialism Are Everyone’s History

594 replies

GodessOfThunder · 13/09/2023 17:52

I was on a thread recently where posters were complaining of slavery and colonialism being “shoehorned” into exhibitions, and were strongly “pushing back” against it being given prominence as a topic in museums and at historic sites. Indeed, transatlantic slavery and colonialism often seem to be regarded as niche historical subjects of interest more to people of colour, and involving only a small number of rich white slave owners and colonial officials.

This perception however, does not reflect reality. Transatlantic slavery effected not only millions of Africans, but pretty much everyone in Britain too. Similarly, colonialism effected not only millions of subjects in the British Empire, but everyone “at home” also. The economy these projects fuelled changed what ordinary people ate and drank and what they wore. They changed how British people thought about non-European people in ways that continue to shape their mindset and create injustice today. Slavery and colonialism helped fund the Industrial Revolution and the jobs people in Britain performed, and much more too.

I’m not suggesting anyone today should feel guilty for these activities. But, these subjects are still all too often not regarded as part of all of our histories. This means attempts to give them proper prominence are met with resistance. If we are to understand British history at a public level properly there is still a great deal of work to do.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
wheresmymojo · 14/09/2023 23:13

"But the point is, people don’t understand the effects of slavery and colonialism (I’m not just talking about slavery) on Britons in Britain. Ergo they are very much part of British history. "

TBH I completely agree with your points OP.

I assumed (as an English person) that most English people DO understand this.

I've been quite surprised by a lot of the comments on this thread that show that people actually don't understand this.

It wasn't "just a few rich people with a few slaves". None of my ancestors benefitted directly as they were Irish and living in poverty but any British person alive today benefits from the legacy of slavery and the Empire.

In fact, any person, of any heritage or ethnicity living in the UK today benefits from its legacy.

We effectively plundered the riches of half the world and brought it back here - this funded the technology explosion of the Industrial Revolution as well as a large part of the increase of the UK banking and insurance sector.

Yes, we have been great industrialists and inventors but that all needed capital. And that capital came on the backs of slaves, colonialism and the working poor.

This is what allows us to be the 5th biggest economy today from a small island. It's what allows us to speak English in almost every country we visit.

ProfessorLayton1 · 14/09/2023 22:58

Just checked AQA syllabus and there is a paper on empire, would be interesting to know how many school actually teaches this.

ProfessorLayton1 · 14/09/2023 22:55

I understand that it is difficult to cover all the important topics in history. Is there even an option to choose a module on colonialism in GCSE or A level history ?

wheresmymojo · 14/09/2023 22:40

I think that's interesting @Lantyslee, I'll try to find the Roman thread.

I imagine it depends on a few different factors, not least whether 'what came after' turned out to be better or worse.

I was in Sri Lanka earlier in the year who've had a terrible time with corruption, massive (95%!) inflation on food meaning some people are now struggling to survive, very little money making its way to the ordinary person's standard of living.

I overheard many conversations of older Sri Lankans saying that it was better under British rule (which wasn't what I was expecting).

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 22:38

I don't think it's whataboutery to say this... it more "Yes, and..."

It's not whataboutery it's simply a matter of recognising that there's only so much time in schools and unless pupils are focusing on history then we need to give a well rounded introduction.

Chickenkeev · 14/09/2023 22:37

wheresmymojo · 14/09/2023 22:33

I agree with you.

I'd also like to see more about the Irish genocide.

I'm English but come from people who managed to escape (only by coming to live in terrible slums working in horrific conditions).

Mumsnet is where I first learned about it. While I'd heard of the famine the role of the English had been completely glossed over.

I have complex PTSD and it helped to see how the trauma from that genocide - seeing so many people die from starvation has had a literal knock on impact through every generation down to me.

I don't think it's whataboutery to say this... it more "Yes, and..."

Generational trauma. I definitely think there's something behind that concept. But it's depressing.

wheresmymojo · 14/09/2023 22:33

I agree with you.

I'd also like to see more about the Irish genocide.

I'm English but come from people who managed to escape (only by coming to live in terrible slums working in horrific conditions).

Mumsnet is where I first learned about it. While I'd heard of the famine the role of the English had been completely glossed over.

I have complex PTSD and it helped to see how the trauma from that genocide - seeing so many people die from starvation has had a literal knock on impact through every generation down to me.

I don't think it's whataboutery to say this... it more "Yes, and..."

CallumDansTransitVan · 14/09/2023 22:17

Clymene · 14/09/2023 22:09

@BigFatLiar

Children in primary school do rudimentary history related topics (the Egyptians, WWII evacuee here).

There is no way that: The industrial revolution, Union of Parliaments, so many reforms, Jackobites, changes in the crown, civil war, tudors, middle ages, saxons & Normans, Romans, pre history.

Plus modern history can be taught in the two years before GCSE. I would suggest that modern history is more relevant and interesting. Knowledge of the Jacobite rebellion really isn't essential

I actually think you make a good point.

It is relateable for those with limited interest in history to be taught about eg WW2 and how it shapes our relationship with other Countries. The same with the Industrial Revolution and how it brought about the modern conveniences we now take for granted.

If they then go on to take history as a chosen subject, researching and learning about further back could take place then. As others have said though, it is important not to politicise the subject.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 22:13

Knowledge of the Jacobite rebellion really isn't essential

Many would disagree, especially those who want to separate from the United Kingdom again.

Clymene · 14/09/2023 22:09

@BigFatLiar

Children in primary school do rudimentary history related topics (the Egyptians, WWII evacuee here).

There is no way that: The industrial revolution, Union of Parliaments, so many reforms, Jackobites, changes in the crown, civil war, tudors, middle ages, saxons & Normans, Romans, pre history.

Plus modern history can be taught in the two years before GCSE. I would suggest that modern history is more relevant and interesting. Knowledge of the Jacobite rebellion really isn't essential

ntmdino · 14/09/2023 22:08

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:52

It’s not necessary.

If you were teaching WW2 would you explain that war has been a norm across peoples around the globe for millennia?

Are you suggesting this because you are concerned people may think British involvement in slavery was unique and fear the consequences of this?

No, I'm saying it because the modern discussion of slavery gives the false impression that it's always exclusively been racially-targeted, which it wasn't for the vast majority of history - for the most part, it was a consequence of losing a war. In fact, even the transatlantic slave trade began that way - because it began through Dutch traders buying existing slaves from African royalty, who acquired them through winning wars.

It also evaluates it in the context of modern moral values, which is to ignore the entire history of civilisation.

The history of war is, and always has been, understood to be a part of human civilisation - and WW2 is studied in that context. Slavery, on the other hand, isn't.

My overall point, though, is that wilfully excluding relevant facts and context from the discussion is how you make propaganda, not study.

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 22:05

@Newusername1273 I am liking the idea of a global history, where we explore our connections, relationships and transitions. Sometimes painful, but more holistic than current methodology. I am going to sleep now!

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:59

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:50

What elements of modern history would you focus on?

As I mentioned above a course entitled something like “The Making of Modern Britain”. Basically Britain from around 1800 to today. Encompassing topics (just off the top of my head - others may have different ideas obvs) such as: Slavery and Empire, Industrial Revolution and Cities, War, Suffrage and Rights, Social change and the state (eg welfare state), Changing economic systems and the ideas behind them.

OP posts:
Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:57

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:52

@Newusername1273 I am rather tired and maybe not thinking straight. But I feel that only some of my history is British history, and that a large part of my history actually concerns another country. Yes, it was a colony of Britain for some time, and there the two stories overlap, but it does actually have a long and rich story of its own. Forgive me if I am not making sense, I shall have to go to bed soon. I hope you understand something of my point.

You are making perfect sense. My comment is referring to the fact you are (presumably) British so automatically your story is British history. Something brought your family members to these shores, that's British history, global history and history of their home nation. It's all those things.

We used to do an exercise at school when I was a child where we explored our family tree and our roots. Do kids still do that? It got us having all sorts of conversations with family members. Do schools still do that?

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:52

ntmdino · 14/09/2023 21:46

No, it doesn't make it alright - but it's a hugely important event, and to properly understand it is to underline the documented (and largely untaught and undiscussed) fact that from the dawn of civilisation, slavery was the norm the world over regardless of race or nationality. That's the entire point, and being infuriated is to miss it by a country mile.

It’s not necessary.

If you were teaching WW2 would you explain that war has been a norm across peoples around the globe for millennia?

Are you suggesting this because you are concerned people may think British involvement in slavery was unique and fear the consequences of this?

OP posts:
user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:52

@Newusername1273 I am rather tired and maybe not thinking straight. But I feel that only some of my history is British history, and that a large part of my history actually concerns another country. Yes, it was a colony of Britain for some time, and there the two stories overlap, but it does actually have a long and rich story of its own. Forgive me if I am not making sense, I shall have to go to bed soon. I hope you understand something of my point.

Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:50

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:48

OK. I would also place more emphasis on modern history, but not exclusively so.

What elements of modern history would you focus on?

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:48

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 21:45

That's exactly what clymene said focus on the 20th century.

You then end up with people who don't realise Macbeth was a real person.

OK. I would also place more emphasis on modern history, but not exclusively so.

OP posts:
ntmdino · 14/09/2023 21:46

nonheme · 14/09/2023 21:39

Your post infuriates me. It's quite defensive from the get go. British outlawed slavery - so that makes it alright then? Nobody can talk about Slavery because alright then we were instrumental in abolishing it. Elizabeth said she's not sorry as it wasn't illegal. Similar thing!

Why bother even saying a word?

No, it doesn't make it alright - but it's a hugely important event, and to properly understand it is to underline the documented (and largely untaught and undiscussed) fact that from the dawn of civilisation, slavery was the norm the world over regardless of race or nationality. That's the entire point, and being infuriated is to miss it by a country mile.

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 21:45

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:41

I don’t think anyone has said only focus on that period unless I misunderstood.

Edited

That's exactly what clymene said focus on the 20th century.

You then end up with people who don't realise Macbeth was a real person.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:45

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:34

Well OK. But one should be mindful that the history of British people of colour, and of those of mixed descent is going to be different to the history of British people who trace their ancestry back to the Norman conquest, for instance. When talking collectively about the history and actions of the British it's important to differentiate.

Well that’s one of the points of placing more emphasis on the history of empire - which was why I started this thread :)

OP posts:
Newusername1273 · 14/09/2023 21:43

user9630721458 · 14/09/2023 21:34

Well OK. But one should be mindful that the history of British people of colour, and of those of mixed descent is going to be different to the history of British people who trace their ancestry back to the Norman conquest, for instance. When talking collectively about the history and actions of the British it's important to differentiate.

Is it?

Surely it's important we understand how we came to be so multicultural and racially tolerant? By doing so won't you capture the views of all different races and nationalities etc?

Assuming your heritage deviates to another nation at some point in your family tree, what brought your family to these shores? What choices were made or what global political issues were going on or what was happening in their home country to make them leave? Why Britain? Your history is British history. By discussing it and having everyone discuss it you'll by default be inclusive of all races.

GodessOfThunder · 14/09/2023 21:41

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 21:38

If you focus on such a short period you miss so much of importance. The industrial revolution, Union of Parliaments, so many reforms, Jackobites, changes in the crown, civil war, tudors, middle ages, saxons & Normans, Romans, pre history. There's just so much in a basic course for schools that you can cover it's fairly certain that some people will think that their pet area has been skipped over. (We both tend to travel around visiting ancient sites as pre historic Briton is fascinating and we'd have more pre history taught. )

I don’t think anyone has said only focus on that period unless I misunderstood.

OP posts:
nonheme · 14/09/2023 21:39

ntmdino · 13/09/2023 18:00

Most people who talk about slavery don't really know the history at all. It wasn't until the British outlawed slavery in the 1800s that the world's history changed - slavery had been a part of every culture and every country on the planet for well over a thousand years, and it was nothing to do with race. Hell, it's not like the Europeans invented it either - slavery was already a thriving economy in Africa when the whites turned turned up there, they just added the "transatlantic" part (and it wasn't even the British who did that, as I recall - it was the Dutch).

The modern British penchant for self-flagellation does get tiresome after a while. Yes, our country has done many overwhelmingly shitty things to others over the centuries, but at least give a passing mention to the good bits too.

Your post infuriates me. It's quite defensive from the get go. British outlawed slavery - so that makes it alright then? Nobody can talk about Slavery because alright then we were instrumental in abolishing it. Elizabeth said she's not sorry as it wasn't illegal. Similar thing!

Why bother even saying a word?

BigFatLiar · 14/09/2023 21:38

Clymene · 14/09/2023 20:50

If you focused on 20th century history, you could cover loads of this. You could do the two world wars, Windrush, the Troubles, and cover colonialism, slavery, Kenyan Asians and other migratory patterns on the way.

How did we get to the multicultural Britain we are lucky to have today would be a good starting point.

If you focus on such a short period you miss so much of importance. The industrial revolution, Union of Parliaments, so many reforms, Jackobites, changes in the crown, civil war, tudors, middle ages, saxons & Normans, Romans, pre history. There's just so much in a basic course for schools that you can cover it's fairly certain that some people will think that their pet area has been skipped over. (We both tend to travel around visiting ancient sites as pre historic Briton is fascinating and we'd have more pre history taught. )