Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to not get jealous of SIL

189 replies

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:02

Mil and FIL are comfortable in retirement. They have a house that is worth over 700k and private pensions.

DH funded his uni and has been financially independent since he was 18. SIL had uni paid for, living expenses paid for and her wedding paid for. She never worked a single day in life. Her husband makes over £300k a year.

inlaws are constantly feeling sorry for her and “helping” her all the time. Her kids are constantly at inlaws place as she needs a break. They rent in central London as they are too poor to buy. She is constantly crying poverty and getting money from inlaws. Fil is worried about her all the time. I have no idea why. we live 10mins away from inlaws and are at their call 24/7 when they need “help”. They are physically able and quite healthy when they help SIL, but become weak when they see DH (his fault for enabling this).

DH and I are in decent jobs and have a 4 bed house (mortgaged to eyeballs) 1 hr away from London. SIL always moaned about this. (They have a house and we don’t - we are so poor! But she wants a similar sized house in Kensington). We are quite tight month on month as we save for retirement too. No fancy outgoings, quite carful with money. We get zero help from inlaws despite them being 10mins away. Our kids were in paid childcare while SILs were looked after by inlaws.

I have a nagging feeling that she is going to take away 100% of inheritance. I’m getting very resentful and jealous of her. DH and I work long hours, drag through life day to day, while she just sulks and takes what she wants.

No judgement please. I’m human! How can I get over this jealousy and just focus on my life? This woman rubs it in on a weekly basis.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/09/2023 12:40

narniabusiness · 13/09/2023 11:09

I think this will probably resonate with many people. There must be quite a few families where one child has not been allowed to grow up in their parents eyes and the other has. So you and your husband are seen as grown ups who can cope with all that life throws at you, whereas your SIL is forever the teenager navigating a dangerous world from which she needs rescuing. Ask yourself which you would prefer to be - the perpetual child or the adult?
Still sucks though. I remember my husband wanting to give his small inheritance to his not so well off sister only to be informed by a third party that she was fine as his parents had paid off her mortgage years ago.

This is a very good point. It’s much better to be the adult.

I can see why it absolutely sucks, but in fairness it doesn’t seem to have made SIL happy.

Codlingmoths · 13/09/2023 12:35

even if I didnt work at all I would be setting fresh new boundaries on being the one to help op. ‘Sorry we are busy, hopefully sil can help.’ ‘Sorry but I just can’t take time out of my work day anymore except for emergencies with the children, it’s stressful paying the mortgage right now.’

Nevermind202020 · 13/09/2023 12:35

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:45

Yes, totally. But we are having to do all the day to day support and “helping”. That’s somehow our duty, but we get nothing. Sounds fair!

Stop supporting and helping, it might feel odd saying no or not offering but I think it will be better for you in the long term.

EasternStandard · 13/09/2023 12:32

pollo8 · 13/09/2023 12:06

I'd be thinking carefully about what exactly you are jealous of. Why be jealous of someone like this? You should be proud of your own hard work, prudence, lovely house etc.

As for the resentment, you need to let go of the idea of getting any inheritance from the PILs. Consider it a done deal that you'll get nothing. (If you do, what a nice surprise.)

Next, stop making yourself quite so available to them. Quietly draw your own boundaries for what you will and won't help with. Then stay polite, but firm.

She sounds annoying as hell but I think you can choose to be less bothered by her.

This

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 13/09/2023 12:31

SunRainStorm · 13/09/2023 11:42

No judgement from me, you'd have to be a saint not to be annoyed by that.

How does DH feel about it?

I agree.

I think it is hard having SIL issues brought up to you all the time in a "poor SIL" sort of way when she is clearly very well off, and also on top of that the expectation that your DH is responsible for buying into the parent's concerns and must give her expensive presents and assistance and sympathy.

I don't think it is jealousy as such, although it is only natural to feel a bit of that when you compare your hard work, but not much left over to spend on extras, and her well heeled life, but as others have said, you will eventually own your own home.

Also as pps said. She's being treated like a child, as someone who is not responsible for themselves and must be sheltered. It doesn't sound as if you would want to live that way.

Your DH sounds kind and caring and a good example to your DC. You have a good life. Her's although comfortable at the moment, sounds a bit unstable.

I think you would benefit from stepping back a bit and not getting any further involved in the "Difficulties" that are SIL's life. That is not to say a break with the family, but just not accepting that SIL's issues are anything to do with you or even DH. She has a DH for that. She has made choices to have a life that is more than they can afford.

Also, maybe step back a little from the PILs too, who you say are unable to do lots of things and need help, unless its for SIL when they are suddenly very capable. ie. Don't always be the ever-reliable Go To available people. Make people appreciate that this is not always a done deal, or you won't be able to escape this role. Where people can stand on their feet, let them. You and DH have to stand on your own feet all the time it appears. There is a line between kindness and your own boundaries.

Moving forward. I believe its actually a very good thing for Parents, Grandparents to discuss with family what their plans are for their future care and be open about it. So that you are not suddenly landed with an assumption when its too late to do anything else.
DH's grandmother did that and it meant that it was all resolved amicably and discussed calmly which was beneficial all round. Other relatives didn't and were stressed, resentful and let things get to crisis point.
DH should try to discuss this, but the two of you decide together how much involvement you want to have so that he can let his opinions be heard to them. If things worry him, these things should be raised.
I say this not because of inheritance issues, because that's up to them who they leave their funds to ,
but because earlier pp suggested that they might donate to contribute to SIL's house purchase which you say could be £1 mill -
That's such a huge sum, can they actually afford to do this, its a valid question for DH to ask because they could be getting into a right old mess and making unrealistic sacrifices, without really ensuring that they have enough to live on themselves and expect DH to step in. So it concerns him too from that aspect.

Luckyduc · 13/09/2023 12:30

I'd be more mad at the fact he gets paid 300,000 in cash ....clearly a tax dodger and something illegal going on.

Maray1967 · 13/09/2023 12:29

This would enrage me, I must admit. My DF/PIL treat me and DB/DH and his DB very fairly and always have.

I would push back on the comments re poor SIL as suggested in previous responses. And I would not be available to help. I’m so petty I’d make it very targeted eg I can’t take you to the opticians as I’m helping out at school/ checking their homework as we can’t afford to send ours to private school with small classes. And repeat.

RampantIvy · 13/09/2023 12:28

Be less available then. Suggest that SIL can "help" more. She doesn't work so she must have plenty of free time on her hands.

This learned helplessness will backfire on her eventually. What will she do after her parents die?

Aquamarine1029 · 13/09/2023 12:26

You feeling put out by all the help you give your in-laws is on you. You can say no, easily. Your husband can deal with them.

As for your SIL, you sound quite petty, and you really need to wind your neck in. How your in-laws handle their daughter and whatever help they give her is absolutely none of your business. This is their child. They can manage their relationship with her any way they wish to. It has nothing to do with you.

MelroseGrainger · 13/09/2023 12:26

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:30

“Kensington” was a bit of frustrated exaggeration on my part. She lives in west London. They can get a nice 4 bed house for about £2.5M. They managed £1.5M with savings and “early inheritance” from her husbands parents. They “need” just 1M.

They have £1.5 million in savings and an income of £300k a year? Do you PILs know this?

I think you should shut down absolutely every future conversation about money, either with your SIL or PILs when they try to say how difficult her life is, by saying “but you’re literally a millionaire / but she’s literally a millionaire.” Say it each and every time. Again and again. And sound completely incredulous when you say it.

maybe they don’t know how much she has or how she spends it? I do think it’s a bit weird that you know so much TBH. I have no clue how much my family members earn or how much they have is savings.

but I sympathise. She sounds dreadful.

MissBiljanaElectronika · 13/09/2023 12:24

Yabu to feel entitled to any IL inheritance

they don’t owe you an inheritance

Howyiz · 13/09/2023 12:23

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:55

We are not talking /asking about inheritance.

im asking for advice to deal with my own resentment and jealousy.

DH works from office full time and I work from home 3 days a week. I’ll leave you to guess who does the most “helping”.

So stop!

It really is that easy. Every time they ask, point them in the direction of their daughter.

'As sil doesn't work, it makes more sense for her to help.'
When they inevitably point out that you are nearer you can respond with, bnt she is over all the time to drop/collect kids so she obviously doesn't mind the journey.

Repeat and rinse.

When your sil/pil bring up about her needing a house. Tell them she needs to do the same as you and take out a loan.
If they can't because she doesn't work, she needs to work the same as you do.
She doesn't have childcare, she has more unpaid than you do.

Etc etc etc keep pointing out her bullshit while refusing to help.
She benefits from help with your in laws and that should be reciprocated.

Toomanyemails · 13/09/2023 12:20

Another voice here to say this dynamic is common, I have it in my family. Reasoning has also been impossible so you have to make peace with which outcomes are not achievable (this might be equal treatment of your DH and SIL, and/or convincing the DP of the unfairness) and focus on the outcomes which are achievable, which could be:

  1. You and DH maximising enjoyment of your own lives and your DC's lives, which includes not being at beck and call of his DP
  2. You and DH ensuring your own financial security, which it sounds like you're well on the way to
  3. Maybe you want to limit time with your SIL?

You did mention inheritance in the OP, and it's not yours to be concerned about and imo not even your DH's (what if his DP need it all for their care, enjoying retirement etc). Doesn't mean he wouldn't be entitled to be upset if it is shaded unequally, but don't let this cloud everything else. As for SIL's ridiculous take on her situation, find a way to laugh it off or just ignore ignore.

applesandmares · 13/09/2023 12:20

Are you happy in your life? Do you have a loving and fulfilling marriage? Focus on that. Who cares what SIL gets, it isn't really anyone else's business what your PIL do with their money (or why) so long as they have capacity and aren't being abused.

It sounds like your husband wanted to be financially independent which is why he has been since 18? And you said yourself that he doesn't have a problem with the set up. SIL sounds a bit pathetic tbh, and if she's always wanting more she'll probably never be happy.

housethatbuiltme · 13/09/2023 12:19

YABVU... its NONE of your business.

Its not your family, your money or your inheritance.

You have zero stake in this and moaning that your in laws spend THEIR money on THEIR might leave their money to THEIR daughter is insane and speaks to pure greed.

If your DH has issues HE should discuss it with HIS family while you butt completely out of it.

His parents don't have to leave him anything if they don't want and they certainly don't owe you anything.

Luckyduc · 13/09/2023 12:19

But this is your SIL parents! They arnt your parents so of course they will help their own daughter out with childcare, wedding and everything else you listed. Your also not entitled to any of their inheritance...that gets split between your husband and SIL and if you diverced your husband, inheritance is one of the things the law doesn't allow to split. Your husband gets to keep it all.
It's abit weird that you know how much they are on or even trying to guess it's not your business.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 13/09/2023 12:18

You’re resentful because you’re supporting your PIL and not getting paid for it while SIL sits on her arse and pleads poverty. The best way to resolve your own feelings is to stop supporting your PIL.

Spottywombat · 13/09/2023 12:18

In 20 years time, you will look at what you've achieved with pride, knowing you did it alone.

I'm the dutiful one in my batshit family, does my head in. It was my own fault tho, looking back.

Look up FOG and the Stately Homes thread. Take a step back.

HollaWithDaRisinSound · 13/09/2023 12:16

Me and H are highly mortgaged in a small semi, both work full time and I've got an inherited genetic condition - (I don't claim any benefit - not that is relevant) - we will be paying this mortgage well into our 60s

Apparently, because we 'own our own home'- my parents have advised me they are leaving their very expensive mortgage-free house to my Sister 100%. During this conversation I never offered an opinion, i just said OK.
My sister knows this and never says a nice word about them and says things like 'hope they hurry up and die haha' ....
...which is actually heartbreaking

I don't feel jealous of my sister and I wouldn't swap her life for mine in any circumstances

But with my parents - This is just one of a long list of crap that my parents have done in my life to emphasize how they feel and I barely speak to them any more (actually their choice)

It is just another indicator that they don't give a shit

Rotterdam · 13/09/2023 12:14

The way to cope is firstly to stop being available. Go full time or pretend to. Or invent a training course/career development on other days. Involve your kids in more activities (or pretend to) so that you are ‘busy’.

Secondly your SIL is one of those silly spoilt people who can’t cope with life. Think of what a shit example she is setting to her own kids.

Further down the line, you have your career etc, she has nothing.

Minimise contact and if PIL need help then SIL can provide it. Forget the inheritance.

UniversalAunt · 13/09/2023 12:12

‘Yes, totally. But we are having to do all the day to day support and “helping”. That’s somehow our duty, but we get nothing. Sounds fair!’

Next time they ask…

‘Sorry, no can do. Just too busy working to pay our own way as independent adults. We are sure that you understand given your own life stories & it’s just so very important to bring up our children to understand how the real world works. Y’know treating people with respect, developing financial independence & adult responsibilities, not taking people & their goodwill for granted.’

<pause for breath>

‘Are you free first Sunday in October for family roast lunch at the Harvester/local pub/bistro ? We know that things are tight for you, Cost of Living etc, so we’ll pay for us & the kids as we’ll have just been paid.’

😉

If they can’t/won’t see a reasoned case, then at least enjoy taking the piss.

TheShinmeister · 13/09/2023 12:12

Why does she need a house that costs £2.5m? No one does. She sounds like a brat

Sisterpita · 13/09/2023 12:10

@User5512 I feel your pain. Unfortunately it is not uncommon for family members to fall into specific roles and conditioning from childhood continues throughout their life. Your SIL is the poor soul who needs support and is so hard done too. Your DH is the capable reliant one. It will take a really major event to get your PIL to shift their behaviour.

As pp have said you and DH need to discuss the level of help you are prepared to give and then stick to it. No. Is a complete sentence.

Look at services like Home Instead https://www.homeinstead.co.uk/ and start suggesting them. MIL I have an optician’s appointment - great I’ll phone Home Instead/ Community Transport to take you. FIL I need a shelf putting up - great we’ll get the local handyman to pop in. You need to go to xyz - great I’ve arranged a taxi for you. Yes you are doing the initial organising but they will start to get the idea and organise themselves. Staying firm is hard but you will regret it if you don’t.

WRT finances this is one I would suggest you keep doing. In my experience the child who always has their hand out is the one that feels entitled to “dip” into their parents money. The one who has been self sufficient is very careful to do it right. These days doing finances on-line is far easier. I recommend setting up an email that is for parents e.g. MumanddadPOA and a joint account out of which bills etc can be paid. This way you keep their bills and finances separate. If you can get them to set up POA for both Health & Well-being and Finances.

Award Winning Home Care | Home Instead

Our award winning home care allows older people to stay connected to their community at home, while still offering complete peace of mind to their loved ones.

https://www.homeinstead.co.uk/

PetiteNasturtium · 13/09/2023 12:10

@PerfectMatch This is exactly what happened when FIL died, he left everything to SIL who now owes money to MIL. She has no health issues and has always earned big money with a decade of having free accommodation plus some years offshore and tax free, she is just shit at life.

ZebraD · 13/09/2023 12:09

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:55

We are not talking /asking about inheritance.

im asking for advice to deal with my own resentment and jealousy.

DH works from office full time and I work from home 3 days a week. I’ll leave you to guess who does the most “helping”.

Then stop doing it for them if it is causing resentment. Be busy or tell them you will see if DH can do it when he finishes work etc. If you are always busy they will soon get the message.

Swipe left for the next trending thread