Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to not get jealous of SIL

189 replies

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:02

Mil and FIL are comfortable in retirement. They have a house that is worth over 700k and private pensions.

DH funded his uni and has been financially independent since he was 18. SIL had uni paid for, living expenses paid for and her wedding paid for. She never worked a single day in life. Her husband makes over £300k a year.

inlaws are constantly feeling sorry for her and “helping” her all the time. Her kids are constantly at inlaws place as she needs a break. They rent in central London as they are too poor to buy. She is constantly crying poverty and getting money from inlaws. Fil is worried about her all the time. I have no idea why. we live 10mins away from inlaws and are at their call 24/7 when they need “help”. They are physically able and quite healthy when they help SIL, but become weak when they see DH (his fault for enabling this).

DH and I are in decent jobs and have a 4 bed house (mortgaged to eyeballs) 1 hr away from London. SIL always moaned about this. (They have a house and we don’t - we are so poor! But she wants a similar sized house in Kensington). We are quite tight month on month as we save for retirement too. No fancy outgoings, quite carful with money. We get zero help from inlaws despite them being 10mins away. Our kids were in paid childcare while SILs were looked after by inlaws.

I have a nagging feeling that she is going to take away 100% of inheritance. I’m getting very resentful and jealous of her. DH and I work long hours, drag through life day to day, while she just sulks and takes what she wants.

No judgement please. I’m human! How can I get over this jealousy and just focus on my life? This woman rubs it in on a weekly basis.

OP posts:
EvilElsa · 13/09/2023 13:31

Also agree with just taking a massive step back and stopping being available so often to help. I don't understand why you are putting yourself out for them when they don't reciprocate.

WallaceinAnderland · 13/09/2023 13:30

coconutpie · 13/09/2023 13:27

So your SIL and her DH have £1.5m in savings, her DH earns £300k a year, they wish to buy a house worth £2.5m but can't get a mortgage for the £1m? Why can't they get a mortgage for that on a salary of £300k?

That's irrelevant though isn't it. The finances of another family are nothing to do with the OP. If they don't want a mortgage that's up to them. I would never be trying to keep track of my BIL's wages, savings and mortgage potential. OP needs to focus on her own life, not theirs.

coconutpie · 13/09/2023 13:27

Also, stop being so available to PIL. Start saying no. "Sorry, I can't help, you'll have to ask SIL to help with that".

coconutpie · 13/09/2023 13:27

So your SIL and her DH have £1.5m in savings, her DH earns £300k a year, they wish to buy a house worth £2.5m but can't get a mortgage for the £1m? Why can't they get a mortgage for that on a salary of £300k?

Womencanlift · 13/09/2023 13:21

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:55

We are not talking /asking about inheritance.

im asking for advice to deal with my own resentment and jealousy.

DH works from office full time and I work from home 3 days a week. I’ll leave you to guess who does the most “helping”.

If it’s you then stop. If they ask for anything just say you have a daughter and a son, ask them

You need to put some boundaries up if you want to not feel put upon all the time

Toys may be thrown out of multiple prams but not your issue, it’s not your family it’s your DHs and therefore for him to sort out

And it’s not your inheritance either so stop focusing on that

Phineyj · 13/09/2023 13:19

You do need to look into why you've got involved with all this help for two fairly healthy, not particularly elderly people. For one thing if you saw them less it would massively reduce the amount of annoying things you need to hear!

I mean, my DP are into their 80s and don't need me to do any of this stuff! (My dad was seriously ill a few years ago and I did help out then -- and they have helped me in the past quite a bit so I would reciprocate).

WallaceinAnderland · 13/09/2023 13:18

You are projecting onto your SIL your frustrations about your own decisions.

Firstly, take her out of it. If you weren't married to her brother, her life would have no affect on your whatsoever.

Focus on your DH's relationship with his parents. If he is happy with it then it does not affect you. It's nothing to do with you what they choose to spend their money on.

If your DH is not happy then he needs to address this with his parents. Both of you can stop helping the parents. You can. You are choosing to do this and then complaining about it as you resent it.

You need a heart to heart with your DH and to understand that if he doesn't want to deal with it then drop it, see less of PIL and try to enjoy your own life without comparison to others.

Capachoochoo · 13/09/2023 13:13

How do the requests for help from PILs get made? Directly to you, or via DH?

Colinswheels · 13/09/2023 13:11

You have my sympathies, my FIL is still working well into his 70's because he bought a house for my SIL to live in rent free and they plan to gift it to her once the mortgage is paid. My DH on the other hand gets asked to go round and help them change lightbulbs. I try and let it wash over me but my DH gets incredibly frustrated but finds it impossible to say no.

lavender2023 · 13/09/2023 13:10

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:30

“Kensington” was a bit of frustrated exaggeration on my part. She lives in west London. They can get a nice 4 bed house for about £2.5M. They managed £1.5M with savings and “early inheritance” from her husbands parents. They “need” just 1M.

the median London house price is £523,666. £1.5 million can get you a house in most parts of London including the nice parts. Yes you will get a smaller home than outside London but this has always been the compromise.

Majority of homes in Kensington are flats and most people (including private school parents) live in the mansion flats.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 13/09/2023 13:08

Parity is important for families and I can see how it must grate to see your husband work hard to potentially be taken for a mug.

Personally I'd act confused "oh you know, SIL needs a break" and assume they're joking "haha yes it's hard being a lady who lunches, rushing between those nail and hair appointments, so rough", "well you know they can't afford a house", "yes it's hard situation to only have 1.5 million, poor dears, we should start a Go Fund Me for them.

elsieandthepooch · 13/09/2023 13:04

Sounds a bit like my SIL but my situation is not about money it is always about how awful her life is, how depressed she is etc. I was even expected to "support" her with her depression when she came to stay with us for a week despite us having our own stressors at the time. How does DH feel about this? I've learnt the best way is to just cut myself off from it all. It's his family at the end of the day and I leave it to him now to do the communicating and to get worked up about things.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/09/2023 13:03

Be proud of your independence
& next time they 'need help', suggest that SiL has more time since she can't be arsed to get a job.

Nosleepforthismum · 13/09/2023 13:03

Firstly, remove any thought of inheritance from your mind. Live your life as if your DH will get nothing. Your PIL’s may decide to sell up and spend it all travelling when they retire, it may get swallowed up in care home fees, they may decide to leave it entirely to the RSPCA. All of which they can do as it’s their money and theirs to spend or leave as they wish.

Secondly, would you want to trade positions with SIL? Pretty sure the answer would be no. You have a career, a house and healthy kids - you have a lot to be thankful for. You also don’t ever really know what’s truly going on in your SIL’s life. It doesn’t sound great if they are struggling on a £300k wage. I’d be feeling more sorry for her than resentful. I don’t know anyone in real life who actually wants handouts from their parents when they have families of their own. It would be seen as something to be ashamed of in my circles.

Robinni · 13/09/2023 13:02

I don’t think you will ever like this woman, her privilege, lifestyle and demeanour are too different from your own.

What could alleviate a lot of stress is having DH sit down with his parents regarding their affairs to sort them out.

Ideally you want to ensure an ironclad will with 50:50 split and your DH being executor or at least joint executor with the sister or she is going to thoroughly take the piss and have it all for herself.

You also need to consider aspects such as inheritance tax - is it better to sign over house now or have it as a Ltd company?

That comes across as your biggest concern really. For you to do the majority of work looking after them and receive nothing would be incredibly unfair.

Your DH needs to sort it out. But I wonder if he wasn’t strong enough to stand up for himself over the Uni funding, wedding help etc would he be able to do it over this?

EvilElsa · 13/09/2023 13:01

There's nothing you can do about that OP so there's no point in worrying about it. Sometimes life isn't fair. Sometimes parents favour a child. It sounds like you have a happy marriage and a good life -concentrate on that and all the great things you have. If you find your relationship with SIL taxing then cut it to the bare minimum. If she/they moan about finances or life be brutally honest in your answers -we have money because we live within our means and I work. Nothing to do with luck. Cut off the bollocks swiftly and change the subject.

Thelnebriati · 13/09/2023 12:59

YANBU, its not an unusual situation at all. Have you heard of the scapegoat and the golden child? Its hard on the scapegoat to be constantly excluded, and the will is usually the last 'fuck you'. Support your DH and go along with however he wants to handle it.

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 13/09/2023 12:58

Shame if your phone accidentally blocked them. My ils never had my mobile number.. And dh certainly would never have lifted a finger to help them. They came once a week. At 8.20 am. If they showed up uninvited I just went about my day. Even if that meant going out and taking dc with me.

wherethewestwindblows · 13/09/2023 12:57

If you have energy to spare focusing negatively on what someone else is doing with their life when it doesn't directly and immediately impact you (the only impact it sounds as though you're worried it'll have is inheritance related, which is a really sad thing to be focused on when people are still alive and well), then you're not focusing enough on your own self and own circumstances.

Fallingthroughclouds · 13/09/2023 12:57

I'd be jealous too!

Milkmani · 13/09/2023 12:54

Has anyone in the family suggested that she get a job?

SunRainStorm · 13/09/2023 12:50

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:55

We are not talking /asking about inheritance.

im asking for advice to deal with my own resentment and jealousy.

DH works from office full time and I work from home 3 days a week. I’ll leave you to guess who does the most “helping”.

This is the only part you have control over.

What will you do with that control?

billy1966 · 13/09/2023 12:45

It's funny how some parents have zero difficulty in identifying that one child should get their time, efforts and free childcare, whilst another can be their PA and future carer.

My single friend has had 20 years of her parents devoting every minute of their time to her brother and his family, whilst she was superfluous to requirements unless they needed something, and they have been quite demanding of her over the years as they had her sort out things for them that they chose not to do.

Never had any interest in her "spinster" life.🙄

They had started to slow down a bit, and her parents and brother made it clear that her future would be as their carer, and she really should think about moving back home, rather than 10 minutes away.

She never said a word but it was the push she need to apply for a transfer immediately within her large organisation and has moved an hour away.

Her parents never called to her, so it was surprisingly easy to sell up her small home.

She has really settled well where she is renting and loves her new job.

Her move was met with absolute incredulity, but she told them that if they had ever asked what she was doing in her life she would have shared her plans.

She still visits and cares for her parents, but she has left her brother squarely in position to continue his close relationship with their parents, but he and his wife are now who they have to call for their PA duties as she is too far away and her new position is very busy.

She is so grateful that she was motivated to move as it has been a hugely positive and she is so much lighter in herself.

CollagenQueen · 13/09/2023 12:44

Why doesn't your DH say to his parents "SIL's family income of £300k, is more than me and User 5512 earn put together. And she has an amazing lifestyle where she doesn't have to work, whereas me and User 5512 have to both work full time. Why are you feeling sorry for her?"

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/09/2023 12:42

Howyiz · 13/09/2023 12:23

So stop!

It really is that easy. Every time they ask, point them in the direction of their daughter.

'As sil doesn't work, it makes more sense for her to help.'
When they inevitably point out that you are nearer you can respond with, bnt she is over all the time to drop/collect kids so she obviously doesn't mind the journey.

Repeat and rinse.

When your sil/pil bring up about her needing a house. Tell them she needs to do the same as you and take out a loan.
If they can't because she doesn't work, she needs to work the same as you do.
She doesn't have childcare, she has more unpaid than you do.

Etc etc etc keep pointing out her bullshit while refusing to help.
She benefits from help with your in laws and that should be reciprocated.

This too.