Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to not get jealous of SIL

189 replies

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:02

Mil and FIL are comfortable in retirement. They have a house that is worth over 700k and private pensions.

DH funded his uni and has been financially independent since he was 18. SIL had uni paid for, living expenses paid for and her wedding paid for. She never worked a single day in life. Her husband makes over £300k a year.

inlaws are constantly feeling sorry for her and “helping” her all the time. Her kids are constantly at inlaws place as she needs a break. They rent in central London as they are too poor to buy. She is constantly crying poverty and getting money from inlaws. Fil is worried about her all the time. I have no idea why. we live 10mins away from inlaws and are at their call 24/7 when they need “help”. They are physically able and quite healthy when they help SIL, but become weak when they see DH (his fault for enabling this).

DH and I are in decent jobs and have a 4 bed house (mortgaged to eyeballs) 1 hr away from London. SIL always moaned about this. (They have a house and we don’t - we are so poor! But she wants a similar sized house in Kensington). We are quite tight month on month as we save for retirement too. No fancy outgoings, quite carful with money. We get zero help from inlaws despite them being 10mins away. Our kids were in paid childcare while SILs were looked after by inlaws.

I have a nagging feeling that she is going to take away 100% of inheritance. I’m getting very resentful and jealous of her. DH and I work long hours, drag through life day to day, while she just sulks and takes what she wants.

No judgement please. I’m human! How can I get over this jealousy and just focus on my life? This woman rubs it in on a weekly basis.

OP posts:
frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 18:43

Yes, but those are flats. OP explicitly says SIL is after a house the same size as her house, which is an hour out of London, but in Kensington.

This isn't a rational thing that is really about housing in an area, these kinds of people are greedy like that. They feel entitled to it. It's weird.

lavender2023 · 13/09/2023 18:28

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 18:10

You would think it was a huge salary, but have you seen the prices in Kensington? They're eye watering.

not kensington but notting hill. I guess its all about expectations and type of property. she had two kids in it.

https://www.houseandgarden.co.uk/gallery/fiona-mckenzie-johnston-flat

I doubt she earns £300k somehow as a journalist. I think this flat sold for less than £500k. Might even be similar value as my 2 bed flat in zone 3 north london (1930s purpose built).

And this red brick mansion 3 bed flat (share of freehold) is well below £1.5 million (£1.1 million)
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/139243259#/?channel=RESBUY

A richly decorated ex-local authority flat in Notting Hill

As she prepares to move out of her Notting Hill flat, Fiona McKenzie Johnston documents the ups and downs of local authority living, and gives us a tour of her highly decorated interiors.

https://www.houseandgarden.co.uk/gallery/fiona-mckenzie-johnston-flat

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 18:10

You would think it was a huge salary, but have you seen the prices in Kensington? They're eye watering.

storypushers · 13/09/2023 17:58

It’s not normal for someone with a household income of £300k to want to live in central London.

Really? Surely that's a huge salary.

Ibizafun · 13/09/2023 17:51

Kensington!! I'd like to live in Kensington! Not v helpful sorry

HamBone · 13/09/2023 17:42

Honeychickpea · 13/09/2023 17:16

Wouldn't they then just ask their son if it is true? I doubt he'd appreciate being put on the spot in that way.

@Honeychickpea I’m joking, I wouldn’t really do it. Although it sounds as if the OP and her DH do have a hefty mortgage and a lot of expenses to cover.

Funkyblues101 · 13/09/2023 17:39

For a house in central London she needs millions a year, not hundreds of thousands. You may need to explain slowly and carefully to your in laws that it's very sad SIL isn't an heiress to multi millions, but only a handful of people are and that, even if they gave her every penny they have and lived in a cardboard box, it would still not be enough for what she wants.

ohboohoo · 13/09/2023 17:35

Also say 'we would sooooo love to live somewhere posh like SIL does but they have £300k coming in and we don't so we have to compromise. It's soooooo hard with BOTH of us HAVING to work and not having free time to spend with the dc'

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 17:33

I think it's relevant, Horsey, it's how you dealt with (and feel about) a similar situation. One of the hardest things is that everyone always assumes it is about money. It is NOT about money. It's about all the other things that money represents: love, being heard, care, emotional support, being respected.

You need to find the right therapist, I think, because a lot of people simply don't understand (or refuse to see) the lack of recognition that this implies. I think OP and her DH would.also benefit from having a place where they are "seen". Misrecognition is a terrible thing to deal with.

ohboohoo · 13/09/2023 17:33

Just repeat every time 'you think it's hard in £300k???? Then you must realise how crippled we are on only £XX and that's with TWO of us working and no help with childcare. You have it sooooo easy'

WallaceinAnderland · 13/09/2023 17:27

Don't waste your life being bitter about someone else being more fortunate (in your eyes).

Honeychickpea · 13/09/2023 17:16

HamBone · 13/09/2023 15:54

@Fairyliz Yes, I’d be SO tempted to lay it on with a trowel once or twice, just to see the reaction. It’s evil, I know. 😈

Wouldn't they then just ask their son if it is true? I doubt he'd appreciate being put on the spot in that way.

Noicant · 13/09/2023 16:47

When they call just say “oh sorry I would love to but I’m super busy with work/kids/ right now, give SIL a call, she’s free to help”. If they says she’s not then just snort and say “freer than I am, y’know work, gotta pay those bills…... Oooh sorry urgent email came through, got to go”

Rinse and repeat. Also it’s not ok for your DH to farm out helping to you without your consent. You need to say no to this, he can do what he wants but he can’t delegate to you.

Tbh yeah this dynamic absolutely sucks, I was the black sheep and just went NC.

horseyhorsey17 · 13/09/2023 16:45

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 16:34

I hear you @horseyhorsey17 . I think it helps to realise that the blindness is deliberate - it is a refusal to see the truth, not an inability to see it. Took me decades to deal with the emotional fallout, which is actually way worse than the financial (why aren't I as loveable? Why isn't my unhappiness as important? Why is my struggle worth less? Those questions get to the heart of something very deep and quite young inside all of us. Therapy really helped me handle them and come out the other side as someone who could simply state the situation without being angry, upset or bitter any more. And to take pride in the fact that I pulled myself up by my own bootstraps!! I am self reliant, hear me roar (often with laughter).

The irony in my case is that I actually do way more for my parents now than my sister does. As soon as she got enough money she flounced off. Leaving them with me. Suddenly they started to see my good side, assisted by the fact that there was no longer someone residing in their house and constantly badmouthing everything I said or did. 😂

Oh god, yeah, I've always done way more for my parents than my sister. I see myself as Cordelia in this King Lear-style scenario! She doesn't lift a finger to help them with anything, and I am quite sure that should anything happen to dad, she'd spend all mum's money and then claim she was too skint to help out with care home costs etc. Which is actually a real worry, but that's another story.

Maybe you're right and therapy is the way forward. It's probably worth a try as I think my inner child is pretty fucked up by all this! Like you say, it's not the money - that's just a material manifestation of love. What I think I find most hurtful is that I am a popular person in my life, I am kind and have lots of friends, and I suppose my career is pretty successful, but I still feel kind of worthless because my parents have always just treated me as an 'also ran'.

Anyway! I am accidentally derailing the thread.

FlamingoQueen · 13/09/2023 16:35

Sadly, in-laws always seem to favour the daughter, no matter how much they earn, what they do, how much of a car crash their lives can be!

Personally, I have massively distanced myself from the in-laws because, tbh, it was embarrassing.

I think this may be what you need to do. Otherwise, you will end up becoming ill.

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 16:34

I hear you @horseyhorsey17 . I think it helps to realise that the blindness is deliberate - it is a refusal to see the truth, not an inability to see it. Took me decades to deal with the emotional fallout, which is actually way worse than the financial (why aren't I as loveable? Why isn't my unhappiness as important? Why is my struggle worth less? Those questions get to the heart of something very deep and quite young inside all of us. Therapy really helped me handle them and come out the other side as someone who could simply state the situation without being angry, upset or bitter any more. And to take pride in the fact that I pulled myself up by my own bootstraps!! I am self reliant, hear me roar (often with laughter).

The irony in my case is that I actually do way more for my parents now than my sister does. As soon as she got enough money she flounced off. Leaving them with me. Suddenly they started to see my good side, assisted by the fact that there was no longer someone residing in their house and constantly badmouthing everything I said or did. 😂

aloris · 13/09/2023 16:34

I think you need to be like my friend who would never put up with this (ok, she's an ex-friend, but she had lots of great skills for not being taken advantage of, and we could all learn from her). If anyone played their "little tiny violin" to get attention, she would just briskly say something like, "Sarah, we all know that's nonsense, you and your husband make plenty of money, in fact your husband alone makes twice what Bob and I make together. Housing in Kensington costs a fortune, so if you can't afford it, then do as we did and move farther out where housing is cheaper. Listening to you complain when your life is so fantastic gives me the itches and I would really appreciate it if you could pipe down a bit so I could enjoy my scone."

In other words, she wasn't mean, she didn't shout or anything like that, but she also didn't tolerate being expected to nod along to a fake narrative.

You aren't owed this inheritance so I agree with others that it's pointless to spend your effort worrying about it. However, you also aren't obligated to serve his parents out of your limited resources while being treated like a lesser person by them. Just stop doing it. If you want to point out, any time you decline to help them, that your resources are limited and that helping them takes away from your own future, then that's up to you. Or you could just silently roll your eyes. But I think if you stop letting your dh's parents combine their neediness of you with their favoritism of his sister, then you'll feel much less resentful about their favoritism of her.

horseyhorsey17 · 13/09/2023 16:27

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 16:18

There is nothing more infuriating than watching someone get all of the help and resources in a family because they play a vulnerability card, when you are struggling proudly, fiercely and independently by yourself! I grew up with a similar situation, only the person in my family is my sister, who colonised all the support functions in the family for 20 years. And I mean everything. She lived at home for nearly 20 years, waited on hand and foot by my parents, saving up for a deposit on a grand fancy house. Meanwhile, when I fell on hard times I had to be self reliant. When my relationship broke down I slept in my car because there was no room at my parents' house for me to stay. I will probably never catch up with the financial advantage she got from all that rent free life and emotional support. But, do you know what, I'm bloody proud of achieving what I've achieved on my own. My sister has accused me of being "jealous" of her life and I suppose in a way I am, but not materially. I think it must have been nice to monopolise all the care, love and space in the family. But I would never actually do that because I'm just a better person than she is. So the so-called jealousy is hypothetical, and comes with a heavy side order of condemnation.

I do think in your case that this is quite gendered and a key to breaking it down is probably to get your DH to open up to them about his struggles too. And that may also mean being a bit less available to do everything for them. Stop being the all-round performing monkeys. Plead exhaustion, illness, busyness - all true excuses. They are well off and can clearly afford to pay for help so it's not like you will be abandoning them or anything. When SIL raises the house issue then "help" by suggesting properties around you that are for sale within their budget. Make them state the trade-off they are making in words. And point out the discrepancy in childcare too. You don't have to be horrible about it, just state it as a fact and say that you wish you had similar help.

Lots of families work by sustaining obvious fictions of various kinds. The more you can do to challenge or dismantle this the better.

This is my situation too. At risk of sounding all bitter (and tbh I am a bit) my parents have given tons of financial support to my brother and sister. My sister is always playing the 'poor little me' card and has help with her mortgage, car paid for, holidays paid, big wedding paid for etc and my brother had help to buy his house and loads of help with his kids. I've had...nothing. No financial help, no help with my kids ever, and in fact my parents expect me to help my sister out but never expect her to lift a finger for me. I was also booted out of home to fend for myself as soon as I left for uni.

I'm not minted, I'm a single mum and am currently working two jobs to make sure I can pay for everything and me and the kids. I could do with some support but never get any. I think my parents justify it by thinking 'oh she's fine, she can cope with anything' and think the other two need more help, but it's actually really hurtful. And tbh I could do with some help! Things are not easy at the mo.

frumpalertt · 13/09/2023 16:18

There is nothing more infuriating than watching someone get all of the help and resources in a family because they play a vulnerability card, when you are struggling proudly, fiercely and independently by yourself! I grew up with a similar situation, only the person in my family is my sister, who colonised all the support functions in the family for 20 years. And I mean everything. She lived at home for nearly 20 years, waited on hand and foot by my parents, saving up for a deposit on a grand fancy house. Meanwhile, when I fell on hard times I had to be self reliant. When my relationship broke down I slept in my car because there was no room at my parents' house for me to stay. I will probably never catch up with the financial advantage she got from all that rent free life and emotional support. But, do you know what, I'm bloody proud of achieving what I've achieved on my own. My sister has accused me of being "jealous" of her life and I suppose in a way I am, but not materially. I think it must have been nice to monopolise all the care, love and space in the family. But I would never actually do that because I'm just a better person than she is. So the so-called jealousy is hypothetical, and comes with a heavy side order of condemnation.

I do think in your case that this is quite gendered and a key to breaking it down is probably to get your DH to open up to them about his struggles too. And that may also mean being a bit less available to do everything for them. Stop being the all-round performing monkeys. Plead exhaustion, illness, busyness - all true excuses. They are well off and can clearly afford to pay for help so it's not like you will be abandoning them or anything. When SIL raises the house issue then "help" by suggesting properties around you that are for sale within their budget. Make them state the trade-off they are making in words. And point out the discrepancy in childcare too. You don't have to be horrible about it, just state it as a fact and say that you wish you had similar help.

Lots of families work by sustaining obvious fictions of various kinds. The more you can do to challenge or dismantle this the better.

Janieforever · 13/09/2023 16:05

Op does your husband know you’re jealous you don’t get money from his parents and are worried about how much money you will get when they die?

does he feel the same, does he know?

im utterly shocked at what I’m reading.

HamBone · 13/09/2023 15:54

Fairyliz · 13/09/2023 15:50

You need to get to acting classes and practice your sad face. Surely you are worried sick about the massive increase in your mortgage payments? What happens if you get thrown out of your house and your children are homeless?
You don’t ask you don’t get op.

@Fairyliz Yes, I’d be SO tempted to lay it on with a trowel once or twice, just to see the reaction. It’s evil, I know. 😈

Janieforever · 13/09/2023 15:53

Goodness me, you’re poor in-laws. They aren’t even your own parents, and you’re already stressing about getting their money when they die and if she will get it instead.

i don’t know how you deal with your own thoughts are that bad. But I’d focus on my own life and stop focusing on others finances and what you can get.

Fairyliz · 13/09/2023 15:50

You need to get to acting classes and practice your sad face. Surely you are worried sick about the massive increase in your mortgage payments? What happens if you get thrown out of your house and your children are homeless?
You don’t ask you don’t get op.

SerafinasGoose · 13/09/2023 15:47

User5512 · 13/09/2023 11:55

We are not talking /asking about inheritance.

im asking for advice to deal with my own resentment and jealousy.

DH works from office full time and I work from home 3 days a week. I’ll leave you to guess who does the most “helping”.

Stop.

outdooryone · 13/09/2023 15:42

I have had to learn to let this go too - albeit with much more modest sums of money involved. I too have a family member who is clearly supported way more than us two other siblings. The family member lives down the road from my father and is supported ongoing - from free childcare, through to 'a few quid' towards holidays and cars being bought on a 'family loan' that are never repaid.
It is not my money. It is my fathers. His choices.