Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel DD’s Birthday tomorrow

282 replies

Bumbleumbo · 13/09/2023 09:47

DD turns 14 tomorrow and for her birthday she wanted a MacBook Air and for me to take her and 6 friends out for dinner.

I’m struggling with her ongoing defiant behaviour and this morning threatened to cancel her birthday and presents as I’ve had enough. Every single day is a battle, she lays in bed until the very last minute refusing to get up, dressed and out of the house. She’ll often claim to be getting ready, then at the very last minute announce that she needs to wash her hair and can’t possibly go to school without washing, drying and straightening. This takes over an hour. This morning I woke her at 6.30am knowing she needs a shower. I proceeded to call her every 10 minutes but each time I entered her room she screams at me to get out. It’s like this every single day and we’re constantly late, this makes DD2 late and impacts my working day.

I have always struggled with boundaries. I’ve been a shitty parent and have spoilt both children over the years. Ive created lazy entitled monsters. I suspect DD thinks I won’t follow through and the guilt I would feel not celebrating her birthday tomorrow will probably get the better of me.

I thing she might have low lying depression so maybe her behaviour doesn’t warrant punishment but help, although Ive tried to get her to speak to someone and open up but she says I’m crazy and she is absolutely fine. She just doesn’t want to do anything or go anywhere most of the time and she absolutely hates school.

In this situation would you use a birthday to enforce boundaries or is that a cruel step too far? Birthdays in this house have always been a big deal but I just can’t be bothered anymore. My DC’s don’t appreciate it and I’m tired of this relentless battle.

I’m a single mum and their dad hasn’t bothered with birthdays since he split with his GF 3 years ago. I’m just exhausted trying to do everything myself all of the time…

OP posts:
Qwertyyui · 13/09/2023 13:50

She needs help with time management. My DD is a lazy sod. She also has Autism which causes time blindness. I also cannot just because I am always running late. I think you need to sit down and look at the reasons why this is happening. Every behaviour has an explanation if you ask. I always check with DD when she needs to next wash her hair. I give her time frames I expect her to be ready for (I build in time buffers to ensure she doesn't miss these because she will) and then take it from there. I wouldn't cancel her birthday at all but I would explain the consequences going forward is she will need to be late and I'd also get in contact with the school to see it there was support that can be put in place for her. Kids are sent to test you. How you react is your choice. On days I know I am short with my temper I talk it through with her and tell her in advance 'if I snap I don't mean to' we have built mutual respect. This might work for you as well? x

ExtraOnions · 13/09/2023 13:46

Gosh … sounds very much his we first started

3 years in, 2 years of school avoidance at high school, missed the first year of college, Anxiety, Depression, Panic Attacks & rage. CAMHS have now diagnosed with ASD, poss ADHD (still being assessed), and anxiety. She has started on meds, has a Consultant Psychiatrist, and a therapist - has just started back at college this term (so far so good)

It’s been 3 tough years, and had involved me having to change the way I parent - sometimes “taking away their electrical” and shouting, just doesn’t work - and what then ?

No young person wants to feel like your daughter is feeling, there is something underlying it, and you need to find out more about that.

Doing what you have always done, has got you to this position, so do something different. I’ve been there, and it’s horrible …

Maray1967 · 13/09/2023 13:45

Not sure that will work with a 6 year old, though!

Shouting and kicking off by my 3 years olds resulted in removal from wherever we were or ending of what we were doing. That worked for mine.

In my experience, gentle conversations only work with very placid kids - but that’s only my experience. Perhaps it does work on more defiant Dc but it didn’t work with mine.

LesLavandes · 13/09/2023 13:44

You must insist she showers and hairwashes before or after supper as mornings are difficult

Maray1967 · 13/09/2023 13:42

YukoandHiro · 13/09/2023 10:04

@randomusername2020

"I would not tolerate EVER being screamed at by my child, so that needs immediate consequences. There are ways to communicate that dont involve screaming."

Genuine question, not being goady, as I think it could help me: what immediate consequences would you use for screaming/shouting?

My 6yo is shaping up to be a screamer and I find it really difficult. We never ignore it but neither firm sanctions (no tv, cancellation of play dates) and gentle conversations/modelling about respectful communication are doing nothing to stop the escalation of it as she gets older.

I have a 15 year old. The immediate consequence of being shouted out is removal of Wi-Fi. That tends to be very effective - only needed to do it twice.

GuanYinShanxi · 13/09/2023 13:40

UniversalAunt · 13/09/2023 13:15

Shocked?

Harsh? Nope, just direct & honest. OP is looking for change in practical matters, there is no doubt that she loves her children & wants the best for them, but the dynamics in the family group are strained. OP is becoming weary & disaffected with her kids as teens are generally hard work & the set up is just not functioning. Time for things to change.

@GuanYinShanxi perish the thought that anyone would use my throwaway comment as a ‘script’ but it is not abusive to make clear to teens that their parents have their own life, go through difficult experiences & hard feelings however that point is made appropriate to the family style of communication. OP’s DD is not unwanted or unloved by her father, he has absented himself. DD may feel hurt (of course an understatement).

The purpose of a family meeting is to make change for everyone’s benefit, & build upon consensus. Some ‘action planning’ for a home schedule is a useful start in life skills for teens.

Not so long ago, people left school at 14yo to go to work/into apprenticeships, had turn up on time, get on with the job & grow into adult responsibilities.

You say this is a throwaway comment that is direct and honest?
I am fucking sick to the back teeth of being your servant, your punch bag & hauling you through your life when you are old enough to do the simplest things, geddit?

Gosh, I’d really hate to see what you think is a harsh comment for a parent to say to an impressionable and potentially depressed child then.

If you’d said it to a poster, it would be deleted as a personal attack and we are adults who can weather abuse from random strangers on the web far better than a child can take it from their mother, who is their only present parent.

Positive41 · 13/09/2023 13:38

Bumbleumbo · 13/09/2023 10:07

I don’t usually spend so much but she needs a new laptop for school. I use them for work and mine is 6 years old and going strong. The dinner thing will be her first social outing in months. She barely left the house during the holidays, so threats of grounding, withholding pocket money etc doesn’t seem to bother her.

We live rurally, so it’s a six mile walk across fields to get to school. I took the youngest to school this morning and left DD to get ready but when I came back she still hadn’t showered. This was apparently my fault as I hadn’t given her clear instructions. She is currently up in her room and I’m about to start work.

I can't believe she was still in her room at this time, when she should have been at school.

I was all for carrying on with the birthday meal but this is unacceptable. You're trying your best, it must be hard as a single parent. People should cut you some slack.

There is NO way she would be getting the MAC. You must lay down stricter rules. All kids try it on but they must know there's a barrier they do not cross- ie not listening/screaming at you.

Have a talk with her today. If she doesn't sort herself out, there should be no birthday meal. I feel awful saying that but this is not acceptable.

SleepingStandingUp · 13/09/2023 13:33

I don't see birthdays as a reward for being good. I don't monitor my kids the week before to decide if they deserve a birthday so no, I wouldn't cancel it. Esp as you're accepting some responsibility for how they've turned out.

What I would do is the following day stay right, your 15. I'm not babying you anymore. I will call you once when I get up and I'll give you a 10 minutes warning when I leave. If you're not with me, you can explain to school. Currently you're both putting drama into the mornings
Stop it. If she's late, she gets real life consequences. Tell her you're sorry to hear she was late this morning, and you'll be sure to call her twice tomorrow morning - when you get up and 10 minutes before you leave.

WillowCraft · 13/09/2023 13:31

Don't cancel her birthday and don't make threats. She will just feel resentful and victimised. You want her to take responsibility herself, not do stuff because of a punishment.

If she hates school why is that? Can something be done about it?
Decide what the main couple of behavioural issues are and ask her what she proposes to do about them. You can make a list together and agree what she will do, she can ask you to help if need be. Then let her get on with it.

If consequences are needed, they should be proportionate and relevant to the problem and helpful rather than punitive - for example, late for school = earlier bed time, earlier phone curfew. Too much time spent on hair = only allowed straighteners after school not in morning.

And always model the behaviour you want - be polite and respectful (most of the time - obviously sometimes you will lose your rag and that is ok as long as it's not too often).

I remember as a teenager absolutely hating the constant reminders to get out of bed. Every time I was reminded I would shout at my parents and stay in bed longer to feel like it was my decision. What I needed was to be given the responsibility to decide for myself when to get up. There is nothing more annoying than being micromanaged!

Nanny0gg · 13/09/2023 13:28

lking12 · 13/09/2023 11:57

I’d keep the dinner so as not to let down her friends and to make sure she knows your happy to celebrate.
keep hold of the laptop and tell her she’ll receive it when her behaviour improves.

I would maybe chat to the school about the issues getting her there on time, then I would leave her home if she missed the “bus” I.e your lift! I assume if she had absence she’ll get detention?! Let her get detention.

But eventually it will trigger Ed welfare involvement.

ActDottie · 13/09/2023 13:27

I think a MacBook Air is a massive present for a 14 year old! Definitely something my parents would never have got me. I would’ve instead been told to save up for it on my own and my parents would maybe have contributed.

I think I’d hold the presents back until she behaves but still go ahead with the meal.

Moodwill · 13/09/2023 13:22

Bumbleumbo · 13/09/2023 10:12

Honestly, I’m not really in a position to talk as I shout too. I start off calm but after being ignored for hours, I eventually resort to shouting. Often I cry.

OP I am you. Could have written that word for word.

I cancelled DS's 13th birthday recently. I still can't believe I was brave enough to do it and follow through! I am a mug and usually get walked over.

I am so glad I did it, although I can't say it's changed his behaviour since recently. But I'm hoping it's shown him that I do mean what I say.

Mumofoneandone · 13/09/2023 13:19

Maybe seek some family counselling to try to reset things - you are struggling to parent difficult behaviour alone.
But things need to change - maybe scale down the birthday plans but not cancel altogether - certainly wouldn't be buying that sort of 'laptop'.
Good luck!

LifeExperience · 13/09/2023 13:17

You've spoiled her by not following through when you make threats. You made another threat, so you must follow through.

She won't die from missing a birthday party and presents. She will learn that you mean what you say. Keep meaning what you say and she will start to respect you.

At one point our daughter had nothing in her bedroom except a mattress because she kept losing privileges. She's now a healthy, loving well-adjusted medical doctor. You have to teach her that actions have consequences, and the only way to do that is to make her actions have consequences.

fluffyguineapig · 13/09/2023 13:17

Hugs OP, it's so bloody hard. I would say that now she's a bit older it's good to shift from imposing on her to a more collaborative process. Can you sit her down and explain the issue to her "We need to leave at xx time and it's not happening. What do we need to change to make sure you're ready on time?"

If you shift to the mentality of "what support do you need to get this done" then there's less for her to push against than "you need to do this or I will punish you".

I would also stop all the waking her up and nagging at her too, she needs to start taking responsibility to get herself to school on time. In three years she could well be out of the house and you won't be able to nag her out of bed, so this is really the time for her to learn how to manage these things herself.

CheshireCat1 · 13/09/2023 13:16

Don’t threaten something that you’re not going to do. Leave her to sort herself out in the mornings, she’s old enough.

UniversalAunt · 13/09/2023 13:15

Shocked?

Harsh? Nope, just direct & honest. OP is looking for change in practical matters, there is no doubt that she loves her children & wants the best for them, but the dynamics in the family group are strained. OP is becoming weary & disaffected with her kids as teens are generally hard work & the set up is just not functioning. Time for things to change.

@GuanYinShanxi perish the thought that anyone would use my throwaway comment as a ‘script’ but it is not abusive to make clear to teens that their parents have their own life, go through difficult experiences & hard feelings however that point is made appropriate to the family style of communication. OP’s DD is not unwanted or unloved by her father, he has absented himself. DD may feel hurt (of course an understatement).

The purpose of a family meeting is to make change for everyone’s benefit, & build upon consensus. Some ‘action planning’ for a home schedule is a useful start in life skills for teens.

Not so long ago, people left school at 14yo to go to work/into apprenticeships, had turn up on time, get on with the job & grow into adult responsibilities.

HappyPurrrsday · 13/09/2023 13:13

A birthday dinner and a macbook air? I used to get £25 on my birthday growing up, wow. She obviously doesn't know how lucky she is.

I don't know about the dinner. I'd want to cancel the dinner for showing me a lack of respect. I would expect huge backlash because she'll use every trick in the book to get you to change your mind. In reality, I'm too soft and I'd probably let her 'earn' it back if she can get out the house and to school on time tomorrow.

But I would bring in a new rule: You wash, dry and straighten your hair at night from now on. Every Sunday, Tuesday, Thursday. Those days, no negotiation. (Or whatever days work best). If it's not done, that's your own fault. The hot water gets turned off. Those evenings are the evenings it gets done, end of. The shower is a ten-minute job and she can sit and watch Netflix while she does her hair after dinner/before bed. So it's not exactly a punishment.

I would permit running the straighteners over any kinky bits before school from where she's slept on it, but only if done say, 20 mins before you're due to leave. No last minute straightening.

If she misses the deadline, I think I'd take the fuse out the fuse box and get in the car/go to school without her. That way she can't even sit watch tv/go on the wifi either while you're gone.

yeahwhatev · 13/09/2023 13:11

Nooo don't cancel her birthday celebrations, that's so sad, and will be remembered long after you care about her being on time for school.

Sounds like the laptop is not just a treat but needed for schoolwork, so withholding it will have other effects.

She's a teenager, it's not good behaviour, but she / you are not alone or unique with these kinds of struggles.

You are better off talking to her, rebuilding communications, and being clear about your boundaries going forward.

NigellaAwesome · 13/09/2023 13:11

Her behaviour sounds awful, but just an alternative view.

My DD showed quite challenging behaviour at a similar age. Withdrew from family, spent a lot of time in her room, couldn't wake her in the morning - constantly tried to use her phone into the small hours even though we had a strict no devices after 9pm policy.

It turned out she had experienced an extremely traumatic attack and we didn't know anything about it. What we were seeing was PTSD, the late nights were because she was too scared to sleep because of the nightmares.

Hopefully this won't be the case for your DD, but often at that age anxiety and depression can manifest itself in quite undesirable ways. You say she didn't go out much over the summer - is she being bullied? Does she have anxiety?

Ffghhhbdbfb · 13/09/2023 13:08

I wouldn’t cancel, particularly as her friends will probably instantly decide you are the bad guy.

After the birthday have a written list of expectations/rules and enforceable consequences. Some good advice in the thread of a phone curfew if she does not get up.

StrangerFingers · 13/09/2023 13:05

mhm...

Are you using extravagant gifts as a substitute for time, focus and interest in your dd? Because if you are, they know it and it won't make them happy at all.

14 year olds are frustrating, immensely so and it's hard.

But such an extravagant and expensive gift, yes you are creating spoilt children and we all know that they are usually not happy because learning boundaries, genuine interest and time time spent together makes them happy.

I suggest you go ahead with the party but do not give the MacBook. Keep that for yourself and give dd your old one.

Then slowly bit by bit you start giving consequences.

The not getting read needs some unpicking. Why is this happening? Does she feel so much pressure to look polished at school? Does she struggle with body image? Is there someone she likes and want to impress or is she being bullied? Have a conversation because being late must be embarrassing for her.

Boundaries yes, consequences yes but also love and understanding. Ditch the consumerism though!

LondonLass91 · 13/09/2023 13:03

Bumbleumbo · 13/09/2023 09:47

DD turns 14 tomorrow and for her birthday she wanted a MacBook Air and for me to take her and 6 friends out for dinner.

I’m struggling with her ongoing defiant behaviour and this morning threatened to cancel her birthday and presents as I’ve had enough. Every single day is a battle, she lays in bed until the very last minute refusing to get up, dressed and out of the house. She’ll often claim to be getting ready, then at the very last minute announce that she needs to wash her hair and can’t possibly go to school without washing, drying and straightening. This takes over an hour. This morning I woke her at 6.30am knowing she needs a shower. I proceeded to call her every 10 minutes but each time I entered her room she screams at me to get out. It’s like this every single day and we’re constantly late, this makes DD2 late and impacts my working day.

I have always struggled with boundaries. I’ve been a shitty parent and have spoilt both children over the years. Ive created lazy entitled monsters. I suspect DD thinks I won’t follow through and the guilt I would feel not celebrating her birthday tomorrow will probably get the better of me.

I thing she might have low lying depression so maybe her behaviour doesn’t warrant punishment but help, although Ive tried to get her to speak to someone and open up but she says I’m crazy and she is absolutely fine. She just doesn’t want to do anything or go anywhere most of the time and she absolutely hates school.

In this situation would you use a birthday to enforce boundaries or is that a cruel step too far? Birthdays in this house have always been a big deal but I just can’t be bothered anymore. My DC’s don’t appreciate it and I’m tired of this relentless battle.

I’m a single mum and their dad hasn’t bothered with birthdays since he split with his GF 3 years ago. I’m just exhausted trying to do everything myself all of the time…

If you cancel it, you'll be absolutely out of order.

But then you already know that.

CosyNightsOnTheSofa · 13/09/2023 12:58

Low lying depression 🙄, she sounds like a lazy entitled brat. She needs to know you will follow through on your threats. The next few years at school are important, there's no room for laziness or excuses. I'd cancel the lot, if her behaviour improves over the next month or so I'd reconsider allowing her to have her present and party then. Don't be a pushover and give over with the having to diagnose something!

GuanYinShanxi · 13/09/2023 12:53

convene a family conference, give notice of need to change & discuss what is to be done. ‘Why?’ ‘Because I am fucking sick to the back teeth of being your servant, your punch bag & hauling you through your life when you are old enough to do the simplest things, geddit?’.

@UniversalAunt you don’t think that is a bit harsh? It’s almost implying that this child is an unwanted burden on the OP. A child that is already unwanted and abandoned by her own father. I wouldn’t ever say this to any child of mine and I’m shocked that you’re advising what appears to be an emotionally abusive script for the OP to say to her child.