Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we are unreasonable landlords?

238 replies

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 09:16

We moved out of London recently, but have kept our house and we are renting it out.

Our tenants moved in last week and so far we are finding them very difficult. On day one they called and the wife was shouting down the phone to my husband with a whole list of things that she was unhappy about.

There are too many things to mention, but she described the house as being filthy, dirty and covered in stains. Firstly the house is rented unfurnished with wooden floors throughout so not sure what could really be stained. Secondly, we had our much trusted long term cleaner spend 8 hours cleaning the property after we moved out and the check in report we have since since seen describes the property as domestically clean throughout. Nevertheless, we subsequently agreed to arrange a professional clean of the house. When the cleaning company arrived they called us to say that there was so much stuff everywhere that they could not even access some rooms and as some boxes etc were piled precariously they considered it a health and safety hazard. They cancelled the clean (with a £50 cancellation fee) which our tenants are very unhappy about.

Before moving in the tenants demanded that we install a washer dryer (we only had a washing machine) which we reluctantly agreed to. We did not have time to do this before we moved out and then needed someone to be at the property to take delivery. We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in. On day 1 the wife went ballistic at my husband about it and asked how she was going to be able to do washing. We pointed out that she could use the existing (perfectly fine) washing machine and put clothes out to dry in the 30 degree heat, but apparently that was unacceptable. We arranged a washer dryer to be delivered 2 days later (the quickest possible delivery slot) and then the night before (after we had had already received a 2 hour delivery slot message) they told us no one would be around to take delivery. We have again incurred a charge to rearrange the delivery.

There is a whole host of other things but I would be here writing for days to detail them all. Funniest was they told us that the boiler is inadequate because it does not have a water tank (it is a combi boiler).

We have asked to go round at some point this weekend to look at a couple of the smaller “issues” and collect a parcel addressed to us that has been accidentally delivered to the house. They are refusing because it is the anniversary of the death of the wife‘s mother.

We are trying our best to help them, but nothing ever seems to be right / good enough for them and frankly is is exhausting!

OP posts:
OhmygodDont · 13/09/2023 09:59

Meh.

I think you should get rid of these tenants as soon as possible.

However the house should have been professionally cleaned before they moved in.

The washer dryer should have been in before they arrived or the date agreed. However you should have never agreed in the first place. You should have simply said if they are unsatisfied with the provided washer they are free to dispose of it and purchase their own machine.

I certainly wouldn’t be in when convenient for the landlord to collect a parcel tbh I’m not your concierge. You can come when I’m free.

Problem is the Relationship if fucked currently now so get rid and move on.

Pot8ohs · 13/09/2023 09:58

Did you do a check-in inventory and schedule of condition? And have them agree and sign the condition?

This is really important to have.

ActDottie · 13/09/2023 09:57

Normally when new tenants move in there are some teething issues but not on this scale! They do sound nuts! Personally I’d be giving them notice in a few months. Another option could be to get a letting agent to manage it? My parents do that for a stress free life.

outdooryone · 13/09/2023 09:57

I am an ex landlord and currently have two student sons who are tenants.

There are a few things here that you as a landlord need to sort, not the tenant.
Cleaning - why did it need two cleans, and from day 1 the place should be spotless. I assume there was a pre-tenancy by owner/landlord/agent along with images take on the day alongside the inventory which is shared by all?

The delivery and install of the new washer/drier - that is Landlord responsibility if you agreed it.

The delivery's etc to their home - that is the tenants home and choice.

Pile of boxes the days after they moved in - that is the tenants choice and responsibility.

There needs to be some give and take on both sides here, as well as awareness that you are dealing with someone's home.

ehupo7 · 13/09/2023 09:57

They sound awful. I think I would have backed out at the point they were ‘demanding’ a washer dryer.

Nightmare. I would be doing everything in writing and making sure there’s a thorough record if all communication, photos of everything (the condition of the property, and clear pictures of any issues they claim).

I would consider asking them to leave – have no fault evictions already been brought to an end? If they haven’t yet, I think I would be looking to wrap up this tenancy while you’re still able to (obviously giving them plenty of notice to find somewhere new).

YANBU

Prettypaisleyslippers · 13/09/2023 09:54

I’m a landlord. Property should have been professionally cleaned, with a receipt as evidence. Washer/dryer should have been in situ when they moved in. Then you wouldn’t have had to entertain those initial complaints.

I would be pissed off if I had to take time off work to receive the landlords delivery, just after moving in.

The other things, including the boiler comment just reply with a stock phrase, something like, “”that is what comes with the property/how the property is” etc

are they new to London?

user1497207191 · 13/09/2023 09:49

Royanne · 13/09/2023 09:41

Hmm, if you break it down though

Obviously you suspected the house might need cleaning or why would you have arranged a further clean?
They've just moved in so of course they'll have boxes around etc - did you expect them to move out again to facilitate the clean?

You agreed to a washer dryer and it wasn't there at the start of the tenancy. They are entitled to be annoyed about that. Why are you booking delivery slots without finding out when they're available?

If it's not convenient for you to pick up the parcel then it's not convenient. This is their home now.

I agree with this. I think both landlord and tenant are being unreasonable.

Why did the landlord arrange a delivery of a washer drier without checking when the tenant would be in to take delivery? That's just crazy.

Why didn't the landlord check the cleanliness and general state of the property themselves before the tenant moved in? If they aren't local and couldn't be arsed to travel to look at it, then they should engage a local managing agent.

Sounds like six of one and half a dozen of the other to me.

Illegallyblonder · 13/09/2023 09:48

They sound like a nightmare, get rid of them as soon as you can.

ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 13/09/2023 09:47

I was a renter until last year, and they do sound like hard work.

Is it their first time renting in the UK? Their expectations do seem a bit off.

You may find that things calm down a bit once they're settled. I'd reserve judgement on what to do at the end of the tenancy for a few months.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 13/09/2023 09:46

Ignore them. Do any maintenance needed but you do not need to supply white goods. I’ve never had a tenancy where they have been supplied before. You also do not need to be at their beck and call whenever they want. Tell them they are only allowed to contact you between 12noon-3pm for any non urgent repairs or maintenance needed. They are only to contact you outwith those hours for emergencies and if their issue is not an emergency you will not be responding to them until your contact hours.

SquashPenguin · 13/09/2023 09:45

Get them out. There are better tenants than this. Do it before they stop paying rent.

GU24Mum · 13/09/2023 09:45

I'd echo a PP and offer them the chance to go with no penalty if they'd like to. They won't but at least you'll have offered.

Otherwise, when can you serve a break notice? There will be a six month minimum term and probably no landlord break but Is definitely check!

Managing agents can be good for being the foil between landlords and tenants but they tend to do anything for an easy life ie won't tell the tenants if their requests tip into being unreasonable. All the referencing they do won't pick up if someone is a pain though.

Cosyblankets · 13/09/2023 09:44

endofthelinefinally · 13/09/2023 09:36

Always use a managing company. Read all reviews, find a good, professional local agent. They will vet potential tenants and draw up the contract, deal with the deposit and manage everything on your behalf. Expect to pay around 12%.
Hopefully you can get rid of these people asap.
It is a mistake to think you can manage a property yourself.
My friend is a managing agent in a local firm and the stories she tells me are hair raising.

I don't have a management company. I used the estate agent to do all the checks for finance etc. I did the viewings with the agents and ruled one or two out immediately! I do the rent collection directly into my own bank and they ring me with any problems.
I know a plumber and an electrician and a handyman and only live 5 min from the property.
It works for me. But my tenants are normal reasonable people who look after the property. When they call we get something fixed as soon as possible.
In your shoes though i would pay an agent and get rid as soon as you can.

HicIocusEst · 13/09/2023 09:44

PS I rent.

HicIocusEst · 13/09/2023 09:42

CFs.

They're awful. Already. You are under no obligation to provide white goods of any kind. Unless it's in the terms they've been given.

They'll be calling you for everything, because they can. My cousin had a couple like this. Called him.to go over for an "infestation" of insects after a couple of weeks. It was the end of summer and the house backed onto a field. They showed him a spider in a matchbox and asked for money off the rent.

TheCurtainQueen · 13/09/2023 09:41

They asked for a washer dryer so you just bought one even though there was already a perfectly functioning washing machine? You sound like a bit of a pushover OP.

Proudgypsy · 13/09/2023 09:41

Just tell them it isn't going to work out.

You've already shot yourself in the foot by proving that you'll bend to their demands so it'll only get worse. Why on earth did you agree to the washer/dryer request?

GoldenKiwi · 13/09/2023 09:41

I've been renting for 25 years and you don't sound like an unreasonable landlord. On the contrary, you sound very reasonable (I have had some bad ones over the years!).

They sound nuts.

Royanne · 13/09/2023 09:41

Hmm, if you break it down though

Obviously you suspected the house might need cleaning or why would you have arranged a further clean?
They've just moved in so of course they'll have boxes around etc - did you expect them to move out again to facilitate the clean?

You agreed to a washer dryer and it wasn't there at the start of the tenancy. They are entitled to be annoyed about that. Why are you booking delivery slots without finding out when they're available?

If it's not convenient for you to pick up the parcel then it's not convenient. This is their home now.

Butterflyfluff · 13/09/2023 09:40

I definitely wouldn’t have replaced the washer with a washer drier - they are never very good as they need to do 2 totally opposing tasks and do neither well IME

If it’s rented unfurnished I have no idea why you agreed this but it’s sounds like it’s opened the floodgates

I’d give them notice now, but be prepared for a battle to get them out, including them not paying rent.

Wrongsideofpennines · 13/09/2023 09:40

Washer dryers are rubbish. They take forever and never dry things properly. If you have agreed to it though but they aren't around to accept delivery then that is their problem and I would be telling them that you will cancel the order if they are not available at a prearranged time.

Unfortunately if they aren't there this weekend then you can't just turn up, but they aren't that desperate to get the issues sorted are they.

Slowlylosingmymind101 · 13/09/2023 09:39

Get an estate agent OP. They will deal with the headaches for you. It costs but it will be worth it. I'm not a landlord but I am a tenant. There are some rubbish ones out there so look carefully. You sound like a good landlord. I've had awful landlords in the past but I have a good one now. It needs to be mutual respect and boundaries to work

mibbelucieachwell · 13/09/2023 09:38

They sound spectacularly difficult.

The only explanation I can think off, is that they feel they're paying a lot for the rent and are therefore entitled to have everything the exact way they prefer it to be. Or they're very anxious generally.

FWIW, I don't have a washer dryer either, but if that was my preference and I was paying a lot of rent I might ask for one too.

flipent · 13/09/2023 09:37

Absolutely don't provide a washer dryer. You are under no obligation to. If the property was rented with a washing machine, and it were to break you are required to replace but only like for like.
As for the cleaning standards, if the check in reported a domestic cleaning level then that is how they are expected to return it at the end of the tenancy. You are not required to have a professional clean.

If they want a washer dryer they can buy one, but they are also obliged to store the current washing machine for the duration of the tenancy and leave it in the property when they leave. Unless you agree for them to replace with a washer dryer that they leave instead.

I think you've been more than accommodating, but you need to understand the tenancy legislation better (I'm a long term renter not a landlord). Would also say that in your case an agent might be a very good investment.

endofthelinefinally · 13/09/2023 09:36

Always use a managing company. Read all reviews, find a good, professional local agent. They will vet potential tenants and draw up the contract, deal with the deposit and manage everything on your behalf. Expect to pay around 12%.
Hopefully you can get rid of these people asap.
It is a mistake to think you can manage a property yourself.
My friend is a managing agent in a local firm and the stories she tells me are hair raising.

Swipe left for the next trending thread