Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we are unreasonable landlords?

238 replies

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 09:16

We moved out of London recently, but have kept our house and we are renting it out.

Our tenants moved in last week and so far we are finding them very difficult. On day one they called and the wife was shouting down the phone to my husband with a whole list of things that she was unhappy about.

There are too many things to mention, but she described the house as being filthy, dirty and covered in stains. Firstly the house is rented unfurnished with wooden floors throughout so not sure what could really be stained. Secondly, we had our much trusted long term cleaner spend 8 hours cleaning the property after we moved out and the check in report we have since since seen describes the property as domestically clean throughout. Nevertheless, we subsequently agreed to arrange a professional clean of the house. When the cleaning company arrived they called us to say that there was so much stuff everywhere that they could not even access some rooms and as some boxes etc were piled precariously they considered it a health and safety hazard. They cancelled the clean (with a £50 cancellation fee) which our tenants are very unhappy about.

Before moving in the tenants demanded that we install a washer dryer (we only had a washing machine) which we reluctantly agreed to. We did not have time to do this before we moved out and then needed someone to be at the property to take delivery. We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in. On day 1 the wife went ballistic at my husband about it and asked how she was going to be able to do washing. We pointed out that she could use the existing (perfectly fine) washing machine and put clothes out to dry in the 30 degree heat, but apparently that was unacceptable. We arranged a washer dryer to be delivered 2 days later (the quickest possible delivery slot) and then the night before (after we had had already received a 2 hour delivery slot message) they told us no one would be around to take delivery. We have again incurred a charge to rearrange the delivery.

There is a whole host of other things but I would be here writing for days to detail them all. Funniest was they told us that the boiler is inadequate because it does not have a water tank (it is a combi boiler).

We have asked to go round at some point this weekend to look at a couple of the smaller “issues” and collect a parcel addressed to us that has been accidentally delivered to the house. They are refusing because it is the anniversary of the death of the wife‘s mother.

We are trying our best to help them, but nothing ever seems to be right / good enough for them and frankly is is exhausting!

OP posts:
Buzzardandsparrowarefriends · 13/09/2023 12:20

If you don’t want to pay an agent to manage, join the NRLA and do the accredited landlord course.
This will give you the knowledge of how to manage them but also there are lots of resources to help.

The problem with supplying white goods is you will now be responsible for any breakdowns or replacement.

Rewis · 13/09/2023 12:19

Get a management company. Don't communicate with them directly. Also don't agree on ridiculous things. If you've rented it with a washer and they want something else, they can buy it themselves.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/09/2023 12:12

They do sound bad, but I will say as a tenant that I have never moved into a home that was properly clean. They always look fine when I visit, but then when I move in I always see dirt. Some of it is just dust accumulated between tenants, but there are also things like dirty toilets and the inside of cupboards. It's annoying considering how we tenants are penalised if we leave anything not perfect - I was penalised for leaving cleaning products for the next tenants, for example.

Katbum · 13/09/2023 12:11

Get an agency to manage the property. Well worth you not having to deal with the tenants

HoisttheMainSail · 13/09/2023 12:10

These people will be a bloody nightmare, but you are where you are, so I suggest that you mark on your calendar the earliest date that you can serve notice and just prepare yourself for a white knuckle ride until then.

And as others have said, get LL insurance and a managing agent.

I thought it was pretty standard for both tenant and landlord to sign off on an itinerary with photographs before the tenancy starts so they cannot complain, and they return it to the landlord in a similar state? This also stops the landlord from claiming the tenants damaged the property. This is vital.

As a general guide, if a tenant has yet to move in and is demanding things like different white goods, the colours of rooms to be changed, different flooring to be put in... run a mile. If you give an inch they will keep demanding more and treat you more like a concierge than a LL.

Good luck.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 13/09/2023 12:02

Do we actually know if they were telling the truth about the place needing another clean; or did OP just arrange it to placate them and so they would have no grounds for complaining again if they'd actually been there when the new clean was done?

You will have problems getting your rent from them. Trust me

I fear you're right here. I think they're setting you up in advance as a nightmare landlord, so they can then DARVO when refusing to pay the rent.

My FIL once had a colleague who invested in an expensive camcorder (this was some years ago!) to take with him on holidays, specifically so that he could find/invent/concoct anything possible to complain about - and 'prove' it (even if he was filming a problem that he'd just deliberately created himself).

His MO was planned right from the very start: find and book a lovely holiday that he had every intention of angrily demanding a full refund for.

Mind, he also knew a couple who lived in a council house, who took up all the upstairs floorboards to burn as firewood in the living room, and then bitterly complained to the council that their house was in an appalling state and so they should not be expected to pay any rent to live there!!

MsSquiz · 13/09/2023 12:02

Ask tenants to provide photos of their issues so you can see if they are being reasonable or not.
Deal with everything via email to keep a written record
Re the washer/dryer, tell them if they are unwilling to be present for delivery, you will cancel the order, as how else can it be delivered?

Don't engage in stupid back and forths with them

FloweryName · 13/09/2023 12:01

Fuck that. Get advice and give them notice to leave asap.

SafferUpNorth · 13/09/2023 12:00

Nightmare! They sound like chancers. What nonsense about the combi boiler! FGS don't let them bully you into replacing a perfectly adequate, working hot water system.

As others have suggested, get a management agent in, or offer to end their tenancy early if they are so unhappy with the property. You'll find easier tenants in no time.

crosstalk · 13/09/2023 11:59

Another one saying check you have done all that is legally required of a landlord including the relevant safety checks and deposit with professional deposit holder. You did not need to provide a washer/dryer if only a washer was in the list of goods - but having done so, you do need to ask them when it can go in. Also, for your protection and theirs, insist everything is emailed except dire emergencies - and even then, for your protection, I would email them to say "you called me at 6am on Sunday morning saying there was a flood in the house ..... I then did x y z". I, too, would be searching for the break clauses in the contract.

Skogrammy · 13/09/2023 11:46

Just get them out as quick as you can.

As soon as they demanded a washer/dryer you should of backed out of the arrangement.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 13/09/2023 11:45

OhmygodDont · 13/09/2023 09:59

Meh.

I think you should get rid of these tenants as soon as possible.

However the house should have been professionally cleaned before they moved in.

The washer dryer should have been in before they arrived or the date agreed. However you should have never agreed in the first place. You should have simply said if they are unsatisfied with the provided washer they are free to dispose of it and purchase their own machine.

I certainly wouldn’t be in when convenient for the landlord to collect a parcel tbh I’m not your concierge. You can come when I’m free.

Problem is the Relationship if fucked currently now so get rid and move on.

We have asked to go round at some point this weekend to look at a couple of the smaller “issues” and collect a parcel addressed to us that has been accidentally delivered to the house. They are refusing because it is the anniversary of the death of the wife‘s mother.

The OP wants to collect the parcel whilst discussing their issues, you can argue "I certainly wouldn’t be in when convenient for the landlord to collect a parcel tbh I’m not your concierge. You can come when I’m free" both ways. OP isn't at their beck and call to come and discuss the issues on their schedule. They can do it when she's free.

Sounds a bit petty, really.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 11:44

I had tenants who requested that I remove the downstairs carpets and have wooden flooring installed. This should have been a huge red flag, but like you I thought I’d show some good will and went along with it.

Anyway, I agree with those saying you should offer them the choice of breaking the contract early if they are not happy.

flipent · 13/09/2023 11:43

As a long term renter, I would love to know where all of these professionally cleaned Air B&B standard rental homes are for rent which can actually be afforded on an average income.
Only rule around cleaning is that the tenant only needs to return it to the same level of clean on ending the tenancy. There is no requirement for a professional clean.

whynotwhatknot · 13/09/2023 11:38

sorry but youre making it harder for yourselves-they agreed to rent as is so no need to buy extra washing machines

they agreed it was clean when they moved you have proof no need for a cleaner

youre being walked over just stop

Daisymay2 · 13/09/2023 11:36

Another saying to involve a managing agent, although it can be difficult to find a good one- too many view it as an easy buck, which it isn't always. do you know anyone who rents out property and can recommend one? It might be difficult now as they are in already.
You shouldn't have agreed to the further clean- it has been described as domestically clean and that is how they will be required to return it to you.
You should not have agreed to a washer drier , they are rubbish and break down all too easily. We actually told one of our difficult tenants who was moaning about not having a washer drier, that her choice was a washing machine or nothing.
I hope you have good landlord insurance in place, I suspect you might have with holding of rent soon, particularly as they have complained about the heating system.

Royanne · 13/09/2023 11:35

I just cannot believe the amount of posters saying to evict them. On what basis? Them expecting to move into a clean property and the items they have been promised to be in situ?

OP says it had been cleaned to a domestic standard. That's really not good enough before a new tenancy. There will have been neglected areas and the OP knows that, hence them arranging a professional clean. But they also should have known that wasn't possible once the tenants had moved in.

Re the washer dryer - no that's not necessary in a property but that's beside the point, it had been agreed to. It should have been there.

I also don't know why everybody is jumping to the conclusion that they won't pay rent. I would imagine that they have every intention to pay the rent, hence them being upset that the property isn't up to standard.

Viviennemary · 13/09/2023 11:31

They sound ridiculous ignore them. Or start proceedings to evict.

Crikeyalmighty · 13/09/2023 11:30

We rent at a high end and yes you do need a professional clean before anyone moving in and if anything has been requested and agreed to then it needs to be in situ before the move- however stuff like stains etc- then that's just tough as house is taken as seen - only time we had issues was actually with a hugely posh agent where the photos had clearly been taken at least a few weeks before, so lawns needed doing and drive needed weeding plus 2 wasps nests- so we asked for those to be sorted. Current house we had a couple of snagging issues like a non working fan and the front door keys didn't work (annoying but was sorted) these sound very OTT

fruitbrewhaha · 13/09/2023 11:21

And tell them they can break the terms of the lease and move out straight away but they been to let you know by the end of the week. After that the terms are binding, or what ever works for you.

fruitbrewhaha · 13/09/2023 11:20

You need to handle the letting process or give it all over to a letting agent.

I rent out a flat in London and I advertise and do the viewings all myself for this very reason. I’ll set aside a day for viewings and have always found someone on that one day. It’s like interviewing, you just let the place out to someone who can speak on the phone and communicate properly, who is polite, who can find the place on time without having to phone up from miles away lost, (from a smartphone that has a map). It’s not much fun having to judge people by a phone call and a 20 minute chat but it’s totally worth it to not have some oddball who calls you endlessly.

Moveoverdarlin · 13/09/2023 11:18

There’s no way I’d have bought the washer / dryer. If that was a deal breaker, they shouldn’t have accepted the property. I would start refusing their requests. If they don’t like it they can leave.

JudgeRudy · 13/09/2023 11:14

Is this the first time you've been a LL? I'd expect more drama. Without listening to the conversation it's hard to gauge how picky they were being but I would expect the house to be clean when I moved in and I'd expect the washer drier to be in situ. I think it's unreasonable to expect your tenant to agree to being at home at a specific time for the delivery. I wouldn't be happy with that.
Others have suggested a management company. It'll cost, but it's worth considering.

Winky1973 · 13/09/2023 11:14

Landlord here. Get yourself an agent ASAP. It is so worth the monthly management fee.

It’s imperative the paperwork is thoroughly up to date these days. Legally, it’s a minefield with electrical testing etc etc. Eviction cannot be started without absolutely everything in place as the defendant will pick holes in the tenancy agreement and relevant certifications if they don’t want to leave. The judge will side with them as the onus is on the landlord to be squeaky clean.

ChristopherTalken · 13/09/2023 11:06

In the nicest way, because you sound like good people, this is why there should be more stringent rules around who can be a landlord. For your protection, and tenants. They are exploiting you massively here, you do not have to provide white goods. Have you done an inventory with photos? I would be concerned that would live the house in a mess and say that was the condition they found it in.
Def pay the professionals to handle this for you!