Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we are unreasonable landlords?

238 replies

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 09:16

We moved out of London recently, but have kept our house and we are renting it out.

Our tenants moved in last week and so far we are finding them very difficult. On day one they called and the wife was shouting down the phone to my husband with a whole list of things that she was unhappy about.

There are too many things to mention, but she described the house as being filthy, dirty and covered in stains. Firstly the house is rented unfurnished with wooden floors throughout so not sure what could really be stained. Secondly, we had our much trusted long term cleaner spend 8 hours cleaning the property after we moved out and the check in report we have since since seen describes the property as domestically clean throughout. Nevertheless, we subsequently agreed to arrange a professional clean of the house. When the cleaning company arrived they called us to say that there was so much stuff everywhere that they could not even access some rooms and as some boxes etc were piled precariously they considered it a health and safety hazard. They cancelled the clean (with a £50 cancellation fee) which our tenants are very unhappy about.

Before moving in the tenants demanded that we install a washer dryer (we only had a washing machine) which we reluctantly agreed to. We did not have time to do this before we moved out and then needed someone to be at the property to take delivery. We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in. On day 1 the wife went ballistic at my husband about it and asked how she was going to be able to do washing. We pointed out that she could use the existing (perfectly fine) washing machine and put clothes out to dry in the 30 degree heat, but apparently that was unacceptable. We arranged a washer dryer to be delivered 2 days later (the quickest possible delivery slot) and then the night before (after we had had already received a 2 hour delivery slot message) they told us no one would be around to take delivery. We have again incurred a charge to rearrange the delivery.

There is a whole host of other things but I would be here writing for days to detail them all. Funniest was they told us that the boiler is inadequate because it does not have a water tank (it is a combi boiler).

We have asked to go round at some point this weekend to look at a couple of the smaller “issues” and collect a parcel addressed to us that has been accidentally delivered to the house. They are refusing because it is the anniversary of the death of the wife‘s mother.

We are trying our best to help them, but nothing ever seems to be right / good enough for them and frankly is is exhausting!

OP posts:
purpleleotard2 · 13/09/2023 13:03

Issue a section 21 immediately.

Do it while the option still exists

sadaboutmycat · 13/09/2023 13:02

I'm a tenant with a lovely landlord and my view is that day to day consumables (cleaning etc, blocked drains, things like that) are my responsibility but something like the shower not working and an electrical repair needed would be his.

They are very unreasonable!

Testina · 13/09/2023 13:01

I don’t think it’s fair to say they “demanded” a washer dryer. It’s a negotiation - it was a fair request for the rent they were going to pay. You were fully at liberty to say no. Having said yes, unless agreed otherwise, it should have been in place before the tenancy. It’s not about whether there was 30° heat. From their point of view, not bothering to do what was agreed and then expecting them to sit in for it comes under red warning flags of a shitty landlord.

GasPanic · 13/09/2023 13:00

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 12:25

No, I think most of us understand that we’ll have problem tenants from time to time, but that doesn’t make it any less frustrating when it happens.

Many tenants seem not to understand that their landlord isn’t a concierge or a hotel manager.

Yes.

But many landlords seem not to understand their tenants are paying customers and view them as an inconvenience.

It's impossible to tell whether the house was up to scratch. Different peoples ideas of what constitutes clean are different. There is also the fact that if the tenant is paying top prices for a top spec property they might expect different levels of cleanliness compared to a lower price and different levels of fittings/service.

It's also true to say that some people from different countries where there are different standards set re renting and the renting high end properties might be more usual and so tenants might be more used to being aggressive in making sure the property conforms to their liking. In a lot of countries renting is not seen as a poor second choice to home ownership that it often seen as in the UK, and is often something done by high earning profesionals.

All we know (I think) is that in this particular instance the landlord decided not to engage an agency (?) presumably because they thought the money they would charge would not be reasonable and that they would be better off providing that service themselves (?) and now maybe is finding out that the service levels and amount of work required is somewhat larger than expected ...

Notcontent · 13/09/2023 13:00

Those who say you need a “professional” clean - do you realise that this just means a cleaning agency charging extra for a clean? There is no magic to it…

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 13/09/2023 12:54

Many tenants seem not to understand that their landlord isn’t a concierge or a hotel manager.

Also, a lot of neighbours of tenants seem to think that the landlord is their parent, and will contact them direct with petty issues that have nothing to do with who owns the property and everything to do with the people who live there.

If you owned your home (with a mortgage), nobody would dream of complaining to the bank who provide the mortgage because they don't like the way you park on the road outside!

AbbeyGailsParty · 13/09/2023 12:53

YANBU.
Get them out asap and make sure all your documentation is 100% watertight.

Royanne · 13/09/2023 12:48

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/09/2023 12:21

Are you the tenant? I would have thought that if you wanted a washer dryer you'd arrange to be in for the delivery and accept that white goods are not always available at short notice (I have recently had to replace both my washing machine and my dishwasher and had to wait a few days for both).

As for the parcel, it doesn't belong to them. They could leave it on the doorstep for the OP to collect.

No I'm not the tenant 😂

I have been a tenant though, and one of the annoying things when we rented was the landlord assuming that we'd always be able to drop everything, with no control over timeslots ourselves - this is when your gas inspection is happening, this is when the boiler repair is happening etc. As a homeowner you have autonomy over liasing with tradespeople and deliveries to ensure you can be there. It would be good if landlords understood that their tenants work and have lives - perhaps when ordering the washer dryer they could have given the tenant's contact details to deal direct with the company to arrange delivery.

greenacrylicpaint · 13/09/2023 12:46

don't you have a start of renting inventory with photos?

Pista41 · 13/09/2023 12:45

They sounds nuts. I had tenants like this, constant messages day and night (I am not exaggerating when I say they did not know how to turn a standard tap on), demands for fixing things they had broken, purchases etc, caused lots of damage, it goes on. Like a PP I also actually offered to break the contract without penalty as they were so unhappy and that did improve things but I also got a managing agent (themselves not great but at least I didn’t have to be the first port of call). I would do both those things and give them notice as soon as you are able.

Oysterbabe · 13/09/2023 12:43

You should have just said no to getting a washer dryer.

You need to bin them as soon as you can. What does the tenancy say? How long is it? Is there a break clause?

Crayfishforyou · 13/09/2023 12:37

Get a property management company and block the tenants from your phone.
It’s the only way.

Totallyterrific · 13/09/2023 12:37

I think you should ensure they are out asap - presumably they are on a 6 month tenancy initially? I would insist that they are out in 6 months at the very latest. They sound like a total nightmare. You however sound lovely and exactly the sort of landlord Id want - dont let them take advantage of your lovely nature and your inexperience of being landlords.

Livelifelaughter · 13/09/2023 12:36

I am a landlord. If new tenants ask for various things I tend to respond with "the rent reflects the contents and condition of the property" this is to prevent tenants basically upgrading to a higher rent bracket while paying less. I tend to still agree a few small up grades because you want goodwill.

During the course of the tenancy I would expect the tenants to be around for deliveries but I would make arrangements or offer to be there for things that are solely landlords resp like the gas cert.

Saying that this lot sound pretty awful and you could offer that they can leave and then I would get managing agents onboard.

YachtMistress · 13/09/2023 12:35

This situation will not improve, discourteous/rude and demanding (unreasonably) tenants from the outset. A break clause asap, failing that an agent until you can end the tenancy agreement. Your sanity and well being needs protecting.
There is a huge demand from tenants for rental property and most are polite and reasonable to deal with.

Future legal changes will make it more difficult for landlords to end situations like this so don't delay. Look at the NRLA website for detail.
Good luck 🤞

HoisttheMainSail · 13/09/2023 12:32

We've had tenants ask us to come round to change a AA battery and a friend of mine was asked to come round to change a lightbulb. (We did, he didn't)

cherryscola · 13/09/2023 12:31

I'd love to have you as my landlord OP.

My landlord drags his feet to fix a broken window and I have two young children here. I ended up having to fix it myself which cost me over 100 quid. No choice - not risking my kids safety.

You sound great.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/09/2023 12:31

Also don't know why people are assuming the OP doesn't have the correct paperwork in place.

Caroparo52 · 13/09/2023 12:29

I could write a very amusing book on the many bizarre tenant requests I've had over the years.
Usually things calm down after the initial stress of moving in.
From now on be strict as to what is and isn't a reasonable request. Its just down to experience, the law and gut instinct.
If its not your cup of tea then either use a management company or sell it.

Pressuretoohigh · 13/09/2023 12:26

When reading the title of your OP I was poised to believe that you were being unreasonable (as a long-term renter who has had some awful landlords) however, taking what you have posted on face value I don't think you are.
As other posters have suggested it may well save you time and stress (and possibly money in the long term) to get a management company to deal with your let.

If you are going to continue managing this yourself then you will need to establish some firm boundaries very quickly, including how any issues should be recorded. You also need to be 100% sure that you are meeting every one of your legal obligations for both yours and the renters protection.

To give the renters the benefit of the doubt, moving is a very stressful time but the longer you allow them to be rude and demanding the harder it will be to manage their behaviour in the long-term.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 12:25

GasPanic · 13/09/2023 12:21

On paper being a landlord looks so easy.

Buy a house. Stick those tenants in and wait for the money to roll in while you spend your time on the beach in Spain.

No, I think most of us understand that we’ll have problem tenants from time to time, but that doesn’t make it any less frustrating when it happens.

Many tenants seem not to understand that their landlord isn’t a concierge or a hotel manager.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/09/2023 12:23

Oh and the combi boiler thing, if that was important to them they should have asked before they moved in.

I manage perfectly well with a conventional boiler and hot water tank.

I agree with others that they are likely to be draining and refuse to pay rent OP. There is a shortage of property - I'd give them notice at the first opportunity and get someone in who's less demanding.

GasPanic · 13/09/2023 12:21

On paper being a landlord looks so easy.

Buy a house. Stick those tenants in and wait for the money to roll in while you spend your time on the beach in Spain.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/09/2023 12:21

Royanne · 13/09/2023 09:41

Hmm, if you break it down though

Obviously you suspected the house might need cleaning or why would you have arranged a further clean?
They've just moved in so of course they'll have boxes around etc - did you expect them to move out again to facilitate the clean?

You agreed to a washer dryer and it wasn't there at the start of the tenancy. They are entitled to be annoyed about that. Why are you booking delivery slots without finding out when they're available?

If it's not convenient for you to pick up the parcel then it's not convenient. This is their home now.

Are you the tenant? I would have thought that if you wanted a washer dryer you'd arrange to be in for the delivery and accept that white goods are not always available at short notice (I have recently had to replace both my washing machine and my dishwasher and had to wait a few days for both).

As for the parcel, it doesn't belong to them. They could leave it on the doorstep for the OP to collect.

bonzaitree · 13/09/2023 12:21

Just give them notice and get them out asap. Nothing good will come of this tenancy.

Next tenants use a management company and have absolutely nothing to do with the stress of it!