Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we are unreasonable landlords?

238 replies

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 09:16

We moved out of London recently, but have kept our house and we are renting it out.

Our tenants moved in last week and so far we are finding them very difficult. On day one they called and the wife was shouting down the phone to my husband with a whole list of things that she was unhappy about.

There are too many things to mention, but she described the house as being filthy, dirty and covered in stains. Firstly the house is rented unfurnished with wooden floors throughout so not sure what could really be stained. Secondly, we had our much trusted long term cleaner spend 8 hours cleaning the property after we moved out and the check in report we have since since seen describes the property as domestically clean throughout. Nevertheless, we subsequently agreed to arrange a professional clean of the house. When the cleaning company arrived they called us to say that there was so much stuff everywhere that they could not even access some rooms and as some boxes etc were piled precariously they considered it a health and safety hazard. They cancelled the clean (with a £50 cancellation fee) which our tenants are very unhappy about.

Before moving in the tenants demanded that we install a washer dryer (we only had a washing machine) which we reluctantly agreed to. We did not have time to do this before we moved out and then needed someone to be at the property to take delivery. We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in. On day 1 the wife went ballistic at my husband about it and asked how she was going to be able to do washing. We pointed out that she could use the existing (perfectly fine) washing machine and put clothes out to dry in the 30 degree heat, but apparently that was unacceptable. We arranged a washer dryer to be delivered 2 days later (the quickest possible delivery slot) and then the night before (after we had had already received a 2 hour delivery slot message) they told us no one would be around to take delivery. We have again incurred a charge to rearrange the delivery.

There is a whole host of other things but I would be here writing for days to detail them all. Funniest was they told us that the boiler is inadequate because it does not have a water tank (it is a combi boiler).

We have asked to go round at some point this weekend to look at a couple of the smaller “issues” and collect a parcel addressed to us that has been accidentally delivered to the house. They are refusing because it is the anniversary of the death of the wife‘s mother.

We are trying our best to help them, but nothing ever seems to be right / good enough for them and frankly is is exhausting!

OP posts:
Testina · 13/09/2023 13:40

How did you arrange the washer dryer on a 2 day service, yet the tenants told you 2 days later that they wouldn’t be in?
Did you actually agree with the delivery slot with them?
I’m sorry, but on this point I think you need to accept that you messed it up. How did you not have time to arrange it? It would have taken you more time to tell the agent that you might not manage it, than it would to actually go online and book a delivery. Which was available in 2 days - so plenty of time.
You have decided to save money by not using an agent for management - so you can’t expect them to have told the tenant you’re not going to bothering completing the washer dryer agreement in time.

MaybeSmaller · 13/09/2023 13:40

Without seeking to cast blame, this could be a tenant who is used to a completely different style of renting (possibly overseas).

Or it could be someone from somewhere where rent is a lot cheaper than London, who is disappointed with what they can get for their money, and expects OP to "make up the difference", as it were, with a higher standard of fittings and appliances.

This is exacerbated by the fact that OP is an inexperienced landlord not really sure of their obligations. As PPs have pointed out OP could have avoided these problems by engaging the services of an agency or management company.

I'll pick on one point which is the washing machine:

Before moving in the tenants demanded that we install a washer dryer (we only had a washing machine) which we reluctantly agreed to.

Either it was negotiated as part of the contract (which would create an obligation on the landlord to provide the item) or it was requested and agreed to afterwards, which would have been entirely at OP's discretion.

This distinction is pretty important. In the first case, the tenants are justifiably upset that they don't have what they are contractually entitled to. In the second case, they are being ungrateful over something that is basically provided as a courtesy.

Regarding deliveries or inspections, you need to negotiate this with the tenant and not just assume they will be available at a given time on a given day.

As for the boiler, it sounds to me like they are just not used to a combi boiler and the way it provides hot water. How you manage expectations like that is an absolutely key part of the landlord "experience".

Being a landlord isn't just money for old rope. You are providing a service to a paying customer, with all the difficulties that go along with that.

StillWantingADog · 13/09/2023 13:40

I’d get rid as soon as you can

i think you were unreasonable to give in to their demands for a washer drier and extra clean.

Bird1970 · 13/09/2023 13:40

Sounds like you are going beyond what most would do. I assume they saw the property and agreed to everything before they moved in. I would explain they signed the lease as was and therefore any changes i.e. washer/dryer would have to be at their expense. If there is a cooling off period within the contracts I would encourage you to ask them to leave.

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 13:33

Thanks for all your messages - wasn't expecting so many replies!

To clarify a few things, we used an estate agent to market the property and find tenants. They did all the referencing and will collect the rent during the tenancy. We have made sure that we have all the right certificates etc. in place, have a proper signed tenancy agreement and the deposit is being held in a deposit protection scheme. A full check in report / inventory was done just before the tenants moved in.

We did not opt for a full management service as we thought we would be able to manage the property ourselves and did not want to eat into the profit. It was our family home and we have done extensive renovations to it, so everything is in good order and pretty new appliances, so we did not expect there would be many issues. I actually previously rented out a flat for 7 years, so do have quite a bit of experience as a landlord. I never used a management company and, perhaps I was just very lucky, but I always had good relationships with my tenants.

When the tenants made an offer to rent, they said that it was on the condition that we provide a washer dryer. We were reluctant to have to replace a perfectly good washing machine, but agreed to it as the offer they made was otherwise a good one. We did advise the estate agent that we would be unlikely to be able to get the machine installed ahead of the move in date, but would sort it ASAP. Perhaps that message never got passed onto the tenants. We ordered the new machine and told the tenants when we were planning to get it delivered and they did not advise us until 2 days later that they would not be around to take delivery by which point it was too late to rearrange delivery.

We thought the level of cleanliness when they moved in was fine, and have pictures from the check in report, but after being shouted at by the tenants agreed to a further clean in order to placate them. They are the ones who told us when they wanted this second clean to be done. Of course we understood that there were likely still to be boxes etc around and that there would be furniture in the property, but we honestly thought that since they had demanded the clean they would ensure the property was in a state that allowed that to happen. The cleaning company send us videos and it was impossible to even open doors to some rooms.

Of course we don't expect the tenants to drop everything so that we can go around and collect our parcel, but the main point was actually to go and have a look at some of the things they have raised as issues. We would just collect the parcel at the same time. We have now just told them to leave the parcel with neighbours and we will come and collect it from the neighbours instead.

Our house is in a pretty expensive area of London and the tenants (well, the husband - the wife is a stay at home mum) are higher earners so we are not really worried about them not paying rent. We are honestly trying our best to deal with issues they have raised in a reasonable and prompt manner, but we feel that the way they have interacted with us is totally unreasonable and, at time, very unpleasant.

They have recently returned to the UK after being expats for quite a long time and we wonder whether that is why they have (in our view) such unreasonable expectations. We honestly feel like we are being treated as servants at their beck and call.

OP posts:
TodayInahurry · 13/09/2023 13:29

You should be doing this through a letting agency, they do everything from finding suitable tenants, arranging cleaning etc. you have been too nice

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 13:27

GasPanic · 13/09/2023 13:19

I never said it did buy them a concierge service.

I said that the fixtures and fittings provided should be consistent with the rental cost.

I have no idea if this is a high end, middle or low end property. I do know that most people renting in the UK these days would expect a dryer to be present in a rental property.

I can imagine if you have just uprooted, stressed and are busy installing all your stuff, the last thing you need is to be spending time hanging out washing and dealing with it in the rain if you are a family producing a lot of it. Again, no one knows the exact circumstances here, how many people there are, what the garden is like etc, but as with all of these things, when you only see it from one perspective with limited information it is hard to get an objective picture.

The cost (£3,000 per month) was for the size and location. If they wanted a house in the same place with top-end appliances then that would cost them more.

ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 13/09/2023 13:26

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 13/09/2023 13:24

Just send them a message stating that this is clearly not working out for either of you. Let them know that if they move within two weeks you will return their bond.

That's not how deposits work.

The OP will be legally required to return their deposit in full so long as when they leave the property (whenever that might be) they have no rent arrears, and leave the property in the same condition minus fair wear and tear.

Oysterbabe · 13/09/2023 13:25

purpleleotard2 · 13/09/2023 13:03

Issue a section 21 immediately.

Do it while the option still exists

You can't do this in the first 4 months, or possibly much longer depending on what the tenancy agreement says.

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 13/09/2023 13:24

Just send them a message stating that this is clearly not working out for either of you. Let them know that if they move within two weeks you will return their bond.

Flipbopboop · 13/09/2023 13:23

We rent our property unfurnished. If they want white goods or a washer etc. they have to provide it themselves. If we provide it, we're responsible and after having too many idiot tenants recklessly damaging the white goods, we're just not willing to do it any more.

GasPanic · 13/09/2023 13:19

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 13:04

My tenants were paying top prices because they were renting a 4,000 sq ft six bedroom townhouse in the city centre. That doesn’t buy them a concierge service too, or the right to have the agreed-upon white goods upgraded if they fancy something better.

I never said it did buy them a concierge service.

I said that the fixtures and fittings provided should be consistent with the rental cost.

I have no idea if this is a high end, middle or low end property. I do know that most people renting in the UK these days would expect a dryer to be present in a rental property.

I can imagine if you have just uprooted, stressed and are busy installing all your stuff, the last thing you need is to be spending time hanging out washing and dealing with it in the rain if you are a family producing a lot of it. Again, no one knows the exact circumstances here, how many people there are, what the garden is like etc, but as with all of these things, when you only see it from one perspective with limited information it is hard to get an objective picture.

Advicerequest · 13/09/2023 13:19

I'm a landlord. I would get rid of them asap. It will get worse.

Barnowlsandbluebells · 13/09/2023 13:18

purpleleotard2 · 13/09/2023 13:03

Issue a section 21 immediately.

Do it while the option still exists

Yes - get rid at the earliest opportunity.

emark · 13/09/2023 13:18

The tenants, I assume, had seen and accepted the property during viewing, and at the point, check-in inventory was completed, and agreements signed? Except for the minor points you agreed to change, I would state this is as accepted, and you will not be making any changes. If they are not happy, you will happily accept their notice to terminate with the polite reminder that they would be liable for the full 6 months' rent.

Webmeister999 · 13/09/2023 13:18

The tenant is not your friend. You have a business contract with them whereby each party has duties and responsibilities. In short you are a service provider and the tenant is a consumer. This relationship is governed by legislation with which the agency is (supposed to be) familiar. The agent will handle issues to do with access, replacements, deliveries etc. They are likewise employed to provide a service for you and your tenants.

If your tenants are working people (which I assume is the case) then you cannot reasonably expect them to take time off work for essential deliveries etc. In this case you would either have to arrange for an out of hours delivery or for someone to be at the property to accept it for them. This is where agents come in. They form a barrier between the LL and the tenant and field the more ridiculous requests. Yes they charge a fee (usually aroung 12 %) but its a tax deductable business expense.

Numerous posters have advised you to employ an agent and this will save you a great deal of hassle and heartache in the long run.

Cosyblankets · 13/09/2023 13:16

Royanne · 13/09/2023 12:48

No I'm not the tenant 😂

I have been a tenant though, and one of the annoying things when we rented was the landlord assuming that we'd always be able to drop everything, with no control over timeslots ourselves - this is when your gas inspection is happening, this is when the boiler repair is happening etc. As a homeowner you have autonomy over liasing with tradespeople and deliveries to ensure you can be there. It would be good if landlords understood that their tenants work and have lives - perhaps when ordering the washer dryer they could have given the tenant's contact details to deal direct with the company to arrange delivery.

I asked my tenant if i could give her number to the plumber.
They sorted a mutually convenient time and i just paid the bill.
Easier all round. Same with any other repairs

Royanne · 13/09/2023 13:13

sthisbest · 13/09/2023 13:08

LOL she doesn't have a magic wand. Delivery is rarely instantaneous for large electrical goods.

OP says they didn't have time to do it before they moved out! So they knew well in advance

Flipbopboop · 13/09/2023 13:12

OP, you are not being unreasonable. Make sure that all of the paperwork / certificates are up to date and the deposit is protected.

Some tenants are just unreasonable. I had one a few years ago that demanded the walls be painted to match her "artwork", she complained that the house was too cold in October when the heating wasn't on, she complained that we had ruined her very expensive coat because there was paint on it (it wasn't paint, it was dust), she snapped a door in half, accused me of breaking into the property because the door was unlocked (not me but her housemate left the door open).

Your mistake OP, was giving in regarding the washer / dryer. Put your foot down and don't give anything above what is in the contract.

Also, to those suggesting "just serving a Section 21", you can't serve notice unless it is after a certain period after they move in.

Royanne · 13/09/2023 13:12

Notcontent · 13/09/2023 13:00

Those who say you need a “professional” clean - do you realise that this just means a cleaning agency charging extra for a clean? There is no magic to it…

That's not what it means. There's a difference between a domestic level and professional level clean - the OP says it was the former. A domestic level clean can be provided by a professional cleaner but it won't have been a deep clean so dust and grime may remain in places

sthisbest · 13/09/2023 13:08

Testina · 13/09/2023 13:04

“We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in.”

Just checked your wording. That does sound very much like you agreed to provide a washer dryer and then didn’t bother.

LOL she doesn't have a magic wand. Delivery is rarely instantaneous for large electrical goods.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 13:08

Testina · 13/09/2023 13:07

@FirstYouGetTheMoney “That doesn’t buy them a concierge service too, or the right to have the agreed-upon white goods upgraded if they fancy something better.”

But the “agreed upon white goods” in this case was the washer dryer. Would you have agreed to change it then not done it before the start of the tenancy? Or by the sounds of it even informed the tenant it would be after?

Was that not requested after the lease was signed? I’d though that that was the implication here.

Testina · 13/09/2023 13:07

@FirstYouGetTheMoney “That doesn’t buy them a concierge service too, or the right to have the agreed-upon white goods upgraded if they fancy something better.”

But the “agreed upon white goods” in this case was the washer dryer. Would you have agreed to change it then not done it before the start of the tenancy? Or by the sounds of it even informed the tenant it would be after?

Testina · 13/09/2023 13:04

“We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in.”

Just checked your wording. That does sound very much like you agreed to provide a washer dryer and then didn’t bother.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 13:04

GasPanic · 13/09/2023 13:00

Yes.

But many landlords seem not to understand their tenants are paying customers and view them as an inconvenience.

It's impossible to tell whether the house was up to scratch. Different peoples ideas of what constitutes clean are different. There is also the fact that if the tenant is paying top prices for a top spec property they might expect different levels of cleanliness compared to a lower price and different levels of fittings/service.

It's also true to say that some people from different countries where there are different standards set re renting and the renting high end properties might be more usual and so tenants might be more used to being aggressive in making sure the property conforms to their liking. In a lot of countries renting is not seen as a poor second choice to home ownership that it often seen as in the UK, and is often something done by high earning profesionals.

All we know (I think) is that in this particular instance the landlord decided not to engage an agency (?) presumably because they thought the money they would charge would not be reasonable and that they would be better off providing that service themselves (?) and now maybe is finding out that the service levels and amount of work required is somewhat larger than expected ...

My tenants were paying top prices because they were renting a 4,000 sq ft six bedroom townhouse in the city centre. That doesn’t buy them a concierge service too, or the right to have the agreed-upon white goods upgraded if they fancy something better.