Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we are unreasonable landlords?

238 replies

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 09:16

We moved out of London recently, but have kept our house and we are renting it out.

Our tenants moved in last week and so far we are finding them very difficult. On day one they called and the wife was shouting down the phone to my husband with a whole list of things that she was unhappy about.

There are too many things to mention, but she described the house as being filthy, dirty and covered in stains. Firstly the house is rented unfurnished with wooden floors throughout so not sure what could really be stained. Secondly, we had our much trusted long term cleaner spend 8 hours cleaning the property after we moved out and the check in report we have since since seen describes the property as domestically clean throughout. Nevertheless, we subsequently agreed to arrange a professional clean of the house. When the cleaning company arrived they called us to say that there was so much stuff everywhere that they could not even access some rooms and as some boxes etc were piled precariously they considered it a health and safety hazard. They cancelled the clean (with a £50 cancellation fee) which our tenants are very unhappy about.

Before moving in the tenants demanded that we install a washer dryer (we only had a washing machine) which we reluctantly agreed to. We did not have time to do this before we moved out and then needed someone to be at the property to take delivery. We had thought the tenants would be OK for this to happen shortly after they moved in. On day 1 the wife went ballistic at my husband about it and asked how she was going to be able to do washing. We pointed out that she could use the existing (perfectly fine) washing machine and put clothes out to dry in the 30 degree heat, but apparently that was unacceptable. We arranged a washer dryer to be delivered 2 days later (the quickest possible delivery slot) and then the night before (after we had had already received a 2 hour delivery slot message) they told us no one would be around to take delivery. We have again incurred a charge to rearrange the delivery.

There is a whole host of other things but I would be here writing for days to detail them all. Funniest was they told us that the boiler is inadequate because it does not have a water tank (it is a combi boiler).

We have asked to go round at some point this weekend to look at a couple of the smaller “issues” and collect a parcel addressed to us that has been accidentally delivered to the house. They are refusing because it is the anniversary of the death of the wife‘s mother.

We are trying our best to help them, but nothing ever seems to be right / good enough for them and frankly is is exhausting!

OP posts:
VeloVixen · 13/09/2023 15:11

I assume they’re on a 12 month contract? I’d give them their notice now that you expect them to move out on the dot of the 12 months being up. It might make them reflect a bit.

MzHz · 13/09/2023 15:10

StillWantingADog · 13/09/2023 13:40

I’d get rid as soon as you can

i think you were unreasonable to give in to their demands for a washer drier and extra clean.

Speak to agent TODAY, and tell them to make whatever moves they need to make to end this tenancy as soon as legally possible.

fo not enter into any negotiations, tell the agent to manage the property fully from this moment on and take whatever hit it means to not have to manage this rental.

in future, you rent as seen, no concessions, your own cleaner with a potential call back (ONCE) to remedy anything and that is IT.

go hard ball, don’t take this crap from these horrible people

justasking111 · 13/09/2023 15:07

@Leavingonajetplane33 they're not going to pay any rent. You've a couple of cuckoos there. They're going to spoil the nest before you manage to evict them. Use a management company

DobbyTheHouseElk · 13/09/2023 15:05

I had a tenant once like that. I told my agent to ask them to vacate the property if it was so awful. I offered to pay any fees involved. They refused and I didn’t hear a peep from them again. They turned out to be very good tenants.

The reason asked them to leave two days into the tenancy was how upset the agent was dealing with them.

You have shot yourself in the foot with the washer dryer thing. Get yourself an agent.

2jacqi · 13/09/2023 14:59

I do not know what kind of lease you have given them, whether a year or short term rolling to 6 month but I would immediately be serving notice to leave because this is not working out for you!!! I can visualize in the future that if you dont get rid of them now then you are going to be creating a rod for your own back!! start proceedings now.

Lantyslee · 13/09/2023 14:50

As others have said, I'd get the agents to take on the management as they're a neutral 3rd party and will have a dispassionate view on whether the tenants are reasonable.

I'm a landlord who uses a letting agency with a tenant who can be difficult. I'm also a tenant who recently moved into a house which not only wasn't clean but needed complete redecoration, new flooring throughout and has no appliances. We were fine with that and we understood what we were taking on.

BurningTheToast · 13/09/2023 14:47

I'm just adding my voice to those advising that you get a letting agent to manage this property.

I have one with a tenant like this and I simply can't cope with the emails at 7.30am, followed up by one at 8.30am if I haven't replied. My letting agent fields those and takes no nonsense about what is reasonable and what isn't.

It will be the best 15% you even pay!

Good luck

ArmchairArtichoke · 13/09/2023 14:33

Having dealt with some demanding tenants myself, even through management companies its a pain. Direct it must be awful.
Please insist on switching to corresponding to only in writing. Email is best. That way you have evidence to show you have been reasonable + acted promptly. If you need to tell a white lie to force the change, say that you have a tonne of work meetings lined up + can only do email. You shouldn't have to put up with shouting, make them write it down.
Secondly, have you got any inspections in the tennancy agreement? You need to inspect that place reguarly yourself! Their behaviour + the excess stuff seen by your cleaners is a red flag that they may not treat your place well. Do it all formerly, in writing, + attend yourself or a trusted friend. If you sign up for management, don't trust them to do it alone. Our management company had supposedly inspected the family that made our rental unliveable. The photos showed they didn't visit all rooms, didn't care about water leak stains (the ceiling fell in eventually), missed the drawings on walls + that they'd flooded + ruined our kitchen. There was stuff in the way + people sleeping that stopped them seeing the damage. A warning sign that the tenants weren't treating our house well was frequent repairs; broken toilets, sinks, radiators, washing machine. It turned out that our tenants had 7 children, not just the 4 disclosed.
Keeping an eye on the state of the place is so important. I don't know if you have ever claimed for repairs out of a deposit, but it is well below what it costs you to replace because it takes off for previous years of use. For example we got £50 towards a burnt carpet that cost £250 to replace. You know they are going to be high maintenance, so try to limit the damage + get them out as soon as you are legally able.

ittakes2 · 13/09/2023 14:25

I am currently a tenant and have been a landlord and mostly I think you are being unreasonable. She has just moved house and you are annoyed she does't want you visiting on the anniversary of the death of her mother? Seriously?
And its odd not to have a dryer in the UK - and also a mistake for you - how are they meant to get clothes dry in winter? drying it on radiators causes condensation problems. And not having it sorted before they move in is annoying - and expecting them to take time off work to be there for a delivery that should have been sorted before they moved in?

Royanne · 13/09/2023 14:24

It's all very well everybody saying get rid, but you have to think about the kind of tenants who can afford this property. High earners in an expensive part of London...it's unlikely that any prospective tenants are going to be falling over themselves with gratitude at being allowed to live somewhere, doffing their cap to the landlord. They're all going to expect a certain standard of cleanliness and agreements to be adhered to.

Crikeyalmighty · 13/09/2023 14:18

@Leavingonajetplane33 having rented abroad and now back in uk- I can see how this happens- when we moved into our house in Denmark not only had all the blinds been removed and cleaned but all the floors had been restripped throughout the whole house and a complete redecorate. Problem was when we moved out 19 months later to go back to uk the same was expected of us which wasn't possible as we needed to move straight after house being emptied- not in a hotel for 2 weeks , re renovating their house. No wonder when we were looking round houses they were all totally mint compared to UK- consequently we lost £3500 of our deposit- even though it had no damage and had been professionally cleaned straight after we moved out , arranged by us and I checked it before our flight . . Many people coming from overseas and renting high end will expect absolutely mint, professionally cleaned show homes- I do think though that your tenants manner sucks, but then I see it as a partnership, I pay good money to both look after and live in your lovely home and you see to any reasonable problems quickly. This may settle down, my husband finds it easy to get bossy and abrupt with letting agents when we first move somewhere, usually because he's very stressed from a move !!

Reugny · 13/09/2023 14:09

OP it is unlikely the estate agent passed on the message to the tenants about the installation of the washer/dryer.

In the past I've had to advise colleagues who have had things like leaks - and not small ones - to contact the landlord themselves when the estate/management agent had not after 24 hours. The landlord was then furious that they hadn't been told immediately due to the risk of structural damage.

Also seen it the other way round e.g. friends and acquaintances who had tenants discovered they were getting messages about e.g. malfunctioning boilers weeks after the tenant complained to the estate/management agent. So by the time they saw the tenants, the tenants were furious.

I would suggest once you have spoken to the tenants about doing anything you confirm anything directly with them in writing - send a normal SMS.

HopefulSeller · 13/09/2023 14:07

I had a few years of being a landlord, and I would say honestly just get them out as soon as you can. Or find a really good management agent (most are pretty bad though) but if they still cause problems again, ask them to leave with notice.

Also post in a landlord forum - there are some online and they are really helpful and very fair. Shows that most landlords are pretty decent.

I say this because I was one of those 'good' landlords and looking back it didn't do me or the tenants any favours. One tenant ended up treating me as if I was the council - with zero expectation on their side of maintenance in the property and they wrecked it. Whilst I was being pestered about minor issues that were actually their responsibility, some repairs were not reported to me which actually did really need sorting out sooner and it all got messy. Tenant was very obstructive about allowing access for repairs.

So in short a tenant that doesn't get what their role and responsibilities are is a nightmare!

ConsuelaHammock · 13/09/2023 14:05

Next time google prospective tenants! Look them up on Facebook / instagram/ twitter. It’s amazing what you can learn about someone’s character from their social media accounts.
Tenants are crying out for properties so you can hand pick your future tenants.

HauntedPencil · 13/09/2023 14:04

You need to just start saying no!

ConsuelaHammock · 13/09/2023 14:01

They’re in now so there’s not much you can do. How long is their tenancy agreement? Try not to think of the house as your home but as an asset that’s making you money. They are paying you rent and you are providing a service. If they don’t turn out to be good tenants be ready to ask them to leave when the minimum term has been reached. They’re already a nightmare . A letting agent won’t have any more luck with them that you will so I would keep managing it myself .

Nat6999 · 13/09/2023 13:59

I would tell them since they are so unhappy with the property, you are happy to break the contract if they want to move out.

MaybeSmaller · 13/09/2023 13:56

Sorry OP, I've just seen your update:

When the tenants made an offer to rent, they said that it was on the condition that we provide a washer dryer.

This does change things significantly. It was not a "demand". It was negotiated and agreed to. So you are contractually obligated to provide the washer dryer.

If I was the tenant in this scenario and had specifically negotiated an appliance, I would be pissed off if I moved in (having paid the chunky deposit) and found the appliance wasn't there.

You did attempt to rectify things, but sadly a cock-up like this is likely to set the tone for the landlord-tenant relationship going forward.

If they are high earners they are likely to have very high expectations - after all, they are surely paying absolute top dollar if it is an expensive part of London.

For example, the combi boiler that they're unhappy with is probably worth less money than a single month's rent.

Advicerequest · 13/09/2023 13:54

in future:
let through estate agent but always check the tenants yourself. Twice top end EA have tried to slip through inappropriate tenants in the hope of a quick agreement (one couple were bankrupt....!)
get an inventory and get everything in writing eg I have in my lease that tenants are responsible for clearing drain on flat roof of leaves. If they don't the flat roof might flood.
i always give 48 hours notice if I have to visit. I never drop in unannounced. I always give them the choice of me or them being at house for essential repairs, gas ch ex is

  • I make sure that everyone knows the house is rented as is and if they want to make changes they have to get permission from
  • me and then revert back before end of tenancy
  • never do anything on faith
  • if my tenants wanted a new washer dryer and I had a good serviceable washer dryer they'd have to pay for it
if you live far away get a managing agent. Otherwise do it yourself. I haven't heard from my tenants in three minutes ths. Good tenants alert you to issues.
  • Break clause!
  • professionals without kids or pets are a good bet!
ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 13/09/2023 13:51

They have recently returned to the UK after being expats for quite a long time and we wonder whether that is why they have (in our view) such unreasonable expectations. We honestly feel like we are being treated as servants at their beck and call.

I think this is key - they're simply not used to renting as it is normally done in the UK. I wonder if they ever rented in the UK before they emigrated? Were they living in a country where having hired help is the norm (e.g. middle east?)

We did advise the estate agent that we would be unlikely to be able to get the machine installed ahead of the move in date, but would sort it ASAP. Perhaps that message never got passed onto the tenants.

The estate agents probably didn't pass the message on - which probably means that from the tenants POV you promised one thing and just... didn't do it.

I'd let things settle until you're much closer to the end of the fixed term of the tenancy agreement before you decide what to do. It's not like you can do anything in the first 4 months of the tenancy agreement anyway.

In future I would consider doing it through OpenRent, and doing the viewings yourself so that you get a sense of people before they sign. They can handle all the things your estate agent currently handles like referencing, inventories and contracts https://www.openrent.co.uk/our-pricing

shieldmaiden7 · 13/09/2023 13:51

This is mad behaviours. I rented for 15 years before buying last year and was over the moon to have somewhere to live and was as accommodating to the landlord and estate agent as possible.
Are they renting directly through you or through a agent?

Royanne · 13/09/2023 13:46

So they're high earners in an expensive part of London, who made a "good offer" - presumably they're paying an arm and a leg for the property, and it was on the condition that you provided a washer dryer. Which you haven't.

This is a business transaction and you haven't fulfilled what you agreed to. It's completely understandable that they are pissed off.

Testina · 13/09/2023 13:45

sthisbest · 13/09/2023 13:08

LOL she doesn't have a magic wand. Delivery is rarely instantaneous for large electrical goods.

LOL back at ya!
OP has since confirmed that she agreed the washer dryer as part of the contract and it could be installed in 48 hours.
I’m not saying these tenants have done nothing wrong, but on the washer dryer - the OP is at fault.

empee47 · 13/09/2023 13:44

Leavingonajetplane33 · 13/09/2023 13:33

Thanks for all your messages - wasn't expecting so many replies!

To clarify a few things, we used an estate agent to market the property and find tenants. They did all the referencing and will collect the rent during the tenancy. We have made sure that we have all the right certificates etc. in place, have a proper signed tenancy agreement and the deposit is being held in a deposit protection scheme. A full check in report / inventory was done just before the tenants moved in.

We did not opt for a full management service as we thought we would be able to manage the property ourselves and did not want to eat into the profit. It was our family home and we have done extensive renovations to it, so everything is in good order and pretty new appliances, so we did not expect there would be many issues. I actually previously rented out a flat for 7 years, so do have quite a bit of experience as a landlord. I never used a management company and, perhaps I was just very lucky, but I always had good relationships with my tenants.

When the tenants made an offer to rent, they said that it was on the condition that we provide a washer dryer. We were reluctant to have to replace a perfectly good washing machine, but agreed to it as the offer they made was otherwise a good one. We did advise the estate agent that we would be unlikely to be able to get the machine installed ahead of the move in date, but would sort it ASAP. Perhaps that message never got passed onto the tenants. We ordered the new machine and told the tenants when we were planning to get it delivered and they did not advise us until 2 days later that they would not be around to take delivery by which point it was too late to rearrange delivery.

We thought the level of cleanliness when they moved in was fine, and have pictures from the check in report, but after being shouted at by the tenants agreed to a further clean in order to placate them. They are the ones who told us when they wanted this second clean to be done. Of course we understood that there were likely still to be boxes etc around and that there would be furniture in the property, but we honestly thought that since they had demanded the clean they would ensure the property was in a state that allowed that to happen. The cleaning company send us videos and it was impossible to even open doors to some rooms.

Of course we don't expect the tenants to drop everything so that we can go around and collect our parcel, but the main point was actually to go and have a look at some of the things they have raised as issues. We would just collect the parcel at the same time. We have now just told them to leave the parcel with neighbours and we will come and collect it from the neighbours instead.

Our house is in a pretty expensive area of London and the tenants (well, the husband - the wife is a stay at home mum) are higher earners so we are not really worried about them not paying rent. We are honestly trying our best to deal with issues they have raised in a reasonable and prompt manner, but we feel that the way they have interacted with us is totally unreasonable and, at time, very unpleasant.

They have recently returned to the UK after being expats for quite a long time and we wonder whether that is why they have (in our view) such unreasonable expectations. We honestly feel like we are being treated as servants at their beck and call.

You and your DH sound one hundred percent reasonable. Wonder if the tenants are struggling with not living abroad anymore and having an army of hired help. Perhaps they are too used to falling back on a landlord doing everything-if they were owners rather than renters, they’d soon see sense!

NigellaAwesome · 13/09/2023 13:43

I would echo what everyone else has said - you need a professional managing agent, especially if you are not living nearby. Being a landlord is no longer something that novices should be doing. The sector is highly regulated and if you don't know what you are doing you could easily get landed with tenants you can't get rid of, unpaid rent, or fines.

Have you got a break clause in the contract?

At a minimum, I would be double-checking you have got all your paperwork in order, such as:

  1. Have they signed the inventory?
  2. Why did you not do an in person check-in? I would be round as soon as possible to photograph / document any issues they claim to have.
  3. Have you protected the deposit in a scheme? Have you provided the statutory information such as details of the scheme, provided the scheme leaflet, provided details of the circumstances in which the deposit may be withheld? (I am in NI, so the requirements may be slightly different, but you need to check).
  4. Have you provided a copy of the gas certificate & EPC?
  5. Have you checked that the property is compliant with fire regs? Are there smoke alarms & CO detectors?
Swipe left for the next trending thread