Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dieting for 6 weeks and guess how much I’ve lost?

543 replies

CollagenQueen · 13/09/2023 06:07

I’ve been dieting for 6 weeks. I’ve been eating like a bird during the day, with a normal evening meal.

I’ve cut out crisps and chocolate (which I used to eat daily).

I’ve dropped my wine consumption massively, now having several tee total days a week (I used to drink every day!)

I’ve also upped my exercise enormously, I now usually walk about 15-20k steps a day, rather than my usual 7k.

After six weeks of this, I’ve just weighed myself and guess what I’ve lost?

Absolutely nothing.

What the hell? Can anyone explain this? I really don’t want to give up, but this just seems insane!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Hunkydory99 · 13/09/2023 08:34

Op I’d suggest taking some measurements. Muscle weighs more than fat, is it possible you’re toning up/gaining muscle mass especially in your legs from walking which has balanced out against th weight you may have lost from reducing your crisp/choc and wine intake?

TeenDivided · 13/09/2023 08:34

hopsalong · 13/09/2023 08:31

But what's the issue with feeling hungry? Some overweight people seem to be terrified of hunger. The thin people (I am 9 stone and 5'9'' and eat chocolate, wine etc every day without a moment's worry) I know are all fine with it.

I would also stop eating between meals. Adults who aren't ill, pregnant, athletes, or employed in hard physical labour don't need to eat more than three times a day, and two seems to be enough for many. Snacking is something the processed food industry wants us to do, but we don't need to.

The issue with feeling hungry is that overweight people are overweight for a reason, and that can often be in part to lack of willpower. When you are starting out if you feel hungry you will be far more tempted to eat, sabotaging the diet. It is just accepting how people are and working around it.

lapsedbookworm · 13/09/2023 08:33

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 08:17

@lapsedbookworm That's great, well done.

But the reason it doesn't work most of the time for most people is that they focus on counting cals, often inaccurately, and still eat unhealthily (but within the calories limits.)

So they don't change their eating patterns, just the amount of the food they ate before.

Long term, they tend to revert to larger portions and gain weight.

Oh I agree. You have to count accurately and you need to eat healthily too and you need to do it in a sustainable way.

But just eating healthily didn't work for me. I needed to learn portion sizes (before I got ill, I exercised tonnes so didn't really think about what I ate)

I dislike people saying any one method does or doesn't work. " experts" trot those lines out to sell their latest book. People need to find a method that works for them and trust in it. And you won't lose weight without a calorie deficit, that's just basic science. How you achieve that calorie deficit is a matter of personal preference

hopsalong · 13/09/2023 08:31

But what's the issue with feeling hungry? Some overweight people seem to be terrified of hunger. The thin people (I am 9 stone and 5'9'' and eat chocolate, wine etc every day without a moment's worry) I know are all fine with it.

I would also stop eating between meals. Adults who aren't ill, pregnant, athletes, or employed in hard physical labour don't need to eat more than three times a day, and two seems to be enough for many. Snacking is something the processed food industry wants us to do, but we don't need to.

TeenDivided · 13/09/2023 08:30

@hopsalong You won't lose wait easily unless you feel seriously hungry quite a bit of the time.

I think that is pretty unsustainable. That is what I am liking about Keto. I believe I am losing weight as my clothes tell me so, but I am not hungry . That is what makes it do-able for me.

PurpleWisteria1 · 13/09/2023 08:30

Reachingreach · 13/09/2023 07:46

Cereal is bad for weight loss, as is snacking and wine.

2 eggs for breakfast
Veggie soup for lunch
Fish and veg for dinner

No snacks, no wine, 10k steps a day and 3x 30 min weight training sessions a week.

It'll fall off.

Yes and so will your sanity doing that.
Thats not sustainable longer term.
Nor is it anywhere near enough protien.

Wisenotboring · 13/09/2023 08:29

It sounds like although you have made some amazingly positive changes, you are possibly not in a calorie deficit yet. You have not put on weight though which is good. Your food sounds healthy, but depending on portion sizes you could still be getting a fair few calories. Now yiu have established some good habits in, add the next level and count calories for a while to see what happens...maybe 1500 per day to begin with?
You should also be massively proud of yourself for reducing your alcohol intake. 2 bottles a night is loads and your long term health will be significantly impacted. Out of interest, on the nights you donstill drink, now much do you have? If you can, perhaps reduce to once per week or a bottle over a week?

ProseccoandPizza · 13/09/2023 08:27

Lost over 5 stone (from 17 plus stone) at 32 and have roughly maintained my weight (give or take half a stone gains through lockdowns).

I have unresolved food issues related to Autism and SPD but it’s all a numbers game.

Highly recommend James Smith macros calculator as a starting point and always taking upper arm, widest part of chest, waist, hip and thigh measurements.

Increase water intake
Reduce portion sizes (I often grab a Boots meal deal for example whilst out or McDonald’s hamburger and medium fries)
Zero alcohol at home
Find a protein bar/clear whey/protein shake you enjoy and make protein a priority always.
Start strength training for a better shape.

It’s really not always about the number on the scale alas. I’m a smaller dress size now at 12.5 stone than I was at 11 stone.

bellac11 · 13/09/2023 08:27

mummabubs · 13/09/2023 08:23

She does @IsleofSkies
My android phone doesn't like mumsnet very much, but here's the post. Definitely says 2 bottles a night.

Thank you

So OP you say you still have some nights where you have alcohol but havent said how much

So people are right if one of those nights is one bottle lets say, thats a lot of intake, for no nutrition

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 13/09/2023 08:27

Then surf out the hunger pangs. You won't lose wait easily unless you feel seriously hungry quite a bit of the time

This is when it all goes tits up, it's perfectly possible to lose weight without feeling constantly hungry.

TeenDivided · 13/09/2023 08:27

As PP have mentioned, you could try Keto?
I have never been on a diet until 6 weeks ago, I'm 55.
I have been doing keto and finding it surprisingly easy as I feel full.
No idea how much I have lost, but my trousers are now too big and if summer were going on longer I'd have to replace them as they are falling down.

I have:
breakfast: 2 scrambled eggs in butter, plus 1.5 slices proscuito
lunch: mixed salad leaves, chicken breast and ~20g cheddar/port salut
evening: salmon/sausages/chicken/other meat and broccoli & cauliflower with a bit of hollandaise sauce or butter
loads of water.

So no hot chocolate, kit kats, dairy milk, desserts, chips, pasta, rice, potatoes, carrots, sweetcorn any more.

RosesAndHellebores · 13/09/2023 08:26

No snacks, no coleslaw, no ham, no chips, no wine, no saturated fat or sugar.

Up the fruit, veg and water, steamed or grilled fish, chicken breast, wholemeal.pasta, rice and bread, cut out all sugar/fructose. You can still eat quite a lot but make virgin olive frylight spray your friend and use chilli, ginger, spices for flavour. Example: finely chopped onion and mushrooms, gently dry fried; spinach bag, 2tbs quark, juice and grated lemon rind whizzed in processer, stir in the onion and mushroom, season with s&p and a cpl tops lazy garlic, stuff 4 chicken breasts and lay on finely sliced spud -45 mins in the oven. Serve with veg.

Is there a chance that the extra walking may have converted some fat to muscle? Muscle is heavier.

I am older than you op but have just lost a stone in 9 weeks following the above. The wine sabotages diets because your liver has to deal with it first and everything else converts to fat.

Well done for cutting down the wine. The amounts you were drinking were potentially catastrophic.

gogomoto · 13/09/2023 08:26

Ditch coleslaw in favour of a mixed salad (as massive as you wantGrin) with a tablespoon low calorie dressing. Toss in 100g protein. Switch to high protein yogurt and fruit for breakfast then a low calorie evening meal eg i recommend the hairy dieters cookbook.

The only other way I lost weight was my husband leaving me, shifted 2 stone not really eating, not to be recommended though

PurpleWisteria1 · 13/09/2023 08:25

hopsalong · 13/09/2023 08:20

My advice as a thin person.
The food you are eating sounds quite grim, especially the lunch. Stop eating snacks, stop eating breakfast unless you're really hungry, add the evening glass of wine back in, and only eat delicious things. It's all about calories in and out and nothing more.
Eg a sandwich you really like for lunch, your favourite new season red pear, a few Maltesers, a flat white from the best place in town, whatever floats your boat. The same for dinner. Other than making sure you have lots of fruit and veg, just eat a small amount of what you want.

Then surf out the hunger pangs. You won't lose wait easily unless you feel seriously hungry quite a bit of the time. I think the trick is to change your mindset about that. Tell yourself that nothing is frightening or dangerous or painful about being hungry. It's a normal human state. Most animals are also hungry most of the time. It is not like having backache or a headache, it is just a normal state of being. And at any point (luckily enough for us) you can end it, if you don't like it, by eating something.

I've never had to do exactly this with food. But I had to learn to do it to give up smoking. Sit with the craving etc. It isn't automatic or simple (it took me three years!), but it will come. Then you wont have to worry so much about the details.

It is also possible that you will get less hungry as you get thinner, I'm not sure. When I gain wait I feel as if I get more hungry, and vice versa.

But you are saying this as a person who can control their portions.
Its not as easy as that if you don’t know what a healthy amount of calories looks like.
That is why calorie counting is so great for people starting out- it forces you to realise just how many calories are in processed foods.
Yes of course avacados are high calorie and healthy but people arnt getting overweight by stuffing themselves full of avacados and almonds.
Once you have been losing for a while then calorie counting can stop becuse you have changed your diet habits and hopefully are much less likely to reach for high calorie processed foods.

mummabubs · 13/09/2023 08:23

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 07:47

The OP didn't say she drank 2 bottles of wine a night or whenever she drinks.

Where's this come from in some posts?

She does @IsleofSkies
My android phone doesn't like mumsnet very much, but here's the post. Definitely says 2 bottles a night.

Dieting for 6 weeks and guess how much I’ve lost?
diddl · 13/09/2023 08:23

I can barely read this thread because the pages keep flipping backwards and forwards, I dont know what Ive read or not read

Awful isn't it!

MN must be "having a moment"🙄

PurpleWisteria1 · 13/09/2023 08:20

Yes and so will your sanity doing that.
Thats not sustainable longer term.
Nor is it anywhere near enough protien.

bellac11 · 13/09/2023 08:20

I can barely read this thread because the pages keep flipping backwards and forwards, I dont know what Ive read or not read

Ive missed the bit where OP says she srinks 2 bottles of wine a night but keeps seeing references to it

And yes calorie counting works, you know for sure that you're in deficit

hopsalong · 13/09/2023 08:20

My advice as a thin person.
The food you are eating sounds quite grim, especially the lunch. Stop eating snacks, stop eating breakfast unless you're really hungry, add the evening glass of wine back in, and only eat delicious things. It's all about calories in and out and nothing more.
Eg a sandwich you really like for lunch, your favourite new season red pear, a few Maltesers, a flat white from the best place in town, whatever floats your boat. The same for dinner. Other than making sure you have lots of fruit and veg, just eat a small amount of what you want.

Then surf out the hunger pangs. You won't lose wait easily unless you feel seriously hungry quite a bit of the time. I think the trick is to change your mindset about that. Tell yourself that nothing is frightening or dangerous or painful about being hungry. It's a normal human state. Most animals are also hungry most of the time. It is not like having backache or a headache, it is just a normal state of being. And at any point (luckily enough for us) you can end it, if you don't like it, by eating something.

I've never had to do exactly this with food. But I had to learn to do it to give up smoking. Sit with the craving etc. It isn't automatic or simple (it took me three years!), but it will come. Then you wont have to worry so much about the details.

It is also possible that you will get less hungry as you get thinner, I'm not sure. When I gain wait I feel as if I get more hungry, and vice versa.

Beezknees · 13/09/2023 08:19

Goodornot · 13/09/2023 08:14

Okay, so breakfast has been cereal like bran flakes. Snack would be a hard boiled egg. Lunch has been some lean chicken, 2 slices of ham, cherry toms, coleslaw. Dinner is just a normal dinner, nothing outrageous.

That's a lot. What is a normal dinner? Normal could mean a huge takeaway for one person and a lean stir-fry for another.

I don't eat breakfast. Just a coffee. I'm having a packet sandwich at lunch so I know how many calories and I try to keep it under 400.

I try to eat healthy at dinner lean meat and vegetables. Or maybe eggs with smashed avocado.

I do snack on chocolate occasionally.

I'm struggling to lose weight and I'm 11 stone.

Also steps are absolute nonsense. I never found walking did anything for weight loss. You need to exercise harder. Swimming, or maybe a gym class.

I agree with steps, I average about 20k a day and I'm still over 12 stone at 5'4. It really is all about the diet.

marblesthecat · 13/09/2023 08:18

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 08:09

I do wish people would stop egging up counting calories.
It doesn't work long term.

There was a good article on this recently and how it doesn't work.

It's impossible for most people to do this accurately. And it's tedious.

It also creates a 'fearful' mindset and doesn't promote healthy eating.
eg Avocado and nuts are high in calories but very nutritious, compared to a muffin with the same number of calories.

If you focus on protein for every meal, with masses of veg, try to get up to 8 to 10 portions of fruit and veg a day, no refined carbs, no ready meals, and recognise what a portion of carbs looks like, you will lose weight.

Best advice given so far.

Also OP I find it's better for me to lose/maintain weight if I eat more in the morning and less as the day goes on.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 13/09/2023 08:18

Wine (lovely as it is) is absolutely full of calories. On the days you have it, you need to get used to having a glass. Not a bottle, not 2. 2 bottles is the equivalent calories of 6 slices of Dominos pizza.

MonoLisa · 13/09/2023 08:17

Just a little, but REALLY important tip for anyone on diet.
Flavour. For the love of god, add spices and herbs and seasoning to things. I saw some diet foods online from people and I would not survive on steamed plain chicken with some barely seasoned veg and plain potato😶 Stocked spicw cupboard makws everything waaaaaaay more enjoyable

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 08:17

@lapsedbookworm That's great, well done.

But the reason it doesn't work most of the time for most people is that they focus on counting cals, often inaccurately, and still eat unhealthily (but within the calories limits.)

So they don't change their eating patterns, just the amount of the food they ate before.

Long term, they tend to revert to larger portions and gain weight.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 13/09/2023 08:17

I did exact the same and lost nothing,not one pound. I started SW and am on my way to 4 stone off now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread