Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dieting for 6 weeks and guess how much I’ve lost?

543 replies

CollagenQueen · 13/09/2023 06:07

I’ve been dieting for 6 weeks. I’ve been eating like a bird during the day, with a normal evening meal.

I’ve cut out crisps and chocolate (which I used to eat daily).

I’ve dropped my wine consumption massively, now having several tee total days a week (I used to drink every day!)

I’ve also upped my exercise enormously, I now usually walk about 15-20k steps a day, rather than my usual 7k.

After six weeks of this, I’ve just weighed myself and guess what I’ve lost?

Absolutely nothing.

What the hell? Can anyone explain this? I really don’t want to give up, but this just seems insane!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
anonymousamy · 13/09/2023 09:45

As someone else said up thread, calorie counting is literally the only weight loss plan that works. I did that a few years ago and lost 1.5 stone.

StoneColdAlibi · 13/09/2023 09:44

CollagenQueen · 13/09/2023 06:26

Honestly I am eating like a bird during the day! Yesterday my intake was:

one bowl branflakes
2 slices of ham
quarter of a small chicken breast
tablespoon coleslaw
one hard boiled egg
piece of fish
peas
small portion of chips
two glasses of water
one coffee

Are you having milk and sugar with your cereal?
In your hot drinks?
Any sauces with your dinner?

SurprisedWithAHorse · 13/09/2023 09:43

Escalateandcreate · 13/09/2023 09:30

Fucking hell. This thread is nuts. Muscle
does not weigh more than fat. A pound is a pound in weight. A stone is a stone in weight.

It's a very common misconception. As PPs have said, what they mean is that it's denser than fat, so a pound of muscle takes up less room than a pound of fat and a muscular person might weigh the same as a fatter one.

We will all know if we really are throwing the scales off because we have so much muscle!

Milkkbottles · 13/09/2023 09:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Poundfoolishpennywise · 13/09/2023 09:41

It’s so hard, isn’t it. I tried to lose weight for years and have only this year managed to shift 3.5 stone (still losing as I was very overweight to begin with - verging on morbidly obese). My mindset changed as I have young DC and realised I was hurtling towards very serious health problems if I didn’t do something about my size.

We are all different but, for me, I can only have a maximum of 1000 calories per day if I want to lose weight. I’ve also found that avoiding snacking completely makes a huge difference. My day looks a bit like this:

Breakfast:

Small (weighed) portion of low calorie cereal with semi skimmed milk

Mid morning:

Small coffee with skimmed milk and sugar free syrup (I guess this is my ‘snack’ but I refuse to give up coffee!)

Lunch:

Small salad but can include anything as long as it’s under 320 calories. I’m a big fan of the boxed salads in M&S as they have some great choices including salmon, pasta with feta/tomato, couscous etc. I just check the calorie total for the box (not portion) to make sure it doesn’t exceed 320

Dinner:

’Normal’ in that it can contain anything but under 380 calories for my main, followed by a piece of fruit

I don’t eat any sugar at all and avoid alcohol (was never a drinker anyway).

I realise this could sound a bit miserable if you are used to eating a lot more but you get used to it very quickly. I also don’t feel deprived because as long as I stick to my calorie limits I can eat pretty much everything. Dinner can be pasta, chicken with potatoes and veg, lasagne, curry. The biggest hurdle for me was cutting out sugar.

Bobbotgegrinch · 13/09/2023 09:39

Also, try not to think of the last few weeks as a waste. You've started training yourself into better habits, and if nothing else you've saved money on the wine!

Viviennemary · 13/09/2023 09:38

Far far too much walking. You will put a strain on your joints. You aren't really counting your calories and probably are eating a lot more than you think, you need to write down everything you eat. It's so easy to underestimate

Bobbotgegrinch · 13/09/2023 09:38

You're probably not running at a calorie deficit yet, so while you've stopped putting any more weight on, you're not losing it yet.

The wine will be the killer, although massively well done on dropping it as much as you have. As someone who used to drink nightly and has now kicked that habit (more or less), I know how hard it can be!

MonoLisa · 13/09/2023 09:37

JumpingQueen · 13/09/2023 09:27

@MonoLisa

I am on a liquid diet prescribed by my GP so yes I am on 800-1000 calories a day. I’m also being weighed weekly at the surgery.

I have blood tests every 2 weeks and I’m due my next set next week.

Even the nurse who weighs me was a bit shocked I hadn’t dropped anything. I showed her my health on my iPhone which shows my activity levels.

Then I am surprised they haven't aigned you up to some studies on non existent metabolism. Don't mean to sound snarky but active person not losing weight on 800cal a day is a groundbreaking study and doctors would fight to be the ones to write a paper on it.

MrsMariaReynolds · 13/09/2023 09:36

Drop the wine altogether? It has never helped me since I rarely drink anyway but everyone I've ever known who has given up all alcohol, all seem to drop like 10 lbs in the first month. lucky sods--

There's a lot of sugar in wine and alcohol just makes you retain water. Try that.

SOBplus · 13/09/2023 09:35

Muscle weighs more than fat in like for like volume; e.g an inch of muscle weighs much more than an inch of fat; yes its true a pound of feathers weighs as much as a pound of rocks but the volume of feathers will be MUCH greater.

IDontOftenComment · 13/09/2023 09:34

Try using the NHS diet app it’s excellent for keeping track of calories, even a few calories over and you won’t lose weight. If you need a drink to accompany your meal try alcohol free wine it’s very low calorie for a small glass.
It may be that you’re not eating enough and your body is going into calorie saving mode especially doing all those steps, cut them down a bit.
I would start again, weigh daily and see those tiny drops in weight that will encourage you to keep going, maybe ask your doctors if they have a dietician.
Good Luck.

TTCbaby2023 · 13/09/2023 09:32

@CollagenQueen I would strongly suggest you to add resistance training to build muscles and therefore improve your metabolism. Walking, I'm afraid, is not quite enough. As far as diet is concerned, make sure you have adequate amount of protein (animal and vegetal - chickpeas, lentils etc are an excellent source), lots of veggies and lots of fibre.
I was the same as you struggling to lose fat (especially after 40 it's hard), but protein and resistance training were my best assets.

ExcitingTimes2021 · 13/09/2023 09:32

Sounds like you are doing great OP! Small sustainable changes are much better then fads and quick fixes which will fizzle out.

I would take some measurements and check them after four weeks. You might not have lost much weight but have lost inches. Go off how you are feeling and how your clothes fit. Not just what a number on a scale says.

Do you feel different and have you noticed any difference in how your clothes fit? X

Americano75 · 13/09/2023 09:31

CollagenQueen · 13/09/2023 06:19

I think I’m going to have to go on My Fitness Pal again and calorie count. But honestly, I have reduced my eating and alcohol intake massively plus all the extra exercise. So it doesn’t make sense at all. I’m 53, that could be the problem? My tummy definitely feels smaller and less bloated, but maybe I’m being delusional!

I was literally about to ask your age. I'm 48 and slowly losing but it's taking twice as long as usual and it feels like I'm fighting against my body, not for it. It's so frustrating.

Escalateandcreate · 13/09/2023 09:30

Hunkydory99 · 13/09/2023 08:34

Op I’d suggest taking some measurements. Muscle weighs more than fat, is it possible you’re toning up/gaining muscle mass especially in your legs from walking which has balanced out against th weight you may have lost from reducing your crisp/choc and wine intake?

Fucking hell. This thread is nuts. Muscle
does not weigh more than fat. A pound is a pound in weight. A stone is a stone in weight.

Foxymoxy68 · 13/09/2023 09:29

I'm struggling too so am going to try 16:8, keto style and swapping wine for the very occasional gin and slimline tonic at the weekend.
Good luck moving forward. I'm sure all your efforts will pay off in time.

CrunchyToes · 13/09/2023 09:28

Bubbles254 · 13/09/2023 08:51

I would suggest not going on a diet which you can't sustain for ever as as soon as you come off of it you will put the weight back on.

Also if you calories count the more you loose the lower you daily calories requirement becomes so it gets harder and harder to loose weight.

The trick is to shift what you eat. If you purely eat nutrient rich foods you will feel satiated and loose weight with the need to calorie count. Combine this with muscle building and your metabolism will increase and you will be able to eat more.

I have been doing this since February and have lost 2 stone and am now down to a bmi of 19 and actively trying to eat more to gain more muscle. I have never felt hungry doing this 'diet' and will eat thus way long term.

This, all of this!

JumpingQueen · 13/09/2023 09:27

@MonoLisa

I am on a liquid diet prescribed by my GP so yes I am on 800-1000 calories a day. I’m also being weighed weekly at the surgery.

I have blood tests every 2 weeks and I’m due my next set next week.

Even the nurse who weighs me was a bit shocked I hadn’t dropped anything. I showed her my health on my iPhone which shows my activity levels.

VanityFlares · 13/09/2023 09:27

CollagenQueen · 13/09/2023 06:15

Okay, so breakfast has been cereal like bran flakes. Snack would be a hard boiled egg. Lunch has been some lean chicken, 2 slices of ham, cherry toms, coleslaw. Dinner is just a normal dinner, nothing outrageous.

I used to have wine every night and I’ve cut that right back to 2-3 nights a week.

I’ve upped my steps from 7k a day to about 17k a day.

Zero weight loss.

A few things here you could change.

  1. The bran flakes are high in carbs and sugars and will set you up for feeling hungry a couple of hours after youve eaten them. Swap this out for something no carb and high protien. A couple of eggs in whichever form you like them best with some soinach or avocado works well, or some full fat greek yogurt with berries and banana.

Your lunch looks good.

Dinner could be where you have an issue too, could you give some examples of what a ‘normal’ dinner looks like?

How much water do you drink a day? You should be aiming for 2 litres a day

You say you only drink wine 2-3 days a week…is it just the one glass or are you drinking more on the days you allow yourself some to make up for the days you dont? Also, wine is high in calories and sugar. Could you swap it out for some gin/vodka and slimline mixer?

the walking is good, but what you need to do is build muscle. Gaining muscle will help you burn fat effectively. You don't need weights. Check out Caroline Girvan on you tube, her beginner series is good.

How much sleep are you getting? Lack of sleep will encourage your body to hold on to fat stores.

lastly what age are you? It gets harder to lose the older we get and hormone inbalance comes into play too.

SalmonBelongInTheWater · 13/09/2023 09:27

JumpingQueen · 13/09/2023 09:13

I have been on 800-1000 calories a day for 3 weeks, I’ve done over an hour of exercise (couch to 5k and pilates one day, swimming and walking another) and I have lost absolutely nothing…

Not even 1/2 kg.

It’s so bloody demoralising 😞

This is literally not possible, unless scientists have harnessed you in some groundbreaking study to understand how a person can magically create energy from nowhere lol. Man the logic.

Cosycardigans · 13/09/2023 09:26

That's not much fruit and veg. Your body might be holding onto the weight because there's not much nutrients in what you're eating.

SalmonBelongInTheWater · 13/09/2023 09:25

Good news OP, it's very simple. If you've not lost anything it's because you haven't been eating at a calorie deficit.

You need to download something like MyFitnessPal and set a calorie goal. At a shorter height it's likely you could lose weight on 1250-1350 calories. Track every single thing you eat or drink. Weight loss isn't easy but it's simple. You've been eating exactly the right amount to maintain your weight with the exercise you've been doing.

Newtothis2005 · 13/09/2023 09:22

I would use myfitness pal to calorie count and focus on upping the vegetable content of your meals. I would probably add in a morning and afternoon snack - I go small amount of cheese in plus an apple. This helps keep me from choosing junk snacks when I get really hungry. As boring as it is when losing weight I had the same breakfast, lunch and snacks daily because I knew the calories. I’d have a normal dinner but half the portion size of the more calorific foods and add lots of vegetables.
I also got hold of some low calorie ice cream to satisfy cravings and this helped me hugely to stay on plan. I lose 1.5 stone in 10 weeks

SurprisedWithAHorse · 13/09/2023 09:20

hopsalong · 13/09/2023 08:31

But what's the issue with feeling hungry? Some overweight people seem to be terrified of hunger. The thin people (I am 9 stone and 5'9'' and eat chocolate, wine etc every day without a moment's worry) I know are all fine with it.

I would also stop eating between meals. Adults who aren't ill, pregnant, athletes, or employed in hard physical labour don't need to eat more than three times a day, and two seems to be enough for many. Snacking is something the processed food industry wants us to do, but we don't need to.

Because if you're already in a place where you need to lose weight, then you've likely got a complicated relationship with food already. Some people can be hungry all the time and not have it affect their work, mental state or urge to eat more but I don't think there are many of them.

Feeling constantly deprived (as opposed to hungry at mealtimes or having to use a bit of willpower here and there) isn't a sustainable state for most people and nor should it be necessary.