Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think paying £300 for tooth extraction is a joke

119 replies

Tiredjoanna · 13/09/2023 00:28

So, have had toothache for couple of years in 1 specific broken tooth. Always got by with strong painkillers and oragel. However for the past week the pain was immense so ended up having to go to an emergency dentist who I had to pay £50 just to look and do quick x-ray. So, he told me it's an infected root of tooth and I'd need an extraction but not a basic one as there isn't enough tooth to pull on to get it out. So scrape it to the root basically, a 10 minute job he said. And then proceeded to tell me it would cost £300!! Now i know they're doing a specialised job but really? I cannot find an NHS dentist by me anywhere so can only go private. Is this a normal price for an extraction or am I being completely unreasonable. Fwiw I seriously don't have £300 so am at a loss. Sorry for the long post

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
userxx · 14/09/2023 15:21

Get a cheap flight to Croatia, I know someone who does that and it's so much cheaper, 7 euro for a check up.

Tiredjoanna · 14/09/2023 11:01

catlovingdoctor · 14/09/2023 10:51

How much do you think a skilled clinician's time is worth? After all their training and expertise? After the cost of keeping a clinic open; rent, utilities, staff, insurance, materials. It takes them 10 minutes because they've spent years training to do it professionally.

I'm not saying their time isn't worth spending for, just that £300 seems excessive when I can get it for £125.

OP posts:
catlovingdoctor · 14/09/2023 10:51

How much do you think a skilled clinician's time is worth? After all their training and expertise? After the cost of keeping a clinic open; rent, utilities, staff, insurance, materials. It takes them 10 minutes because they've spent years training to do it professionally.

Tiredjoanna · 14/09/2023 10:48

Just wanted to update everyone who replied. Spoke to my normal dentist who said that a complex extraction which is what i need would cost £125. Now that to me seems more reasonable than £300 so will await wages and book myself in. Never want to feel that pain ever again. Thanks to everyone who took the time to reply😀

OP posts:
justasmalltownmum · 13/09/2023 20:52

It's £1,000 for a root canal here.

raynedeer · 13/09/2023 20:48

Ach, I had to pay over £1200 for dental treatment recently (money I DO NOT have). It's weird how much things are changing...

Littlemissprosecco · 13/09/2023 20:15

Birmingham has a huge dental teaching hospital hospital. Try them

Lollygaggle · 13/09/2023 19:27

The multiples per hour you pay defray the upwards of £200 an hour it costs to run a room in a private dental practice .

The simple job is actually microsurgery performed in a tiny confined space in a conscious patient using a mirror and lights to overcome the lack of light and vision.

Abbimae · 13/09/2023 19:27

‘Only care Only get pence for nhs patient’ what an awful thing to say. Are you a dentist? Would you want to get paid for going to work after 5 years of uni? Why should they work for free? It’s a underfunded NHS issue… not the dentists fault. Blame the government.

TrishTrix · 13/09/2023 19:16

I do a lot of NHS dental anaesthesia.

When I needed a new dentist the unequivocal advice I got from all my dental colleagues and I canvassed loads was to start paying for dental treatment because the NHS no longer really offers preventative dentistry.

Dentists will offer the treatment that loses them the least amount of money or they won't exist.

I now have a lovely private dentist who is my age and went to Uni with one of my dental colleagues and several of my own dept but it pisses me off every time I pay him multiples of my hourly rate to have something really simple done.

He also does no one call and only works 4 days a week.

I think I picked the wrong bloody degree.

WomblingTree86 · 13/09/2023 18:52

Have you tried phoning 111? If you can't get in an NHS dentist and it's an emergency perhaps they will refer you to Birmingham Dental hospital?

Lollygaggle · 13/09/2023 18:50

Ginmonkeyagain · 13/09/2023 18:43

I remember my dentist saying that dentistry had advanced a lot in the last few decades in terms of what would be done to save teeth but NHS funding had not caught up.

Quite, when I qualified back in prehistoric days , the instruments we used for root treatment (endodontics ) were reusable and fairly basic. Today , even in NHS practice , we use systems that are one use only and cost a minimum of £35 a patient and materials such as mdta or biodentine which are used in root treatment and to save teeth from needing root treatment are £90 a use .

A pot of glue used to cement fillings in , even on the NHS , is £95 for 5ml! Dental inflation is running at over 10% a year for materials , labs etc and yet NHS funding to dentists increased by 3.5% this year , which means for around the 15th year in a row , in real terms, NHS dentistry is facing yet another cut .

Ginmonkeyagain · 13/09/2023 18:45

And as I have said before I think one of the huge failings of the NHS full stop is it does not encourage or incentivise preventive actions or behaviour.

I go to the hygienist regularly as it helps prevent issues but that has only ever been a private service.

Ginmonkeyagain · 13/09/2023 18:43

I remember my dentist saying that dentistry had advanced a lot in the last few decades in terms of what would be done to save teeth but NHS funding had not caught up.

HalfasleepChrisintheMorning · 13/09/2023 18:31

Thank you @Lollygaggle for trying to explain the UDA mess.
I post on every dental thread and say the same- NHS dentistry is dying. In many areas it is dead. On a population level you can campaign to the government. On an individual level the only option is to pay privately. Think of it like opticians or vets.
NHS dentistry has given the U.K. public a weird idea of what dentistry actually costs.
I do have sympathy for people with pain and problems who can’t afford private. That sympathy doesn’t run to charity - ie paying for it myself! Which NHS dentists effectively do.
If I ran the world exempt patients- so those on benefits and children- would have easy access to a core service of basics. Exam, simple scale, fillings, extractions and plastic dentures. The dentists who worked there would be first year post graduation and would be salaried with crown indemnity.
Foundation training as it is now would be years 2 and 3.

Ericaequites · 13/09/2023 18:11

I’m an American who just paid $ 75- for a dental X-ray, and will pay $ 200- for a filling in a chipped tooth which will resolve my pain. My dentist is a sole private practitioner in a fairly basic suburban office. GBP 50 sounds fairly reasonable for an X-ray with consultation.

Tiredjoanna · 13/09/2023 17:55

MinnieTruck · 13/09/2023 17:28

Yep that sounds about right!

I had a dead tooth (front one) and I was in extreme pain. I purposely waited until I had my son as dentistry is free in the first 12 months. I had an extraction (which would have cost around £275) and a denture provided (which would have cost £296) all at no cost. Maybe have another baby so you won’t have to pay? Joke🤣

Despite saving £571, I’m now paying 3K over the course of 8 months so that I can have an implant. You win some, you lose some🫠

I am actually covered for another 2 weeks when baby turns 2. However I had to pay £50 for a private prescription and the chemist said that I had to pay the £9 for it as it was private. So £60 for something I could have got free if didn't need it straight away and waited for doctors appt

OP posts:
Lollygaggle · 13/09/2023 17:36

MsFrost · 13/09/2023 17:25

@Lollygaggle Thanks, I didn't know that.
That makes me feel a bit more sympathetic to practices who say they aren't taking on NHS patients but will take on private ones.
It's all a bit of a mess isn't it :(

£75 for a course of treatment that may take several hours if someone needs several fillings and extractions will mean a dentist is working for less than minimum wage after expenses are paid and the business will not even cover its overheads .
This is why dental practices are closing because they cannot cover the overheads and if they are in an area of deprivation people cannot afford private charges. Eg BUPA recently closed 85 dental practices.

hellohelp · 13/09/2023 17:32

Ah @Lollygaggle I didn't think about that but it makes sense, I am in Scotland

Lollygaggle · 13/09/2023 17:31

hellohelp · 13/09/2023 17:27

That is so expensive. Likely what my mum would have to pay if she needed that treatment too as she's private
I am an NHS patient and my surgery charge £32 for an extraction and £12 for X-rays if you pay for your treatment

Have you tried calling NHS 24 (out of hours) for an emergency dentist appointment? I have had to phone them 2 times before when wasn't registered and they've given me an app locally for the next day

In England the charge would be a band two charge £70.70 which includes check up , x rays , any necessary fillings , gum treatment , extractions.

Only in Scotland and Northern Ireland do you pay for individual bits of treatment .

MinnieTruck · 13/09/2023 17:28

Yep that sounds about right!

I had a dead tooth (front one) and I was in extreme pain. I purposely waited until I had my son as dentistry is free in the first 12 months. I had an extraction (which would have cost around £275) and a denture provided (which would have cost £296) all at no cost. Maybe have another baby so you won’t have to pay? Joke🤣

Despite saving £571, I’m now paying 3K over the course of 8 months so that I can have an implant. You win some, you lose some🫠

hellohelp · 13/09/2023 17:27

That is so expensive. Likely what my mum would have to pay if she needed that treatment too as she's private
I am an NHS patient and my surgery charge £32 for an extraction and £12 for X-rays if you pay for your treatment

Have you tried calling NHS 24 (out of hours) for an emergency dentist appointment? I have had to phone them 2 times before when wasn't registered and they've given me an app locally for the next day

MsFrost · 13/09/2023 17:25

@Lollygaggle Thanks, I didn't know that.
That makes me feel a bit more sympathetic to practices who say they aren't taking on NHS patients but will take on private ones.
It's all a bit of a mess isn't it :(

Lollygaggle · 13/09/2023 17:19

MsFrost · 13/09/2023 17:05

@Lollygaggle Wait, sorry I might be being a bit thick. Are you saying that the NHS wouldn't pay towards the cost of NHS treatment?

If a patient pays for their treatment , hundreds of dentists they will not get paid the full amount the patient pays , the dentist will, in effect , give money back to the NHS.

For most dentists, if a patient pays , the NHS will contribute a couple of pounds at most . Therefore for a band two treatment (check up , x rays , fillings, root fillings extractions , gum disease treatment etc) in England a patient will pay £70.70 and the NHS pays , on average £25 a UDA . Band two attracts three UDAs (units of dental activity) which pays £75 in total so NHS pays £4.30 on top of patient contribution. The NHS has committed to paying a minimum of £23 a UDA from October 2022 so a lucky practice being bumped up to the new minimum will earn £66 for treatment so will pay back the NHS £4.70 from what the patient has paid!

The NHS gives no other money , but obviously for people who do not pay and children the NHS pays the whole £25 or whatever the practice value for the UDA.

Topseyt123 · 13/09/2023 17:12

My dental costs so far in the last six weeks due to a broken molar which was cutting at my tongue:

£75 for an emergency appointment and a temporary filling.

£80 for an x-ray of my gums as I am a new patient there and hadn't seen a dentist for several years.

£175 for a permanent (composite) filling on Monday afternoon this week.

In October I will have to pay £175 again for another filling on the other side plus probably another £60 for the hygienist.

I was a SAHM for a number of years too, which is why we couldn't afford much dental treatment then, and probably why I need to spend so much now. Fortunately the "children" are in their twenties now so pretty much independent. Plus I did work again for a few years so can now just about afford it. Have to now, really. No other choice if I want to keep reasonably healthy teeth.

Yes, I'm afraid I really can believe that an extraction could cost £300. Some dentists do offer payment plans, but by no means all I don't suppose. I guess you have enquired well there?