Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this friendship is finished?

111 replies

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:22

DH and I have very long standing friends. Over 20years of friendship.

Our children went to same primary school and we did lots of things together when they were young holidays, days out, camping etc.

We have all been through tough times over the years but class each other as extended family. The lady, let's call her J doesn't have siblings and would call me her sister.

As the DC got older we didn't meet up as much but always got together for special occasions and spoke regularly on the phone, especially if either one of us had a problem. She was my go to for advice and me her.

Last year I was having a particularly bad time. One of my family members was very ill and we came close to losing them a few times. Thankfully they improved, when they did I can only describe what I had as a nervous breakdown resulting in a long hospital stay.

J did text me and sent love and seemed really happy when I was discharged. I was always careful when we spoke so it wasn't all about me, enquiring on her and her family etc.

However, contact between us became bare minimum. A week after my discharge I had a car accident which resulted in having major surgery. When I was discharged from hospital after 3 weeks I text her why I hadn't been in contact and she messaged back to say how awful and hope you recover etc.

I never got a card, visit, or any offer of help.
All the time I was in hospital J never reached out to my DH or any of my DC.

Today was our wedding anniversary and she sent a card. My DH said how lovely but I can't help feeling really upset in her lack of concern or support. If it had happened to her I would have wanted to visit and help out.

Im so upset about this and due to my mental health problems I can't stop thinking about it. My family just say "forget it and she obviously isn't a true friend." But I can't help going over and over it and wondering what I have done wrong?

It's my birthday next month and if she sends a card I don't want to phone and say thank you. I feel that it's pretty laughable to send cards and just ignore someone who has been through so much.

Half of me wants to message her and ask why and what have I done? The other half says ignore and rise above it.

Wwyd and AIBU to feel like this?

Sorry for the length of the post

OP posts:
Lalagahgah · 13/09/2023 07:49

A slightly different perspective. I've been the bad friend in this scenario. Not exactly the same circumstances but basically over a period of years my very good friend had a series of bad events happen to her and at the same time my life was going great. I didn't know how to deal with it and withdrew from the friendship. It's hard when a friendship is unbalanced and any moans you have are absolutely minute in the face of the others' issues. We also weren't physically near each other which made that easier. Completely on me and not in any way ok but that's what happened.

Luckily for me, after a few years I came to my senses and begged her forgiveness and she did forgive me. We're closer than ever now and I have supported her through bad times again and not repeated the behaviour.

I'm not saying don't ditch her, but if you really value the friendship, I think it's worth you speaking to her to see what's going on. As others have said, she may have something going on herself, or maybe she's struggling to cope with how to deal with the inevitable changes in friendship dynamics. Maybe she's just a shit who isn't worth your time of course but I wouldn't give up on a really long term close friendship easily. They're not easy to replace!

NeedToChangeName · 13/09/2023 07:40

Highdaysandholidays1 · 12/09/2023 23:39

Not everyone has the time, energy or ability to step up exactly when you need them. This is a harsh truth and often only revealed when you get ill or have a crisis. My approach, having had a lot of disasters over the years, is to have a few friends rather than one or two friends, and so at any one time, there is someone with a bit of spare capacity, but not everyone at the same time. I also had a tough time with my MH at one point and one friend just didn't know what to say at all, and I was too depressed to reach out, it got quite awkward but she told me she didn't want to pester me and since then has been a good friend.

I guess I'm trying to say a lot of people on here will say ditch a friend if they don't respond effusively in your time of crisis, but my own experience is to try to leave room for friends to come in and out of your life- it may be at one time they are super-worried about work, or their own lives, or depressed or in the menopause, and can't be the brilliant friend you want but at another time they can step forward- the same is true for me, sometimes I'm a great friend, sometimes not so much. I have friends I speak to weekly, some once a month, some once a year, it's not all the same.

If they are never there for you, and you don't ever have fun with them, obviously don't continue the friendship, but I might give your friend a chance on this one.

Wise advice

Bluewitch · 13/09/2023 07:36

Nope. Get rid.

The reality is that you find out who your friends really are during a time of crisis.

It seems that people on this thread are bending over backwards to find excuses as to why this person did not bother to get in touch more often when you were struggling, the reality is usually much simpler: she chose not to.

I always think that you always find time for people and things that matter.

As for the people who suggested that it is your fault for inconveniently going through a crisis or sharing your worries: real friends are with you through good and bad times not just for the pleasant, fun, stuff.

Frankly it takes very little effort to send emails/text or to call someone. If you are struggling yourself and can't give someone else who is struggling much support again all you have to do is communicate that and state that you are thinking of the person and wish you were more present but going through some tough times yourself.

Be kind to yourself and focus on developing other friendships.

TheCraftyOne · 13/09/2023 07:17

Few things here. First of all you're being naive to say nothing is going on with her because your DH plays football with her DH......anyone who speaks to my DH and asks about me he will say yes shes brilliant thanks. But in reality I have been having such a bad time, crying a lot, not going out, in a massive rut with likely some depression. Would ANYONE know that, even my DH, definitely not!

Second of all...3 months in a psychiatric hospital. Sorry but I think you have to realise that not everyone knows how to handle this. It doesn't mean she's not a friend, it might mean she has backed off not knowing what the hell to do for the best. 3 months in somewhere like this is not an evert day occurance, it's massive. Not everyone knows what they should be doing in this situation.

And how could she have reached out when you were in hospital after your crash, when she didn't know about your crash until you came out of hospital and told her? I've never sent a card to anyone who has had a crash, it's not an illness to get well from. I've also never received a card for being in a crash.

I think YABU and really harsh on this friend.

Scienceadvisory · 13/09/2023 07:16

Maybe she thought keeping in touch via text while you had your first stay in hospital was better than a card? Regular communication is surely more helpful than a few words on a bit of paper?

As to the second stay, she wasn't aware of it and may have just thought you needed space having just got out of hospital so was giving you time. She responded kindly when you told her.

Alternatively maybe she needed some space. Having supported you through the previous year, she may have reached her limit.

dayswithaY · 13/09/2023 07:13

You said that you were there for her, very supportive etc so why can’t she do the same for you. It doesn’t work like that, one good deed doesn’t guarantee another in return, you do what is right at the time.

I had a friend who has not suffered anywhere near as much as you have, but to listen to her, you’d think she had been through two world wars. She would count how many sympathy cards she had received and write a list of people who visited during hard times. I had to step away for my own self preservation, and I just couldn’t be what she wanted me to be.

I’m not comparing her to you, but your friend may feel overwhelmed and not know how to even start helping you. Friends are precious, when you feel stronger - and you will - you might really appreciate her friendship.

Friends don’t have to tick every box all the time to still be a friend.

RadioFoot · 13/09/2023 06:19

I don't think she wants to be friends anymore.

Nanny0gg · 13/09/2023 00:34

Aquamarine1029 · 12/09/2023 23:42

You are being completely unreasonable. Has it not occurred to you that she is also a person with her own issues, some you may have absolutely no knowledge of due to her not wanting to burden you with. She is not indebted to be your therapist or emotional punching bag. Friendship has limits.

All I see is you, you, you.

Good friends are there in times of trouble

This one isn't a good friend.

She may have been once, but she isn't now.

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 13/09/2023 00:28

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:45

I know there isn't anything going on as my DH sees her partner regularly. They play football together.

When I have spoken to her I have always asked if everything is ok. My next door neighbour showed more concern, she bought me flowers, chocolates and a beautiful card and offered help and I hardly know her.
My DH asked her partner if I had upset her and he said " no but I think J has messaged her and she hasn't replied" which isn't true.
Im really trying to think what could be wrong but surely a get well card wouldn't have been too hard?
I'm not sure if I should phone her and risk an argument or just accept the friendship is gone?

The difficult reality OP is that lots of people only like the happy and easy aspects of friendship.
As soon as difficult life events happen for the other person they arent gaining from the friendship and move on.

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 13/09/2023 00:23

ValleyClouds · 12/09/2023 23:35

Unfortunately it is very common and very tough that people with disabilities, serious health issues and mental illness lose friends because the friend can't cope, doesn't want to or has prejudices. It's wrong but a lot of people face it

My best to you Flowers it's not a great club to be in

This with bells on.

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 00:18

Again thanks, your replies have given me a lot to think about.

Im not abandoning this thread but I have work tomorrow so need to sleep.

OP posts:
Vijia · 13/09/2023 00:15

I think you may have trauma dumped one time too often and she is avoiding you

The people I know with MH problems are quite self centered and are not very good at listening...

Perhaps you are unaware of how you come across and how much you actually offload.

Of course it would be lovely if if our friends don't have compassion fatigue but it is a real thing and puts people off instead of stepping up.

Dotcheck · 13/09/2023 00:14

Maybe she’s giving you what she thinks you would need ( space).
Is a card really necessary? She messaged to give her best wishes, why do you need a card? Are your kids at a stage where you need childcare?
If she’s been a good friend for 20 years, you’re being massively ott to dump her for not reacting perfectly in this situation.

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 00:11

Thank you for your replies, it has given me a lot to think about.

@Highdaysandholidays1 just wanted to say it isn't just a football match. They go for a drink after and have met up several times for meals.

Maybe I am being a bit "woe is me" but I guess spending 3 months in a psychiatric hospital and being seriously hurt I'm entitled to feel a little like that?

Maybe though she is fed up of my drama and can't cope with it. It's just very upsetting

OP posts:
TottenhamGirl · 13/09/2023 00:08

Sometimes people just don’t know what to say when it comes to mental health problems, or they fear saying the wrong thing, so they keep putting it off until it becomes awkward. The fact that she’s sending cards shows she still cares I think. I would maybe gently point out that you have noticed a distance between you in a non accusatory way. If it’s affected you so deeply, it must mean that you care.

Anewnamea · 13/09/2023 00:04

OP your friend may have been triggered, perhaps a close family member of her went through an accident and it reminded her of a difficult time and she felt she couldn’t cope.

Or perhaps you’ve had quite a few tough times she’s been there for and as a result the friendship had become one-sided without you knowing it and she had to take a step back?

Also you say she wasn’t dealing with anything, but you don’t actually know that. There are battles people face that not even their own partner knows about.

I had to step back from a friend who constantly used me as their therapist. I tried to keep it light with her and put boundaries in place with our conversation, as there was only so much I could listen to her tales of trauma. However she kept trauma dumping and pushing against my boundaries to the extent it was affecting my mental health.
If they never want to be friends again that suits me because I feel lighter already not having to deal with her problems anymore.

Perhaps send your friend a text thanking her for the card and suggesting you should meet up for coffee as you’d love to hear what’s been going on in her life or something like that. Make it clear you want a fun, light hearted catch up rather than wanting to lay anything heavy on her.

Vijia · 13/09/2023 00:00

Woe*

Vijia · 12/09/2023 23:59

I am sorry to say this all very wor is me and if you are not feeling great yourself, having so much negativity in one person can be too much for some person especially if they have friends to boost them like radiators rather than drains.

I am very sorry for the awful things you have gone through op, but please remember this sounds like a fair weather friend who wants to have fun and doesn't have the bandwidth to deal with so much tragedy.

Itt actually very common so if you want her back in your life, it's probably best to fake it until you make it, in this case joviality and light-heartedness and fun I'm afraid.

Tired6789 · 12/09/2023 23:58

I can totally see why you feel let down and it must be really tough after everything you've been through.

JustFrustrated · 12/09/2023 23:57

So you just wanted to vent and share your hurt in this thread. Which is fine.

But you should have said as much.

I'm agreeing with PPs...it's probable she just didn't have the emotional bandwidth to keep supporting you in your 12 months of horrible time. And you know what, that's not her being nasty or suchlike. It's her being human.

She's extended an olive branch.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 12/09/2023 23:53

@DaisyDuke111 her partner isn't going to tell you anything on a football pitch about her emotional state, is he?

It's easy when you see someone daily to get invested for a short time in their lives, pick up a box of chocs in the supermarket, but if you moved away, you might not stay friends. People who stay in your life long-term are valuable.

I would not bother calling if you feel angry and resentful, just leave it for a bit or send a neutral text (perhaps checking how she is too?)

Wait and see what happens, she wasn't there for you that much (although she did text and respond it seems) during that time, only you know if you want to ditch her, perhaps in a while you might welcome someone who has known you a long time.

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:52

I didn't expect her to be my therapist or emotional punchbag. I expected her to my friend.
When she lost her DF 10years go I went above and beyond for her. Dropping/ picking the DC from school, feeding them and just being there for her.
She regarded me as the "sister she never had."

OP posts:
Newnamehiwhodis · 12/09/2023 23:50

Highdaysandholidays1 · 12/09/2023 23:39

Not everyone has the time, energy or ability to step up exactly when you need them. This is a harsh truth and often only revealed when you get ill or have a crisis. My approach, having had a lot of disasters over the years, is to have a few friends rather than one or two friends, and so at any one time, there is someone with a bit of spare capacity, but not everyone at the same time. I also had a tough time with my MH at one point and one friend just didn't know what to say at all, and I was too depressed to reach out, it got quite awkward but she told me she didn't want to pester me and since then has been a good friend.

I guess I'm trying to say a lot of people on here will say ditch a friend if they don't respond effusively in your time of crisis, but my own experience is to try to leave room for friends to come in and out of your life- it may be at one time they are super-worried about work, or their own lives, or depressed or in the menopause, and can't be the brilliant friend you want but at another time they can step forward- the same is true for me, sometimes I'm a great friend, sometimes not so much. I have friends I speak to weekly, some once a month, some once a year, it's not all the same.

If they are never there for you, and you don't ever have fun with them, obviously don't continue the friendship, but I might give your friend a chance on this one.

This! Well said

ValleyClouds · 12/09/2023 23:49

Why do you think there'll be an argument, why would there be?

Swipe left for the next trending thread