Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this friendship is finished?

111 replies

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:22

DH and I have very long standing friends. Over 20years of friendship.

Our children went to same primary school and we did lots of things together when they were young holidays, days out, camping etc.

We have all been through tough times over the years but class each other as extended family. The lady, let's call her J doesn't have siblings and would call me her sister.

As the DC got older we didn't meet up as much but always got together for special occasions and spoke regularly on the phone, especially if either one of us had a problem. She was my go to for advice and me her.

Last year I was having a particularly bad time. One of my family members was very ill and we came close to losing them a few times. Thankfully they improved, when they did I can only describe what I had as a nervous breakdown resulting in a long hospital stay.

J did text me and sent love and seemed really happy when I was discharged. I was always careful when we spoke so it wasn't all about me, enquiring on her and her family etc.

However, contact between us became bare minimum. A week after my discharge I had a car accident which resulted in having major surgery. When I was discharged from hospital after 3 weeks I text her why I hadn't been in contact and she messaged back to say how awful and hope you recover etc.

I never got a card, visit, or any offer of help.
All the time I was in hospital J never reached out to my DH or any of my DC.

Today was our wedding anniversary and she sent a card. My DH said how lovely but I can't help feeling really upset in her lack of concern or support. If it had happened to her I would have wanted to visit and help out.

Im so upset about this and due to my mental health problems I can't stop thinking about it. My family just say "forget it and she obviously isn't a true friend." But I can't help going over and over it and wondering what I have done wrong?

It's my birthday next month and if she sends a card I don't want to phone and say thank you. I feel that it's pretty laughable to send cards and just ignore someone who has been through so much.

Half of me wants to message her and ask why and what have I done? The other half says ignore and rise above it.

Wwyd and AIBU to feel like this?

Sorry for the length of the post

OP posts:
Honeyroar · 13/09/2023 15:25

I very much see your point. I’ve had a lot of really horrible things happen over the last four or five years, and have been surprised how many, what I thought were, really good friends completely dropped off the radar. I was very hurt and haven’t much picked up the friendships since. But it seems that most people on here agree that they’d not expect a friend to be there for them and it’s out of order to be upset, so perhaps I’m just not normal thinking friends are there for each other. I remember a “share this” type thing on Facebook recently berating friends that dropped people because they’d not contacted them - it also said those people might have things going on that people didn’t know about. I thought it was a bit nasty, but most people were applauding it. So perhaps I’m just not normal. Perhaps I over share. I try to keep myself to myself nowadays.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 13/09/2023 15:04

I would (and did) feel the same as you. Those friends who walked away from me when I needed them most I refused to have in my life when things got better. This who distanced themselves (but didn't walk away completely) I kept that distance, I was politely friendly and saw them at social functions, kept them as acquaintances, but the "friendship" was gone. I don't need friends who won't support me when I need them the most.

All those saying that there may be reasons that they couldn't cope with what was going on in my life, well too fucking bad. It wasn't like I was leaning in them heavily. But an occasional listening ear or joining me for a cuppa to get away from everything really shouldn't have been that much of an ask.

The silver lining for me was finding that some casual friends were actually amazing and I became closer to them as a result.

Vijia · 13/09/2023 14:56

Op have you heard of vicarious trauma? It's where what you hear or see negatively affects you, you don't actually have to experience it to be negatively affected.

Surely after all the trauma you have suffered, would it be a good idea to arrange something really nice to look forward to and invite her along so that you can put the bad things behind you and focus on the positive?

I think you are cutting off your nose to spite your face if you have been really close friends until all this kicked off.

It is better for your mental health to acknowledge what has happened to you but try to see the future in terms of positivity instead of wallowing yourself in the misery of the past few months and wanting to blame and shame instead of taking the attitude of, wow, that was then,this is now, time to kickstart the good times again with her

spuddel · 13/09/2023 14:40

J did text me and sent love and seemed really happy when I was discharged. I was always careful when we spoke so it wasn't all about me, enquiring on her and her family etc You may well have, I'm sure you did! But the truth is, when you have a lot going on, a lot of worries you're talking over with your friend, when it comes to their turn to talk they may simply not feel you have any resources left to give in return and so they clam up or say all is fine. That's ok, she was still there for you and still listening when you spoke. And possibly it took it's toll on her inner resources or possibly she is simply busy giving to herself, as you were in your recovery.

readbooksdrinktea · 13/09/2023 14:30

RantyAnty · 13/09/2023 14:11

When was the last time you sent her a card or gift, invited her out, rang up for a chat?

Important point. Also agree with possible lack of emotional bandwidth. I have a lot less these days. Doesn't mean I don't like or care about my friends, but life is a lot.

Notjustamum28 · 13/09/2023 14:24

She is your friend, speak to her. I'd be more concerned if i felt i couldnt speak openly and honestly to someone who i had been friends with for 20years.

spuddel · 13/09/2023 14:21

Cola2023 · 13/09/2023 13:29

Seconding this - any bad situation people find uncomfortable.

I lost at least three close friends and became distant from several others after being in an abusive relationship for several years.

I learnt that to keep 'friends' I had to only see them on days I could pretend to be happy and never speak about it.

I withdrew from a good friend who was in an abusive relationship, knew she was but stayed and wanted me to continue to socialise with him, listen to her dramas and traumas and say the bare minimum, just 'be there for her' as she said. Fuck that! People do not have to bleed themselves dry in order to 'be there'. Everyone has their limits. And luckily, when she was no longer propped up by listening ears, she saw the light and left his sorry ass. We're great friends again.

RantyAnty · 13/09/2023 14:11

When was the last time you sent her a card or gift, invited her out, rang up for a chat?

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 14:06

" If it had happened to her I would have wanted to visit and help out"

I think this is the important line here. You're judging her and finding her wanting based on what you would do.

And everyone is an individual with different ways of doing things and dealing with things and what individuals think is very different.

Some people seem to think there's this unspoken social/friendship contract that everyone is aware of and agreed to and that isn't the case.

As we see time and time again on MN.

It doesn't mean anyone is a bad friend if they don't meet your expectations of what you would do as a friend.

Cola2023 · 13/09/2023 13:44

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 11:58

@PorridgeOnToast
I'm not trying to compare the two. I was just using that to show how close we were.

I'm also aware that some people don't know how to deal with MH problems. We are told that constantly in hospital. They say as it's not physical some people don't understand.
After my car accident I was on bed rest for 6weeks. I broke both my legs and may still have to have more surgery.

It was J that always pushed the sisters narrative. It was very much an even friendship.

When I was going through my crisis I didn't lean on her at all. Just said that things had been a bit much of late. She was also very close to my family member so asked for regular updates on their health.

However, I am aware that it may have been all a bit too much for her. I just don't feel that we can ever pick up our friendship again.
Rightly or wrongly I do feel very let down by her.

Thats why I can't speak to her, I don't want to say something I may later regret. But part of me wants her to know how upset I am.

Just to point out, I didn't start this thread so everyone would agree with poor little old me.
I did want peoples honest opinions and it has given me a lot to think about, so thanks.

I would downgrade rather than end the friendship. Expect less, contact less and see less.

Keep chat superficial.

Anewnamea · 13/09/2023 13:43

PorridgeOnToast · 13/09/2023 07:50

I'm not sure being there for her when her dad died and being there for you for 12 months of trials, can be equated.

If a Happy Anniversary card wasn't enough for you, then a Get Well card wouldn't have been either. You want more. She can't supply that.

Friendships sometimes run their course.

I agree, this is the issue - sometimes people think they have given as much as they have taken and it’s not the case at all.

My trauma dumping friend would listen to me talk about a late train or an annoying colleague and seemed to think because I’d droned on about that for a few minutes it was fair game for her to share heavy details Of trauma with with no warning for several years on the trot . She would say she loves how we support each other - she didn’t have a clue. It was a very unequal friendship for several years and it got progressively worse.

It’s likely here the friendship has been very one-sided and Op’s friend doesn’t have any further capacity. The problem is a lot of those demanding friends be there in need always do a vanishing act when that same friend tries to lean on them. And they probably don’t even realise.

Many posters piping up to say friends should always be there in difficult times are probably the type of people who drain those around them. Either that or or they’re martyrs who get some sort of ego boost /sense of identify from having people pour out their trouble to them all the time.

Of course I’ve been there for friends in hard times, and them for me but there are limits as I realise people have others to support, as well as their own lives and personal struggles.

I have had various mental health issues since I was a tween, as well as difficult life circumstances as an adult and may share bits with friends here and there but I’m mindful that they’re not my therapist and I don’t know what they are going through.

Friendship shouldn’t be solely based on how much someone can listen to your trauma.

Cola2023 · 13/09/2023 13:29

ValleyClouds · 12/09/2023 23:35

Unfortunately it is very common and very tough that people with disabilities, serious health issues and mental illness lose friends because the friend can't cope, doesn't want to or has prejudices. It's wrong but a lot of people face it

My best to you Flowers it's not a great club to be in

Seconding this - any bad situation people find uncomfortable.

I lost at least three close friends and became distant from several others after being in an abusive relationship for several years.

I learnt that to keep 'friends' I had to only see them on days I could pretend to be happy and never speak about it.

DoubleTequilaSunrise · 13/09/2023 13:19

First you don't know what she is going or went through herself.
Why do you assume her DH would tell yours if she had an awful time?
Maybe he doesn't know, maybe he wouldn't share HER problems, maybe your DH went in length about yours, it didn't seem appropriate to tell their stories.

I would be wary of assuming someone is trouble free because they look fine, or because you haven't been told.

If you enjoy her company, I would give her the benefit of the doubt for all the reason given by posters above. Your DH saying "we're fine thanks", not knowing how to help, maybe not wanting to intrude but ready to visit if you invited...

Nothing is simple or black and white. It hurts when someone you thought as close family is only a good friend, it's completely understandable, but don't you want to at least keep the good friend?

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 13:08

I wasn't expecting anything whilst I was in the psychiatric hospital. I was in no fit state to see anyone.

Even the offer of help I was ok with. But a visit would have been nice.

I know I'm coming across as this needy depressed friend but that's really not the case.

But again, after your replies I will think things over more rationally. Maybe we have just grown apart?

OP posts:
MyEyesMyThighs · 13/09/2023 12:38

I think the DH contact will be influencing things a bit, so she is still hearing about how you're getting on. Is there a chance that her DH has said "is there anything we can do," and he's said "we're fine, I'll let you know" or something that makes them feel you'll reach out when you're ready?

There's two more layers of Chinese whispers from you-DH-her DH-her that you can't make assumptions only on the direct contact with her.

I'd send a text saying how you are going stir crazy and would love to see her, if she is holding back because she is taking her lead from you, then it'll be fine. If she's still not very enthusiastic, then you know.

ManateeFair · 13/09/2023 12:31

I think most people would actually not have a clue what sort of help/support is appropriate for someone who is spending three months in a psychiatric hospital, and it would vary tremendously from person to person anyway. For some people, contact with friends wouldn't necessarily be the right thing for the patient. And I guess how easy/reasonable it was to offer support while you were in psychiatric care would be very dependent on your condition at the time.

Regarding your accident, she didn't hear from you for three weeks and then when she heard from you, you'd already been discharged from hospital. So she probably thought it was a bit late to start sending cards at that point. She was sympathetic and wished you well for your recovery. Also you have a husband who is there to help you, so I don't really know what extra help you were expecting from her. If I was on my own I might be grateful for a mate coming round to help me out with stuff or keep me company while I was laid up after an accident, but as I live with my DP I imagine my friends would assume he had everything covered.

If you'd said 'I'm a bit miffed that she didn't step up, but I guess not everyone thinks of doing things like that. Hey ho, I suppose our friendship's just a little different these days' that would feel like a proportionate response to this, in my opinion. I think saying it would be 'laughable' to get a birthday card from her and refusing to thank her for it, however, is quite an intense and OTT response to this situation.

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 11:58

@PorridgeOnToast
I'm not trying to compare the two. I was just using that to show how close we were.

I'm also aware that some people don't know how to deal with MH problems. We are told that constantly in hospital. They say as it's not physical some people don't understand.
After my car accident I was on bed rest for 6weeks. I broke both my legs and may still have to have more surgery.

It was J that always pushed the sisters narrative. It was very much an even friendship.

When I was going through my crisis I didn't lean on her at all. Just said that things had been a bit much of late. She was also very close to my family member so asked for regular updates on their health.

However, I am aware that it may have been all a bit too much for her. I just don't feel that we can ever pick up our friendship again.
Rightly or wrongly I do feel very let down by her.

Thats why I can't speak to her, I don't want to say something I may later regret. But part of me wants her to know how upset I am.

Just to point out, I didn't start this thread so everyone would agree with poor little old me.
I did want peoples honest opinions and it has given me a lot to think about, so thanks.

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 13/09/2023 09:13

You’ve been through hell and I’m so so sorry 💐

I can completely see why you feel the way you do. I don’t think you need to do anything, it’s okay to sit with your feelings about it.

BluebellsForest · 13/09/2023 08:54

Oh god, just realised this is on AIBU, OP, hence the number of people just waiting to blame and dismiss you rather than show any understanding. Relationships would be better. Never post in AIBU if you are hurt.

BluebellsForest · 13/09/2023 08:50

I sorry you've had so many "you don't know what she's going through" replies. It's become the dismissive go to response on MN.

Of course there are situations where that may be relevant and worth considering. It really doesn't sound like this is one of them.

Vastly more likely is that she couldn't cope with your hospitalisation for MH and withdrew. A less emotionally avoidant person would have possibly managed to switch back into friend mode when you had your car accident. She didn't and that must hurt a lot.

It's not you, OP. Many people who have had serious ill health experience similar, and find unexpected people are kinder than those they thought would be supportive.

It's like they can't tolerate the level and duration to which someone close to them is suffering, so they just sweep it all under the carpet. The anniversary card is an attempt to just carry on as if nothing ever happened. 'It's all fine. Life is continuing as usual.' This is all about her need to avoid challenging and uncomfortable times.

Flowers
marblesthecat · 13/09/2023 08:42

Sorry OP but I think YABU. I know being ill can make you feel very emotional but I wouldn't expect that from my friends I have my close family for that. I generally hate the "you don't know what someone is going through" mantra but in this case I agree with it plus emotionally supporting other people can be exhausting. She may have something going on that her DH doesn't want to disclose.

ButterCrackers · 13/09/2023 08:39

Some people can’t manage other people’s difficulties. She sounds like this type of person. All going fine and she’s there. You need a friend for support and she’s distancing. It’s not your fault or anything you’ve done it’s her lack of empathy that’s her problem. Focus in on taking care of you. Reply to her card. Don’t have any expectations. It’s sad when a friend can’t be there for you but now you know her better. Look out for other friends when you feel up to this.

fruitstick · 13/09/2023 08:38

Some friends just aren't good in a crisis.

I went through a very hard time when my son died and I was completely surprised by the friends who stepped up and the (very long term) friends who didn't.

I had a big falling out with one of my close friends because she wasn't supportive.

We are friends again now and I'm glad she is back in my life. It she is a 'fun, positive, motivating' person and not at all great at empathy or support. I know that now and get that from somewhere else.

Think of it as all your friends being Top Trumps cards. She gets a low score for this, but think about her other qualities.

Some friends, on the other hand, have literally never spoken me again.

I'm sorry you've been through a lot and hope you have other people to support you.

Strugglingtodomybest · 13/09/2023 08:32

But I can't help going over and over it and wondering what I have done wrong?

Please don't beat yourself up over this OP. You haven't done anything wrong.

Reading your post, I thought to myself that you don't actually sound like you are that close anymore, ie. only meeting up on special occasions. I know you said that you're like sisters, but the truth if that you're not sisters, and it sounds to me as if this friendship was petering out anyway.

My advice would be to either just leave it to continue as it is, with the odd meet up and cards and accept that you no longer have the relationship you had before, or, if you really can't stop thinking about it, ask to meet up and have a talk with her about how you feel.

PorridgeOnToast · 13/09/2023 07:50

I'm not sure being there for her when her dad died and being there for you for 12 months of trials, can be equated.

If a Happy Anniversary card wasn't enough for you, then a Get Well card wouldn't have been either. You want more. She can't supply that.

Friendships sometimes run their course.

Swipe left for the next trending thread