Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this friendship is finished?

111 replies

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:22

DH and I have very long standing friends. Over 20years of friendship.

Our children went to same primary school and we did lots of things together when they were young holidays, days out, camping etc.

We have all been through tough times over the years but class each other as extended family. The lady, let's call her J doesn't have siblings and would call me her sister.

As the DC got older we didn't meet up as much but always got together for special occasions and spoke regularly on the phone, especially if either one of us had a problem. She was my go to for advice and me her.

Last year I was having a particularly bad time. One of my family members was very ill and we came close to losing them a few times. Thankfully they improved, when they did I can only describe what I had as a nervous breakdown resulting in a long hospital stay.

J did text me and sent love and seemed really happy when I was discharged. I was always careful when we spoke so it wasn't all about me, enquiring on her and her family etc.

However, contact between us became bare minimum. A week after my discharge I had a car accident which resulted in having major surgery. When I was discharged from hospital after 3 weeks I text her why I hadn't been in contact and she messaged back to say how awful and hope you recover etc.

I never got a card, visit, or any offer of help.
All the time I was in hospital J never reached out to my DH or any of my DC.

Today was our wedding anniversary and she sent a card. My DH said how lovely but I can't help feeling really upset in her lack of concern or support. If it had happened to her I would have wanted to visit and help out.

Im so upset about this and due to my mental health problems I can't stop thinking about it. My family just say "forget it and she obviously isn't a true friend." But I can't help going over and over it and wondering what I have done wrong?

It's my birthday next month and if she sends a card I don't want to phone and say thank you. I feel that it's pretty laughable to send cards and just ignore someone who has been through so much.

Half of me wants to message her and ask why and what have I done? The other half says ignore and rise above it.

Wwyd and AIBU to feel like this?

Sorry for the length of the post

OP posts:
Atethehalloweenchocs · 13/09/2023 20:37

I see people saying she may be having a hard time but over and above that, I think people get into rhythms and if something happens that interrupts this, contact levels can really change.

Stifado · 13/09/2023 20:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MariaLuna · 13/09/2023 20:27

We're all burnt out OP.

Covid changed everything.

Sorry you're hurting.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 13/09/2023 20:26

In all those messages about her daughter she never once asked how you were?

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 20:23

@SallyWD sorry that you have been through all that.

OP posts:
Banana1979 · 13/09/2023 20:22

Sounds like she found it all too much to deal with remember before it was all about happy friendly stuff. However the shit hit the fan for you in terms of your mental health and physical health and she didn’t know how to deal with it. That’s how it sounds
her reaction isnt that uncommon
it’s also possible, she wanted to give you space to deal with your mental health
If She’s been such a good friend up until now I wouldn’t say that this was coming from a bad place
if you are as close, as you say, you are, then you would have no problem asking her why she didn’t come to see you. you can ask our opinions on here all you like however, no one is gonna know what’s in her head. Talk to her

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 20:16

@Createausername1970 I definitely didn't miss any messages. Lost in cyberspace, really?

OP posts:
DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 20:13

@fruitstick so sorry for your loss x

OP posts:
SallyWD · 13/09/2023 20:13

Honestly, some people are just pretty rubbish at dealing with others tragedies. They don't know what to say, they feel awkward, they back away. It doesn't make them bad people, but it does mean they're not going to be much support when you're having a shit time. You had a prolonged period of suffering and difficulty and maybe she just didn't know what else to say. Maybe she was uncomfortable, some people are.
I've had two really difficult periods in my life. Once when I had a nervous breakdown and once when I had cancer, whilst my children were toddlers. Some of my friends were useless. I could see and sense their discomfort, they very obviously backed away from me, kept their distance from my suffering. I don't actually believe they're bad friends. I just think they couldn't cope with it. These people are still in my life as my friends but I remember that they're not the ones I can turn to in a crisis.

DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 20:09

I really am a bit shocked at some of these replies.

A visit would have been nice.

As I said before I did not offload on her. I sent her a birthday card and anniversary card last month.

I have also sent a number of messages regarding her daughter taking exams and sympathising what a terrible time it is.

@OrderOfTheKookaburra that has happened to me. Someone I knew very casually has turned into a god send for me and gone above and beyond. So I have made a lovely friend and I don't offload to her either. I leave that for my pyschiatrist.

OP posts:
DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 20:03

Sorry it didn't quote your post @Vijia but that was aimed at you

OP posts:
DaisyDuke111 · 13/09/2023 19:55

Sorry but I think that's a bit harsh, it takes a long time to build yourself back up after a breakdown and believe me a psychiatric hospital is not a health farm.

OP posts:
readbooksdrinktea · 13/09/2023 19:49

Anewnamea

However, what eventually made me stop doing it was her pointless comments about how she would “treat” me if she came into money.

That's some weird version of future faking!

Lemmony · 13/09/2023 19:34

I'd be very hurt, poor you OP

Anewnamea · 13/09/2023 19:22

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 17:28

OP didn't say they needed it. They seemed to be very well supported by many.

OP said she expected more from their friend based on what OP would do in a similar situation .That's not the same as OP needed anything

In fact, OP seems to have not really needed anything from the friend. But is offered that it wasn’t forthcoming or offered

I agree Op seems to be well supported. Unfortunately some people demand ALL hands on deck when they’re going through something.

I am single , live alone and don’t enjoy close relationships with my immediate family but my friend who kept trauma dumping had a live in partner/father to her kids, a decent relationship with her Dad and very close to two of her cousins and had an NHS therapist.

Its unfortunate that people who already have a very strong support network seem to think every friend needs to be part of holding them up, even if those friends don’t have as much of a support system as they do.

This many not apply to OP but generally speaking I’ve came across this a few times and it’s the height of selfishness.

A friend of mine use to borrow a lot if money from me, and I’d always say she didn’t have to pay it back and she never did which is fine. However, what eventually made me stop doing it was her pointless comments about how she would “treat” me if she came into money. It was really annoying because instead of dealing with the reality she was placing her genorisity in some sort of conditional fantasy future. She could have paid for a coffee or a meal once with the money she had now and showed her gratitude with what she actually had instead of meaningless comments about what she would do.

It’s too easy for people to say they “would do” x and y if the tables were turned but we don’t actually know.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 13/09/2023 18:18

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 17:28

OP didn't say they needed it. They seemed to be very well supported by many.

OP said she expected more from their friend based on what OP would do in a similar situation .That's not the same as OP needed anything

In fact, OP seems to have not really needed anything from the friend. But is offered that it wasn’t forthcoming or offered

This, what I've inferred from op and other posters is that you'll only consider someone a friend if they do what you want, when you want, even if they may not know what it is you want. It also doesn't matter if they have anything going on for themselves, why should it as that's not about you?

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 17:28

WildFeathers · 13/09/2023 16:47

Also just because she wasn’t able to provide the support you needed, doesn’t mean you didn’t need it. And it is is sad for you that you didn’t have the support you wanted.

OP didn't say they needed it. They seemed to be very well supported by many.

OP said she expected more from their friend based on what OP would do in a similar situation .That's not the same as OP needed anything

In fact, OP seems to have not really needed anything from the friend. But is offered that it wasn’t forthcoming or offered

Createausername1970 · 13/09/2023 16:55

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:45

I know there isn't anything going on as my DH sees her partner regularly. They play football together.

When I have spoken to her I have always asked if everything is ok. My next door neighbour showed more concern, she bought me flowers, chocolates and a beautiful card and offered help and I hardly know her.
My DH asked her partner if I had upset her and he said " no but I think J has messaged her and she hasn't replied" which isn't true.
Im really trying to think what could be wrong but surely a get well card wouldn't have been too hard?
I'm not sure if I should phone her and risk an argument or just accept the friendship is gone?

Her husband says she has messaged you but got no response. You don't think she has. Maybe that message from her got lost in cyberspace. It does happen.

My honest opinion - contact her and say "Hi J, really sorry - hubby has said I have not responded to a message from you recently. Its been such a difficult time and my head is all over the place, I think I may have missed some messages, so how about a long awaited catch up over a bottle of wine when the men next go to football?"

Or however you would word it.

TheShellBeach · 13/09/2023 16:55

DaisyDuke111 · 12/09/2023 23:45

I know there isn't anything going on as my DH sees her partner regularly. They play football together.

When I have spoken to her I have always asked if everything is ok. My next door neighbour showed more concern, she bought me flowers, chocolates and a beautiful card and offered help and I hardly know her.
My DH asked her partner if I had upset her and he said " no but I think J has messaged her and she hasn't replied" which isn't true.
Im really trying to think what could be wrong but surely a get well card wouldn't have been too hard?
I'm not sure if I should phone her and risk an argument or just accept the friendship is gone?

I have a feeling that this friendship is over.
She wasn't supportive to you when you really needed her.
If there's no good reason for this, I can see why you can't forgive her.

WildFeathers · 13/09/2023 16:47

Also just because she wasn’t able to provide the support you needed, doesn’t mean you didn’t need it. And it is is sad for you that you didn’t have the support you wanted.

WildFeathers · 13/09/2023 16:45

My parent was sectioned when I was a child. Their siblings never visited when they were in hospital for months. At the time I judged them and felt they’d treated my parent and me awfully. However, looking back they did what they could do and others who could do more than them did and that was really helpful. However, I think now that if you want someone to accept you as you are then you need to accept them as they are. It sounds as though she hasn’t abandoned you completely and still wants to be your friend. You now know that she doesn’t offer what you would offer in a crisis situation. That may change how you feel about your friendship. No amount of wishing she is different will change her. Tackling her on it won’t change her either. You’ve had a very difficult time. All the best with everything.

BluebellsForest · 13/09/2023 16:34

it's not "pouncing" to have a different opinion from yours BluebellsForest.

And I didn't suggest that it was, @DoubleTequilaSunrise. I was making a wider point about AIBU.

What a depressing thread.

DoubleTequilaSunrise · 13/09/2023 16:27

BluebellsForest · 13/09/2023 16:14

I honestly think the huge number of 'why do you expect anything more?' posts is due to it being on AIBU, @Honeyroar. It's so clear that people just wait to pounce on an OP and tell them how unreasonable they are, whatever the circumstances. YANBU and nor is the OP, imo.

it's not "pouncing" to have a different opinion from yours BluebellsForest.

Ultimately, you cannot expect other people to have the strength, the energy, the headspace to deal with your problem on top of their own.

Sometimes people need to walk away to protect their own mental health and not be drawn into full drama. It's a sad truth that everyone around you will have a sick relative or friend right now, or health scare themselves, and countless issues.

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 16:26

Honeyroar · 13/09/2023 15:25

I very much see your point. I’ve had a lot of really horrible things happen over the last four or five years, and have been surprised how many, what I thought were, really good friends completely dropped off the radar. I was very hurt and haven’t much picked up the friendships since. But it seems that most people on here agree that they’d not expect a friend to be there for them and it’s out of order to be upset, so perhaps I’m just not normal thinking friends are there for each other. I remember a “share this” type thing on Facebook recently berating friends that dropped people because they’d not contacted them - it also said those people might have things going on that people didn’t know about. I thought it was a bit nasty, but most people were applauding it. So perhaps I’m just not normal. Perhaps I over share. I try to keep myself to myself nowadays.

But the OP hasn't at all suggested that their friend wouldn't be 'there for them'.

The OP didn't actually ask anything. The OP just had an expectation that the frend would do certain things based on what the OP would do. Which seemed to be around action, being sent cards or chocolates, offers of visits or some undefined practical 'help'

And that isn't necessarily universally known that that's what some people expect of friends. The OPs friend could very easily think they were giving the OP space to recover and their texts were enough and balancing caring and not being intrusive so that was the best thing they could do as a friend.

And the friend clearly cares enough to remember the OPs anniversary and send a card. So it's not like they don't care.

OP is judging a 20 year friendship on what she would do. And that isn't the same thing as what every friend should do or is aware of being expected to do.

BluebellsForest · 13/09/2023 16:14

I honestly think the huge number of 'why do you expect anything more?' posts is due to it being on AIBU, @Honeyroar. It's so clear that people just wait to pounce on an OP and tell them how unreasonable they are, whatever the circumstances. YANBU and nor is the OP, imo.