Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dislike school's attendance competition

105 replies

PostmanPatAlwaysRingsTwice · 12/09/2023 23:10

Our primary school's latest newsletter contains the usual lines about attendance at school being important, which it is. It then goes on to show the attendance statistics since the beginning of term, I think, for each year group. A year contains one or two classes. It's titled 'Attendance Race' and congratulates the class with the best attendance that week.

AIBU to think this is ineffective, unfair and discriminatory? In primary, it's down to the parents to get their DC to school - the children have little to no control over it. If a child is reluctant, it's up to their parent to deal with that and ask school for help if need be (I've been there). Most kids are off because they're ill. What are they expected to do about that? Others are off because their parent didn't get out of bed to take them. The child can't change that. Why make the children get in a race they can't compete in?

Also, it means that children with long term conditions who are more likely to be off may be blamed for their class not winning the race - 'we're not going to be the best because X is in our class and she's off a lot with her diabetes/asthma/Crohn's disease'. Or 'why is your class the worst, Jimmy?' 'because Y is off all the time. We'll never get it because of him.' It's none of the children's business to talk about why one of their class is off. I have skin in the game here - my DD was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes this year and was off sick for a while. Sorry for losing the race for the class 😒Some children will be worried that they're ill and losing their class's position.

Children are off because of health (temp or longer term) that they can do nothing about, or because of additional needs leading to difficulties at school (that the school have a responsibility to help with), or because of difficult family situations such as being refugees/EAL, domestic abuse, mental health or addiction. Those families need support, and are not going to suddenly change because of this attendance race.

School need to focus on children who are persistently absent and work effectively and sensitively with families to support them to get their children into school. Not do this.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Youhaveyourhandsfull · 12/09/2023 23:48

It's bollocks and should be ignored. It really doesn't matter.
I've interviewed college age kids before and they all put their attendance % on their CVs now. Total lunacy.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 12/09/2023 23:44

I mean it would be interesting to see it challenged under the Equality Act

Dramatic · 12/09/2023 23:44

YANBU, my daughter's school had a raffle for kids who got 100% attendance and they had the chance to win a bike and a tablet. Absolutely ridiculous, I made a complaint about it not least because my daughter has a health condition meaning she'll never have 100% attendance, yet she was always putting in a huge amount of effort with her homework, behaviour etc and none of that was rewarded with such big prizes

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 12/09/2023 23:43

The 100% attendance obsession is inherently discriminatory against all kids with health issues who might need hospital visits, YANBU

longtompot · 12/09/2023 23:40

Ya absolutely nbu I read a post today on a Facebook group I am part of for a condition my dd has. The person who posted has a child with the same condition and has been told by their school they need to do ' something about their condition ' as it's affecting their attendance! Wtf! My dd always felt sad she wouldn't get any awards for attendance as she would miss a lot of school for appointments or for when her pain was high.

Swipe left for the next trending thread