Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for regretting being a stepparent...

212 replies

mnuser2021 · 12/09/2023 21:50

Hear me out. I adore my stepchild - he is very mature for his age (can have the best conversations with him), well-mannered, and probably the most caring child I have ever encountered. Seriously.He only remembers a life with me in it and practically sees me as his mum. I do everything daily-life related; ofc OH helps when he can but stepchild generally prefers to do daily "boring" stuff with me. He lives with us almost full-time (2 weekends a month spent with biological mum), and I was prepared for this coming into this relationship. This was never a problem for me, I'm happy to help and he's such a good kid. However... Ever since OH and I had our own, the love I have for each of them is very different. Do I care about my stepchild? Absolutely, and very deeply so. I genuinely love watching him grow and feel proud of his accomplishments. However, it doesn't compare to the love I have for my own. And I must admit, I thoroughly enjoy and look forward to the weekends he's not here when I'm just with my "real" family (for the lack of a better word). I now wish my partner didn't have a child as taking care of and managing both of their schedules tires me out and, for this reason, I couldn't imagine having a third, which makes me sad - that I don't want a second "because of" stepchild, i.e. I will only have 1 biological, which I never imagined. It makes me very sad thinking I'll have two children I don't hold the same emotional love for, and I wish I'd be pouring all my efforts into two I truly loved equally (gosh, sounds so cold written out like this... I hope you'll understand where I'm coming from). Luckily, the two of them (siblings) are unbelievably close! It's utterly heartwarming. But even in their most intimate moments, I catch myself wishing I'd be experiencing it with two biological kids.I don't want this to come across heartless - hell, I've been the stepchild myself my whole life, and I LOVE my stepmum! Which makes me even more committed to never treating them differently. But admittedly, I feel very differently about them in my heart even though they're both amazing kids (I guess it's a "you never love anyone like your own" thing), and god... I have many moments I feel I've robbed myself of the family dynamic I now crave (which I never knew I wanted until I had my own) and it genuinely makes me sad and regretful in hindsight.AIBU? Can anyone relate?

OP posts:
TheLadyofShalott1 · 13/09/2023 08:24

@mnuser2021 I have read all of your posts on this thread, but not all of the others, so apologies if I say what has already been said.

I am straight, but I think I love you OP. In some ways your post is very sad in that you feel that you cannot love your DSS in the same way, or as much as your DC. But OP, your OP is absolutely full of love for your DSS. If you didn't have any biological children of your own - for whatever reason - you might wonder about it (as you are obviously both a very thoughtful and intelligent person), but you wouldn't know for sure whether you would love your own biological child more, or maybe how much more than your DSC.

I think that particularly when our children are still actually children, rather than being adults, it would be almost inevitable for us to love our own children that bit more, especially when their bio mum is still on the scene. However in my experience (and I am the only person whose experience I can talk about!) when I became pregnant with my second child I was really worried about whether/how I could possibly love my second child as much as my first child, because I already loved my first child so very much.

When my second child was born I fell in love with them as soon as they were born - I had of course loved them when they were still in my womb, and would have been devastated if I had lost them while pregnant, but I was still worried in case it wasn't as much as my first (PFB) - My second child is the same sex as my first, so I don't know if they had they been the other sex, whether that would make any difference, but in my case I don't think it would have. I later went on to have a third child (same sex again, and still not a problem). My second baby had, and still does have, a very different temperament to my first child, and then my third had, and has, a very different character to the other two!

I actually found bringing up two young children easier than when I just had one, but that was probably because I had already learned so much baby related with baby number one - I had virtually no experience at all with babies until I had my first - when I was about 9 I pushed a baby in it's pram for about 10 minutes, and when I was about 14 or 15 I held a 6 month old baby on my knee for about a minute, but she started crying so I gave her back to her mum almost straight away 🙈 That was the sum knowledge of babies until I had my own.

Anyway, the point I am trying to make above, is that your baby is your first born, and obviously I have no idea how much experience you already had with newborns, but if not much, you might find having a second baby much easier than having one baby, and one older stepchild. So if you want another bio child please don't rule it out because of your recent experience. Your DSS will also have experience now of being an older sibling.

@mnuser2021 I felt (and still feel now even though I am now a grandmother) a different love with all of my children. I don't mean that I love one more than either of the other two, and I can't think of a way of describing my love for each of them - even to myself - but every baby became the most vunerable of my children when they were born, and that was simply because a tiny baby is more vunerable than most older children, so if there was a fire in the house most of us would try to dave the baby first as it couldn't climb or run away from the danger by itself.

I am not trying to suggest that that is why you feel differently towards your two children, as I think it is only human nature to do so in your sort of situation, but with one of your children being so young, your different feelings might be for more complex reasons than just one being your stepchild and one being your born to you child.
By the way when my husband and I only had our youngest child at home, while the other two were with their Grandparents, we used to enjoy it being just the three of us, and having a rest from the other two.

You are such a lovely mum, stepmum, and person, that I think you need to try to stop thinking about the negatives of a situation that you can't change without making such drastic changes that I think you would hate them, and that would not make you happy, even in the long run. You cannot force a change in how you feel about your stepson, but as all your children get older I think a change will happen organically anyway. Please be kind to yourself, and forgive yourself, you have NOT done anything wrong.

If you have managed to get to the end of this post OP, Thank You, and apologies for it being ultra long, even by my standards.

Umjellu · 13/09/2023 08:17

Ontheperiphery79 · 13/09/2023 05:33

@Umjellu do you refer to twice a month Dads as 'biological' or 'birth' fathers?

@Ontheperiphery79 usually I would refer to them as ‘useless cunts.’

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 13/09/2023 08:14

So-called 'blended' families are the absolute pits.

GrapeEscape · 13/09/2023 07:59

I've not read the full thread yet but just wanted to say there is nothing wrong with you OP. You are completely normal in my experience both of being a step parent and knowing plenty of others.

ofc OH helps when he can

Firstly what the fuck does this even mean? "Helps"??? It's his son, he should be doing the vast majority of his care and you, as his partner, should then be the one helping him if and when appropriate not the other way around. Far too many men get into relationships with new women and then treat them as a replacement nanny. It's not acceptable for a RP dad (or a NRP dad) to merely help 'where he can' with his own child. That's completely unacceptable and should have been nipped in the bud from the start. I know posters will jump on "but they are a teeeeeam OP chose to be with a man with a kid', it makes no odds imo. The starting point for a step parent should always be that the parent does the bulk of the work and the step parent helps as and when able, not the other way around. That is the problem on the huge majority of step parenting threads on this forum and it very often leads to massive resentment further down the line for the step parent.

Secondly, of course its fine to feel differently about your own child. I have two step children and there's no way the way I feel about them and my own DC is even within the same universe. And yes I also look forward to the days they aren't here so I can focus on our DC, the house is quieter, less chaotic ect. I just don't have that unconditional love of a parent for them and therefore I value the time to decompress from them being here, I don't feel bad about that at all.

Its an entirely unreasonable expectation for someone who isn't your child's parent to love them completely as their own. Does it happen? Yes I'm sure in some circumstances it does (I suspect more often in step dad's than step mums because I personally think they often get a far easier deal but that's another thread). Should it be expected? No absolutely not. Only a fool expects someone else to love their children as much as they do. Feelings are what they are, you feel it or you don't. Expecting someone to feel something is stupid unless you're willing to be disappointed.

Basically you're doing fine, your step son sounds happy and loved, he doesn't need to be secretly as loved as your child by you. It is what it is, you're not his mum (although she also sounds useless so the comment about you never replacing her is rich considering you sound like you do more for him than mum and dad combined).

I regret being a step parent all the time, I still show affection, am caring and welcoming and friendly. But if I had my time again I'd never do it and I do wish I'd made different choices now and had a nuclear family, things would definitely be simpler. But it is what it is, I didn't make that choice and now here we are so I guess you just need to accept your feelings are normal and nothing to be ashamed of, cut yourself some slack and try and focus on the good things (like your child's relationship with their sibling for example).

Isometimeswonder · 13/09/2023 07:59

So many people would love your "problem".
A loving stepchild who causes no issues, a child of your own with a decent man?
Jeez, wake up to yourself.

Justdontforgethelegofrog · 13/09/2023 07:56

@Anni1234 with respect (and you sound fantastic BTW) co-parenting a child with another fully responsive parent who is reliable and consistent in their care, such as your SC's mum, is different to parenting a child with a parent who is only present twice a month. We don't like to admit it but kids really need a mum. That's why so many of us can grow up without dads around and turn out mostly ok. I don't know many who didn't have a mum around who grew up equally well adjusted. In OP's case, she knows that she has to love that child ten times more, and be ten times more responsive and consistent to 'make up' for that absence of mother. That's not fair. It's not her job to have to do that. But that unfortunately is what that child needs. Attachment matters.

OrlandointheWilderness · 13/09/2023 07:52

It is very difficult sometimes, it can feel a little out of balance. DP and I both have a child each from a previous relationship, and we have decided we are done, we don't want another. Our family feels complete and to me we all equally feel part of that family even though DPs child doesn't live with us (we aren't married so technically not my DSS). I genuinely look forward to him coming, my DD loves him and we have so much fun all together.

However...

I understand where you are coming from.

feralunderclass · 13/09/2023 07:48

I think nearly all stepparents feel this way if they are being honest, and it intensifies when they have their own dc. I think there's something subconscious about the child serving as a reminder of your spouses past that makes loving a stepchild 'like your own' different from a child through adoption.

TooOldForASugarDaddy · 13/09/2023 07:48

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 13/09/2023 00:11

I agree! Just can't imagine moving a man in and then him doing all my childcare

Quoted the wrong person, sorry.

Anni1234 · 13/09/2023 07:41

Maybe it can help to reframe it all a bit.
. I have a DS and step children and I know the love can feel different. My step children have a fabulous involved mother btw.
so I know my love for my step kids is different but it’s also unique to me and my step kids. We grew to love each other and it happened in a different way to what they have with their mum/dad or what i have with my DS.
but what me and my step kids have is just for us and we don’t have that with anyone else. So I love to remember how special that is in its own way if that makes sense?
and I see the bond they have with my DS and it’s so special, in way it brought us closer together to have a ‘blood bond’ between us. Even though we are already bonded but i think it just reaffirmed it for the kids that we share something the same now (DS). I’m terrible
with words so hope this makes sense.
I also make time still for 1:1 time with the older kids and make a point of still doing things with them that DS is too young for.

for example the oldest and myself love sushi. Nobody else like sushi. We go on sushi dates just the two of us where we can go out and appreciate the same thing without any complainers :D
or the oldest and i both love chess and DS is too young to take it seriously anyway.
or the middle and I go rock climbing together.
so there are things we can enjoy together without DS which means we don’t always have to adapt to suit him (which the kids are good at when needed). And can all enjoy the things we love most :)
is there anything you and SS can do to together that’s just for you two?

Blanca87 · 13/09/2023 07:40

‘Oh helps where he can’ with his own child? What I’m I reading. We need to be raising the parental bar for men. Fuck me.

TooOldForASugarDaddy · 13/09/2023 07:37

What you are feeling is normal, don’t beat yourself about it, just keep the love flowing on the same way you have. You are that child mother to him and to your own child, even if you feel the difference privately.

One thing that I don’t think has been mentioned is that such difference in age may be the cause of your issues and that you may feel exactly the same if they both were your own kids:

It is difficult to set priorities and provide the same level of attention when the kids have such different needs and interests due to their different age.

All children are different and behave differently at different ages so this want to be able to devote more time to your younger child you might have felt anyway if you were the birth parent of both.

And also, despite everyone claiming all their children are equal and loving them the same, it is very usual for siblings to have at least an idea about who of them is the mum’s or dad’s favourite. The added complexity when it comes to half siblings is that that preference if often blamed 100% on one of them being the SC, who then becomes the scapegoat as a step child is often perceived more like “an option” or “choice” that you can revert 😕

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 13/09/2023 07:36

That poor child.

Epidote · 13/09/2023 07:32

Agree with most of PP. It is not your bio child but at other effects is your child and the child feel it that way.

Is hard to have to littles around.

Obviously your bio little is a priority, as it was your stepchild when he was younger, and you wish to had more time to expend with.

You are a good mum, step or not step in the prefix. That doesn't matter.

I think a good way is now there are two of them involved your husband more in the childcare of both to avoid you to get burnt out.

If he works a lot outside even if is just some mental load of planning that will help you and the family dynamics.

Don't feel bad for felling this way and work on those feelings, don't let them grow and make you resent or grudge.

NotAMug · 13/09/2023 07:32

Moveoverdarlin · 12/09/2023 23:24

Every step-mother I have ever known (those that have gone on to have their own families) feel exactly the same. Two close friends feel similar and both openly said they wish they didn’t have step-kids and dread it when they visit, despite loving relationships with them.

But this is quite different, in the OPs case the child lives with her. Completely different scenario here.

I know one who dreaded the kids visiting, but the others didn't. The strange thing is, that only one family I know has the dad as resident parent with a step mum and they didn't have their own children, the others are all step dads and most have joint DC also, so perhaps this is why they are able to love the DC as their own because in most cases (of the people I know) they are not doing the lions share of the child rearing.

MattDamon · 13/09/2023 07:27

Ontheperiphery79 · 13/09/2023 05:33

@Umjellu do you refer to twice a month Dads as 'biological' or 'birth' fathers?

My thoughts exactly. Of course they wouldn't.

IAmNoLady · 13/09/2023 07:26

Op I agree with other posters who say your DH needs to step up.

I am an adoptive mum and I have sympathy with you. My adopted child is my world and whilst I use the word adopted in this post for clarity, he is my own.

Your role in providing daily care is similar to mine. But, if you and DH split, what would happen? I don't imagine you would be able to insist on any contact arrangements. So, whilst I can see my child as my own, how can you?

The other thing, I would like to say, is that my love for my child has changed over time. As a baby and toddler, although I didn't give birth to my child, my hormones were raging and there was such an intensity there. It is primal and instinctual. Now he is a pre teen it us a different sort of love

So, maybe the two different feelings toward the children is almost an inbuilt biological response. I don't know.

But DH needs to step up. Also, has circumstances changed for DH's EX, which means in a gradual and thoughtful way, keeping your stepchild's interests central, she can have more contact. That might be worth considering.

NotAMug · 13/09/2023 07:22

Wouldyouguess · 13/09/2023 06:03

How do you know how they feel?
Many people would not/do not admit anything like that to a friend or family, because of stigma and people like you judging. Step parents I know don't talk about it, but some act very differently and if you read this very board, many step parents seem to admit they do not care about a step child as much as their own, unless they do it to showw off from their high moral horse.

Because they talk about it, it hasn't been an easy ride, i never said it was. Some people do confide in people so please don't pretend to know anything about me or them. I just said it was sad for the child. I was only commenting on resident step parents there. I know many others who do EOW etc or certainly don't feel that way as they have confided in me, perhaps they feel comfortable to do do as I wouldn't jump to conclusions or judge them, unlike you jumping at me over my post.

Luckily the OP has read my posts properly and commented in response understanding what I was saying.

Marian220 · 13/09/2023 07:19

as they get along so well, it’s nice that your biological child has this special sibling relationship. The step child is ‘step’ to you, but they are your child’s ‘real’ sibling, half or otherwise, who will be in their life forever. They also have the opportunity to spend so much time growing together in the same household which other half siblings may not.
that’s another way of looking at it from outside the impact on you. It doesn’t come across like it’s detrimental to your biological child so maybe when you feel regretful you could try to also see it as a gift in their life?

Seashellies · 13/09/2023 07:18

I think it's perfectly natural to have a different sort of love for your own biological child to be honest! The issue seems to be more around your DH prioritising his work and maybe not giving the support his child needs? Sounds like you're a caring and great step-mum who DSC clearly enjoys spending time around etc, but whilst some of what you feel is natural some would be alleviated if you had more help?

Vijia · 13/09/2023 07:14

Really shocking that without you in the picture your DC would be neglected as he prioritises work over his need to make an adjustment as a committed dad.

When we knew I was pregnant my DH ditched the long commute and trips abroad for a job that would be compatible with being a loving and commited father and our 5 DC have been very blessed as a result.

Sure we had to ditch the materialistic rewards of a high salary and live within our means but the strong family bond and loving and caring "nest" we have created together is well worth having a hands on dad.

Our DC are all older now so we both work full time and I would say an excellent, hands on father makes the job of being a good mother to multiple DC much easier. It also makes the whole bringing up a family fun and rewarding.

Before a man commits to having a DC I think it's important to have the discussion about what adjustments he is prepared to make to that child/ children and of he isn't interested then walk away because all DC need good fathers, many DC are terribly short changed by this through no fault of their own..

CharlieBoo · 13/09/2023 07:08

I know you can’t help how you feel but I feel so sorry for that little boy.

His father has abandoned the parenting to you and he has limited access to his mum.. for whatever reason, so it’s you, him and your baby for the majority of the time. Try and imagine your own child in this scenario.

This is why I never want my children involved in a blended family, it can be so damaging.

FloweryWowery · 13/09/2023 07:08

Your step child isn't being parented by either of his parents. This isn't okay. I appreciate your partner has a big important man job (don't they all) but this means you're the default parent. It seems like the parents are 'winning' in this situation and the needs of you and your step-child are being disregarded.

Justdontforgethelegofrog · 13/09/2023 07:04

This is a hard read as a stepchild.
Unfortunately children pick up on things and we just know, we feel the exhales when we get into the car, we pick up on the excited energy when you drive us home, we hear the hushed arguments about who and who doesn't 'have' to have us on which weekend and why.
It's just not ideal for us either.

Thelonelygiraffe · 13/09/2023 07:02

Time40 · 12/09/2023 22:13

If you're tired out dealing with most of the work of looking after your stepchild, I think that shows your OH isn't doing enough to care for his own child. It's just wonderful how these men get women to look after their children for them.

Edited

This.

I'd talk to your DH about how HE can do a better job of looking after HIS own dc.