Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for regretting being a stepparent...

212 replies

mnuser2021 · 12/09/2023 21:50

Hear me out. I adore my stepchild - he is very mature for his age (can have the best conversations with him), well-mannered, and probably the most caring child I have ever encountered. Seriously.He only remembers a life with me in it and practically sees me as his mum. I do everything daily-life related; ofc OH helps when he can but stepchild generally prefers to do daily "boring" stuff with me. He lives with us almost full-time (2 weekends a month spent with biological mum), and I was prepared for this coming into this relationship. This was never a problem for me, I'm happy to help and he's such a good kid. However... Ever since OH and I had our own, the love I have for each of them is very different. Do I care about my stepchild? Absolutely, and very deeply so. I genuinely love watching him grow and feel proud of his accomplishments. However, it doesn't compare to the love I have for my own. And I must admit, I thoroughly enjoy and look forward to the weekends he's not here when I'm just with my "real" family (for the lack of a better word). I now wish my partner didn't have a child as taking care of and managing both of their schedules tires me out and, for this reason, I couldn't imagine having a third, which makes me sad - that I don't want a second "because of" stepchild, i.e. I will only have 1 biological, which I never imagined. It makes me very sad thinking I'll have two children I don't hold the same emotional love for, and I wish I'd be pouring all my efforts into two I truly loved equally (gosh, sounds so cold written out like this... I hope you'll understand where I'm coming from). Luckily, the two of them (siblings) are unbelievably close! It's utterly heartwarming. But even in their most intimate moments, I catch myself wishing I'd be experiencing it with two biological kids.I don't want this to come across heartless - hell, I've been the stepchild myself my whole life, and I LOVE my stepmum! Which makes me even more committed to never treating them differently. But admittedly, I feel very differently about them in my heart even though they're both amazing kids (I guess it's a "you never love anyone like your own" thing), and god... I have many moments I feel I've robbed myself of the family dynamic I now crave (which I never knew I wanted until I had my own) and it genuinely makes me sad and regretful in hindsight.AIBU? Can anyone relate?

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 13/09/2023 17:31

Love as a verb. You are actively loving your SS by being there for him and taking on the mum role. That's all you can do. You don't need to police your inner feelings or try and force yourself to feel something you don't.

I am a stepmother. Sometimes I feel resentful - but I have to say this is mainly because DH's family deifying DSD's dead mum and trying to be best friends with her mother (who DH doesn't like). She actually died of alcoholism and wasn't particularly a 'mum' to her, according to DH. Honestly, sometimes I feel like the second Mrs De Winter. I try really hard to avoid them because this has a negative effect on me and it is absolutely 100% NOT DSD'S FAULT. So yes, I totally understand the whole resenting being the actual mum in the sense of doing all the mum stuff, but apparently someone else is the 'real' mum even if they haven't behaved like one. I firmly believe that family is as family does.

It is not always straightforward, bringing up a child who is not 'your own'. I do feel differently about my biological children (I have three - one with DH). You are doing your best for your stepson. Perhaps look at it as - any extra loving adult in his life is a good thing, even if you cannot love him in exactly the same way. Good luck, you sound lovely.

ChicaneTurn · 13/09/2023 16:55

I cannot believe so many people responded with ‘poor boy’. Yes this kid didn’t ask to have divorced parents. But he got a stepmum who speaks of him with genuine affection and wants to do her best for him. Despite having a baby of her ‘own’ now. He could have had a lot worse.

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/09/2023 16:21

You are such a superstar of a 'step'mum @mnuser2021

If more step-parents were as thoughtful and reflective there would be a lot more love in the world. I have children who have different fathers, there is no half, there is just love. Keep focusing on that and how secure this little boy is despite what how difficult it must be for him to see his other Mum so little.

ChicaneTurn · 13/09/2023 16:21

mnuser2021 · 13/09/2023 15:46

I have to admit, this has been incredibly eye-opening and has made me reflect on my bond with my stepchild, who is 6 (almost 7) years old by the way.

Whilst I may never be able to love SS like my own, I do agree that the love I feel may change over time, particularly when he becomes an adult; the bond we have is incredibly special and all your comments made me realise that. I've shed many tears about his situation with his mum and wanted to protect his pure heart as much as I could. It has been indoctrinated to SS that I am his STEPmum only and that he is never to call me mum, which is, in reality, factual but similarly 1) hurtful as the person who takes care of him every day, and 2) heartbreaking that he is not to make up his mind on who he deems true family himself. It has been very hard for a plethora of reasons and has taken a toll on me, perhaps causing me to harbour this unjust resentment towards SS - i.e., 'ruining' the family dynamic through no fault of his own. On the flip-side, I also have shed many happy tears of his continuous love for me, for example for once screaming my name out loud during an end-of-school-year performance out of sheer happiness to see me, and for giving me massages in the middle of labour contractions. He is a bundle of love and I am sure looking back on all of these memories will be more meaningful once he gets older.

I think there is indeed truth to what some of you pointed out regarding it being my first biological child and thus the overwhelming love a mum can experience in this time, causing (unfair although seemingly natural) comparisons. My biological son is only 9 months old which may be a massively contributing factor to my feelings. I also think considering a third child (second biological) may be crucial for long-term life-satisfaction.

I feel I may be in a baby bubble clouding my thoughts, and whilst the love I feel for both may or may never 'even out', I feel confident it will be a very special bond nonetheless. And the reminder of him being biologically related to my biological son is such a powerful reminder. In fact, one of our family members told us that his brother will never actually be his real brother, and we were absolutely fuming with her for saying such a thing. In SS's mind, that is his baby brother (no prefixes attached) and so that is the reality we live by.

I feel a lot more aware of my feelings now - their origins, for example - and will be able to rationalise them a lot more in the future. It is hard and I feel incredibly guilty, but I know I am where I am supposed to be, I am hopeful everything will work out, and I am fortunate he loves me so much.

I want to thank everyone for commenting, whether with opinions (even if not in favour of me), personal anecdotes, advice etc.

OP you sound lovely. Your stepson is a lucky boy.

mnuser2021 · 13/09/2023 15:46

I have to admit, this has been incredibly eye-opening and has made me reflect on my bond with my stepchild, who is 6 (almost 7) years old by the way.

Whilst I may never be able to love SS like my own, I do agree that the love I feel may change over time, particularly when he becomes an adult; the bond we have is incredibly special and all your comments made me realise that. I've shed many tears about his situation with his mum and wanted to protect his pure heart as much as I could. It has been indoctrinated to SS that I am his STEPmum only and that he is never to call me mum, which is, in reality, factual but similarly 1) hurtful as the person who takes care of him every day, and 2) heartbreaking that he is not to make up his mind on who he deems true family himself. It has been very hard for a plethora of reasons and has taken a toll on me, perhaps causing me to harbour this unjust resentment towards SS - i.e., 'ruining' the family dynamic through no fault of his own. On the flip-side, I also have shed many happy tears of his continuous love for me, for example for once screaming my name out loud during an end-of-school-year performance out of sheer happiness to see me, and for giving me massages in the middle of labour contractions. He is a bundle of love and I am sure looking back on all of these memories will be more meaningful once he gets older.

I think there is indeed truth to what some of you pointed out regarding it being my first biological child and thus the overwhelming love a mum can experience in this time, causing (unfair although seemingly natural) comparisons. My biological son is only 9 months old which may be a massively contributing factor to my feelings. I also think considering a third child (second biological) may be crucial for long-term life-satisfaction.

I feel I may be in a baby bubble clouding my thoughts, and whilst the love I feel for both may or may never 'even out', I feel confident it will be a very special bond nonetheless. And the reminder of him being biologically related to my biological son is such a powerful reminder. In fact, one of our family members told us that his brother will never actually be his real brother, and we were absolutely fuming with her for saying such a thing. In SS's mind, that is his baby brother (no prefixes attached) and so that is the reality we live by.

I feel a lot more aware of my feelings now - their origins, for example - and will be able to rationalise them a lot more in the future. It is hard and I feel incredibly guilty, but I know I am where I am supposed to be, I am hopeful everything will work out, and I am fortunate he loves me so much.

I want to thank everyone for commenting, whether with opinions (even if not in favour of me), personal anecdotes, advice etc.

OP posts:
Onlyforfun · 13/09/2023 14:09

Backagain23 · 13/09/2023 10:33

OP l think you sound like such a lovely mum and step mum. I could not disagree more with all the "poor child" type comments.
You obviously care for your DSC very much, do alot with and for them, and value their relationship with your own child. This is all good!
The only place you are going wrong is expecting too much of yourself. It's not unreasonable not to love a step child as your own. You'd be the only person in the scenario pretending to be equal to the childs own mother. Ridiculous.
You need to focus on what your relationship is , rather than what it is not and can never be.
And your DH needs to get more involved with both his kids.

This! That stepson is not a “poor child”. I feel very bad for him given the very unfortunate circumstances of divorced parents and an absent biological mum, but in this instance, he is very fortunate to have OP in my opinion.

Daffodilwoman · 13/09/2023 12:18

Op, I think what you feel is perfectly natural.
My mum always said to me way before I had my dcs, nobody will ever love your dcs as much as you do. That is true.
People can bleat on about how it’s not true, but actions speak louder than words and in the vast majority of cases it is true.
People need to stop and think much harder about who they have a child with. They also need to think very hard about taking on someone else’s child. Then stop and really, really think about bringing another child of their own into the mix.
I can’t speak from experience (luckily) but I cannot tell you how many people I have come across over the years with truly horrendous takes about what life was like for them having to be kart if a blended family. Yes there will be those who speak of roses and fairytales but the vast majority have had it bad ( from what people have told me).

TooOldForASugarDaddy · 13/09/2023 12:08

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 13/09/2023 09:12

There are lots of perfectly adequate men who for whatever reason are childless past 30! Are you seriously saying there are no good childless men past 30, so your only choice is to shack up with one who has kids, and then procreate with him yourself?

What utter bollocks.

The utter bollocks is to asume that every person with children is a bad match to any person with none.

Backagain23 · 13/09/2023 10:33

OP l think you sound like such a lovely mum and step mum. I could not disagree more with all the "poor child" type comments.
You obviously care for your DSC very much, do alot with and for them, and value their relationship with your own child. This is all good!
The only place you are going wrong is expecting too much of yourself. It's not unreasonable not to love a step child as your own. You'd be the only person in the scenario pretending to be equal to the childs own mother. Ridiculous.
You need to focus on what your relationship is , rather than what it is not and can never be.
And your DH needs to get more involved with both his kids.

HereToRelate · 13/09/2023 10:13

WeirdBarbie · 13/09/2023 09:46

OP - I think it’s genuinely okay to love your child more than your step child. I love my stepchildren like I love my friends, not “as much” as I love my nieces and nephews, so there’s biology here and that’s just the way it is.

I think you need to cut yourself some slack. You aren’t failing by loving your child differently. There’s a weird myth that step parents need to love step kids as their own, but they aren’t their own! It’s such a bizarre expectation.

You sound like a lovely stepmum and venting about the nuances of this weird role doesn’t make you less lovely.

But you do need to separate allocating blame on that child for your decision to have more kids. That’s misplaced. The logistical set up of your life making a third child challenging isn’t your stepson’s fault.

I agree with this very much

WeirdBarbie · 13/09/2023 09:46

OP - I think it’s genuinely okay to love your child more than your step child. I love my stepchildren like I love my friends, not “as much” as I love my nieces and nephews, so there’s biology here and that’s just the way it is.

I think you need to cut yourself some slack. You aren’t failing by loving your child differently. There’s a weird myth that step parents need to love step kids as their own, but they aren’t their own! It’s such a bizarre expectation.

You sound like a lovely stepmum and venting about the nuances of this weird role doesn’t make you less lovely.

But you do need to separate allocating blame on that child for your decision to have more kids. That’s misplaced. The logistical set up of your life making a third child challenging isn’t your stepson’s fault.

WeirdBarbie · 13/09/2023 09:40

Adreno · 12/09/2023 22:11

Step-parenting is the worst of both worlds.

This is absolutely not my experience.

Sebock · 13/09/2023 09:37

I'd take a guess at that your biological child is still very young. When my 1st was born my previously strong feelings for my stepkids evaporated. The baby took so much of my time. Those feelings did come back. Honestly I think hormones have a lot to answer for here. I wouldn't discount a third either. You don't know how the demands on you will change as the current two get older.

fearfuloffluff · 13/09/2023 09:15

You don't say how old the children are.

I have two thoughts, slightly dependent on their ages:

  1. You don't know how it would be to have an older child then a younger one come along - what you describe is a tiny bit similar to having a second baby and working out who takes priority, how to show love to a big stroppy toddler when there's a tiny baby you want milky cuddles with and you're secretly glad when the toddler goes to nursery and it's quiet and just the two of you
  2. Your step child will always be a step child, you don't have to force the relationship to resemble a biological relationship, it's ok for it to be different so long as you keep working at it and not excluding SS. You don't need to feel guilt about biology mattering, but you do have to give SS the best start you can
  3. Your OH should be stepping up and thinking about all this stuff as well - doing what you can as soon as you can is still dependency on you to do the parenting legwork, it's optional for him but not for you
herewegoroundthebastardbush · 13/09/2023 09:12

TooOldForASugarDaddy · 13/09/2023 08:41

What a constructive comment.. what do you suggest? Drowning the step kid? Leaving the dad of her child?, find a single 30 to 40 year old man who despite his age has never been able to have a long term committed relationship?

The absolutely perfect Prince Charmings marry early and stay married to their first true love until they die. You cannot get them at the supermarket or download them from the web. Obviously, you can choose to stay single but staying single forever is a very personal choice and one that many find rather lonely.

There are lots of perfectly adequate men who for whatever reason are childless past 30! Are you seriously saying there are no good childless men past 30, so your only choice is to shack up with one who has kids, and then procreate with him yourself?

What utter bollocks.

ASCCM · 13/09/2023 09:11

I absolutely relate. I never wanted to be with someone that had kids because of all the extra drama etc. ( and there is loads, their mother is an absolutely bloody cow)

it’s really hard work and I also much prefer just my kids here. But it is what it is isn’t it. The kids don’t care either so we are at least mutual in our relationship with each other ( they are older than in OP situation and spend the majority of their time with their mum)

my OH is also a much nicer person to me and my kids when his aren’t here so that doesn’t help me enjoy the time when they are! ( it’s the pressure to be everything I think and him really wanting them to be included , they don’t care or make any effort though so that disappointment is hard to manage)

so I feel you OP and don’t let anyone make you feel bad, families are complex things.

LaGiaconda · 13/09/2023 09:09

I think there can be a sort of grief for the child you didn't have. I've got two stepchildren and one child that I had with my partner. All are now grownup. I have a good relationship with my adult stepchildren, who I have known since they were 5 and 7. Being a mother of 2 as well as doing a lot of stepmothering for another 2 seemed too much. I was an older mother. There wasn't a lot of money around. And my stepchildren were brilliant with my child.

I think we just have to learn to live with those 'What ifs'. All of us have them one way or another.

Britneyfan · 13/09/2023 09:04

I think a lot of hormones kick in especially when our children are small, plus many people would feel more protective instinctively over a baby or toddler compared to an older child. So it maybe doesn’t totally shock me to hear you don’t feel the same sort of overwhelming love for your stepchild and I don’t think this makes you a bad person. The important thing is your actions and how you treat him although it’s also important not to wish him away. I think people who commented pointing out the close biological ties your own child has with your stepchild are ok the right tracks as to how you should try to think of it.

Worth remembering that although you have this worry that you’ve robbed yourself of the family dynamics you wish you had, you would never have had them with your current partner and therefore your own child would never have been born. There is no guarantee you’d have found someone else, been able to conceive twice, had children without special needs etc. and been able to recreate this perfect dynamic anyway. We all have our crosses to bear in life. Your feelings may change as times goes on. Just keep an open heart and mind.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 13/09/2023 08:53

flapjackfairy · 13/09/2023 07:00

I haven't had time to read all replies but if your child is still v little then I think the maternal love is at its most intense and overwhelming then. You might find that as they grow up a bit your feelings will level out

It is a bit like the falling in love with your partner stage which is so overwhelming but then settles into.strong but more settled feelings. So time may resolve this issue .
Secondly it is absolutely possible to love non biological children like children you gave birth to yourself just as much. How do you think.adoptors feel about their kids ? I have a mix of birth , adopted and foster children and honestly I love them all with the same passion so my advice is give it time .

To be fair this is also true, the overwhelming feelings with the first born baby - even with your biological second- born it won't be "the same", I thought it would and had a second baby largely expecting it to be a reprise of that overwhelming passion but with me more competent - instead it was completely different, not less but different entirely. So you may be comparing apples with oranges, and then your second bio child would be bananas 😆 if you see what I mean.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 13/09/2023 08:52

I suggest not forcing children into "blended" families TooOldForASugarDaddy. But you do you and put yourself first instead.

Namechangeforreasons · 13/09/2023 08:44

@ChicaneTurn Thank you 💙

TooOldForASugarDaddy · 13/09/2023 08:41

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 13/09/2023 08:14

So-called 'blended' families are the absolute pits.

What a constructive comment.. what do you suggest? Drowning the step kid? Leaving the dad of her child?, find a single 30 to 40 year old man who despite his age has never been able to have a long term committed relationship?

The absolutely perfect Prince Charmings marry early and stay married to their first true love until they die. You cannot get them at the supermarket or download them from the web. Obviously, you can choose to stay single but staying single forever is a very personal choice and one that many find rather lonely.

OrlandointheWilderness · 13/09/2023 08:34

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 13/09/2023 08:14

So-called 'blended' families are the absolute pits.

In your opinion. My blended family has given every one of us more people to love, and who love us. It has been something so positive for everyone and I wouldn't change it for the world.

Peachee · 13/09/2023 08:32

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable however I think you’re massively overthinking it all. I personally feel like my cup is tipping over with two often thinking that having a third would cause me to crash and burn - gosh I already do on the daily tbh it’s hard work - but there is a saying you don’t become a parent until you have 2+ and whilst I don’t want to sound like people who have 1 aren’t - I honestly really struggle with two in comparison. What I’m trying to say is that if you want another then I would honestly go for it. A bit like myself I will never say never - for a start we don’t have the space and I certainly don’t feel like I have the mental capacity - that being said I feel like if it happened I would like to think in those super hard moments love prevails. Life with kids (especially multiples) can and will be hard work and have huge ups and downs.
I think it would be harder to deal with the resentment you hold for your stepson for the life choice you made based on him being around.
On a side note I’ve done a lot of research on love and it’s more so the actions you take for someone you care about rather than a feeling.
Hth and sorry if I’ve offended anyone.

Blixem · 13/09/2023 08:30

I can tell that you really care for your stepchild. I'm in the same situation and I really thought I loved my DSC before I had my own child but the overwhelming love I feel for my own child is nothing like I feel for anyone else.
I try my hardest to treat them all the same but it is different.