Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for regretting being a stepparent...

212 replies

mnuser2021 · 12/09/2023 21:50

Hear me out. I adore my stepchild - he is very mature for his age (can have the best conversations with him), well-mannered, and probably the most caring child I have ever encountered. Seriously.He only remembers a life with me in it and practically sees me as his mum. I do everything daily-life related; ofc OH helps when he can but stepchild generally prefers to do daily "boring" stuff with me. He lives with us almost full-time (2 weekends a month spent with biological mum), and I was prepared for this coming into this relationship. This was never a problem for me, I'm happy to help and he's such a good kid. However... Ever since OH and I had our own, the love I have for each of them is very different. Do I care about my stepchild? Absolutely, and very deeply so. I genuinely love watching him grow and feel proud of his accomplishments. However, it doesn't compare to the love I have for my own. And I must admit, I thoroughly enjoy and look forward to the weekends he's not here when I'm just with my "real" family (for the lack of a better word). I now wish my partner didn't have a child as taking care of and managing both of their schedules tires me out and, for this reason, I couldn't imagine having a third, which makes me sad - that I don't want a second "because of" stepchild, i.e. I will only have 1 biological, which I never imagined. It makes me very sad thinking I'll have two children I don't hold the same emotional love for, and I wish I'd be pouring all my efforts into two I truly loved equally (gosh, sounds so cold written out like this... I hope you'll understand where I'm coming from). Luckily, the two of them (siblings) are unbelievably close! It's utterly heartwarming. But even in their most intimate moments, I catch myself wishing I'd be experiencing it with two biological kids.I don't want this to come across heartless - hell, I've been the stepchild myself my whole life, and I LOVE my stepmum! Which makes me even more committed to never treating them differently. But admittedly, I feel very differently about them in my heart even though they're both amazing kids (I guess it's a "you never love anyone like your own" thing), and god... I have many moments I feel I've robbed myself of the family dynamic I now crave (which I never knew I wanted until I had my own) and it genuinely makes me sad and regretful in hindsight.AIBU? Can anyone relate?

OP posts:
Namechangeforreasons · 17/09/2023 19:27

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 19:18

I suppose the difference is that my non-bio children didn’t have another mum or dad. It was just my DH and I
i think you're absolutely right on this.

I do wonder if it’s because of the non-bio kids having a mum and dad that puts up this barrier. In my original post on this thread, I made mention of the fact that it might be that there’s always a chance that the child could be kept from you, for some reason, so it’s easier to not love the child, then to be hurt further down the line.

But then, I was brought up at a time when everyone very much still believed in it takes a village, and I think that’s carried forward in me to this day, as I strongly believe that the more people that a child has who loves them, the more secure that child is growing up. If that makes sense 🙂

NeedToChangeName · 17/09/2023 19:22

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 12/09/2023 22:13

This is why blended families are so often so shit, and why is do almost anything to prevent my kids ending up in one.

You're not wrong to feel how you feel, but you're delusional if you think that poor child won't know, and won't be badly affected. He's already got to deal with hardly seeing his mum, hardly seeing his dad either by the sound of it, and now the person who so far has cared for him most and most consistently has emotionally ditched him for a younger model. One who doesn't have to leave the family every two weeks, who's always wanted. It fucking sucks for him and I'm afraid I have no sympathy for you, an adult who made her choices - that poor little boy has made no choices and has drawn the shitty end of the stick with a mum who hardly sees him and a stepmum so wishes he didn't exist. Honestly breaks my heart.

@herewegoroundthebastardbush agree with this

Current situation doesn't sound good for this child. And presumably not what he chose

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 19:18

I suppose the difference is that my non-bio children didn’t have another mum or dad. It was just my DH and I
i think you're absolutely right on this.

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 19:17

CoParents · 17/09/2023 17:06

I think that’s a bit narrow minded tbh. One of my aunts is technically I suppose a “step”, or at least she was originally. She came into my mum’s family when she was 7, her dad married my grandmother. When they divorced my aunt chose to stay living with my granny. Since then she is 100% one of the family. My granny has 5 children (4 biological and 1 not) her will divides her assets between all five children equally .
My aunt is my mother’s sister, and she is my aunt. Her children are my cousins.
Who knows how my granny secretly feels deep down in her heart about who she loves the most, I would never ask such a thing of course. but I would be absolutely disgusted if my mother said she expected her mother to love my aunt less (and said she would feel less “special” or devalued otherwise), or suggested my aunt was less “equal” than her and her other siblings. I know my mum doesn’t feel that way, she’s closer to my aunt than any of her other (biological) siblings tbh and she loves her to bits. She’d never for a second , for example, question the equal inclusion of my aunt in her mother’s will.

Edited

It's absolutely meant to sound narrow minded.
Of the 8billion people in the world, only two of them are above and beyond all the others, no comparison, no compromise, no apologies. Of all the untold billions up in heaven, only one is mine. My boys are my sun, moon and stars and any pretence otherwise would be cruel to all involved.
To be honest I'm disgusted by disgust at the suggestion that a mother/child relationship is sacred.

Namechangeforreasons · 17/09/2023 18:03

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 11:58

People are obviously very different as it's a complicated business.
Personally I feel sad for children whose parents don't think they are that extra bit special.
After I "pushed out" my dead son, if I'd been handed a button to press to make DSD or indeed any of the other children in the world swap places with him, I would have done so without blinking.
My ultimate loyalty as a mother is to my children and they deserve nothing less.
It doesn't mean I don't care for DSD, it's just that she's got a mother to love her as deeply as I love mine and I don't feel like ive been "gifted" another woman's child. She's not mine, she's her own mothers.

I’m so sorry that you lost your baby. It’s very hard, I know. in my previous post on this thread, I said similar. I would do anything to get my children back. But I wouldn’t swap any of my other children for them. As a mother, they are all mine!

I suppose the difference is that my non-bio children didn’t have another mum or dad. It was just my DH and I.

CoParents · 17/09/2023 17:06

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 14:12

My brother is my equal. We are both the children of our parents. My mum and dad are still together, but if they split and then said they loved the child of their new GF/BF as much as me and my brother is think they were either lying about how much they love this new child (dangerous game to play) or had been lying about how much they loved me if they could just replicate it for someone elses child.
There are different types of love. OP loves her DSC as a DSC and not as a DC. Nothing to see here, really.

I think that’s a bit narrow minded tbh. One of my aunts is technically I suppose a “step”, or at least she was originally. She came into my mum’s family when she was 7, her dad married my grandmother. When they divorced my aunt chose to stay living with my granny. Since then she is 100% one of the family. My granny has 5 children (4 biological and 1 not) her will divides her assets between all five children equally .
My aunt is my mother’s sister, and she is my aunt. Her children are my cousins.
Who knows how my granny secretly feels deep down in her heart about who she loves the most, I would never ask such a thing of course. but I would be absolutely disgusted if my mother said she expected her mother to love my aunt less (and said she would feel less “special” or devalued otherwise), or suggested my aunt was less “equal” than her and her other siblings. I know my mum doesn’t feel that way, she’s closer to my aunt than any of her other (biological) siblings tbh and she loves her to bits. She’d never for a second , for example, question the equal inclusion of my aunt in her mother’s will.

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 14:12

My brother is my equal. We are both the children of our parents. My mum and dad are still together, but if they split and then said they loved the child of their new GF/BF as much as me and my brother is think they were either lying about how much they love this new child (dangerous game to play) or had been lying about how much they loved me if they could just replicate it for someone elses child.
There are different types of love. OP loves her DSC as a DSC and not as a DC. Nothing to see here, really.

Tandora · 17/09/2023 13:33

I don’t feel that sharing my parents’ love with any of my (biological siblings) somehow makes me any less “special” or loved by them , than say an only child? So why would it be any different if you had to share that love with your step siblings? Love is not a zero sum game.

Backagain23 · 17/09/2023 11:58

Namechangeforreasons · 17/09/2023 11:39

Some of these replies make me so sad 😞.

I think it’s because I struggle to imagine that grown, emotionally intelligent adults feel this way, with regards to “pushed out” (what does that even mean? What if the mother had to use a surrogate? Some crazy ideas on here 🤦🏽‍♀️) children vs stepchildren.

As I said in a post earlier on this thread, I have 2 non-bio children and they are just me and my DH’s kids, just as our other bio children are our kids.

I love them all so much, I’m a very “present” parent even though I live in a different country to 3 of them and they know I’m always here for them. And I think that is the most important thing. Being there for your children, loving them and supporting them!

When DC#6 was little they asked me who I loved more, them or DH, and I had to laugh a little and then explained that there’s different types of love, and even when it comes to children, there’s different types of love. Yes, it’s a maternal love but the love you may have for a son, might be different to the love that you have for a daughter. But I have never loved non-bio children less than I loved my bio children and neither has DH.

Perhaps it's because by the time DC#6 asked me that question, we had lost a son, aged 16, and my heart was broken. I was broken. My DH picked me up and carried me for years. Losing another son 5 years later was the end of my world. I struggled to function in any meaningful way. Yes, I cleaned and cooked and did what I was supposed to do, but it was all by rote.

A poster on here told me that she remembered the news stories from when my 16 year old died. I thought perhaps I was the only one who remembered him. And my other son. DH doesn’t talk about it, and my youngest two DC’s have very little memory of either brother, as they were literally babies.

Anyway, love the children that you’ve been gifted with, whether you “pushed” them out or someone else did. Because time goes quickly, life can be fickle 💕

People are obviously very different as it's a complicated business.
Personally I feel sad for children whose parents don't think they are that extra bit special.
After I "pushed out" my dead son, if I'd been handed a button to press to make DSD or indeed any of the other children in the world swap places with him, I would have done so without blinking.
My ultimate loyalty as a mother is to my children and they deserve nothing less.
It doesn't mean I don't care for DSD, it's just that she's got a mother to love her as deeply as I love mine and I don't feel like ive been "gifted" another woman's child. She's not mine, she's her own mothers.

Namechangeforreasons · 17/09/2023 11:39

Some of these replies make me so sad 😞.

I think it’s because I struggle to imagine that grown, emotionally intelligent adults feel this way, with regards to “pushed out” (what does that even mean? What if the mother had to use a surrogate? Some crazy ideas on here 🤦🏽‍♀️) children vs stepchildren.

As I said in a post earlier on this thread, I have 2 non-bio children and they are just me and my DH’s kids, just as our other bio children are our kids.

I love them all so much, I’m a very “present” parent even though I live in a different country to 3 of them and they know I’m always here for them. And I think that is the most important thing. Being there for your children, loving them and supporting them!

When DC#6 was little they asked me who I loved more, them or DH, and I had to laugh a little and then explained that there’s different types of love, and even when it comes to children, there’s different types of love. Yes, it’s a maternal love but the love you may have for a son, might be different to the love that you have for a daughter. But I have never loved non-bio children less than I loved my bio children and neither has DH.

Perhaps it's because by the time DC#6 asked me that question, we had lost a son, aged 16, and my heart was broken. I was broken. My DH picked me up and carried me for years. Losing another son 5 years later was the end of my world. I struggled to function in any meaningful way. Yes, I cleaned and cooked and did what I was supposed to do, but it was all by rote.

A poster on here told me that she remembered the news stories from when my 16 year old died. I thought perhaps I was the only one who remembered him. And my other son. DH doesn’t talk about it, and my youngest two DC’s have very little memory of either brother, as they were literally babies.

Anyway, love the children that you’ve been gifted with, whether you “pushed” them out or someone else did. Because time goes quickly, life can be fickle 💕

lollydu · 17/09/2023 09:44

This is really sad. I'm on the opposite side of the situation, I have two biological children, living with my OH who is only bio dad to the youngest. I would be devastated to know he felt that way about my eldest. In fact, often I have asked him if he wants one more as I'm conscious he might feel he wants one more biological child, he always says I have two kids and feel fulfilled with that so no. I hope he's not just saying that and genuinely feels the way you do. It's really sad especially as you have a good relationship with your SS.

Timmytap18 · 17/09/2023 09:27

You can't help how you feel. I do think as step parents though we over analyse our feelings about things. So you look forward to the weekends without DSC and you think it's because they're your step child. Maybe it's because they're a difficult age and the break is nice?

I have a DSD and DD. Sometimes I look forward to a night when DD is with my Mum and we have a film and pizza.night with DSD. That's because she's a teenager now and we can have a little girlie chat and watch a film in peace without a toddler running round. That doesn't mean i don't love my own child.

The love you have for your own child will be different but so what? We love lots of people in different ways. I think try to change your mindset and enjoy the family you have.

There's another thread up today about having fantasies about being child free and that's about biological children.

Being a parent is hard either way so just try not to overthink it.

SlippySarah · 17/09/2023 09:12

My children have a step mother and two half siblings and although there are challenges I wouldn't change it, they have a great life. The children don't always suffer from such an arrangement if the adults continue to make the best decisions possible.

SGANDRUE · 17/09/2023 09:04

You can't help the way you feel, that's just a fact. But please don't fantasise about biological siblings and the perfect relationship they would have. My own sister hated me from birth and 50 years later we don't have anything to do with each other. Your kids get on well, please don't take that for granted, it's a blessing. Your stepchild sounds lovely. You're lucky to have them.

flowerr · 17/09/2023 07:44

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

GotMooMilk · 17/09/2023 07:34

OP you can’t help your feeling and as someone who’s never had SC I can imagine it can be difficult at times. Agree that it sounds like dad needs to step up. Also I think if you want and can afford another child don’t let it put you off!

Tandora · 15/09/2023 12:12

Onlyforfun · 15/09/2023 12:02

You are showing strong bias by allowing one side (which you agree with) to express themselves in a rude manner and the other barely gets acknowledgements for expressing their personal opinions, even when that person clarified it is simply what they believe, NOT universalising it. Don’t think name-calling belongs in this thread at all. There’s being fierce and there’s being straight judgemental and rude.

What I challenged was one side universalising their experience and saying everyone feels this way because it is natural. It’s perfectly fine to say this is how I feel. It’s ignorant, arrogant and judgemental to say this is how everyone feels. I’m not calling anyone names, I’m calling words, behaviours, attitudes exactly what they are.

Backagain23 · 15/09/2023 12:05

Can we maybe recognise that birth, adopted, foster and step children are all different?
I accept my DSD, but I didn't want her enough to go through the adoption process, my caring for her isn't rescuing her from traumatic circumstances, I have no real authority over her life and I'm not expected to do any real parenting. Totally different relationship so it seems strange to compare them.

Onlyforfun · 15/09/2023 12:05

@Tandora Can think of a million better and more productive ways to challenge something like this than calling someone ignorant, arrogant and narrow-minded all at once

Onlyforfun · 15/09/2023 12:02

Tandora · 15/09/2023 11:55

I don’t think there was anything wrong with what you said tbh. You were fiercely challenging a really dominant but harmful (and false) narrative that needs to be challenged. ❤️

You are showing strong bias by allowing one side (which you agree with) to express themselves in a rude manner and the other barely gets acknowledgements for expressing their personal opinions, even when that person clarified it is simply what they believe, NOT universalising it. Don’t think name-calling belongs in this thread at all. There’s being fierce and there’s being straight judgemental and rude.

Tandora · 15/09/2023 11:55

flapjackfairy · 15/09/2023 10:58

@HereToRelate
Well others have come on to say they have been dismayed as a stepchild to read this thread so that point stands ( though I am glad you are not one of them ). And yes I can see how I sounded judgemental though I was stating the fact that some people are capable of loving non biological children and as this thread has shown some are not.. I was riled by the adamant sentiment Liok expressed as if it was an accepted fact but I will admit that I am sensitive to slights on non biological children because of some of my personal experiences
However I apologise for my tone nonetheless as you are right there was no need to be rude .

I don’t think there was anything wrong with what you said tbh. You were fiercely challenging a really dominant but harmful (and false) narrative that needs to be challenged. ❤️

Tandora · 15/09/2023 11:51

flapjackfairy · 15/09/2023 07:07

@Liok
I KNOW you are wrong ! I absolutely do.

I have birth , adopted and foster children and I love them all the same . It feels the same and I have the same fierce maternal love for them all.
How offensive this thread is to anyone who is a step child or an adopted child so many hurtful comments.
Just because you havent got it in you to love someone else's biological child like your own doesn't mean nobody else has.

❤️❤️❤️

Tandora · 15/09/2023 11:50

Liok · 14/09/2023 20:05

Oh yeah, we can agree on that 100%. I’ve also never stated you can’t love children that aren’t yours biologically. I’m simply talking from a perspective of a household with biological children and stepchildren, that if you were forced to compare, the love for your own would go that bit deeper. Only natural and not shameful. Love my stepchildren to bits, genuinely. Certainly don’t see myself as ignorant and narrow-minded so that’s that.

Edited

Yes but there are plenty of families with a blend of kids biologically related or not, (or “pushed out the body” or not) and plenty of people describe feeling differently to you, in terms of comparing love.
You don’t have to be ashamed of how you feel and it may feel “natural” to you, but please don’t universalise your experience or tell others what they can or can’t feel, that can be really harmful to promote a narrative that love for biological children is always greater/ more meaningful/
more powerful. And it just isn’t how the world really works in practice for many.

DisappearingGirl · 15/09/2023 11:13

I think as someone else said, you should allow yourself to feel what you feel without beating yourself up. It's hard wired into us to love our biological kids. Personally I think what you do in life is more important than how you feel. You care deeply about your stepson and look after him and spend time with him. You have probably made that boy's life much happier and stable than it would have been without your input. I think you should give yourself a lot of credit for that.

As for not having time/energy for another child of your own, that's trickier. I guess it's the same when you take on any big commitment in life, whether that's a step child or someone/something else. I'm not sure what the answer is.

flapjackfairy · 15/09/2023 10:58

@HereToRelate
Well others have come on to say they have been dismayed as a stepchild to read this thread so that point stands ( though I am glad you are not one of them ). And yes I can see how I sounded judgemental though I was stating the fact that some people are capable of loving non biological children and as this thread has shown some are not.. I was riled by the adamant sentiment Liok expressed as if it was an accepted fact but I will admit that I am sensitive to slights on non biological children because of some of my personal experiences
However I apologise for my tone nonetheless as you are right there was no need to be rude .