Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To search for a small dog that can be left alone during the day?

434 replies

PleasedToBeAFlower · 12/09/2023 21:49

I will accept it if I get flamed by dog lovers for this.
But is there such a thing as a small dog that can be left alone for 5 or 6 hours 3 days a week?
Or is it just completely unacceptable to plan to do this?
My DD aged 9 has a significant educational learning delay. This is affecting her self esteem and self confidence. She is otherwise highly intelligent.
So I need to chanel in to things she loves, so that she can feel good about things she loves and is good at, to compensate for spending all day at school feeling rubbish about herself for not being able to learn.
And boy oh boy does she LOVE dogs. She literally adores them. She cannot pass one without making friends with it. Dogs seem attracted to her. And she's amaaaaazing with them. All breeds, all ages, doesn't matter, she adores them and they do seem to adore her.
She has begged for a dog for 6 years so far. I've always said no.
But I actually think it would be incredible for her to have one.
I have no doubt she would be 100% committed to it, and it would be a lucky dog as she would love it and care for it so much.
BUT it would be alone in the house 3 days a week for about 6 hours a day.
No way round this.
Kids at school.
DH and I go to work, and we dont have jobs that we can take dogs to.
Is this ever, ever, ever do-able???
Or is there never a way to have a dog if it's left on its own?
I realise it has to be fair on the dog, not just what we want.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Snoken · 13/09/2023 14:16

OP you said that you would take it out in the morning, then it would be with the family for 2 hours at home before you leave it for 6 hours. That makes it 8 hours without a toilet break. Or did I misunderstand your previous post?

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 14:16

Anna8089 · 13/09/2023 12:01

Would you have left your child alone, no. I don't understand why people get a dog to leave at home on own. They bark all day causing noise nuisance for others. It should be considered animal abuse. If you can't be there to actually look after it , then no.

Dogs aren't children.

I do lot of things with my dogs that I wouldn't do with children - feed them from bowls on the floor, train them to shit in the garden and take them to the vets 🙄

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 14:13

Snoken · 13/09/2023 13:49

I think with a dog walker and a dog that is already used to being home alone for a few hours I think you will be OK after a couple of weeks of it living with you and you building up its tolerance to being home alone in a new place.

I don't think the plan of walking it, then letting it be with you for 2 hours and then leave it for 6 hours is great. That way it's without access to the outside for 8 hours. You should walk it just before you leave, even if you are leaving it for 2-3 hours.

I recently moved with my two dogs and they were fine being home alone in the old place 4-5 hours, but it has taken me months to work up to them being on their own in the new place for more than an hour or so. It's like they have completely reset to how it was when they were puppies.

I'm terribly confused by your message. How would the dog be left on its own for 8 hours, as you say?
And how do you reach the conclusion that I would walk it 2 hours before I go to work? Where have I said that?

OP posts:
andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 14:11

RunningFromInsanity · 13/09/2023 13:55

Dogs are left for a hell of a lot longer than 6 hours in a rescue centre. 20hours+ a day in a kennel surrounded by constant barking of other dogs.

Exactly.

Or does everyone think rescue dogs have constant company, enrichment and exercise?

A dog will be much happier in a loving home with a wonderful family with two short days alone than stuck in kennels.

Janiie · 13/09/2023 14:10

6 hours twice a week with walks before and after? Of course that is fine, I would suggest it is probably what the majority of dog owners do. Ours isn't left as she doesn't need to be but I'd have no qualms about doing so if anything changes.

When I walk ours the local dog walkers have a different group every time so clearly many rely on dog walkers. You may not need to, many dogs will happily be left for 6hrs a couple of times a week as long they have plenty of exercise amd attention the rest of the time.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 14:10

My family owned dogs my entire life and we would never leave a dog in the house alone regularly for 6 hours a time. Each to their own but I don’t see this fair.

How much company do you think dogs get in kennels?

People are arguing that six hours, twice a week without company is cruel - do you really think dogs in shelters get that?

WhatWouldHopperDo · 13/09/2023 14:04

TheFlis · 12/09/2023 22:31

Our dachshund is happy to be left that long, as long as he’s been well fed and walked he just takes himself off to bed the whole time (we watch on a camera). We only do it once a week or so though and it took until he was about 18 months to get to that point though, until he was nearly a year he would bark after 10 minutes!

It would not be remotely realistic to do this with a puppy and you never know how a dog will turn out. Some have terrible separation anxiety for no apparent reason, that no amount of training fixes.

I agree that the issue is you don't know how a dog is going to be naturally. We also have a Dachshund and we can't leave him alone at home ever. He howls after 5 minutes. We have done everything recommended such as leaving him for short, increasing periods but nothing works.

Luckily I wfh most of the time which is part of how we factored in managing a dog. He goes to doggy day care if I need to go into the office. We are not massively sociable but he can go to kennels if absolutely necessary.

It has massively impacted us and although we knew this, a bit like having a baby, you never really fully appreciate it until you have one.

MatildaTheCat · 13/09/2023 14:00

An older dog can be left for several hours occasionally and if it’s regularly 2 days a week they will get used to it, especially if you leave entertainment for them.

Also consider asking around locally for anyone who might be willing to help out a bit. We lost our beautiful boy last year and have decided not to replace him yet. However I saw a local lady was looking for help with her dog as she was in a tight spot and I now have her once or twice a week for the day ( a walk or home visit might be enough for you). It helps her out and ticks my craving for doggy company. Just be very careful about an arrangement like this before committing.

RunningFromInsanity · 13/09/2023 13:55

Dogs are left for a hell of a lot longer than 6 hours in a rescue centre. 20hours+ a day in a kennel surrounded by constant barking of other dogs.

RunningFromInsanity · 13/09/2023 13:54

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:15

Thank you to everyone who has provided polite and well balanced answers to my post.
It has been really interesting to read all of your responses.
I am taking on board all of the sound advice given, including the points made against getting a dog as well as the supportive posts.
It's an enormous, life changing decision, so I want to ensure I get it right.
For the record, I think some posters missed my update saying it's 2 days a week at a maximum of 6 hours each day, not 3 days a week, although I accept this makes no relevance to some posters.
On these 2 days, the dog would have a good walk in the morning and 2 hours of family company and interaction, then stay home without a family member for 6 hours (maximum), then after that get taken straight out for a big run around in the fields, played with and interacted with whilst out on the run, we'd be out walking with it for more than an hour, come home, then DH or I would take it for another walk before bed. Rain or shine.
On the other 5 days a week it would be with us.

For a dog without separation anxiety, this will be fine.

maratara · 13/09/2023 13:54

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:41

I'm not saying I won't.
Why are you assuming I won't?

Please ignore the hysterical dog people on here. Nobody would buy a dog if they would meet their standards of never leaving them home for more than 4 hours or whatever arbitrary figure they have come up with. You'd barely make it out for a nice dinner.
As you are even worried, you get a tick on my list.
I would seriously look at getting 2. I mean once you've got one , you've still got to worry about kennels for any holidays etc . They keep each other company and and are happy together generally.
Don't buy 2 from the same litter though!!
As I already said I think a lovely lazy lab and and maybe a smaller dog for company are perfect for your family.
The people that haven't read your update - not that it was really necessary - are crazy if they think everybody that buys a a dog never leaves it alone for more than 12 hours a week.
Fostering from a rescue is also an option .
There are a lot of foster "fails" - i.e. they keep they dog after falling in love.
Still in favour of a cav or a lab in your situation. preferably one of each. Best wishes.

Snoken · 13/09/2023 13:49

I think with a dog walker and a dog that is already used to being home alone for a few hours I think you will be OK after a couple of weeks of it living with you and you building up its tolerance to being home alone in a new place.

I don't think the plan of walking it, then letting it be with you for 2 hours and then leave it for 6 hours is great. That way it's without access to the outside for 8 hours. You should walk it just before you leave, even if you are leaving it for 2-3 hours.

I recently moved with my two dogs and they were fine being home alone in the old place 4-5 hours, but it has taken me months to work up to them being on their own in the new place for more than an hour or so. It's like they have completely reset to how it was when they were puppies.

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:41

tennesseewhiskey1 · 13/09/2023 13:29

Why won’t you get a dog Walker?

I'm not saying I won't.
Why are you assuming I won't?

OP posts:
BMW6 · 13/09/2023 13:33

If you do get a dog

  1. How will you know its OK on its own for those times and not distressed
  1. What will you do if its not OK?
tennesseewhiskey1 · 13/09/2023 13:29

Why won’t you get a dog Walker?

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 13/09/2023 13:26

Universitynewbie · 13/09/2023 07:40

I love how if we don't agree with a dog being left all day on its own we are hysterical. Maybe we just care about another life?
Would you leave your child locked in a room all day every day with no access to a toilet and nothing to do, mo company, no devices, no choice but to lie down and sleep? If your answer is no, why is it OK to do that to a dog? What makes them lesser? I am sure a lot of children would sadly resign themselves to the situation and not look distressed but I am also sure there would be a lot of distress under the surface

A dog is not the same as a child FFS. Why would they have nothing to do? I assume OP will give them toys, food and water - they've already said they'd get a dog flap.

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:25

LlynTegid · 13/09/2023 13:18

Even with your clarification, I do not think you should get a dog. Much as I realise you will be missing out on something that will give you a lot.

So are you saying that no-one should have a dog unless there is someone at home with them all day every day? Or are you saying that dogs can be left, but gor much shorter periods of time?
Are you saying people who go out to work cannot have a dog?
I'm not being facetious here, I promise. I genuinely want to know if this is what you are saying.

OP posts:
PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:18

maratara · 13/09/2023 13:15

So agree. I sometimes wonder if MN over estimates the intelligence of dogs. I love them . I have 3. But my lab/shepherd will greet me with the same amount of ridiculous loving excitable yipping if I've been gone for 5 minutes or 5 hours. It's not like they can tell the time!
Buy a healthy ( non-puppy farmed dog) and you will be fine OP. Train them as well as you can ( maybe with a trainer if you are worried ) and treat them with lots of love and affection. The 18 hours a week you are away will make no difference. A dog walker is a good idea but not really necessary. Walking dogs for ages in the UK seems to be a big thing. A wander around the block is fine in the rest of the world.
Most dogs sleep at least 12 hours a day.
I wouldn't get a puppy in your situation - aim for a 2 year old. Cavvies are a bit needy , but you could get 2 and they'd be fine. Havanese , whippets, Basenjis, Greyhounds ( not small but quiet and lazy) ; a good old mutt from a rescue. All good options. And don't discount a labrador. The easiest , friendliest, most chilled out dog in the world IME. Just DO NOT GET A LABRADOR PUPPY if you don't want most of the things you own ( including your walls to be destroyed). I think a 2-3 yo lab would be perfect for you but feel free to ignore me.

Good luck.

Thank you - it's 12 hours a week. 2 days a week, 6 hours maximum each day.
It's my fault for the confusion I'm afraid - I accidentally typed 3 instead of 2 in my OP (I'm always hitting the button next to the one I'm meant to hit when I'm typing on my mobile!)

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 13/09/2023 13:18

Even with your clarification, I do not think you should get a dog. Much as I realise you will be missing out on something that will give you a lot.

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:15

Thank you to everyone who has provided polite and well balanced answers to my post.
It has been really interesting to read all of your responses.
I am taking on board all of the sound advice given, including the points made against getting a dog as well as the supportive posts.
It's an enormous, life changing decision, so I want to ensure I get it right.
For the record, I think some posters missed my update saying it's 2 days a week at a maximum of 6 hours each day, not 3 days a week, although I accept this makes no relevance to some posters.
On these 2 days, the dog would have a good walk in the morning and 2 hours of family company and interaction, then stay home without a family member for 6 hours (maximum), then after that get taken straight out for a big run around in the fields, played with and interacted with whilst out on the run, we'd be out walking with it for more than an hour, come home, then DH or I would take it for another walk before bed. Rain or shine.
On the other 5 days a week it would be with us.

OP posts:
maratara · 13/09/2023 13:15

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 11:41

Of course you can - people up and down the country leave their dogs alone while they go to work.

MN is incredibly weird when it comes to dogs - people either hate them and are terrified of them if they bark, or think that anyone who wants a dog needs to spend thousands of pounds a year on daycare.

Meanwhile, back in reality, people go to work, kids go to school, people go on days out and the dogs are quite happy.

So agree. I sometimes wonder if MN over estimates the intelligence of dogs. I love them . I have 3. But my lab/shepherd will greet me with the same amount of ridiculous loving excitable yipping if I've been gone for 5 minutes or 5 hours. It's not like they can tell the time!
Buy a healthy ( non-puppy farmed dog) and you will be fine OP. Train them as well as you can ( maybe with a trainer if you are worried ) and treat them with lots of love and affection. The 18 hours a week you are away will make no difference. A dog walker is a good idea but not really necessary. Walking dogs for ages in the UK seems to be a big thing. A wander around the block is fine in the rest of the world.
Most dogs sleep at least 12 hours a day.
I wouldn't get a puppy in your situation - aim for a 2 year old. Cavvies are a bit needy , but you could get 2 and they'd be fine. Havanese , whippets, Basenjis, Greyhounds ( not small but quiet and lazy) ; a good old mutt from a rescue. All good options. And don't discount a labrador. The easiest , friendliest, most chilled out dog in the world IME. Just DO NOT GET A LABRADOR PUPPY if you don't want most of the things you own ( including your walls to be destroyed). I think a 2-3 yo lab would be perfect for you but feel free to ignore me.

Good luck.

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I have reported you.

OP posts:
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 13/09/2023 13:00

This little guy ! No vet bills, no problem at home alone, no dog poo, no walkies, no ripping faces off, just wants to play

To search for a small dog that can be left alone during the day?
PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 12:57

Flipflopflipperdiflop · 13/09/2023 10:15

Cocker spaniel here, not the first year or so, but after that she'd happy to stay home while I work. No problem at all. We did also adopt a cat for company, after a couple of years. Lovely, cute, very nice.
Don't worry to much about the dog being home alone for 6 hours, 3 days a week.
Go for a walk in the morning, and she'll be fine when you come home.
I would advise not to expect too much from your daughter in the dog department. Yes she will play and cuddle etcetera, but you will be the one doing the walks, the baths, the vet visit, making sure there is clean water before you leave, that the dog is fed. It's because your daughter is 9 years old and she might look like she's specially skilled now, but lower your expectations and accept that you will be the one responsible.
Other than that yes go for it, the love a child receives from a pet can't be compaired.
Please Don't "try and see how it works out" though. If you get a dog, it will be with you lifelong. But I think you know this.
Find a certified breeder and put your questions on them. Spare no money there. A healthy dog will be costly.

Of course I know it's me and DH that would be fully responsible and accountable for looking after a dog.
Do you honestly think I'm expecting a 9 year old to take on the responsibility of independently meeting the care and welfare needs of a dog?

OP posts:
maratara · 13/09/2023 12:55

erikbloodaxe · 13/09/2023 08:16

Meanwhile back in the real world.........

Yes you can leave a dog for that period as long as it's environment is suitable.

Access to outside space for toileting via dog flap.
Enrichment activities
Safe space to sleep.

Having two would be better for the dog. Yes you can have a dog for your daughter. Support dogs/guide dogs are there purely to meet a need.

I'm saying this as someone whose dogs were never left but that's because I had a kennels, 12 dogs of my own, I was a breeder (yes KC accredited) and dog groomer. Dogs were my business and my life.
Canine welfare has come on leaps and bounds and in recent years has started going too far. Dogs are no longer being respectfully treated as the intelligent, beautiful creatures they are. They are not human and anthropomorphism is damaging them in so many ways.
Humans benefit by all the dog related services (non of them are free are they), someone is making money from every service offered..

Thank you for that!