Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To search for a small dog that can be left alone during the day?

434 replies

PleasedToBeAFlower · 12/09/2023 21:49

I will accept it if I get flamed by dog lovers for this.
But is there such a thing as a small dog that can be left alone for 5 or 6 hours 3 days a week?
Or is it just completely unacceptable to plan to do this?
My DD aged 9 has a significant educational learning delay. This is affecting her self esteem and self confidence. She is otherwise highly intelligent.
So I need to chanel in to things she loves, so that she can feel good about things she loves and is good at, to compensate for spending all day at school feeling rubbish about herself for not being able to learn.
And boy oh boy does she LOVE dogs. She literally adores them. She cannot pass one without making friends with it. Dogs seem attracted to her. And she's amaaaaazing with them. All breeds, all ages, doesn't matter, she adores them and they do seem to adore her.
She has begged for a dog for 6 years so far. I've always said no.
But I actually think it would be incredible for her to have one.
I have no doubt she would be 100% committed to it, and it would be a lucky dog as she would love it and care for it so much.
BUT it would be alone in the house 3 days a week for about 6 hours a day.
No way round this.
Kids at school.
DH and I go to work, and we dont have jobs that we can take dogs to.
Is this ever, ever, ever do-able???
Or is there never a way to have a dog if it's left on its own?
I realise it has to be fair on the dog, not just what we want.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Broodywuz · 13/09/2023 19:25

SaylessSayless · 13/09/2023 19:01

OP is talking about getting an adult dog. In all likelihood this dog is currently sitting in kennels or a rescue centre somewhere and only getting out of their pen for a short time each day. They would be delighted to be with a loving family who would exercise them lots, feed them well and keep them company for all but 2 6 hour periods a week.

Perspective is needed on Mumsnet when people mention getting dogs. So many posters automatically leap in declaring the poster couldn't possibly. There is a crisis in British rescue centres at the moment and anyone with a good, loving, responsible home to offer should be encouraged to help a dog.

Exactly this!

SaylessSayless · 13/09/2023 19:01

OP is talking about getting an adult dog. In all likelihood this dog is currently sitting in kennels or a rescue centre somewhere and only getting out of their pen for a short time each day. They would be delighted to be with a loving family who would exercise them lots, feed them well and keep them company for all but 2 6 hour periods a week.

Perspective is needed on Mumsnet when people mention getting dogs. So many posters automatically leap in declaring the poster couldn't possibly. There is a crisis in British rescue centres at the moment and anyone with a good, loving, responsible home to offer should be encouraged to help a dog.

Janiie · 13/09/2023 18:53

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 13/09/2023 18:37

But the dog is being left alone all night and THEN all day... (if you have a dog and then go out to work full time in the day.) If you don't work away all day, it will only be alone at night. I am baffled to fuckery that you - and some others - are not grasping this basic fact.

There are some ludicrous posts on this thread. Hmm

Some people should REALLY not be dog owners! It is NOT OK to leave a dog alone all day while you're at work, ever. And there are no dogs that are 'OK all day alone.' FFS. I despair for humanity that the OP even asked this question!

It's 6 hours, that isnt all day and is twice a week. Dogs can't tell the time, they don't know how long they're alone for. Granted 6hrs is the max I'd leave a dog but it is certainly acceptable and doable.

Fed, watered, exercised and loved is all that is required. Constant human supervision is not.

Robotalkingrubbish · 13/09/2023 18:40

Miniature poodles are lovely but you’d need care for the dog on your three days. You can’t leave any dog for that length of time.

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 13/09/2023 18:37

Flipflopflipperdiflop · 13/09/2023 15:18

But surely a dog owner can leave the house for 6 hours without the dog. They can learn. And not mind.
Youll be fine. The dog will be fine. In a warm bed, chewing on a bone, drink of water, more sleeping. I don't see the poblem. Really.

Oh FFS! Hmm PLEASE tell me you don't have a dog!

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 13/09/2023 18:37

Janiie · 13/09/2023 14:22

'5-6 hours is too long for any dog.'

Oh it isnt. They manage overnight just fine. Quality of life is the important bit, love and exercise when the owners are around. If the op said she worked 12 hr shifts with no time for walks and no one at home obviously that obviously wouldn't work. 6 hrs is fine.

But the dog is being left alone all night and THEN all day... (if you have a dog and then go out to work full time in the day.) If you don't work away all day, it will only be alone at night. I am baffled to fuckery that you - and some others - are not grasping this basic fact.

There are some ludicrous posts on this thread. Hmm

Some people should REALLY not be dog owners! It is NOT OK to leave a dog alone all day while you're at work, ever. And there are no dogs that are 'OK all day alone.' FFS. I despair for humanity that the OP even asked this question!

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 18:08

Universitynewbie · 13/09/2023 18:02

I think there is a difference between treating them like children and thinking they have the same right as a human being not to suffer because of our selfish choices (emotional and physical suffering). I haven't seen anyone on here suggesting treating them and disciplining them like a child- you are conflating 2 different things

But your average, well-adjusted adult dog isn't going to "suffer" because they're left alone for 12 hours out of 168 in a week.

MN has a tendency to go very OTT when it comes to dogs - either they're all vicious, smelly beasts out to kill children and shit on your doorstep, or they must never be left at home even in an emergency.

Yes, dogs are social animals and yes, they love company but that doesn't mean they can never be left alone for more than a couple of hours (puppies and separation anxiety aside, of course).

MiddleAgedMess · 13/09/2023 18:07

I think people are actually bonkers on mumsnet. 6 hours a day twice a week is perfectly reasonable! Obviously if it's a puppy then no because they'll probably be destructive and need the toilet, but for a grown adult dog they will likely just sleep for that time. Or give them boredom toys to use.
For God's sake if everyone acted as high and mighty in real life as they do on mumsnet about dogs then no one would own one.

Universitynewbie · 13/09/2023 18:02

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 13/09/2023 16:24

This is why we have so many misbehaved dogs and quite frankly batshit owners because they treat them like babies. I love dogs, I grew up around them and loved them wholeheartedly so I'm not a dog hater but people who compare them with children are honestly insane.

I think there is a difference between treating them like children and thinking they have the same right as a human being not to suffer because of our selfish choices (emotional and physical suffering). I haven't seen anyone on here suggesting treating them and disciplining them like a child- you are conflating 2 different things

Universitynewbie · 13/09/2023 17:59

boromu222 · 13/09/2023 15:34

You're genuinely asking why a DOG is not as important as a CHILD?

Like, actually?

Yes

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 17:57

ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 13/09/2023 14:52

Some dogs with severe separation anxiety won't last 5 minutes - and that isn't an exaggeration. You would do well to have a backup plain in place, such as a dog walker.

I would go down the rescue route - there's a lot of dogs in the rescues at the moment so they're slightly less picky with candidates than they once were, though as you're looking for a child friendly dog with no separation anxiety you'll have to be flexible with other criteria (e.g. breed / size).

I wouldn't get a puppy - no young pup can go 5-6 hours alone in the early months.

Thanks for the advice, but I have explained this earlier in the thread.

OP posts:
Batatahara · 13/09/2023 17:26

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/09/2023 15:45

All those saying "It will be fine...just leave the dog..." - PLEASE read this.

Every dog is different. Even if a rescue centre KNOWS a dog's 'provenance' and that it was regularly left with no problems, this does mean it will be when put in a ew environment.

And if it becomes distressed, destructive, etc - the OP MUST have a back-up plan that is not 'return the dog to rescue'.

So I agree that the OP should have some options like a dog walker or doggy daycare but if those don't work (and some dogs presumably don't do well with those options) then return to the rescue is always going to be the ultimate back up plan. What else is there other than quit her job and go on benefits to be fully available to her dog?

I realise that some on here probably do think that's the obvious answer but it's ridiculous

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 13/09/2023 17:17

Don't do it. A friend came back to a dog with a broken leg

HatingSchoolButLovingit · 13/09/2023 16:31

I'm a single parent and have a West Highland Terrier (as name suggests). I'm out the house 1 day a week.

She is the laziest thing ever. We do a 30 minute walk in the morning every day. Then I do school run and she's alone for that, then she sleeps on the sofa or under my desk all day. I let he out maybe every 2 hours (I can get up whenever I want so if she sits by the door as if to go out I let her out). Then another 30-40 minute walk in the evening and she's happy.

My day I'm in the office, I watch her on the cameras in the living room and kitchen, shes either asleep or watching the cars from the window. Worst thing she's done while alone is knock her entire water bowl over so I now always leave 2 out just in case.

We have a dog flap but she refuses to use it.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 13/09/2023 16:24

Batatahara · 13/09/2023 15:35

TBH I think some people think dogs are more important than children.

This is why we have so many misbehaved dogs and quite frankly batshit owners because they treat them like babies. I love dogs, I grew up around them and loved them wholeheartedly so I'm not a dog hater but people who compare them with children are honestly insane.

erikbloodaxe · 13/09/2023 16:23

No Op you wouldn't need to look at day care at all.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 13/09/2023 16:20

Universitynewbie · 13/09/2023 15:31

Why is a dog's happiness and quality of life not as important? Genuine question

A dog's quality of life is very important, obviously but comparing leaving a dog for 6 hours twice a week with a child is frankly just stupid. They are not the same, and anyone who compares dogs with children is silly.

Cheirosa · 13/09/2023 16:17

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 09:09

It's not everyday. It's twice a week.

Ah sorry, yes. OP says 3 times a week.

You’d absolutely need to look at daycare.

Mrsttcno1 · 13/09/2023 16:07

I have a 2 year old Labrador and both DH and I work full time, he is based in an office whereas I am hybrid so there are 3 days a week where I am in the office. On those days I take him out for a good walk before I leave (about 60-90 mins, a good run around) and he has his breakfast from a Kong to work his brain, then I leave for work, our dog walker picks him up at 11am and has him out for a group walk with other dogs so he doesn’t get dropped back off until 1pm and I’m home by half 3/4 oclock, I have cameras in the house and he literally sleeps the entire time we are gone😂 but we have trained him to be able to do this, and from him being 8 weeks to about 10 months he went to doggy day care instead as he couldn’t yet be on his own for too long! One thing I would say OP with regards to getting an older dog or rescue is that if that dog comes with separation anxiety, or is dog reactive, anxious etc, you’re going to really struggle to leave them or get them booked in with a dog walker or day care as they won’t pass the assessments.

GoldenSpangles · 13/09/2023 16:04

In a slightly similar situation we chose to get a Tonkinese cat. She is very affectionate and loves to play. She'll even play fetch (when she feels like it). They are very striking looking cats. Ours is a "basic" Tonkinese being a straight cross with a Siamese and a Burmese rather than being a true breed Tonkinese but we were looking for genetic diversity. She has short hair and is very easy care compared to a dog.

Frenchfancy · 13/09/2023 15:53

You were brave to post on MN where no dog should be left alone ever.

People have dogs and jobs. Yes maybe it isn't 100% ideal, but then what life is. Ideally I would like to stay at home all day and play with the dog but that doesn't pay for the dog food.

The life you are describing for a dog is 100% better than the life it would live in a shelter. And quite possibly far better for the dog than having random strangers come in and then the family not walking or playing with the dog when they get home.

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/09/2023 15:52

Flipflopflipperdiflop · 13/09/2023 15:18

But surely a dog owner can leave the house for 6 hours without the dog. They can learn. And not mind.
Youll be fine. The dog will be fine. In a warm bed, chewing on a bone, drink of water, more sleeping. I don't see the poblem. Really.

It can take months to teach that, and get to a point where the dog does not mind.

Separation anxiety sufferers can howl constantly for hours, they can dig or scrabble at doors til their paws bleed and their rip out their claws, crated dogs can trash crates, escape, ripping themselves to bits on the bars or plastic. I have had client with dogs who have gone through windows (single glazed!)...

Even if you discount entirely the fact the animal is suffering, most people can't handle their neighbours being disturbed or the cost of constantly repairing the damage.

Even those who do not do the extreme levels of obvious damage to themselves and their surroundings can experience behaviour problems as a result of SRP that make them hard to live with - increased anxiety, reactivity, development of phobias, aggression.

RSPCA stats (and i think they got them from Lincoln University, they've probably done the most dog related stuff in the UK) are 85% of dogs suffer some SRP.

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/09/2023 15:45

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/09/2023 15:11

@PleasedToBeAFlower Separation anxiety treatment is what I do (and ideally, avoidance of..)

Factor in it will take around 6 months to a year for a rescue dog to settle in.

Any separation anxiety issues - and it is normal for dogs to not want to be alone, not cope well alone, have to learn this - could also take that sort of time frame to fix.

So you need to find full cover initially, work on ensuring either any issue is fixed or that there is no issue in the first place... at the dogs pace, not the pace that suits you or your pocket... before you can bank on leaving the dog several hours between dog walker visits and people returning home.

Even dogs who have had no prior SRP's (Separation Related Problems) may well exhibit them on moving into a new home - again, this is normal and should be expected.

Preventing SRP means firstly, not leaving the dog alone at all.

Then it means working to desensitize the dog to the various visual cues and routines you will have around leaving the house.

It means building up the time they are left, sometimes in increments of a few seconds (not the 'five minutes, then ten minutes, then 15 minutes' you will so often hear suggested around the internet and even on some doggy tv shows).

If your new dog can't cope alone, then each time they are left you undo the work you put in - this means you may have to seriously re-jig how the household works. It means things like, you might prefer a dog that sleeps downstairs alone but you've got a dog who needs to sleep with a person for at least the next 6 months; arranging for everyone to be out whilst you (it will be you!) spend half an hour shuffling in and out of the front door boring your dog shitless; you spend 40 minutes parked at the end of the road watching a pet-cam, three times a week, having chucked everyone else out so you can do this in the correct context.

It is do-able, and you may get lucky and find you do not need to put in that level of work, however there is no way to tell which dog needs this level of work, until they are in your home, and you're already attached (or your kid)....

Rescues can tell you the dog has displayed no signs of SRP, a foster can tell you this too, but the reality is, dogs behaviour is relevant to their environment as well as prior learned experiences, genetics, pain levels.... so there are no guarantees.

All those saying "It will be fine...just leave the dog..." - PLEASE read this.

Every dog is different. Even if a rescue centre KNOWS a dog's 'provenance' and that it was regularly left with no problems, this does mean it will be when put in a ew environment.

And if it becomes distressed, destructive, etc - the OP MUST have a back-up plan that is not 'return the dog to rescue'.

Possimpible · 13/09/2023 15:44

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 14:13

I'm terribly confused by your message. How would the dog be left on its own for 8 hours, as you say?
And how do you reach the conclusion that I would walk it 2 hours before I go to work? Where have I said that?

Why have you picked out one part of this excellent post and ignored the rest? Yes PP misunderstood what you meant about the 2 hours of company in the morning, but they also made excellent points about needing a dog walker initially, and about how their settled adult dogs needed months to readjust after a house move. Interesting that you're ignoring those.

@WiddlinDiddlin 's post is excellent too

Janiie · 13/09/2023 15:40

Flipflopflipperdiflop · 13/09/2023 15:18

But surely a dog owner can leave the house for 6 hours without the dog. They can learn. And not mind.
Youll be fine. The dog will be fine. In a warm bed, chewing on a bone, drink of water, more sleeping. I don't see the poblem. Really.

This.

I do worry that there are some mumsnetters reclusive in their homes because of the misplaced belief that a dog cannot be left. They can!

Walk them, feed them, toilet them and play with them. Then leave the house and do stuff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread