Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To search for a small dog that can be left alone during the day?

434 replies

PleasedToBeAFlower · 12/09/2023 21:49

I will accept it if I get flamed by dog lovers for this.
But is there such a thing as a small dog that can be left alone for 5 or 6 hours 3 days a week?
Or is it just completely unacceptable to plan to do this?
My DD aged 9 has a significant educational learning delay. This is affecting her self esteem and self confidence. She is otherwise highly intelligent.
So I need to chanel in to things she loves, so that she can feel good about things she loves and is good at, to compensate for spending all day at school feeling rubbish about herself for not being able to learn.
And boy oh boy does she LOVE dogs. She literally adores them. She cannot pass one without making friends with it. Dogs seem attracted to her. And she's amaaaaazing with them. All breeds, all ages, doesn't matter, she adores them and they do seem to adore her.
She has begged for a dog for 6 years so far. I've always said no.
But I actually think it would be incredible for her to have one.
I have no doubt she would be 100% committed to it, and it would be a lucky dog as she would love it and care for it so much.
BUT it would be alone in the house 3 days a week for about 6 hours a day.
No way round this.
Kids at school.
DH and I go to work, and we dont have jobs that we can take dogs to.
Is this ever, ever, ever do-able???
Or is there never a way to have a dog if it's left on its own?
I realise it has to be fair on the dog, not just what we want.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
purpletrees16 · 14/09/2023 07:11

This dog is reserved and you’d have to take holiday to do a settling in period or use a dog sitter (as in someone who comes to your house) but she’s an example of a dog that:

  • child tested
  • can be left up to 5 hours

it might take a while to find the right dog but I think as long as:

6 hours is absolute max. & only 3 days
you have a plan B to let the dog out if there’s an issue / emergency e.g. a neighbour with a dog who would be sympathetic
you have the time for play, training and enrichment outside of those working hours.

https://woodgreen.org.uk/pets/pippin/

PS: I have a spaniel who is the neediest creature you have met and is hardly alone - but my point is dogs are individuals and there’s is probably one for your circumstances. My parents dachshund would have liked more alone time than he got!

Pippin | Woodgreen Pets Charity

https://woodgreen.org.uk/pets/pippin/

Baba197 · 14/09/2023 06:58

Or look at cats instead? Does she like cats? Much less work involved

Baba197 · 14/09/2023 06:56

A dog walker would be a good option for you. In the meantime what about signing up to sites like borrow my doggie, you can both take someone else’s dog out for walks, borrow it to have at home for a few hours etc and it would give you an idea of whether she will take it seriously and also what kind of breeds will work best for you. Making friends with dogs out n about is very different to owning one (as I’m sure you know) and this way it’s less of a commitment.

purpletrees16 · 14/09/2023 06:50

Explain at shelters - seems like you need an older dog that is ok with being left. They may have one! Certain greyhounds spring to mind - I know one that if they don’t sleep for 8 hours during the day will be grumpy

once back in the house, you will need to give it loads of attention, play, games. Some dogs love walks; some value 1 or 1 time but I’d say at least 30mins of this (time on your phone.)

my parents had an aging dachshund when growing up that required alone time & valued play more than anything.

You definitely can’t get a puppy.

Harperhan · 14/09/2023 06:39

The only way this would work is if you got a dog walker to come in and take them out during the day.

LeedsMum87 · 14/09/2023 06:10

Yes of course it’s possible, hire a dog walker to take them out in the middle of the day. The going rate is £12 per hour.
However dogs with separation anxiety are hard work and you won’t know if they’ll have it until you get them, so be prepared for lots of training needed to ensure they’re happy at home for a few hours without you. I’d also advise taking some annual leave when you first get the dog, maybe you take 2 weeks, then your husband takes 2 weeks to get them settled in before you start their routine, so that you’re not leaving them straight away.
Do loads of research on the best breed for you and buy from a reputable breeder if you’re getting a puppy.
Good luck!

JustKen · 14/09/2023 05:32

We really wanted a dog. But we are all busy through the day (even when I'm on nights...I'm sleeping!) so... we got a cat.

I'll get a dog when I retire or am able to go part time.

My retired mother in law used to take her neighbour's dog out for walks during the day as something to do. It was mutually beneficial to all parties.

LT1982 · 14/09/2023 05:01

PleasedToBeAFlower · 12/09/2023 21:49

I will accept it if I get flamed by dog lovers for this.
But is there such a thing as a small dog that can be left alone for 5 or 6 hours 3 days a week?
Or is it just completely unacceptable to plan to do this?
My DD aged 9 has a significant educational learning delay. This is affecting her self esteem and self confidence. She is otherwise highly intelligent.
So I need to chanel in to things she loves, so that she can feel good about things she loves and is good at, to compensate for spending all day at school feeling rubbish about herself for not being able to learn.
And boy oh boy does she LOVE dogs. She literally adores them. She cannot pass one without making friends with it. Dogs seem attracted to her. And she's amaaaaazing with them. All breeds, all ages, doesn't matter, she adores them and they do seem to adore her.
She has begged for a dog for 6 years so far. I've always said no.
But I actually think it would be incredible for her to have one.
I have no doubt she would be 100% committed to it, and it would be a lucky dog as she would love it and care for it so much.
BUT it would be alone in the house 3 days a week for about 6 hours a day.
No way round this.
Kids at school.
DH and I go to work, and we dont have jobs that we can take dogs to.
Is this ever, ever, ever do-able???
Or is there never a way to have a dog if it's left on its own?
I realise it has to be fair on the dog, not just what we want.

There are ways around this. They're called dog walkers/dog sitters/doggy daycare.

I'd love à dog but aware of the fact Im not home enough and it would be cruel to the dog

meadowlass · 13/09/2023 22:44

Two dogs could work but one dog of a pair can still experience significantly more separation anxiety than the other. I have two dogs who are not close and while there is no agression between them they spend as much time as possible far away from one another in separate parts of my house. One of them gets very anxious when left. It very much depends upon the personality of the two dogs. In order to train both dogs effectively you would need to get one on its own first and then a second one later so the first one would still be left alone. The worst combination is a sibling pair from the same litter. They focus on each other rather than the owner and consequently can be very difficult to train leading to more problems,

MrsPaddyGrant · 13/09/2023 22:36

People do leave their dogs on their own for 6 hours but it doesn’t mean the dogs are happy. RSPCA say you shouldn’t leave a dog alone for more than 4 hours. If you can make a plan to break up the dogs day on the 2 days it may be ok ie dog walker, doggy day care - depends on the dog.

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/09/2023 22:28

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/09/2023 21:04

Why are people bashing on about what a well trained, happy, chilled adult dog can handle?

OP won't be getting one of those, no one gets one of those, you can't order them up online.

OP will be getting either a puppy or a second hand dog - either option involves work, time, compromises and sacrifices, to get to the hallowed grounds of 'well trained, happy, chilled, adult dog'.

Getting dogs to where they can be left 4 hours regular, 6 hours occasionally is very possible - if you understand dogs of course and can meet all their needs.

Heads up for those who think dogs will be grateful that they were rescued, super thankful that they're not sat in kennels waiting hopefully for someone to save them.

Dogs don't think like that. If they did, I'd be out of a job.

You can move a dog from a shit situation to a better, but still not ideal situation, and the dog will still suffer, will still be a problem to live with. 'Better' is not good enough!

Again, THIS.

Loloj · 13/09/2023 21:48

Please don’t plan to leave a dog for that long. Some dogs can be ok for up to 5 hours but not when young and a lot of dogs definitely wouldn’t cope well for that long. If you can budget for a dog walker or doggy daycare then this is a solution.

Another great idea is a website called “borrowmydoggy” which is a great way of meeting local people who may want to look after your dog during the day to keep them company - of course this isn’t guaranteed so I wouldn’t rely on it but we do this 2 days per week with our dog and it is mutually beneficial.

RunningFromInsanity · 13/09/2023 21:30

MrsB74 · 13/09/2023 20:29

Unpopular opinion here, but some dogs don’t actually mind being left for that long a few days a week. Perhaps not a very small one as they will have a small bladder! I’ve had several dogs that ended up being left that long occasionally (not every day or even every week) and were absolutely fine, no separation anxiety, well adjusted and no destruction at all (not in a crate either). They do get left all night after all. They tend to just snooze all day. I also know friends and neighbours who have done/are doing this a few days a week when they have to go in to the office. They get a long walk in the morning and in the evening. It very much depends on the dog’s personality- some breeds would hate this. I certainly would not leave a puppy that long, but you are not talking about getting a puppy.

I’m pretty sure that during lockdown when I started WFH, my dog was sick of sight of me! He would look at me wondering why I wasn’t leaving him to his daily peace

MarvellousMonsters · 13/09/2023 21:21

My dogs can be left up to 6 hours, I don't do it regularly as it's a bit too long really, but if I leave for work at 8 and am not back by 2 they are fine, but this is the longest I'll leave them. When I worked full days I had a dog walker come in at lunchtime to take them out in the garden for a wee and half an hours company. I'd consider talking to a rehoming centre, they'll help you find a dog that will fit your family, and you can go and meet various dogs and see how they get on with you all. A puppy is cute, but aside from the high price, they are a lot of work for the first couple of years, and need lots of training etc. A rehomed dog will allow you to bypass the puppy stage.

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/09/2023 21:04

Why are people bashing on about what a well trained, happy, chilled adult dog can handle?

OP won't be getting one of those, no one gets one of those, you can't order them up online.

OP will be getting either a puppy or a second hand dog - either option involves work, time, compromises and sacrifices, to get to the hallowed grounds of 'well trained, happy, chilled, adult dog'.

Getting dogs to where they can be left 4 hours regular, 6 hours occasionally is very possible - if you understand dogs of course and can meet all their needs.

Heads up for those who think dogs will be grateful that they were rescued, super thankful that they're not sat in kennels waiting hopefully for someone to save them.

Dogs don't think like that. If they did, I'd be out of a job.

You can move a dog from a shit situation to a better, but still not ideal situation, and the dog will still suffer, will still be a problem to live with. 'Better' is not good enough!

Snoken · 13/09/2023 21:01

@Universitynewbie I agree. The dog flap might solve the problem of going to the toilet but dogs need and crave company. They are pack animals. I think it would all be solved by getting a dog walker (once the dog is settled) to break up those lonely hours and it sounds like the OP is considering that too.

Universitynewbie · 13/09/2023 20:49

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 13/09/2023 18:08

But your average, well-adjusted adult dog isn't going to "suffer" because they're left alone for 12 hours out of 168 in a week.

MN has a tendency to go very OTT when it comes to dogs - either they're all vicious, smelly beasts out to kill children and shit on your doorstep, or they must never be left at home even in an emergency.

Yes, dogs are social animals and yes, they love company but that doesn't mean they can never be left alone for more than a couple of hours (puppies and separation anxiety aside, of course).

The op was suggesting leaving the dog for 6 hours a day for 3 days a week, plus I am sure there would also be social reasons they would leave the dog at other times, plus at night so it wouldn't just be 12 hours. For me it is the planned regular 6 hour stints that are an issue. I am not of the mind a dog cannot be left alone ever or in an emergency (shit happens!) I just don't think it should be part of the plan to be leaving a dog alone all day. I see the op has updated to say there would be a dog flap which improves conditions in my mind somewhat but I still think a lot of dogs would be distressed in this situation.

Aquestioningmind · 13/09/2023 20:47

PleasedToBeAFlower · 13/09/2023 13:25

So are you saying that no-one should have a dog unless there is someone at home with them all day every day? Or are you saying that dogs can be left, but gor much shorter periods of time?
Are you saying people who go out to work cannot have a dog?
I'm not being facetious here, I promise. I genuinely want to know if this is what you are saying.

Tbh I completely think people shouldn’t have dogs if they plan on leaving them alone routinely (I.e to go to work). Why get a ‘pack’ animal and then leave it alone for several hours a day?

I also think you’re quite naive for thinking that two walks a day and interaction can make up/justify leaving it for 6+ hours twice a week.

Clarabell77 · 13/09/2023 20:41

I have two dogs and they’re fine for about 4-5 hours on the very odd occasion we’ve had to leave them that long. That’s pretty much the recommended maximum that the rspca state.

If you’re planning on a puppy you won’t be able to do this right away though, as they need out for the toilet very regularly for the first few months (depending on the dog) and they also would be likely to be anxious. You would potentially be the same with a rescue as they can have behavioural issues and would need time to settle but in any case it’s very hard to get a rescue dog if you have kids.

I would say you’d need to get a walker to come the three days you’re working, someone you trust with a key to come in and take the dog out. But you will have to think about the first couple of months as the training period isn’t too dissimilar to having a newborn!

Sophie89j · 13/09/2023 20:33

Lol puppy*

Sophie89j · 13/09/2023 20:32

What about a rescue dog? An older one? Our dog when a puffy we couldn’t leave him alone that long, my gran used to pop over to check on him but we’re lucky enough to have constant access to back porch and garden for him and locking the inside door so he’s always got shelter and outside access but once again a puppy will probably be unlikely to be left for that long and probably won’t be able to leave an older dog straight away.

MeridaBrave · 13/09/2023 20:32

It’s not realistic to leave a dog that long. Could you get a cleaner 3x a week to keep
dog company and give short extra walk.

OUR dog is 3 and I can leave fo 3-4 hours but not sure that would have been possible in first year.

MrsB74 · 13/09/2023 20:29

Unpopular opinion here, but some dogs don’t actually mind being left for that long a few days a week. Perhaps not a very small one as they will have a small bladder! I’ve had several dogs that ended up being left that long occasionally (not every day or even every week) and were absolutely fine, no separation anxiety, well adjusted and no destruction at all (not in a crate either). They do get left all night after all. They tend to just snooze all day. I also know friends and neighbours who have done/are doing this a few days a week when they have to go in to the office. They get a long walk in the morning and in the evening. It very much depends on the dog’s personality- some breeds would hate this. I certainly would not leave a puppy that long, but you are not talking about getting a puppy.

Lemmony · 13/09/2023 20:04

Agree with other posters than an older dog or a cat is a better choice.

Mirabai · 13/09/2023 19:33

SaylessSayless · 13/09/2023 19:01

OP is talking about getting an adult dog. In all likelihood this dog is currently sitting in kennels or a rescue centre somewhere and only getting out of their pen for a short time each day. They would be delighted to be with a loving family who would exercise them lots, feed them well and keep them company for all but 2 6 hour periods a week.

Perspective is needed on Mumsnet when people mention getting dogs. So many posters automatically leap in declaring the poster couldn't possibly. There is a crisis in British rescue centres at the moment and anyone with a good, loving, responsible home to offer should be encouraged to help a dog.

A rescue dog with an uncertain, possibly traumatic history left alone for 6 hours a day 3 x per week. What could possibly go wrong?