Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dartford Crossing protester, possible deportation

262 replies

WildAlphabet · 12/09/2023 21:37

Essex radio did an interview with the partner of a protester who climbed the dartford bridge as part of Just Stop Oil.

The gist of it is he was surprised to get three years in prison, they expected a few months. The length of his sentence means he’s facing deportation, as a German national.

They did a phone in, and I was quite surprised that even the angry radio essex listeners they put on, who were massively against his actions, disagreed with deportation as additional punishment. Some wanted community service to make up for the loss they suffered, others name called, but they thought splitting a family was too much.

I was kind of intrigued how the mumsnet demographic would view it, often being quite rule-bound or conservative. Personally I disagree with the one year rule for deportation, particularly for non violent crimes. It’s out of sync with most of the world. I guess also as a second generation immigrant who could also potentially lose the right to stay here if wrongly convicted, it’s scary on a personal level. It’s played on my mind the last few days

Here’s an article https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

Marcus Decker and Holly Cullen-Davies

Partner of activist trying to stop his deportation - BBC News

German national Marcus Decker is in jail for scaling the Dartford Crossing bridge over the Thames.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
yogasaurus · 13/09/2023 17:49

but not the failed little boys raised here who disproportionately face the justice system or are sentenced harshly.

So they should be let off? Upbringings should be reflected in sentences? What do you want to happen? The victims would have a different view I’m sure

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 17:48

timetochangethering · 13/09/2023 17:32

Rape is a MINIMUM 4 year sentence.... people convicted of Rape cannot get less than 4 years. Likewise Murder is minimum 15 years (for over 18's)....a quick google will tell you this.

A quick google tells you that no, some men got three years and one got two years https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1732724/Rape-jail-sentence-short-data-police-force-Survivors-Trust/amp

Sentences for rape less than three years in data seen by Survivors Trust | UK | News | Express.co.uk

Twenty rapists received custodial sentences of less than five years between January and June 2022.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1732724/Rape-jail-sentence-short-data-police-force-Survivors-Trust/amp

OP posts:
WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 17:47

It’s exactly the same issue. Short prison sentences leading to automatic deportation for non-violent crimes.

OP posts:
WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 17:46

Insommmmnia · 13/09/2023 17:34

I’m not referring to Windrush non-law breakers.
People like this amp.theguardian.com/global-development/2023/mar/07/jamaica-hostel-vulnerable-us-uk-mental-health-deportees-acc
and many others.
Not ‘good’ immigrants. I’m making the point I still support the humane treatment and equality for those petty law breaker’s deported caught up in untreated mental health needs, poverty or desperation in their young lives

Then talk about those @WildAlphabet

Because that is an extremely different senario to the one you started the thread about and you are berating posters for not caring enough about the second senario because they don't agree with you about the first entirely different senario.

I am talking about them.
I’ve explained the issue with the law because a poster tried to twist this into a ‘what about the non-whites’ thing. Claiming that I was only interested in this one man.
I clarified that this particular radio show put the issue in my mind, but that I didn’t support the law in the wider sense.
The poster in question then didn’t recognise that weighing up immigrants as good/ bad in circumstances like I shared above was in itself racist- that a black child and a white child raised in this country do not have equal chances in many circumstances and also are the main losers here.
But it’s about the ‘good’ windrush to them, they are acceptable, but not the failed little boys raised here who disproportionately face the justice system or are sentenced harshly. They matter too, not just the ideal immigrants.

OP posts:
FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:43

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:31

What city are you referring to? Easy to state they are 'thick' etc but it is just insults for the sake of it. Having watched the Guardian investigative journalist report they are definitely not think, they are educated and articulate. I like to keep an open mind about things though as to solve the green issues we need to work together not throw around insults.

The City. The square mile, where they turn up each year to smash windows and graffiti the buildings.

And yes, they are definitely thick, which is why they are gluing themselves to roads rather than engineering better solutions for green technology and decarbonisation of our economy.

Insommmmnia · 13/09/2023 17:34

I’m not referring to Windrush non-law breakers.
People like this amp.theguardian.com/global-development/2023/mar/07/jamaica-hostel-vulnerable-us-uk-mental-health-deportees-acc
and many others.
Not ‘good’ immigrants. I’m making the point I still support the humane treatment and equality for those petty law breaker’s deported caught up in untreated mental health needs, poverty or desperation in their young lives

Then talk about those @WildAlphabet

Because that is an extremely different senario to the one you started the thread about and you are berating posters for not caring enough about the second senario because they don't agree with you about the first entirely different senario.

timetochangethering · 13/09/2023 17:32

WildAlphabet · 12/09/2023 22:03

I was personally also shocked at a 3 year sentence, like they were. I mean multiple men in the same year were convicted of rape and got a shorter sentence. It’s nearly the average for manslaughter by negligence. I don’t agree with him, but it seems surprisingly harsh to get a sentence up there with someone who has actually directly harmed or killed

Rape is a MINIMUM 4 year sentence.... people convicted of Rape cannot get less than 4 years. Likewise Murder is minimum 15 years (for over 18's)....a quick google will tell you this.

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:32

Thick, not 'think'.

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:31

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:17

If it took any bravery they’d not be shining like stuck pigs when incarcerated and / or deported, they’d be proud of their sacrifice.

No, they are a bunch of thick, unpleasant trouble makers who care less about the environment than about just causing trouble, just like when they smash up the city each May Day.

What city are you referring to? Easy to state they are 'thick' etc but it is just insults for the sake of it. Having watched the Guardian investigative journalist report they are definitely not think, they are educated and articulate. I like to keep an open mind about things though as to solve the green issues we need to work together not throw around insults.

Superfood · 13/09/2023 17:24

7Worfs · 13/09/2023 17:09

It’s not the UK/courts/laws splitting his family - it’s that numpty putting his politics and activism ahead of his family.

I for one welcome the opportunity to see a zealot demonstrate his burning convictions through self-sacrifice of this magnitude. 🤭

He doesn't have a family here to split

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2023 17:23

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 11:05

Then, if you don’t recognise the social disadvantages, poorer health care, poorer education and institutional racism many in the black community face that compound their life chances and likelihood of coming into contact with the criminal justice system then you shouldn’t be pretending to be on a high horse saying ‘oh but what about the non-whites’. You can’t just say ‘oh the good ones can stay’, and totally ignore the institutional racism. People are valid full stop

I didn't get on my high horse, so don't quote me for things I never said.

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:22

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 16:59

But what have you done? Or the protesters you support?

Caused disruption to many and embarrassed themselves.

I'd see the point if it galvanised support but it doesn't.

IT. IS. NOT. WORKING.

The whole point of protest is that it raises awareness and gets people on board to support the cause.

All the stop-oil protestors are doing is committing crimes for which they are rightfully convicted and disrupting life for so many people that it's just pissing people off.

And the more it happens the more people are pissed off.

You're not getting supporters, just more people who think you're twats who don't have to work for a living and have time to dedicate to causing the public to lose out on time and earnings while some twat glues their arse to a road and causes huge amounts of public money to be spent unglueing them, or using cherry pickers to get them off bridges or take them through the courts

And the abject narcissisism or sociopathy of the people involved who don't give a single shit about the people that suffer is just beyond the pale.

You're not doing a thing other than feeding your own narcissisism or sociopathy where people's real, happening today suffering because of your actions means nothing to you in your entitled self-absorbed campaign

I'm not a Just Stop Oil member and I've just pointed out how I don't do enough but they did make me stop and think, which I suppose was their intention. I have a job why do you assume I don't.

I watched the Guardian Environment reporter follow the Just Stop Oil people, many of them appear to be retired and had occupations like Teachers or are vicars. They acknowledged their disruption wasn't working so they have tried different stuff. I don't know if it is a good idea but it did make me think about how I don't do that much at all given the impending doom that faces us and is happening now!

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 17:20

MoxieFox · 13/09/2023 17:03

The law isn’t racist. Foreign nationals on visas in this country are of all races and all are subject to the same law.

The institutional racism in regards to “Caribbean young men” and so on was about wrongful and illegal deportation. As in the U.K. Government broke the law and deported people who had every right to be here and this happened in a way that was absolutely racist.

I don’t think it’s right for you to compare the two cases. Whether or not this German man gets deported has no impact on how the Home Office is institutionally racist and will continue to illegally and wrongfully deport non-white people who have every right to be here. You should not pretend it does.

I’m not referring to Windrush non-law breakers.
People like this https://amp.theguardian.com/global-development/2023/mar/07/jamaica-hostel-vulnerable-us-uk-mental-health-deportees-acc
and many others.
Not ‘good’ immigrants. I’m making the point I still support the humane treatment and equality for those petty law breaker’s deported caught up in untreated mental health needs, poverty or desperation in their young lives

‘I don’t know why I was sent here’: the Jamaica hostel supporting vulnerable US and UK deportees | Global development | The Guardian

For those like Andrew O’Connor, who despite significant mental health needs has been repatriated to a country he left as a child, the Open Arms is a lifeline

https://amp.theguardian.com/global-development/2023/mar/07/jamaica-hostel-vulnerable-us-uk-mental-health-deportees-acc

OP posts:
HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 17:18

Begsthequestion · 13/09/2023 17:03

I understand that many posters don't see any value in street protest or direct action, even when billions of lives are at stake, but nevertheless you'll be in the minority in a few years time.

I think the fact that there is such massive opposition to the protests at the moment suggest that will not change in any way in a few years.

Societies don't change that much so quickly.

That's just fact. And I know your leaders or TikTok accounts or whatever tell you otherwise but sorry, the overwhelming public and governmental opinion is you are time-wasting narcissisitic twats causing damage.

That's not going to change in the next few years as society isn't going to change that much in the next few years.

That's not how it works.

But carry on listening to them and believing you'll be on the 'right side of history' very soon. You won't but enjoy 😉

MoxieFox · 13/09/2023 17:18

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:13

It is direct action that is a reaction to people's apathy and disinterest. Given that is the case I suspect they don't really care about your respect they want to draw attention to the situation and the seriousness of it. You say people know about it but many people don't have a clue as they don't read a newspaper, they don't watch the news, they don't read full stop. To take that action whether you agree with it or not takes an element of bravery knowing the backlash and consequences. I could not do it and I definitely don't do enough to reduce my carbon footprint but it has made me think about what I should be doing and even who I work for in my job as I have DC and I have a moral obligation to them and their friends, peers, generation to not be a fatalist and just think, "fuck it".

The protesters are all about getting into the news- their actions are purely attention seeking. How are they going to reach this illiterate population you speak of that do not read or watch the news and are also apathetic and don’t know anything about the climate or the environment? I don’t think this segment of the population exists. Where did you get the idea they do?

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:17

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:13

It is direct action that is a reaction to people's apathy and disinterest. Given that is the case I suspect they don't really care about your respect they want to draw attention to the situation and the seriousness of it. You say people know about it but many people don't have a clue as they don't read a newspaper, they don't watch the news, they don't read full stop. To take that action whether you agree with it or not takes an element of bravery knowing the backlash and consequences. I could not do it and I definitely don't do enough to reduce my carbon footprint but it has made me think about what I should be doing and even who I work for in my job as I have DC and I have a moral obligation to them and their friends, peers, generation to not be a fatalist and just think, "fuck it".

If it took any bravery they’d not be shining like stuck pigs when incarcerated and / or deported, they’d be proud of their sacrifice.

No, they are a bunch of thick, unpleasant trouble makers who care less about the environment than about just causing trouble, just like when they smash up the city each May Day.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/09/2023 17:16

DesperateHousewife2018 · 12/09/2023 23:26

@Seagullchippy there is no alternative route. He blocked a bridge with no alternative until either the Blackwall tunnel or tower bridge in central London. You have no idea the issues he caused!

The police can be blamed for a lot things but not this! The only one responsible is him and his equally stupid mate. I have no sympathy for him at all.

Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:13

MoxieFox · 13/09/2023 16:54

I’m sorry but I agree with @FirstYouGetTheMoney . Protesters don’t actually do anything to fight climate change. I have buckets more respect for all the apprentices signing up to man each wind turbine on our offshore wind farms. That is a very dangerous job with little to no recognition but it is doing far more to fight climate change than a protester sitting on a bridge causing excess CO2 to be emitted and diversions of people killing NO2 and particulate emitting diesel lorries into central London.

I don’t do more than live a very low carbon footprint lifestyle, which I do, but on the other hand I’m not claiming that I’m saving the planet by highlighting untold suffering and shouting about catastrophes which, let’s face it, everyone already knows everything the protesters are saying. It’s pointless virtue signalling that actually ends up harming the environment and causing more human suffering.

It is direct action that is a reaction to people's apathy and disinterest. Given that is the case I suspect they don't really care about your respect they want to draw attention to the situation and the seriousness of it. You say people know about it but many people don't have a clue as they don't read a newspaper, they don't watch the news, they don't read full stop. To take that action whether you agree with it or not takes an element of bravery knowing the backlash and consequences. I could not do it and I definitely don't do enough to reduce my carbon footprint but it has made me think about what I should be doing and even who I work for in my job as I have DC and I have a moral obligation to them and their friends, peers, generation to not be a fatalist and just think, "fuck it".

MeadAndPie · 13/09/2023 17:10

I think emotive use of splitting families was probably swaying phone in people - no-one likes idea of that.

I do think there are issues around immigration and deportation that do need to change but this example I'm fine with - if your status depends on certain condition like work or not being in prison longer than 12 months I think most people can and do take care not to breach them.

The partner who he doesn't live with does have option of trying to move to Germany a safe and democratic country with it's own immigration rules - not ideal but better than some cases I do worry about.

Having sympathy for why he broke the law or not ( where I am ) is kind of irrelevant - he deliberately broke the law took a risk the prison term would be under 12 months and lost.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:10

HaileyFailet · 13/09/2023 16:59

But what have you done? Or the protesters you support?

Caused disruption to many and embarrassed themselves.

I'd see the point if it galvanised support but it doesn't.

IT. IS. NOT. WORKING.

The whole point of protest is that it raises awareness and gets people on board to support the cause.

All the stop-oil protestors are doing is committing crimes for which they are rightfully convicted and disrupting life for so many people that it's just pissing people off.

And the more it happens the more people are pissed off.

You're not getting supporters, just more people who think you're twats who don't have to work for a living and have time to dedicate to causing the public to lose out on time and earnings while some twat glues their arse to a road and causes huge amounts of public money to be spent unglueing them, or using cherry pickers to get them off bridges or take them through the courts

And the abject narcissisism or sociopathy of the people involved who don't give a single shit about the people that suffer is just beyond the pale.

You're not doing a thing other than feeding your own narcissisism or sociopathy where people's real, happening today suffering because of your actions means nothing to you in your entitled self-absorbed campaign

Precisely so. While these idiots have been enjoying causing mayhem the UK has quietly halved our carbon output per capita, and is currently commissioning the world’s largest offshore wind farm in the North Sea, something that the protestors likely don’t know or care about.

It’s the same hippies who riot in the square mile on May Day, just spoiled kids who enjoy upsetting people.

7Worfs · 13/09/2023 17:09

It’s not the UK/courts/laws splitting his family - it’s that numpty putting his politics and activism ahead of his family.

I for one welcome the opportunity to see a zealot demonstrate his burning convictions through self-sacrifice of this magnitude. 🤭

Gilmorefurls · 13/09/2023 17:05

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 16:56

Totally evading the wider point there. The wider issue, since you raised it @Superfood
Ive cleared stated I disagree with the law in general, because it disadvantages people already disadvantaged and notably young Caribbean men.
You’ve tried to evade that one.
To be clear, if you support this law and ignore institutional racism you are no champion of non-white people so wind down on that one preaching. It’s a racist law in the wider sense, he’s one man but good if it shines a spotlight, or any reason, on an unjust law. I don’t want him as a special case. I want to see people question the law

I think the simplest solution is to not commit crimes? Wild I know. Unless you have some statistics on how many people have been deported following a wrongful conviction? Looking at stats from the first half of this year the vast majority deported seem to be Albanians- that's not in the Carribean is it, and it doesn't look like any have been overturned.

MoxieFox · 13/09/2023 17:03

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 16:56

Totally evading the wider point there. The wider issue, since you raised it @Superfood
Ive cleared stated I disagree with the law in general, because it disadvantages people already disadvantaged and notably young Caribbean men.
You’ve tried to evade that one.
To be clear, if you support this law and ignore institutional racism you are no champion of non-white people so wind down on that one preaching. It’s a racist law in the wider sense, he’s one man but good if it shines a spotlight, or any reason, on an unjust law. I don’t want him as a special case. I want to see people question the law

The law isn’t racist. Foreign nationals on visas in this country are of all races and all are subject to the same law.

The institutional racism in regards to “Caribbean young men” and so on was about wrongful and illegal deportation. As in the U.K. Government broke the law and deported people who had every right to be here and this happened in a way that was absolutely racist.

I don’t think it’s right for you to compare the two cases. Whether or not this German man gets deported has no impact on how the Home Office is institutionally racist and will continue to illegally and wrongfully deport non-white people who have every right to be here. You should not pretend it does.

Begsthequestion · 13/09/2023 17:03

I understand that many posters don't see any value in street protest or direct action, even when billions of lives are at stake, but nevertheless you'll be in the minority in a few years time.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:02

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 16:56

Totally evading the wider point there. The wider issue, since you raised it @Superfood
Ive cleared stated I disagree with the law in general, because it disadvantages people already disadvantaged and notably young Caribbean men.
You’ve tried to evade that one.
To be clear, if you support this law and ignore institutional racism you are no champion of non-white people so wind down on that one preaching. It’s a racist law in the wider sense, he’s one man but good if it shines a spotlight, or any reason, on an unjust law. I don’t want him as a special case. I want to see people question the law

It only “disadvantages them” when they commit crimes, and I don’t care if people who aren’t citizens are getting deported after committing serious crimes.

Maybe if their community had as low a level of criminality as the rest of us they’d not suffer so much disadvantage.