Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dartford Crossing protester, possible deportation

262 replies

WildAlphabet · 12/09/2023 21:37

Essex radio did an interview with the partner of a protester who climbed the dartford bridge as part of Just Stop Oil.

The gist of it is he was surprised to get three years in prison, they expected a few months. The length of his sentence means he’s facing deportation, as a German national.

They did a phone in, and I was quite surprised that even the angry radio essex listeners they put on, who were massively against his actions, disagreed with deportation as additional punishment. Some wanted community service to make up for the loss they suffered, others name called, but they thought splitting a family was too much.

I was kind of intrigued how the mumsnet demographic would view it, often being quite rule-bound or conservative. Personally I disagree with the one year rule for deportation, particularly for non violent crimes. It’s out of sync with most of the world. I guess also as a second generation immigrant who could also potentially lose the right to stay here if wrongly convicted, it’s scary on a personal level. It’s played on my mind the last few days

Here’s an article https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

Marcus Decker and Holly Cullen-Davies

Partner of activist trying to stop his deportation - BBC News

German national Marcus Decker is in jail for scaling the Dartford Crossing bridge over the Thames.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Stomacharmeleon · 13/09/2023 22:44

@Superfood has put it much more succinctly than I ever could.

Insommmmnia · 13/09/2023 20:35

The reason to deport him is because he is here on a work visa, he gave up his job, he no longer has the legal right to remain in the UK. If they were to not deport him after his sentence he would essentially be here illegally with no recourse to help to put his life back together.

Returning him to Germany where he has the right to any support and assistance such as social housing and benefits is far more humane than putting him in a halfway house with no entitlement to housing or benefits and leaving him to try to find a job that will give him a work visa with a criminal record.

If left in the UK he could end up homeless and with no way to actually get the money to get back to Germany. He has no family here and a partner who he wasn't even living with who will quite possibly have moved on with her life by the time he comes out.

Its all very well to say he shouldn't be deported but its not really that simple and not deporting him is potentially not in his best interests.

It would be different if he was going back to a country where he was fearful for his life, or didn't have any ties but that's not the case here.

If I committed a crime in Germany I think I would much prefer to end up back in the UK where I have ties, family and friends and a right to certain state support than left to drift in Germany with none of those things.

RamsesTheChub · 13/09/2023 20:23

I'm generally supportive of any protest (whether i agree or not) but I very much disagreed with the way these protests were carried out and felt it took far to long for police to move these people on.

However, I can't see any good reason to jail any of them, let alone deportation.

Insommmmnia · 13/09/2023 20:19

it's disgusting that you are trying to manipulate and distort the situation by bringing in situations of people who are genuinely being fucked over by the system, in the service of this massively overprivileged white man from one of the world's wealthiest countries.

This

Lemmony · 13/09/2023 20:03

Unfortunately the law is the law :(

Superfood · 13/09/2023 19:36

Some young black men have been deported in hugely vulnerable states in mental health crisis. Some have grown up in poverty and had such a shit hand, been a product of this country’s failings then been deported to a foreign land when we’ve failed then. Some have been exploited children, then deported as young adults. European or Caribbean or African, I think we should recognise children born and raised here as having rights, and I don’t think deportation should be such a trigger happy consequence.

none of this applies to this dickhead. None of it.* *He wasn't an exploited child, he isn't from a global majority background, he doesn't have mental health issues, he wasn't born and raised here, he wasnt raised in poverty, he isn't being deported to somewhere he doesn't know. He's going back to fucking Germany after a couple of years of overgrown teenage gap year fucking about over here.

it's disgusting that you are trying to manipulate and distort the situation by bringing in situations of people who are genuinely being fucked over by the system, in the service of this massively overprivileged white man from one of the world's wealthiest countries.

These people are deserving of care and empathy and understanding and support. He deserves fuck all.

Superfood · 13/09/2023 19:28

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 17:46

I am talking about them.
I’ve explained the issue with the law because a poster tried to twist this into a ‘what about the non-whites’ thing. Claiming that I was only interested in this one man.
I clarified that this particular radio show put the issue in my mind, but that I didn’t support the law in the wider sense.
The poster in question then didn’t recognise that weighing up immigrants as good/ bad in circumstances like I shared above was in itself racist- that a black child and a white child raised in this country do not have equal chances in many circumstances and also are the main losers here.
But it’s about the ‘good’ windrush to them, they are acceptable, but not the failed little boys raised here who disproportionately face the justice system or are sentenced harshly. They matter too, not just the ideal immigrants.

I've just come back to this thread and seen this fairly unsubtle attempt to call me a racist.

no, I don't think that black boys have a fair chance at life here, and I don't think people who grew up here should be deported for minor crimes.

and I think it's incredibly telling that you are trying to call other people racist when you've started an entire thread in defence of a rich white German bloke who came here as an adult, broke the terms of his visa, fucked around repeatedly, and has no family ties or reason to be here.

The hypocrisy. Fuck him.

nealjacob53 · 13/09/2023 19:23

yes, i think that they just enjoy mayhem, its a good excuse !

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:52

I’ll be honest, I don’t feel lucky to have acquired a passport here as an adults. I sat tests, paid a lot of money out and tens of thousands over the years on family visas too. I’ve worked professional jobs and paid high taxes, contributed to the economy hugely as a family. No luck or charity offered, I had skills and I paid like my parents with their leave. As did my husband.
I just think it’s home, I have worked and earned a right for equality under the laws of the land. I’m not feeling lesser for it, on special behaviour .
I don’t think that’s entitled

OP posts:
EdithStourton · 13/09/2023 18:46

BiscuitsandPuffin · 12/09/2023 22:24

I think it's the height of rudeness to turn up in a foreign country, shit on it repeatedly (this wasn't his first rodeo), and expect to be able to stay.
Utterly entitled, in fact.

Edited

That's pretty much how I feel - and I have lived abroad, and considered myself lucky to be able to do so.

If you block a major crossing like Dartford, you must know that you will cause some combo of stopping a blue-lighted ambulance/ stop an organ on its way to a transplant that someone has waited for for years/ cause people to miss funerals of friends and relations/ stop people getting to their hospital appointments or critical operations or chemo. Do that sort of thing, and you will lose allies.

There was a protest where I live some years ago which could have blocked the road, but given the risks of delaying the emergency services the organisers took good care to ensure that it didn't.

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:45

frecklejuice · 13/09/2023 18:34

Absolutely no sympathy from me, I was caught up in the traffic at the dartford toll as I was driving from Kent to Essex to take my mum to a hospital appointment.. Left myself two hours and she still missed it, had to wait 8 weeks for another one.

Pain in the arse the lot of them and maybe this will show them that actions have consequences.

My child also missed a hospital appointment due to picketing during train strikes and travel chaos being beyond all my contingency plans. No one has been deported for not standing down their protest (and I wouldn’t want them to be).

OP posts:
WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:43

Insommmmnia · 13/09/2023 18:31

*But it’s about the ‘good’ windrush to them, they are acceptable, but not the failed little boys raised here who disproportionately face the justice system or are sentenced harshly. They matter too, not just the ideal immigrants.

I believe people born, raised and schooled here should have equal rights
I believe people shouldn’t be disadvantaged by their parents’ immigration status and there should be a pathway for those who turn 18 in the UK for those with no links to any other country and long term childhood residence or birth here. For example automatic rights for continuous residence since primary school with no care covers abroad.
Many people came over in good faith when visas were more relaxed. Their children shouldn’t be treated as foreign because of this, their children are equal to mine*

Literally none of which actually applies to the person you started the thread about.

But now you are making out like if posters are okay with a man on a temporary work visa who gave up work being deported then they are equally okay with people who grew up here being deported.

I agree that people who have gone through schooling here should have an easy pathway to continuous residence. That doesn't mean I think someone on a temporary work visa shouldn't be deported if they stop working, with or without a criminal record.

When asked directly the same posters who have played the whataboutery card have not been willing to say they aren’t ok. They’ve been asked directly a few times after they themselves raised the Windrush issue. It became part of the thread as it developed and others tried to claim it was about one man being a special case.
If anything posters have doubled down on the idea of deporting anyone without full citizenship for minor crimes

OP posts:
WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:40

DerekFaker · 13/09/2023 18:34

Yeah plus numerous threads every week about how bad the Tories are and how awful Brexit has been.

Having said that, I agree that the punishment seems overly harsh. And I say that as someone who hates JSO protesters and their tactics.

Edited

I think you are one of the first people to manage to separate the concepts of what you like or support from what is just.

Others are making it about disliking him, meaning he should be deported. I also disagree with the action, think he’s stupid and feel no affinity- despite what others are trying to claim to justify their position.

Ultimately though being an idiot isn’t usually a reason for a sentence of a similar scale or deportations.

OP posts:
DerekFaker · 13/09/2023 18:39

Ok, now I have rtft, I see there is more to the story as per

frecklejuice · 13/09/2023 18:34

Absolutely no sympathy from me, I was caught up in the traffic at the dartford toll as I was driving from Kent to Essex to take my mum to a hospital appointment.. Left myself two hours and she still missed it, had to wait 8 weeks for another one.

Pain in the arse the lot of them and maybe this will show them that actions have consequences.

DerekFaker · 13/09/2023 18:34

BiscuitsandPuffin · 12/09/2023 22:28

LMAO I find it quite left. Anti-private schools, anti-second homes, anti-landlords, people saying "read the room" ad infinitum if a poster has a problem that involves them having more than £5 in the bank, always turning things into some sort of social issue...

Yeah plus numerous threads every week about how bad the Tories are and how awful Brexit has been.

Having said that, I agree that the punishment seems overly harsh. And I say that as someone who hates JSO protesters and their tactics.

Insommmmnia · 13/09/2023 18:31

*But it’s about the ‘good’ windrush to them, they are acceptable, but not the failed little boys raised here who disproportionately face the justice system or are sentenced harshly. They matter too, not just the ideal immigrants.

I believe people born, raised and schooled here should have equal rights
I believe people shouldn’t be disadvantaged by their parents’ immigration status and there should be a pathway for those who turn 18 in the UK for those with no links to any other country and long term childhood residence or birth here. For example automatic rights for continuous residence since primary school with no care covers abroad.
Many people came over in good faith when visas were more relaxed. Their children shouldn’t be treated as foreign because of this, their children are equal to mine*

Literally none of which actually applies to the person you started the thread about.

But now you are making out like if posters are okay with a man on a temporary work visa who gave up work being deported then they are equally okay with people who grew up here being deported.

I agree that people who have gone through schooling here should have an easy pathway to continuous residence. That doesn't mean I think someone on a temporary work visa shouldn't be deported if they stop working, with or without a criminal record.

QuizzlyBear · 13/09/2023 18:28

When rapists get months (if they even have the case taken to court!) and violent crimes less, I think it's ridiculous. Pandering to the 'anti forriners' crowd, as usual.

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:28

MonoLisa · 13/09/2023 18:25

You just jumped to Windrush because you were told Yabu

No, because it was raised by a previous poster.

OP posts:
MonoLisa · 13/09/2023 18:25

You just jumped to Windrush because you were told Yabu

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:20

yogasaurus · 13/09/2023 17:49

but not the failed little boys raised here who disproportionately face the justice system or are sentenced harshly.

So they should be let off? Upbringings should be reflected in sentences? What do you want to happen? The victims would have a different view I’m sure

I believe people born, raised and schooled here should have equal rights
I believe people shouldn’t be disadvantaged by their parents’ immigration status and there should be a pathway for those who turn 18 in the UK for those with no links to any other country and long term childhood residence or birth here. For example automatic rights for continuous residence since primary school with no care covers abroad.
Many people came over in good faith when visas were more relaxed. Their children shouldn’t be treated as foreign because of this, their children are equal to mine

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 13/09/2023 17:59

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:43

The City. The square mile, where they turn up each year to smash windows and graffiti the buildings.

And yes, they are definitely thick, which is why they are gluing themselves to roads rather than engineering better solutions for green technology and decarbonisation of our economy.

Oh, I see, you didn't refer to The City in capitals so it wasn't clear what city you were/are referring to. The people I watched on the documentary weren't smashing up The City!

How do you know the extent of their projects, every one of them, all members of this group? It is short sighted to be so absolute in your convictions and dare I say it, not demonstrative of intelligence.

Begsthequestion · 13/09/2023 17:57

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 17:43

The City. The square mile, where they turn up each year to smash windows and graffiti the buildings.

And yes, they are definitely thick, which is why they are gluing themselves to roads rather than engineering better solutions for green technology and decarbonisation of our economy.

Another poster who could do with reading up on civil disobedience.

Begsthequestion · 13/09/2023 17:56

MoxieFox · 13/09/2023 17:18

The protesters are all about getting into the news- their actions are purely attention seeking. How are they going to reach this illiterate population you speak of that do not read or watch the news and are also apathetic and don’t know anything about the climate or the environment? I don’t think this segment of the population exists. Where did you get the idea they do?

Edited

Who told you their only goal was to get in the news?

The idea is to apply pressure to the government to take climate change seriously and stop investing in oil.

Maybe you need to read up a bit on how civil disobedience functions.

CMZ2018 · 13/09/2023 17:51

Yeah get rid of him