Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dartford Crossing protester, possible deportation

262 replies

WildAlphabet · 12/09/2023 21:37

Essex radio did an interview with the partner of a protester who climbed the dartford bridge as part of Just Stop Oil.

The gist of it is he was surprised to get three years in prison, they expected a few months. The length of his sentence means he’s facing deportation, as a German national.

They did a phone in, and I was quite surprised that even the angry radio essex listeners they put on, who were massively against his actions, disagreed with deportation as additional punishment. Some wanted community service to make up for the loss they suffered, others name called, but they thought splitting a family was too much.

I was kind of intrigued how the mumsnet demographic would view it, often being quite rule-bound or conservative. Personally I disagree with the one year rule for deportation, particularly for non violent crimes. It’s out of sync with most of the world. I guess also as a second generation immigrant who could also potentially lose the right to stay here if wrongly convicted, it’s scary on a personal level. It’s played on my mind the last few days

Here’s an article https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

Marcus Decker and Holly Cullen-Davies

Partner of activist trying to stop his deportation - BBC News

German national Marcus Decker is in jail for scaling the Dartford Crossing bridge over the Thames.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Doingtheboxerbeat · 15/09/2023 17:36

I know I'm in the minority here but I hate the idea of punishing people twice , no matter what the crime is. It seems disproportionate . It's like fining someone after sending them to prison - how would they ever be able to pay?
Massive prison sentence OR massive fine OR deportation - pick one.

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 17:32

To the above replies:

Totally agree about the shoplifting point but it's not a battle between protesters and poor people.

No-one 'needs' to protest at all, it is their right.

He hasn't breached his visa. Edit: to clarify that, why wasn't he deported already?

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:22

“He didn't breach his visa, the only reason he will be deported is the unecessary prison sentence.”

He breached the requirements of his pre-settled status which is a type of 5yr visa for EU nationals that arrived before Brexit day.

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:00

Prison for protest is nothing but tyranny.

I disagree because this was more than protesting.
In addition shoplifting can get you landed in prison even if you are stealing essential items like food or nappies and formula for a hungry baby.

I think prison for a minor nonviolent crime done out of desperation because you or your children are starving to death is tyranny.

No one needs to protest in the manner he did. It’s not a necessity for life. He could have protested without endangering the lives of innocent bystanders.

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 16:20

Thanks OP, seems I was right.... a completely over the top law with a nasty knock-on effect. He didn't breach his visa, the only reason he will be deported is the unecessary prison sentence.

I don't support their protest btw, I think disrupting peoples' lives to the extent they did is entirely unacceptable (and that's from someone who defends anyone's right to protest / use civil disobedience). I was as annoyed as anyone the police weren't dealing with these people more quickly*. But being arrested - or even found guilty - is not the same as being sent down. Prison for protest is nothing but tyranny.

*with hindsight I think they were deliberately left in order for Government to make these legal changes. I recall anti-lockdown protesters weren't left to their own devices, they had cops lining up and charging at them swinging batons around like some scene from a medieval battle. Funny Dishy Rishi and his mob of morons weren't too worried about the legal side then....

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/09/2023 12:26

He chose to break the law, as an adult he accepts the consequences

Quite

And if his OH "doesn't want to break up the family" - probably something she's been coached to argue - why not go to Germany with him?

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 12:23

WildAlphabet · 14/09/2023 11:20

I don’t know the past laws, I’ve questioned it to be honest. As a very young child I also spent a few years abroad on and off with grandparents that may have complicated it. I’m not entirely sure they couldn’t have better navigated the system and I don’t have clear proof if they had work or ILR then. They had younger children with special needs after me, I was unsure myself the rules, they had financial crisis. I left home young in it all… I think they may have dropped the ball, but I can’t prove it and to be honest what’s the point. It happened and as an under 18 it was out of my hand. I just know when I dealt with it there was no recourse over 18 to claim

It doesn’t help that the government changes the immigration rules and laws very frequently so you don’t know from one year to the next what you could or could not apply for. I’m really glad you managed to navigate it all and get the citizenship in the end. It must have been really challenging as an 18yr old.

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 12:20

pre-settled status under EU law.

Thank you for updating the thread on his immigration status. Unfortunately, the requirements of pre-settled status mean that he would still end up deported either now or when his 5yr visa expired even if he had gotten a much much lower custodial sentence, 1 day even.

”5.7. Breaks in continuous residence due to a prison sentence of any length
Residents with pre-settled status who have been convicted for an offence and receive a prison sentence, or have been detained in a young offender institution, will be considered to have broken their continuous residence regardless of the duration of the prison sentence or detention. As a result, they will not qualify for settled status and would lose their residence rights. These residents will not receive a deportation order if the offence is not sufficiently serious to trigger one, so they would not necessarily be aware that they have lost their right to be permanent status in the future. For example, a 20-year-old with pre-settled status may receive a few weeks sentence for possession of drugs if they had a past conviction (e.g. for shoplifting). This short sentence represents a break in continuous residence which would make them ineligible for settled status.”
https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/reports/how-secure-is-pre-settled-status-for-eu-citizens-after-brexit/

How Secure is Pre-Settled Status for EU Citizens After Brexit? - Migration Observatory

This report identifies several features of the EU Settlement Scheme that will impact the ability of vulnerable residents to upgrade their status.

https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/reports/how-secure-is-pre-settled-status-for-eu-citizens-after-brexit/

WildAlphabet · 14/09/2023 11:20

MonoLisa · 14/09/2023 11:15

I don't know how long ago was that but your parents could have applie for you even if they had ILR not just citizenship before you were 18 considering you were born here and spent childhood here

Edited

I don’t know the past laws, I’ve questioned it to be honest. As a very young child I also spent a few years abroad on and off with grandparents that may have complicated it. I’m not entirely sure they couldn’t have better navigated the system and I don’t have clear proof if they had work or ILR then. They had younger children with special needs after me, I was unsure myself the rules, they had financial crisis. I left home young in it all… I think they may have dropped the ball, but I can’t prove it and to be honest what’s the point. It happened and as an under 18 it was out of my hand. I just know when I dealt with it there was no recourse over 18 to claim

OP posts:
MonoLisa · 14/09/2023 11:15

WildAlphabet · 14/09/2023 11:11

Because when I turned 18 my parents didn’t have citizenship. Student visas, then still in the succession of work visa stage.
Your parents need to have full citizenship, and you be their dependent, before you are 18.

I don't know how long ago was that but your parents could have applie for you even if they had ILR not just citizenship before you were 18 considering you were born here and spent childhood here

WildAlphabet · 14/09/2023 11:11

SueVineer · 14/09/2023 11:07

Why have you “sat tests”, etc if you’re a second generation immigrant (as you claim)? I’m a second generation immigrant and have been a citizen all my life as would usually be the case.

Because when I turned 18 my parents didn’t have citizenship. Student visas, then still in the succession of work visa stage.
Your parents need to have full citizenship, and you be their dependent, before you are 18.

OP posts:
SueVineer · 14/09/2023 11:07

WildAlphabet · 13/09/2023 18:52

I’ll be honest, I don’t feel lucky to have acquired a passport here as an adults. I sat tests, paid a lot of money out and tens of thousands over the years on family visas too. I’ve worked professional jobs and paid high taxes, contributed to the economy hugely as a family. No luck or charity offered, I had skills and I paid like my parents with their leave. As did my husband.
I just think it’s home, I have worked and earned a right for equality under the laws of the land. I’m not feeling lesser for it, on special behaviour .
I don’t think that’s entitled

Why have you “sat tests”, etc if you’re a second generation immigrant (as you claim)? I’m a second generation immigrant and have been a citizen all my life as would usually be the case.

WildAlphabet · 14/09/2023 11:07

Oh I just found this statement:
https://settled.org.uk/statement-about-the-case-of-marcus-decker/

It says he did not breach a work visa, he had pre-settled status under EU law.
I’m not from an EU country so not totally sure- but isn’t this not tied to work? Just that he lived here prior to Brexit and the existing EU law carried over for people here? Where are people seeing the work visa thing? I’m open to it- I just can’t find it.

Apparently it’s also the first case of deportation linked to a protest here, so I guess that’s why it’s newsworthy- especially on the back of the new laws around the restrictions of protests and the reduction of the automatic sentence for deportation from 4 years to 1 year.

Statement about the case of Marcus Decker - Settled

Settled is a registered charity, accredited to give immigration advice at OISC level 3. In the last 4 years Settled has provided immigration advice directly to more than 40 thousand EU citizens: in-person, online or through telephone helplines. Settled...

https://settled.org.uk/statement-about-the-case-of-marcus-decker/

OP posts:
WildAlphabet · 14/09/2023 11:00

I didn’t read up any further beyond the phone in and quickly scanning that article to link for anyone who wanted info. His particular case is obviously different if he would actually be liable to deportation without the prison term, because it’s not actually the cause of his deportation order if it’s true what others have researched. He’d have been deported if caught anyway. I haven’t really followed the news that much on just stop oil, nor is it my friendship circle so I’m not as read up as others on the backgrounds. I don’t drive much in day to day life so the impact hasn’t hit me either, bar avoiding journeying for a few days near dartford. If he has actively chosen to breach his visa, not follow all the routes accessible to him and knowingly deliberately left work well he did enter an inevitable situation by choice. If it’s true and it’s wilfully misleading the reporting then I can’t support his particular person.

I do however still disagree in the wider sense with the blanket one year automatic rule for those here legally and think it has a disproportionate impact.

I laughed out loud at @Superfood and the outrage about having your views questioned. You slung enough mud at me, ignored all clarifications and clear answers to push a weird agenda that I have a thing advocating for rich white people only. Then when you are questioned yourself on the same vein you are full of outrage. I’m no lesser being, nor are you special on here. If you chose to twist people’s words, imply awful things about them then people may in turn question you are your motives like I did. Especially when you evade answering, in particular the direct question about deporting. You accept some groups are facing institutional racism, are disadvantaged and disproportionately hit by the law- but do you accept that this law is harming those groups mainly. Not the odd white man, they get caught up, but the wider impact is not mainly people with the resources to correctly and easily follow immigration rules and costs. I don’t generally ask if people are racist, I presume they are decent, but you implied it was my motive enough and since it was such a forefront thing for you- it was worth exploring the exact position since you brought it to the thread. Don’t accuse others and twist their posts if you want the same courtesy

OP posts:
MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 10:01

RamsesTheChub · 14/09/2023 05:26

That's not what the article says. I don't know if you're right or if you're making it up to suit your opinion, but yes if someone breaches their visa I have no issue with them being deported. Equally if someone commits a serious crime.

I've seen no evidence this is the case here and I don't agree with jailing people for protesting.

The article says it. He left his job as a musician to be a JSO protester and is of NFA. Musician is a shortage occupation where it is cheap and easy to get a work visa. The requirements of a work visa is that you have a job in the category of your visa, you do not quit that job, and you earn a minimum amount of money each year.

Obviously, they either didn’t know he’d left his job and was in violation or they did but could not find him as “no fixed address” is what people who are in hiding do not just the homeless. Then he showed up in a hammock on a bridge so they caught him out. Tons of visa holders get away with violating their visa until they are caught out for something else or a triggering event happens like no tax return, or the visa expired and wasn’t renewed.

VegMam · 14/09/2023 09:58

MonoLisa · 14/09/2023 09:46

No, it's putting ordinary people against each other for absolutely minimum climate gains so while they fight amongst each other, the actual mega polluters are left alone.

There are many examples of these protest groups directly protesting large corporations, banks, oil and gas, private jets etc., they don’t only target public roads but that’s what gets media attention.

But protest is not the only option, here’s a handy list of options http://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/

and if you already do most of those things then amazing! But most aren’t do anything much and that’s a problem.

9 things you can do about climate change

With so many experts on climate change here at Imperial, many people ask us what they personally can do about it?

http://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/

MoxieFox · 14/09/2023 09:55

Begsthequestion · 13/09/2023 17:56

Who told you their only goal was to get in the news?

The idea is to apply pressure to the government to take climate change seriously and stop investing in oil.

Maybe you need to read up a bit on how civil disobedience functions.

Their stated idea is to put pressure on the government to take climate change seriously, but that is a smoke screen. The U.K. has been taking climate change seriously since the 1990s. As a pp said, we have quietly halved our CO2 per capita and on an absolute scale have reduced total CO2 by almost 40%.

So it’s protesting under a false premise as climate change is already being taken seriously. The whole “investment in oil” is a red herring too because oil only affects the climate if you burn it. Millions of barrels of oil are needed for other industries- pharmaceuticals, agriculture, engine lubricants (including the wind turbines), and cosmetics.

Investment in oil to maintain a gentle down trend in the production and use of oil until we have phased out the burning of oil (petrol and diesel), is both necessary and also especially needed to combat the impact of climate change on agriculture so that we don’t all starve to death.

This means that all the leaders of JSO and XR are doing is attention seeking with the aim to get into the news in order to recruit more gullible but good intentioned but vulnerable pensioners to their cause as well as get them to donate money to them.

One reason XR keeps creating splinter groups like JSO and Insulate Britain is due to serious questions being asked about where the money they have raised through donations has gone? And why leaders of these groups seem so flush with money and property all of a sudden?

There is a boldness to many thinking it is right and proper that they be paid a high salary from these donations to be essentially paid activists, supppsedly pressuring the government to do something it has been doing these past 30yrs. It’s win-win because they can fabricate crises, do a protest, and then claim credit for progress they had nothing to do with.

MonoLisa · 14/09/2023 09:46

VegMam · 14/09/2023 09:34

Of course the ordinary Joe can do something! Saying that is just a cop-out for the people who are too lazy / selfish / entitled etc. to do something.

No, it's putting ordinary people against each other for absolutely minimum climate gains so while they fight amongst each other, the actual mega polluters are left alone.

VegMam · 14/09/2023 09:34

MonoLisa · 14/09/2023 07:11

Except that an ordinary Joe in UK just living their normal live has very little they can actually do to actually make difference.
So blocking us from work/hospital/visots etc is useless bullying of small flies because they can't get to the big ones with private jets and emmissions like 7k of normal people a year.

ALSO! Maybe he should go and proteat his own government about closures of their nuclear power plants.

Of course the ordinary Joe can do something! Saying that is just a cop-out for the people who are too lazy / selfish / entitled etc. to do something.

Insommmmnia · 14/09/2023 08:12

@RamsesTheChub it's been reported that he gave up his job to be a climate activist.

Now if thats the media twisting things then fair enough. But as it stands as far as we, the public, can tell he has broken the terms of his visa and is therefore eligible for deportation irrespective of his crime.

MonoLisa · 14/09/2023 07:11

Fifireee · 14/09/2023 05:29

In the decades to come as climate change continues to ravage the earth we will look back at this incredulous.

Except that an ordinary Joe in UK just living their normal live has very little they can actually do to actually make difference.
So blocking us from work/hospital/visots etc is useless bullying of small flies because they can't get to the big ones with private jets and emmissions like 7k of normal people a year.

ALSO! Maybe he should go and proteat his own government about closures of their nuclear power plants.

Fifireee · 14/09/2023 05:29

In the decades to come as climate change continues to ravage the earth we will look back at this incredulous.

RamsesTheChub · 14/09/2023 05:26

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 23:25

He’s breached the terms of his visa by leaving his job.

Should we ignore visa conditions for everyone, or just him?

That's not what the article says. I don't know if you're right or if you're making it up to suit your opinion, but yes if someone breaches their visa I have no issue with them being deported. Equally if someone commits a serious crime.

I've seen no evidence this is the case here and I don't agree with jailing people for protesting.

DdraigGoch · 13/09/2023 23:49

Superfood · 13/09/2023 11:32

Not all deportees have committed crimes. Do you not understand this?

This thread is specifically asking about whether a given crime is serious enough to warrant deportation as part of the punishment. This thread has nothing to do with people who have overstayed their visa/broken up with a partner/no longer have a job etc. Nor anything to do with those who did have the right to remain but there's been a cock-up with the paperwork. Those are separate from criminal justice.

Do you not understand this?

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 13/09/2023 23:25

RamsesTheChub · 13/09/2023 20:23

I'm generally supportive of any protest (whether i agree or not) but I very much disagreed with the way these protests were carried out and felt it took far to long for police to move these people on.

However, I can't see any good reason to jail any of them, let alone deportation.

He’s breached the terms of his visa by leaving his job.

Should we ignore visa conditions for everyone, or just him?