Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dartford Crossing protester, possible deportation

262 replies

WildAlphabet · 12/09/2023 21:37

Essex radio did an interview with the partner of a protester who climbed the dartford bridge as part of Just Stop Oil.

The gist of it is he was surprised to get three years in prison, they expected a few months. The length of his sentence means he’s facing deportation, as a German national.

They did a phone in, and I was quite surprised that even the angry radio essex listeners they put on, who were massively against his actions, disagreed with deportation as additional punishment. Some wanted community service to make up for the loss they suffered, others name called, but they thought splitting a family was too much.

I was kind of intrigued how the mumsnet demographic would view it, often being quite rule-bound or conservative. Personally I disagree with the one year rule for deportation, particularly for non violent crimes. It’s out of sync with most of the world. I guess also as a second generation immigrant who could also potentially lose the right to stay here if wrongly convicted, it’s scary on a personal level. It’s played on my mind the last few days

Here’s an article https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

Marcus Decker and Holly Cullen-Davies

Partner of activist trying to stop his deportation - BBC News

German national Marcus Decker is in jail for scaling the Dartford Crossing bridge over the Thames.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-66756841.amp

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
MoxieFox · 16/09/2023 17:33

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 17:30

"Probably not have been there"

Probably means it is more likely they would not have been there than they would have been there.

Thats a lot more certain than potentially.

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 17:30

"Probably not have been there"

MoxieFox · 16/09/2023 17:29

Seagullchippy · 16/09/2023 10:12

Exactly. And my point earlier in addition to this is that the emergency services do have a responsibility to prepare and plan for emergency road closures and to have backup systems that are fit for the purpose in place. That they failed to do this is not the protestors' fault.

If we were to apportion blame for wider and indirect but predictable if conducting a comprehensive risk assessment, this is probably to a large degree the fault of people who voted for a government whose remit they knew was to cut public services, if, I repeat, we want to play blaming people for indirect results of their actions they could have predicted.

Obviously also, if we're looking at potential, predictable, long-term, indirect risks, the fault with the political and financial power to have begun to produce and use alternative, renewable energy sources a very long time ago.

I have seen no evidence that the emergency services did not
”prepare and plan for emergency road closures and to have backup systems that are fit for the purpose in place”

I rather think this is not unlike say blaming the fire services for not “planning for emergencies” after arsonists fire bomb an Amazon warehouse instead of the arsonists themselves.

You do know that JSO did not submit any of the required notices of a protest prior to climbing the Dartford bridge? They just showed up and did it.

MoxieFox · 16/09/2023 17:23

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 07:10

The article doesn't say the woman was stranded because of the traffic hold up, it says she was stranded. It hangs on whether the ambulance arrived quickly enough, which the article only defines as may have been impacted by the queues - I seem to recall our health services were/are in crisis and ambulances weren't getting to anyone too quickly - so yes I did read but the opinions of this man, which I entirely sympathise with, do not dictate the law.

Of course I understand how his actions are potentially dangerous, so are many activities. If this man is in prison for the appalling accident these poor women suffered, fine. That's not my understanding but happy to be corrected.

It's not about defending one individual prat protester, who's actions I entirely disagree with btw.

Yes it does.
”One woman was stranded on the M20, which led to another woman stopping her car to help her – both were then tragically involved in an accident while waiting on the hard should four hours after the protest had started.”

”A former Detective Chief Inspector, Mick Neville, went further in his interview with The Sun, stating: “Had their irresponsible demo not taken place, the women and van driver would probably not have been there.”
The drivers flooding the M20 were doing so to avoid the appalling traffic caused by the two Dartford Bridge protestors, who were hanging off the bridge, leading to a two-day closure.”

Im going to repeat what the Detective Chief Inspector concluded which chimes with the eyewitness account from Mark Heap- the man present who was injured along with the women who were killed.
Had their irresponsible demo not taken place, the women and van driver probably would not have been there

They wouldn’t have even been on the road to be stranded for four hours on the shoulder and then killed because the traffic jam caused by the protesters created the entire situation.

WildAlphabet · 16/09/2023 10:19

In addition to what you said, for long term planning it’s a bit insane having one crossing point between the sea and central London. If you said that to the average primary school child they’d quickly ask ‘but what happens if that bridge is closed, or breaks or we have high winds for a few days’? It’s a rather special case for saying we should have a contingency plan (as well as another crossing point)

OP posts:
Seagullchippy · 16/09/2023 10:12

WildAlphabet · 16/09/2023 08:05

Ignoring the individual person in this and if people like him or not, two things that stuck me

  • ambulances are in crisis, people are dying due to the shortage- no one is being held to account otherwise apart from him.
  • In our law to be held accountable using there has to be direct causation and or intent to harm. If I for example went hill walking in poor shoes and fell I wouldn’t be prosecuted if a rescuer was harmed reaching me or if someone tripped over my scattered belongings and died. It would be morally wrong I endangered people with my poor choice but it wouldn’t be criminal in the eyes of the law. That’s the norm

Exactly. And my point earlier in addition to this is that the emergency services do have a responsibility to prepare and plan for emergency road closures and to have backup systems that are fit for the purpose in place. That they failed to do this is not the protestors' fault.

If we were to apportion blame for wider and indirect but predictable if conducting a comprehensive risk assessment, this is probably to a large degree the fault of people who voted for a government whose remit they knew was to cut public services, if, I repeat, we want to play blaming people for indirect results of their actions they could have predicted.

Obviously also, if we're looking at potential, predictable, long-term, indirect risks, the fault with the political and financial power to have begun to produce and use alternative, renewable energy sources a very long time ago.

WildAlphabet · 16/09/2023 08:05

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 07:10

The article doesn't say the woman was stranded because of the traffic hold up, it says she was stranded. It hangs on whether the ambulance arrived quickly enough, which the article only defines as may have been impacted by the queues - I seem to recall our health services were/are in crisis and ambulances weren't getting to anyone too quickly - so yes I did read but the opinions of this man, which I entirely sympathise with, do not dictate the law.

Of course I understand how his actions are potentially dangerous, so are many activities. If this man is in prison for the appalling accident these poor women suffered, fine. That's not my understanding but happy to be corrected.

It's not about defending one individual prat protester, who's actions I entirely disagree with btw.

Ignoring the individual person in this and if people like him or not, two things that stuck me

  • ambulances are in crisis, people are dying due to the shortage- no one is being held to account otherwise apart from him.
  • In our law to be held accountable using there has to be direct causation and or intent to harm. If I for example went hill walking in poor shoes and fell I wouldn’t be prosecuted if a rescuer was harmed reaching me or if someone tripped over my scattered belongings and died. It would be morally wrong I endangered people with my poor choice but it wouldn’t be criminal in the eyes of the law. That’s the norm
OP posts:
RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 07:10

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 21:26

Wouldn’t have happened if he hadn’t shut down Dartford Crossing.

“One woman was stranded on the M20, which led to another woman stopping her car to help her – both were then tragically involved in an accident while waiting on the hard should four hours after the protest had started.
Mark Heap, the man trying to help the stranded women, was a passing van driver who has sustained broken bones in his back and a fractured leg in his attempt.
Speaking in an interview from hospital, the 54-year-old said: “[The protestors] may not have intended to hurt anyone but they’ve got blood on their hands now.”

The article doesn't say the woman was stranded because of the traffic hold up, it says she was stranded. It hangs on whether the ambulance arrived quickly enough, which the article only defines as may have been impacted by the queues - I seem to recall our health services were/are in crisis and ambulances weren't getting to anyone too quickly - so yes I did read but the opinions of this man, which I entirely sympathise with, do not dictate the law.

Of course I understand how his actions are potentially dangerous, so are many activities. If this man is in prison for the appalling accident these poor women suffered, fine. That's not my understanding but happy to be corrected.

It's not about defending one individual prat protester, who's actions I entirely disagree with btw.

Boomboom22 · 15/09/2023 23:38

I don't understand how people can defend what he did as a protest.

Againstmachine · 15/09/2023 22:05

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:11

His 'crime' was a protest. If he's not here legally as you claim, just send the fucker home with a slapped wrist. It's not rocket science.

I hardly think hanging in a hammock high in the sky is endangering other peoples' lives. The cops didn't deal with any of these morons when they were blocking roads, they brought them tea and support.

You do realise someone hanging in hammock or dropping something from a big height can be dangerous.
It's a bit worrying you don't understand this.

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 21:34

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:27

Nothing to do with the BMW crossing three lanes then.

Its so obvious you didn’t click on the link I posted to read the full story on how these two women tragically lost their lives because of this protester and his partner’s actions.

I have had to cut and paste from the article and post excerpts because you seem to want to deny their actions had anything to do with the deaths they caused.

Who is this man to you? How can you defend protest tactics that have directly caused people to die horribly and suddenly?

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 21:26

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:27

Nothing to do with the BMW crossing three lanes then.

Wouldn’t have happened if he hadn’t shut down Dartford Crossing.

“One woman was stranded on the M20, which led to another woman stopping her car to help her – both were then tragically involved in an accident while waiting on the hard should four hours after the protest had started.
Mark Heap, the man trying to help the stranded women, was a passing van driver who has sustained broken bones in his back and a fractured leg in his attempt.
Speaking in an interview from hospital, the 54-year-old said: “[The protestors] may not have intended to hurt anyone but they’ve got blood on their hands now.”

EdithStourton · 15/09/2023 19:58

CousinGoldfinch · 15/09/2023 18:59

I don't even understand why he was jailed for climbing a bridge and protesting.

I would imagine because he caused massive disruption, resulting in people missing medical appointments, funerals and God knows what else.

CousinGoldfinch · 15/09/2023 18:59

I don't even understand why he was jailed for climbing a bridge and protesting.

Nagado · 15/09/2023 18:53

They did a phone in, and I was quite surprised that even the angry radio essex listeners they put on, who were massively against his actions, disagreed with deportation as additional punishment. Some wanted community service to make up for the loss they suffered, others name called, but they thought splitting a family was too much

It’s not an additional punishment. It’s a direct consequence of him doing something that changed his immigration status. Also, it’s not splitting up a family. He doesn’t have a family here. He’s got a girlfriend. They don’t live together. That isn’t a family unit. And even if it were, the girlfriend says she agreed to him doing something that would cause him to be imprisoned for several months. Where was their concern for their family unit then?

If nobody died because Emergency services couldn’t reach them in time, it is more by luck than judgement. I agree that sentences for violent crimes are way too low but it was pretty obvious that the Courts would look to make an example of him to try and put off anyone looking to do something similar. Any idiot could see that.

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:27

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 18:24

A mother in her 50s and a GP in her 40s have been reported as the two victims, who were hit by a BMW X5 crossing three lanes on Monday morning.
Due to the protest, ambulances and paramedics took 40 minutes to reach the scene in Kent.

Nothing to do with the BMW crossing three lanes then.

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:26

Boomboom22 · 15/09/2023 18:21

If he fell he would make someone a killer, that is not peaceful protest and why the police had to close the road amd divert traffic. You might as well say waving a gun around is protest.

If he fell, he'd be dead. Your analogy makes no sense.

Besides, what's so difficult to understand about thinking the police should have the power - which they always had - to deal with disruption but it not resulting in a custodial sentence?

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 18:24

A mother in her 50s and a GP in her 40s have been reported as the two victims, who were hit by a BMW X5 crossing three lanes on Monday morning.
Due to the protest, ambulances and paramedics took 40 minutes to reach the scene in Kent.

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 18:23

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:11

His 'crime' was a protest. If he's not here legally as you claim, just send the fucker home with a slapped wrist. It's not rocket science.

I hardly think hanging in a hammock high in the sky is endangering other peoples' lives. The cops didn't deal with any of these morons when they were blocking roads, they brought them tea and support.

Two women were killed because of their hammock in the sky stunt.
https://www.energylivenews.com/2022/10/21/two-people-die-during-just-stop-oil-protest/

Two people die during Just Stop Oil protest - Energy Live News

The victims were hit by a car while waiting in the traffic caused by the Dartford Crossing protest

https://www.energylivenews.com/2022/10/21/two-people-die-during-just-stop-oil-protest/

Boomboom22 · 15/09/2023 18:21

If he fell he would make someone a killer, that is not peaceful protest and why the police had to close the road amd divert traffic. You might as well say waving a gun around is protest.

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 18:11

His 'crime' was a protest. If he's not here legally as you claim, just send the fucker home with a slapped wrist. It's not rocket science.

I hardly think hanging in a hammock high in the sky is endangering other peoples' lives. The cops didn't deal with any of these morons when they were blocking roads, they brought them tea and support.

Boomboom22 · 15/09/2023 18:09

Why are you minimising his offence and calling him a silly boy? People might well have died, ambulances not able to get through, he blocked a major traffic route that pedestrians cannot go on. This is not lawful protest or civil disobedience it is a crime, a serious crime that gets prison time. It is not standing in front of Parliament with a placard getting in the way of the news reporters, he doesn't care about the environment at all if he thinks diverting all traffic onto London Bridge through lez is a good option.
Also why he is not at work? Does he have enough money? If he is claiming benefits that is very very wrong, a rich white middle class German who has overwhelming privilege. It is right that his right to settled status should be removed given the severity of the crime.

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:59

“No-one 'needs' to protest at all, it is their right.”

Its not anyone’s right to protest in a manner that recklessly endangers lives.
Our rights to protest end where other human beings right to life begins.

MoxieFox · 15/09/2023 17:58

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 17:32

To the above replies:

Totally agree about the shoplifting point but it's not a battle between protesters and poor people.

No-one 'needs' to protest at all, it is their right.

He hasn't breached his visa. Edit: to clarify that, why wasn't he deported already?

Edited

He has breached the terms of his pre-settled status which is a type of visa for those on the path to settled status. It’s roughly similar to a partner visa which are also on 5 or 10yr paths to settled status.

As to why he wasn’t deported already, it’s because he has been charged with a crime in the U.K. International law means that criminals get tried and convicted in the country in which they did their crime(s) and that includes foreign national criminals. That’s why we have extradition treaties- to bring back criminals who have done a crime here and then fled the country- so that we can prosecute and try them here, where they did their crime(s).

So that has to be done first. And as I posted up thread. A criminal conviction with prison sentence of “any duration”, (even a few weeks for shoplifting was the example given) means a break in the continuous residence requirement of pre-settled status, thus making the person ineligible to continue on to settled status or get ay other visa. Which then means you are here illegally and leave the country voluntarily for losing your presettled status if a very minor crime and short sentence or if a serious crime it then triggers a deportation order as well.

brownsugarsoymilk · 15/09/2023 17:37

WildAlphabet · 12/09/2023 22:03

I was personally also shocked at a 3 year sentence, like they were. I mean multiple men in the same year were convicted of rape and got a shorter sentence. It’s nearly the average for manslaughter by negligence. I don’t agree with him, but it seems surprisingly harsh to get a sentence up there with someone who has actually directly harmed or killed

The real issue then is that the sentences for rape are far too short.

Swipe left for the next trending thread