Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why it’s unacceptable to eat Veal, but Lamb is fine?

133 replies

Wills · 12/09/2023 14:04

I’ve just returned from a holiday in France where Veal is as common as Lamb yet back here Veal is a big no no but lamb is acceptable? I’m not keen on Beef or Veal, just interested in what the difference is in terms of eating baby animals?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tygertiger · 14/09/2023 19:27

tenbob · 14/09/2023 17:35

Animals behave in the same way when they are being rounded up to go into a nice warm barn to be fed

They aren’t trying to escape the slaughterhouse because they know it’s a slaughter house and they are about to die.
They are trying to escape because that’s what they do

It is beyond stupid to think they can comprehend the concept of what a slaughter house is for and why they are there

Exactly this. My dog is terrified of the vet and shows real fear when he has to go. Doesn’t mean I don’t take him.

Animals will show fear in unfamiliar environments for that reason only. There is much that can be done to mitigate this in abbatoirs - look at the work of Temple Grandin. Her research and proposals are now widespread.

The reality for the majority of farm animals in this country is that actually their death is quick, painless and much better than that of wild creatures (eg deer in the UK which aren’t shot starve to death when their teeth wear down and they can’t chew food, due to the lack of wolves and other natural predators). Slaughter legislation and welfare has made massive progress even in the last ten years. Our goal now should be to eliminate many of the poor practices in factory farms which compromise welfare - which incidentally do not apply to lambs or British veal. Chickens and pigs are the most concerning from a welfare point of view. I don’t buy factory farmed chicken or pork, only free-range, but it’s not the slaughter which stops me buying the factory farmed meat.

tenbob · 14/09/2023 17:35

ABC123DoReMiDoeRayMe · 14/09/2023 12:45

It is in the UK. Even from "red-tractor" approved places.

Animals may not understand death like humans do, but they definitely fear being rounded up and slaughtered. Have you not seen the videos of them trying to escape?

Animals behave in the same way when they are being rounded up to go into a nice warm barn to be fed

They aren’t trying to escape the slaughterhouse because they know it’s a slaughter house and they are about to die.
They are trying to escape because that’s what they do

It is beyond stupid to think they can comprehend the concept of what a slaughter house is for and why they are there

Puppalicious · 14/09/2023 17:11

@squareyedannie if neither were acceptable, then the animal wouldn’t have a life at all. Maybe it’s a philosophical position about whether not existing is better than living a nice life (and then dying - like every living creature) v living a tortured life. Welfare standards make a huge difference.

squareyedannie · 14/09/2023 12:57

@FoodCentre
Wouldn't it be far better if neither were acceptable?
Yes, you're right, one is slightly more palatable than the other.

FoodCentre · 14/09/2023 12:55

squareyedannie · 14/09/2023 12:49

So the difference is that one is given a nice life before they're murdered and the other gets tortured first?

Yes. One is reared suitably and one is treated cruelly. Both animals are slaughtered.

Should we not bother them, and treat all animals in the cheapest (most horrible) way? Of course welfare standards make a difference. Meat isn't going out of fashion anytime soon.

I'd much rather an animal is treated well in its life. But we're all different, eh.

squareyedannie · 14/09/2023 12:49

So the difference is that one is given a nice life before they're murdered and the other gets tortured first?

Alleycatz · 14/09/2023 12:48

toadasoda · 12/09/2023 14:09

Why separated from the mums? It that more cos of the dairy industry rather than veal industry? I've heard cows are sent back to milk immediately after birth to maximise milking, don't know if that's true?

No not immediately because they produce colostrum too like human mammals, typically calves feed off the mother until the colostrum is gone.

ABC123DoReMiDoeRayMe · 14/09/2023 12:45

It is in the UK. Even from "red-tractor" approved places.

Animals may not understand death like humans do, but they definitely fear being rounded up and slaughtered. Have you not seen the videos of them trying to escape?

SerendipityJane · 14/09/2023 07:36

PickAChew · 12/09/2023 14:10

Rose veal isproduced in much less inhumane conditions.

Waitrose sell it - in chop and mince form.

Mmmmmm

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/09/2023 07:27

I wouldn't eat a dog or cat, not because they are cuter or fluffier than sheep but because they are carnivores and in the case of dogs absolutely revolting (they eat their own and other animals' shit and vomit fgs).

Tygertiger · 13/09/2023 22:27

ABC123DoReMiDoeRayMe · 13/09/2023 21:27

So the YouTube videos showing the distressed animals is AI or something? Lies. It's a barbaric industry, and people like you aren't fooling most of us any more.

I’ve seen that kind of footage. It’s generally either not from the UK (other countries’ welfare standards can vary hugely, including the US) or outdated. Eg it usually shows pigs being manually stunned with electrodes to the head when they are stunned until death with gas in modern facilities. They aren’t actually handled by humans at all until they are dead. Similarly chickens are no longer shackled upside down in lines while conscious, but that’s usually still what the footage shows.

It’s also worth remembering that animals have no concept of death. There are strict rules about not slaughtering animals in sight of one another in case they get distressed. However, experiments which measured levels of stress hormones in animals which were allowed to see other animals being killed found no increase. The concept of abbatoirs to us is abhorrent because we imagine how we would feel, but that is because we are scared of death in a way animals simply can’t be.

Similar tactics to the abbatoir videos are used with footage of lab animals. Most of it is either old footage of conditions which are no longer allowed, or overseas facilities.

And no, this isn’t dismissing the contents of the videos: it’s pointing out that they are often misleading and come with their own agenda.

FoodCentre · 13/09/2023 21:34

ABC123DoReMiDoeRayMe · 13/09/2023 21:27

So the YouTube videos showing the distressed animals is AI or something? Lies. It's a barbaric industry, and people like you aren't fooling most of us any more.

There's obviously different standards of animal welfare. Everyone knows this.

I believe pp. I believe the videos showing cruelty. There are tens of billions of livestock in the world. Of course treatment varies!

ABC123DoReMiDoeRayMe · 13/09/2023 21:27

So the YouTube videos showing the distressed animals is AI or something? Lies. It's a barbaric industry, and people like you aren't fooling most of us any more.

Scrowy · 13/09/2023 21:23

Thementalloadisreal · 13/09/2023 11:52

They are looked after and have good lives and then the have a swift dispatch.

Actually it’s usually a very long, slow, painful, loud, inefficient, traumatic and messy slaughter.

Edited

We send around 600 lambs directly to the abattoir every year in batches of around 50 -60 every fortnight from September through to late Feb

They have to be at the local collection centre (3 miles away) for 11am and usually we get our kill sheet (an email from the abattoir detailing the dead weight and condition score of each carcass) through by about 4pm.

The abattoir works very efficiently so unless there is a breakdown of some sort on the line we are fairly confident our lambs are processed within an hour or so of getting there.

Anyone who knows anything about this stuff knows that it is absolutely paramount that animals remain calm before death as otherwise the stress hormones taint the meat and its virtually unusable.

They would also know that every abattoir has an vet on site who is responsible for welfare. If an animal is in a poor condition and not fit for slaughter the farmer who sent it receives a bill for it to be destroyed and disposed of by the vet.

Your posts just make you look like everything you think you know, you learnt from YouTube

Tygertiger · 13/09/2023 20:29

Thementalloadisreal · 13/09/2023 20:23

What an odd question. Vets don’t work in slaughterhouses. But the people who do, have higher rates of depression, and suffer from perpetrator-induced traumatic syndrome (like PTSD but for people who themselves commit violent acts)

Does anyone truly think terrified animals can be swiftly and somehow “humanely” killed, en mass, by methods that frequently miss or fail?

Humans are such hypocrites. There is no reason to eat one animal but not another, pigs are smarter than dogs, lambs are babies just as calves are.

When undercover footage of miserable farmed animals in hideous conditions come out in the news everyone is outraged for about 10 minutes - or they’re rooting for the sheep who escaped the truck on the way to slaughter - then it’s back to a lamb roast for dinner.

Edited

Actually, it’s a legal requirement for UK slaughterhouses to have an Official Veterinarian (OV) as well as CCTV in all areas where animals are held and killed. Google the role of the OV and you’ll see they are highly trained and have wide-ranging powers.

But I’ll take your ignorance as no, you’ve never seen it for yourself.

stayclosetoyourself · 13/09/2023 20:26

Rearing and killing

stayclosetoyourself · 13/09/2023 20:26

Neither is fine but resting veal is even more horrific than the rest of the meat industry

Thementalloadisreal · 13/09/2023 20:23

Tygertiger · 13/09/2023 19:56

Have you actually seen this with your own eyes? Are you a vet?

What an odd question. Vets don’t work in slaughterhouses. But the people who do, have higher rates of depression, and suffer from perpetrator-induced traumatic syndrome (like PTSD but for people who themselves commit violent acts)

Does anyone truly think terrified animals can be swiftly and somehow “humanely” killed, en mass, by methods that frequently miss or fail?

Humans are such hypocrites. There is no reason to eat one animal but not another, pigs are smarter than dogs, lambs are babies just as calves are.

When undercover footage of miserable farmed animals in hideous conditions come out in the news everyone is outraged for about 10 minutes - or they’re rooting for the sheep who escaped the truck on the way to slaughter - then it’s back to a lamb roast for dinner.

derxa · 13/09/2023 20:19

Thementalloadisreal · 13/09/2023 11:52

They are looked after and have good lives and then the have a swift dispatch.

Actually it’s usually a very long, slow, painful, loud, inefficient, traumatic and messy slaughter.

Edited

God Almighty

HangingByYourFingernails · 13/09/2023 20:16

beccahamlet · 13/09/2023 20:00

I choose not to eat any dead babies. Even if they're grown up . I don't normally mention this to anyone, but you did ask.

Did anyone ask you? The OP presumably already knows that some people are vegetarians or vegans and roughly why they make that choice.

She asked why people who refuse to eat one sort of young mammal on humanitarian grounds are happy to eat another sort of young(ish) mammal.

She's had a variety of answers, some of which seem reasonable to her.

chasemeridien · 13/09/2023 20:13

I always wonder about this myself. Personally I can't even drink milk after they told me how it's farmed!

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 13/09/2023 20:02

I wouldn't eat either

beccahamlet · 13/09/2023 20:00

I choose not to eat any dead babies. Even if they're grown up . I don't normally mention this to anyone, but you did ask.

Tygertiger · 13/09/2023 19:56

Thementalloadisreal · 13/09/2023 11:52

They are looked after and have good lives and then the have a swift dispatch.

Actually it’s usually a very long, slow, painful, loud, inefficient, traumatic and messy slaughter.

Edited

Have you actually seen this with your own eyes? Are you a vet?

Thementalloadisreal · 13/09/2023 11:52

They are looked after and have good lives and then the have a swift dispatch.

Actually it’s usually a very long, slow, painful, loud, inefficient, traumatic and messy slaughter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread