Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GP's don't give a shit about menopause

117 replies

GentrifiedLDN · 12/09/2023 11:01

I never realised how hard menopause would hit. For those who haven't been hit this time of their life yet, it fucking sucks ladies - No one and i mean NO ONE tells you how fucking awful this is and how no one gives a shit

I have visited the GP four times now to try and get help, and all they want to do is medicate each individual symptom without addressing the hormone imbalance.

GP seem more concerned about the potential (imo small) risks of HRT than the fact there is a suicidal woman sat in front of them and will fuck you off out the door with a pamphlet about local talking services that take three years to get an appointment at

Anxiety is absolutely awful, it is so bad I have even considered ending it all, as I can NOT live like this much longer

It took my sister four years to get given HRT and feel better.

I am going to have to go private. I can't take this anymore.

OP posts:
olderbutwiser · 12/09/2023 13:49

I disagree - but YANBU if your GP is crap on Menopause.

  • there is loads of chit chat on how crap some GPs are
  • my GPs have been fantastic

It depends on your surgery and your GP.

Pollyputhekettleon · 12/09/2023 13:47

DivaDroid · 12/09/2023 12:49

I'm 41 & almost certainly in peri. I have all the symptoms & been on 150mg (mcg?) of sertraline for a few years for PTSD/depression/GAD
Dr has had me do blood tests & referred for an abdominal ultrasound which I had yesterday.
So far, nothing unusual has turned up.
I feel that because I'm under 45, they dismiss peri straight away!
If scan comes back clear, GP wants to put me on hormonal contraception. Which gives me migraines & affects my mental health negatively.
It does seem that womens health isn't taken seriously or that we might know what is going on with our own bodies.

You can just refuse the contraception and ask to try HRT instead. If they've ruled out other causes then that's the next step.

Crochetablanket · 12/09/2023 13:31

I’m sorry you and so many of us have to go through this.

Firstly take a look at the Newson Clinics plus the balance App produced by Dr Louise Newson https://www.google.com/aclk?sa=l&ai=DChcSEwivrLu0iKWBAxVE8e0KHRaWACoYABABGgJkZw&ae=2&gclid=Cj0KCQjwmICoBhDxARIsABXkXlJN5ZmgH-LF8xz7xPzqN63YRCX36j2NTlWT0_wK1zrtTozpmZizYIQaAvJLEALw_wcB&sig=AOD64_1n3hNrfyioJLsXHsuJg3QY9oFSiw&q&adurl&ved=2ahUKEwjG_a-0iKWBAxUUQUEAHWTgBFsQ0Qx6BAgHEAE you can see them privately and I hear brilliant things about them.
…..all the advise is really useful and CURRENT - which is where a lot of GPs fall down in their advice through lack of training.

About 8 years ago I was peri menopausal and desperate to get help with headaches - sent away with anti depressants and no advice ( I didn’t know I was peri and if someone had even told me that I may have understood more) I didn’t take the anti depressants because in my mind I hadn’t been listened to at all.

So fast forward to now - 3 years post periods - menopause with all the symptoms listed above - I needed to get help but was afraid to go.

I read up on everything - all Newson health stuff NICE guidelines and all the books and podcasts the lot - really armed myself with all the facts - went along and advocated for what I wanted- had a great discussion with my practice AHCP and was prescribed the HRT.

it should be easy OP but sadly we are still being let down by the system. Good look and don’t lose hope!

About us - Newson Health Menopause and Wellbeing Centre

Newson Health has been created to allow women to receive unbiased, evidence-based advice and treatment for perimenopause and menopause. We have created this menopause and wellbeing centre to be a centre of excellence

https://www.google.com/aclk?sa=l&ai=DChcSEwivrLu0iKWBAxVE8e0KHRaWACoYABABGgJkZw&ae=2&gclid=Cj0KCQjwmICoBhDxARIsABXkXlJN5ZmgH-LF8xz7xPzqN63YRCX36j2NTlWT0_wK1zrtTozpmZizYIQaAvJLEALw_wcB&sig=AOD64_1n3hNrfyioJLsXHsuJg3QY9oFSiw&q&adurl&ved=2ahUKEwjG_a-0iKWBAxUUQUEAHWTgBFsQ0Qx6BAgHEAE

Naunet · 12/09/2023 13:25

Slippersandacuppatea · 12/09/2023 12:37

Oh grow up. GP is just about the hardest job in medicine. And I say that as a consultant in a hospital specialty

My own GP was amazing and my friends have universally had great care. This sort of thread always attracts those who have more to say and scares other posters.

OP if it didn’t go well ask to see a different GP who has an interest in women’s health and specifically say you feel HRT may help. It's important to reflect on how you are presenting. If you are suicidal it would be very remiss of a GP not to try and address this as urgent issue on its own else imagine how they would be accused of negligence if they ‘blamed it all on your hormones’. They can’t win.

Nice job proving OPs point.

It’s well documented that women’s health is often not taken seriously in the medical profession, don’t tell me your ignorant of that fact? Also don’t patronise women by suggesting we can’t talk about negative experiences because it scares other women 🙄

TheShinmeister · 12/09/2023 13:14

I’m a fool that thought the menopause just meant hot flushes (which I didn’t really have; just felt warm now and then). Then the anxiety kicked in a few years down the line. The inability to rationalise things. The crying over nothing. Next was the constant weeing with stinging and burning. A few urine infections. Cut to the chase: the gp put me on citalopram to calm me down but missed the vaginal atrophy which was causing the other problem. I researched Ovestin cream and asked for that. It’s sorted out the bladder problems. In fact it’s been miraculous.

Eve223 · 12/09/2023 13:11

My friend went to the GP for help with menopause and all the things you describe OP, but just got told to lose weight and was offered weight loss jabs. No care or concern whatsoever as apparently losing weight helps everything.

MojoDojoCasaHouse · 12/09/2023 13:07

I’m saying YABU because in my experience not all GPs. The first I spoke to was lovely and sympathetic but wanted me to try antidepressants and counselling despite being 48 and having a list of typical peri symptoms.

Luckily after having a meltdown at work I tried again and spoke to a very sensible GP who prescribed HRT without any fight. Another GP added topical cream as well for urogynae symptoms.

No doubt at all that some GPs don’t follow NICE guidelines but some are really good. I’d say don’t give up, go armed with a symptom list and the NICE guidelines.

GentrifiedLDN · 12/09/2023 13:04

Slippersandacuppatea · 12/09/2023 12:37

Oh grow up. GP is just about the hardest job in medicine. And I say that as a consultant in a hospital specialty

My own GP was amazing and my friends have universally had great care. This sort of thread always attracts those who have more to say and scares other posters.

OP if it didn’t go well ask to see a different GP who has an interest in women’s health and specifically say you feel HRT may help. It's important to reflect on how you are presenting. If you are suicidal it would be very remiss of a GP not to try and address this as urgent issue on its own else imagine how they would be accused of negligence if they ‘blamed it all on your hormones’. They can’t win.

HI,
Yes I have tried, four separate times in fact

This however feels part of the issue, in terms of they seem to want to medicate each symptom rather than the actual hormonal imbalance

Heres a tablet for your night sweats
heres a tablet for your palpitations
another for your anxiety
oh and here is another one for your moodswings
and so on and so forth

Instead of 'Lets talk about HRT, and get to the bottom of it'

OP posts:
Laiste · 12/09/2023 13:03

For a bit of balance I would just like to put my hand up and say i'm in the middle of menopause i'm doing ok. The occasional hot flush some nights but throwing the covers off stops it. It's not been hellish for me at all.

BUT - The discussion you've started here is important OP and i'm not saying you shouldn't have started it. You absolutely should!

People, women, (half the population!) shouldn't be having to go to multiple GPs to get the right help for a basic, not out of the ordinary medical problem.

Menopause should not still be this big bloody mystery with treatment being a matter of the GPs opinion!

bridgetreilly · 12/09/2023 13:02

Hot flushes
Night sweats
Some increased anxiety and depression (already on antidepressants)
Aches in joints
Massive mood swings
But the brain fog is what is killing me.

If the GP won’t prescribe HRT whenever I finally manage to get an appointment, they will regret it. I am not in a mood to be messed with…

OneAndDon3 · 12/09/2023 13:00

Interestingly I've had a split experience recently.

I'm 43 so considered quite young for HRT. My GP was supportive and helpful, but openly admitted she didn't know enough about the things that I was specifically talking about (progesterone Vs progestins, plant base body identical estrogen and testosterone) but she was happy to refer me to the menopause clinic after some blood tests.

After the blood tests I spoke to a different female GP who didn't know me or my history at all and who insisted that I wasn't in peri menopause as I was too young, refused to refer me to the clinic and was very dismissive.

It turned out there was a 33 week wait for the clinic so I opted to go private and get seen the next week. I recognise that iam very fortunate to be able to afford the £180 to do that though. The book that really helped me advocate for what I wanted and have an informed conversation was Kate Muir's Everything you want to know about the menopause but were too afraid to ask.

Mouthfulofquiz · 12/09/2023 12:53

@Slippersandacuppatea wow, really going low there. ‘Daily mail reader’ 😂 If you were really a consultant you’d have the brains to do better than that.

foxxymoron · 12/09/2023 12:50

@Slippersandacuppatea Ah sorry, then I apologise, and I do actually agree with your basic premise.

DivaDroid · 12/09/2023 12:49

I'm 41 & almost certainly in peri. I have all the symptoms & been on 150mg (mcg?) of sertraline for a few years for PTSD/depression/GAD
Dr has had me do blood tests & referred for an abdominal ultrasound which I had yesterday.
So far, nothing unusual has turned up.
I feel that because I'm under 45, they dismiss peri straight away!
If scan comes back clear, GP wants to put me on hormonal contraception. Which gives me migraines & affects my mental health negatively.
It does seem that womens health isn't taken seriously or that we might know what is going on with our own bodies.

Delatron · 12/09/2023 12:49

You need to see a different doctor and the guidelines now are to offer HRT for anyone with those symptoms over the age of 45. Print off the guidelines, ask to see another doctor and to be honest I’d also make a complaint. We shouldn’t have to fight for HRT.

We have a menopause specialist at our doctors. You should ask to see if you have one. She was willing to give me HRT if I wanted despite a breast cancer history.
So all practices are different but do try again.

Slippersandacuppatea · 12/09/2023 12:48

foxxymoron · 12/09/2023 12:46

@Slippersandacuppatea Bang out of order. OP is clearly suffering, and if your response (as a consultant) is to tell her to "grow up" then I put it to you, that you are in the wrong profession.

I wasn’t responding to the OP if you read it but to a past poster taking cr*p about how all GPs are useless and overpaid and only care about money and the golf course

Slippersandacuppatea · 12/09/2023 12:47

ZebraD · 12/09/2023 12:41

Grow up?! How patronising are you?!
If you are a consultant then perhaps you are just too arrogant to diss your own profession.
GP’s are widely known to be dismissive and ineffective. They don’t even want to do their job - face to face appointment anyone?! You have confirmed what I M saying in your own post - why on earth should OP have to see another GP! The job is supposed to be too important to get it wrong!

Edited

oh rant away you sound like a Daily Mail reader so it’s all noise.

foxxymoron · 12/09/2023 12:46

@Slippersandacuppatea Bang out of order. OP is clearly suffering, and if your response (as a consultant) is to tell her to "grow up" then I put it to you, that you are in the wrong profession.

HeyHoTheWindAndTheRain · 12/09/2023 12:44

It definitely must depend on the doctor. I went to see my GP earlier this year to try to get a different type of antidepressant as my anxiety had increased over the past six months (I'm 47). The doc suggested I try HRT instead and it's been amazing - I feel a lot better

Gettingbysomehow · 12/09/2023 12:43

I absolutely agree OP, it hit me like a train, I had 6 months off work sick, my marriage broke down and I fell apart - my GP was not interested at all.

foxxymoron · 12/09/2023 12:42

I've found the best kind of GP to talk to about it is a woman going through it herself, so if you can make an appointment in your surgery with the GP mostly likely to be female and above around 45, you will probably get a better quality consultation. Or someone who has a specific interest or specialty in women's health.

ZebraD · 12/09/2023 12:41

Slippersandacuppatea · 12/09/2023 12:37

Oh grow up. GP is just about the hardest job in medicine. And I say that as a consultant in a hospital specialty

My own GP was amazing and my friends have universally had great care. This sort of thread always attracts those who have more to say and scares other posters.

OP if it didn’t go well ask to see a different GP who has an interest in women’s health and specifically say you feel HRT may help. It's important to reflect on how you are presenting. If you are suicidal it would be very remiss of a GP not to try and address this as urgent issue on its own else imagine how they would be accused of negligence if they ‘blamed it all on your hormones’. They can’t win.

Grow up?! How patronising are you?!
If you are a consultant then perhaps you are just too arrogant to diss your own profession.
GP’s are widely known to be dismissive and ineffective. They don’t even want to do their job - face to face appointment anyone?! You have confirmed what I M saying in your own post - why on earth should OP have to see another GP! The job is supposed to be too important to get it wrong!

Grapesoda7 · 12/09/2023 12:39

I used to work in a large GP surgery that had a menopause clinic every fortnight ran by a GP and nurse who both specialised in women's health.
This was over ten years ago.

I don't know how common this type of clinic is, but it might be worth looking if any other local surgeries offer better support than yours and moving GP (if you can)

beguilingeyes · 12/09/2023 12:39

GentrifiedLDN · 12/09/2023 11:05

@beguilingeyes Did you ever get HRT - what happened in the end, or are you still on anti-depressants?

I saw Davina's doc, which was a total lightbulb moment. I'd had a coil fitted because of bad flooding, which I realise now that probably meant that I was peri, but nobody suggested that.
I developed crippling anxiety, my work was badly affected..hence the Citalopram.
After the doc I got an appointment with the Newson clinic and got HRT and my GP has now picked up the prescription.

Slippersandacuppatea · 12/09/2023 12:37

ZebraD · 12/09/2023 12:12

The only thing GP’s care about is their pay packet…which still isn’t high enough for them!

Oh grow up. GP is just about the hardest job in medicine. And I say that as a consultant in a hospital specialty

My own GP was amazing and my friends have universally had great care. This sort of thread always attracts those who have more to say and scares other posters.

OP if it didn’t go well ask to see a different GP who has an interest in women’s health and specifically say you feel HRT may help. It's important to reflect on how you are presenting. If you are suicidal it would be very remiss of a GP not to try and address this as urgent issue on its own else imagine how they would be accused of negligence if they ‘blamed it all on your hormones’. They can’t win.