Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe that my daughter is autistic?

215 replies

lionsandtigers21 · 12/09/2023 09:29

I know that may sound bad, but my dd17 seems utterly convinced that she has autism and ADHD and I just don’t buy it. She wasn’t always an easy child, but I don’t remember her having significant sensory issues or huge trouble with socialising. Now she’s a teenager, I think she may be depressed because she self-isolates so much but I think that’s the crux of it. She changed schools a lot as a child and I’ve also had issues in the past, so I accept that that may have caused problems. But I really can’t see how she would fit onto the autism spectrum. Her main argument is that, as a little girl, she would frequently go off on her own to collect stones (her special interest) and talk to herself instead of socialising or playing with toys, but she did definitely also have friends at that age. What she seems to remember as meltdowns seemed to me more like tantrums, and would normally occur if she was taken somewhere she didn’t want to go, although she did have unexplained tantrums as well (usually saying that she wanted to go home when she was already in the house and wanted to go back to being a baby) and I remember that she would cry dramatically as soon as I picked her up from school and all the way home at a certain period. She also told me that she would do things in class that would definitely been deemed socially inappropriate, liking uninhibitedly touching her private area in front of everyone until relatively late on in primary school and ignore the teacher who told her it was inappropriate, but I think a lot of kids are uninhibited? Things that might be considered ‘stimming’ she has always done to an extreme (she once scratched her face so much that I was convinced she had scabies!), but she could definitely make friends at school if she wanted to, even if she liked to be alone sometimes. Sensory-wise, I can’t really remember any issues aside from her hating me resting my head on her shoulder and putting my chin on her head, she also found things like nail filing very uncomfortable to witness. She insists that she struggles with social cues/situations today and engages in ‘masking’ behaviours where she unconsciously finds herself copying the speech and body language of those around her, but don’t we all do that? No one is the exact person at home and at school. She’s done things before that would suggest she’s a bit clueless, like exposing a lie that I told to my parents in a very excruciating situation (which I blamed her for at the time). There’s also more stuff that I could list, but does any of this override her apparent social competence as a child? I think the issues she has today are a result of lack of experience and isolating herself in a dark room rather than autism/ADHD? I don’t know, maybe I’m being facetious. Has anyone experienced this?
Thank you :)

OP posts:
NoMor · 12/09/2023 20:01

IWillNoLie · 12/09/2023 19:22

You know they spend the majority of the assessment actually assessing the child, right? It isn't just based on what the parent tell them.

On of the main tools used for diagnosing autism is ADI-R (Autism diagnostic interview - revised). This doesn’t involved assessing the child directly but involves a series of interviews with parents focusing on early life. So diagnosis is just based on what the parent tell them.

https://www.pearsonclinical.co.uk/store/ukassessments/en/Store/Professional-Assessments/Behavior/Autism/Autism-Diagnostic-Interview%2C-Revised/p/P100009201.html?tab=product-details

Can't find anything in that link that says this can solely be used to diagnose someone with autism. Any diagnosis done this way would not follow NICE guidelines. Parental questionnaires and a detailed history would never be used as the only basis for diagnosis.

If you know of anyone doing this please report them, they need to be struck off.

IWillNoLie · 12/09/2023 19:22

You know they spend the majority of the assessment actually assessing the child, right? It isn't just based on what the parent tell them.

On of the main tools used for diagnosing autism is ADI-R (Autism diagnostic interview - revised). This doesn’t involved assessing the child directly but involves a series of interviews with parents focusing on early life. So diagnosis is just based on what the parent tell them.

https://www.pearsonclinical.co.uk/store/ukassessments/en/Store/Professional-Assessments/Behavior/Autism/Autism-Diagnostic-Interview%2C-Revised/p/P100009201.html?tab=product-details

Autism Diagnostic Interview, Revised

Autism Diagnostic Interview, Revised

Autism Diagnostic Interview, Revised (ADI-R) is used to diagnose Autism, plan treatment and distinguish Autism from other developmental disorders

https://www.pearsonclinical.co.uk/store/ukassessments/en/Store/Professional-Assessments/Behavior/Autism/Autism-Diagnostic-Interview%2C-Revised/p/P100009201.html?tab=product-details

NoMor · 12/09/2023 16:22

User923081 · 12/09/2023 13:33

You will not get a remotely balanced response to this on MN OP...

The default response on here is 'how dare you question whether somebody has ASD', that 'the reason half the world is now ND is because we were all too pigheaded in the 80s to recognise that half the world was ND and it has nothing to do with the fact our society is, for many reasons, now much more crap for nurturing a young child and getting crapper and that people are growing up fundamentally unhappy and lacking in resilience as a consequence)

I agree with some pp that say it's very easy (especially as you get older) to make your narrative fit the diagnosis rather than visa versa. I've seen this with a friend's child. They had their child assessed as a teen and told barefaced lies about their child to get a diagnosis. They would deny this but they described a kid who never wanted to make eye contact and who didn't play properly as a child etcetc. I spent a lot of time with this child as a baby/toddler and it's 100% not true. However, the clinician assessing them will go by what they're told. This is one reason diagnosis is going up IMO.

Ultimately you don't really have any say in this though OP. Your dd is almost an adult. If she wishes to seek a diagnosis she will be free to. I would just concentrate on giving her love and support, getting her away from her computer screen and enjoying the true joys in life and just be completely neutral to her about ASD. You love her and support her regardless. Ultimately it probably isn't the key to her inner peace and happiness either way but she'll have to find that out for herself

Everyone has a bias, yours is very clear. Is it rooted in reality though...?

Children are brought up lacking in resilience now are they? So why is the suicide rate half what was it was in the 1960s?

You may have friend who you believe, based on spending the occasional hour with her child when they were younger, lied to get them a diagnosis but how did they get that child to act autistic on the day? How did they get the school to agree and the person doing the observation while the mother isn't present? You know they spend the majority of the assessment actually assessing the child, right? It isn't just based on what the parent tell them. Or does that not fit your 'balanced' view?

SensationalSusie · 12/09/2023 15:05

Please believe your daughter if she is reaching out for help and get your GP to do a referral. You may have to provide more information to support this so be aware of that. Waiting times are several years so you might want to go private and have the report ratified by NHS.

I am autistic and had friends. DC has a best friend and is popular…. It isn’t all about the having of friends, it’s about finding socialisation difficult and tiring. Please read up on autism in girls as it presents differently to boys.

Yarnysaurus · 12/09/2023 15:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Poppycock

keffie12 · 12/09/2023 14:54

lionsandtigers21 · 12/09/2023 11:28

Thank you for all the replies. It’s really made me consider the situation and my own behaviour. I just want to make a few things clear, as I think I may have given off the wrong impression about my daughter. She is not trying to self-diagnose and is actually very against self-diagnosis. She is conscious of social contagion and claims that she has often tried to convince herself that she is exaggerating everything, which I find concerning. She is also by no means a social butterfly and friends have been one of her main concerns throughout her school career. Her main struggle is not making them, but keeping them. I’ve had another chat with her and she told me that part of the reason she lives in her own head is because she finds everything about the outside world so overwhelming (including the noises) and tends to focus on individual objects and thoughts when she is walking down the road. She is also very, very prone to daydreaming. Almost as soon as she walks in the door, it’s upstairs, headphones on and rocking/swaying/jumping on the bed, which she says helps stimulate her daydreaming. In answer to another question, she does spend a lot of time online and probably has ample access to people self-diagnosing on TikTok. However, other things like her chronic disorganisation, abilities to go an entire day without eating or eat a hell of a lot in one go, extreme food fussiness, constant lateness (despite being late often provoking an extreme reaction) and determination to avoid demands, which, now I think of it, caused her to miss what could be considered milestones, are definitely red flags. A lot of them I have already seen in family members so they do appear normal to me, with some exceptions. I will seek out a GP appointment.

I'm so glad you have taken the responses and observations on board and are now seeking an assessment that will look at a diagnosis.

You say her main struggle is not the making of friends, not the keeping of them. That is very common with Autism.

I get how you could have missed it now with it seeming normal as other family members present the same.

I wish you and your family well

Zenithia · 12/09/2023 14:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Where exactly can you pay to get a legitimate diagnosis online?

MellyMavis · 12/09/2023 14:45

Her childhood behaviour reminds me of my 5 year old autistic daughter. Although she has a few more 'symptoms' thrown in. She's very and has lots of friends.

LuluBlakey1 · 12/09/2023 14:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mamai90 · 12/09/2023 14:14

Proudgypsy · 12/09/2023 09:39

Does she spend a lot of time online?

Looks to me like she's been viewing (increasingly popular) content of people self diagnosing. They often pick through their life on the way she has, trying to find examples that they can categorise as 'traits'. They remember things the way they want to just to tick off a box.

It's a bit like the trans trend, it's fashionable among certain communities to self diagnose. Many of them it's mental health disorders (like pretending to have multiple personalities) and now more commonly autism and ADHD.

I suppose the only way to know for sure would be an assessment but my guess is that she's done too much research and would lie, not sure how well trained they are in picking that up.

Just to add, the reason I think this is because she seems to have found almost all of the personality traits in herself. This is uncommon, people usually have some but not all.

Edited

This is absolute BS.

It's not 'fashionable' to be autistic 🙄

Mamai90 · 12/09/2023 14:12

My mum is in her 70s and recently spoke to me thinking she might possibly be autistic, now that she's pointed it out I think she could be right but we would have always put it down to her introverted personality.

I honestly think with women and girls their difficulties can be so much more subtle and they are more likely to mask. My friends DD was recently diagnosed aged 20, big surprise to me, she's always had friends too and it didn't appear to me that she had any social struggles.

I think you need to listen to what your DD is saying and support her if she wants to seek a diagnosis.

Tweedledeee · 12/09/2023 14:05

I don’t understand why you wouldn’t want a diagnosis. You are still who you are regardless. But once diagnosed there are lots of Ah-hah moments. And perhaps some aspects that you can develop which no one is looking for as you are assumed NT.

off · 12/09/2023 14:02

IWillNoLie · 12/09/2023 13:45

The fact that you also copy others' body language and speech doesn't mean it's 'normal'. Autism runs in families.
We don't all do it.

Autism does run in families, but yes of course we all copy others’ body language and speech. It is how children (and adults) learn what is socially acceptable and how we become part of the group. The difference is most non-autistic children is is fairly unconscious. But if you were to place yourself in a very different context to your normal context eg formal office environment for work, you would look around at how others sit at the table, how they address each other, the manner of their speech, and adapt your own to fit. We all do.

Even eye contact norms can be very different. It's a while since I read it, so apologies if my details are wrong, but IIRC Japanese (I think?) children learn from very young that they shouldn't make too much direct eye contact with adults as it's considered quite rude (whereas I remember as a British kid being told things like, "Don't be so rude, look at me when you're talking to me!" and while I suspect modern parenting manuals wouldn't condone that, the societal expectations won't have changed much, and typically-developing children will pick up on that).

[We apparently think that staring at each other's glassy, meaningless eyeballs until you can practically feel the hot surface of the other person's corneas on your own is PERFECTLY NORMAL 🤢]

off · 12/09/2023 13:53

You will not get a remotely balanced response to this on MN OP...

The default response on here is 'how dare you question whether somebody has ASD', that 'the reason half the world is now ND is because we were all too pigheaded in the 80s to recognise that half the world was ND and it has nothing to do with the fact our society is, for many reasons, now much more crap for nurturing a young child and getting crapper and that people are growing up fundamentally unhappy and lacking in resilience as a consequence)

Are you reading a different thread to me? I've only seen a lot of responses saying things like, "None of us can diagnose the DD over the internet but as your DD is struggling it may be harmful and damage your relationship to dismiss her concerns out of hand, and there are enough suggestive features in what both you and DD describe that it would seem worth getting professionally assessed by specialists, especially given the apparent level of distress, but also please bear in mind the potential downsides of an official diagnosis, and the effects of this current societal trend for possibly-spurious self-diagnosis of neurodevelopmental conditions, which hopefully the specialists will be well aware of and be able to take into account". (It's funny, though, how the TikTokers and ex-Tumblrites and Twitter self-DX crowd never seem to self-diagnose, for example, foetal alcohol spectrum disorder…)

IWillNoLie · 12/09/2023 13:45

The fact that you also copy others' body language and speech doesn't mean it's 'normal'. Autism runs in families.
We don't all do it.

Autism does run in families, but yes of course we all copy others’ body language and speech. It is how children (and adults) learn what is socially acceptable and how we become part of the group. The difference is most non-autistic children is is fairly unconscious. But if you were to place yourself in a very different context to your normal context eg formal office environment for work, you would look around at how others sit at the table, how they address each other, the manner of their speech, and adapt your own to fit. We all do.

jollyhorse · 12/09/2023 13:37

Woman and girls get very good at masking, I used to come straight home from school and go to my room and rock back and forth until bedtime and at the weekends I'd spend up to 8 hours as a teen in my room rocking my parents never knew, it was just my way of disconnecting from reality and I'd never want them to know, they thought I was doing homework and couldn't understand why I had so many detentions for not doing my homework and such poor grades when I stayed in my room studying all day.

off · 12/09/2023 13:36

She […] claims that she has often tried to convince herself that she is exaggerating everything

Same. Both before and after my adult ASD diagnosis, TBH. Less so now, though, almost a decade on. I don't think about it much these days, and in my head I take a fairly neutral view about what I do and don't "have", neurodevelopmentally — though I acknowledge I meet the criteria and that specialists agree (and I can still ruminate on it when I'm mentally unwell). If I need to disclose, I phrase it as "I have an ASD/ADHD diagnosis", which both avoids taking a position on it in terms of correctness or personal identity, and lends it more credibility in a world of self-DX.

I vacillated a fair bit about the whole being-autistic thing, even after I got a solid NHS diagnostic report from a team headed by a highly specialist neurodevelopmental psychiatrist, who had access to 15 years' worth of my psychiatric notes, plus oodles of questionnaires for me and my parents, and hours of interview. And I still don't totally buy into my (later) ADHD diagnosis. (Happy to have the drugs, though…)

I mean, surely school wasn't that bad, even if I hoped each schoolnight that I wouldn't ever wake up from as far back as I remember, had serious behaviour problems that seemed inexplicable to staff, got kicked out at 10, left another school for the mental hospital at 15, and dropped out of college twice, and anyway I had no excuse for that behaviour and the social misery was entirely my own fault…

…and clearly I'm just finding excuses for myself both in the present and in the past, for what I've put my loved ones through over the years, and am making a big deal out of normal little things when everyone has quirks and difficulties, and anyway isn't it possible I've trained myself into this somehow or am unconsciously putting it on, or I've got learned helplessness, and doesn't it seem more likely I'm actually just wilfully crap at stuff rather than disabled…

…and anyway maybe I met the ASD criteria because the things I'm shit at just coincidentally line up with the things autistic people often struggle with, but the difference is autistic people can't help it, and besides which, isn't it kind of circular anyway, like "why am I shit at this stuff — it's because I'm autistic — how do we know I'm autistic — because I'm shit at this stuff", and also it could be that they only diagnosed me because I knew too much about autism and behaved the "right" way and gave the "right" answers subconsciously-on-purpose, and there are so many things that I can do just fine that real autistic people struggle with, and obviously if I put more effort in I could do the things that I prefer to believe my autism makes difficult…

…so maybe I'm just lazy, attention-seeking, gullible, manipulative, unlikeable, selfish, tactless, lack resilience…

Or alternatively:

I know I have this diagnosis but I don't want to be autistic, that would mean there was no hope I could ever be different, this means I have a faulty, substandard brain that doesn't work like it should [even though I don't think like that about other autistic people, obviously!], so maybe I should try being not autistic-like, and instead of using autism as a pathetic excuse to be crap, realise that I'm not actually autistic and get on with it, not lumber myself with a lifelong condition, and I know I've never yet managed it but I must've not been trying all those previous times…

And on and on and on. I'm an overthinker. Maybe it's because I'm autistic, or maybe it's a personal flaw that I could get over it I only put in the effort Grin

Maybe your DD's thought process is similar, maybe not, but what you describe her saying — that self-doubt about your own subconscious motivations — is something I find very familiar, and I don't think it's that uncommon a thought to have, at least among later-diagnosed people.

User923081 · 12/09/2023 13:33

You will not get a remotely balanced response to this on MN OP...

The default response on here is 'how dare you question whether somebody has ASD', that 'the reason half the world is now ND is because we were all too pigheaded in the 80s to recognise that half the world was ND and it has nothing to do with the fact our society is, for many reasons, now much more crap for nurturing a young child and getting crapper and that people are growing up fundamentally unhappy and lacking in resilience as a consequence)

I agree with some pp that say it's very easy (especially as you get older) to make your narrative fit the diagnosis rather than visa versa. I've seen this with a friend's child. They had their child assessed as a teen and told barefaced lies about their child to get a diagnosis. They would deny this but they described a kid who never wanted to make eye contact and who didn't play properly as a child etcetc. I spent a lot of time with this child as a baby/toddler and it's 100% not true. However, the clinician assessing them will go by what they're told. This is one reason diagnosis is going up IMO.

Ultimately you don't really have any say in this though OP. Your dd is almost an adult. If she wishes to seek a diagnosis she will be free to. I would just concentrate on giving her love and support, getting her away from her computer screen and enjoying the true joys in life and just be completely neutral to her about ASD. You love her and support her regardless. Ultimately it probably isn't the key to her inner peace and happiness either way but she'll have to find that out for herself

Tweedledeee · 12/09/2023 13:31

. However, I would find it nigh on impossible to make friends outside of ‘enforced friendships’ and find small talk excruciating.

Aaaah -I have adhd and this description ‘enforced friendships’ explains a lot.
Had friends at school - had friends at college (but not really outside college) and have had almost none since -for decades.
I am now mostly going it alone as that is better than rejection and now I know the reason don’t feel bad about it.

NoMor · 12/09/2023 13:21

12moose · 12/09/2023 11:34

Everyone is on the spectrum somewhere. She may well have some stronger autistic tendencies. The question is, does it matter? Is it impairing her ability to function in the world?

No they are not. Everyone is on a spectrum, let's call it the spectrum of life, but only autistic people are on the autism spectrum. That's why they call it that.

babbscrabbs · 12/09/2023 13:20

I have a number of female friends who are autistic - but honestly you couldn't tell they were autistic if they were having a good day. And even if they were having a bad one you'd likely say mental health issues rather than anything obviously related to autism. I'm glad you're going to support your DD in getting an assessment.

ntmdino · 12/09/2023 13:16

Zenithia · 12/09/2023 13:13

If you think a teenager would and could lie to professionals to get a diagnosis you are as ignorant about this as you are about most things.

Precisely - in fact, somebody trying to pretend they have a condition like autism or ADHD would be going to great lengths to avoid encountering a professional in a diagnostic setting, for obvious reasons.

Zenithia · 12/09/2023 13:13

Proudgypsy · 12/09/2023 09:39

Does she spend a lot of time online?

Looks to me like she's been viewing (increasingly popular) content of people self diagnosing. They often pick through their life on the way she has, trying to find examples that they can categorise as 'traits'. They remember things the way they want to just to tick off a box.

It's a bit like the trans trend, it's fashionable among certain communities to self diagnose. Many of them it's mental health disorders (like pretending to have multiple personalities) and now more commonly autism and ADHD.

I suppose the only way to know for sure would be an assessment but my guess is that she's done too much research and would lie, not sure how well trained they are in picking that up.

Just to add, the reason I think this is because she seems to have found almost all of the personality traits in herself. This is uncommon, people usually have some but not all.

Edited

If you think a teenager would and could lie to professionals to get a diagnosis you are as ignorant about this as you are about most things.

ntmdino · 12/09/2023 13:12

@lionsandtigers21 - autism, in the late-diagnosed and/or heavy-masking (often the same, but not always), is primarily a condition that affects the internal perception of the world. So...the question is, why do you think you're more qualified to make a judgement on this than she is?

With a parent as dismissive as you seem to be, it's reasonably likely that she's masking even more heavily around you than she is to the rest of the world, so of course you'd have no clue that something else is going on. Hell, even the things she's doing to take a break from all that masking and sensory input - like sitting in a dark, quiet room - are things that almost every autistic person does in order to appear more typical the rest of the time, but you're flipping it to try to make out that's the reason for the problem.

So...why the mental gymnastics to find a variety of different excuses for things she's doing, where there could be a single explanation for all of them? Why not admit that there's even a remote possibility that she's right?

Finally...you ask if anybody else has experienced this. Yes, every late-diagnosed autistic person in the world has experienced this from other people trying to dismiss their lived experience.

EDIT: Missed your reply at the bottom of page 4 - fair play, and well done for taking a moment to reflect and open your mind a bit. Not many can do that.

ParentingSolo · 12/09/2023 13:12

My autistic child has lots of friends! Is incredibly social and in fact, craves time with friends

Swipe left for the next trending thread