Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Meeting: 'Working from home' - your vote needed!

371 replies

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 00:53

Got a meeting invite late tonight titled simply: Working from home'. Scheduled for half an hour. No additional info.

What are they gonna say?

Return to the office full time? Full time WFH???

Your guess is as good as mine. We're currently in once every two weeks.

Results posted in here tomorrow once the meeting has been held.

Yanbu = back to office
Yabu = WFH

OP posts:
SurprisedWithAHorse · 12/09/2023 16:59

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 15:28

UPDATE

Meeting has just been held. We have to go in to the office twice per week.

The team are not happy.

What reasons did they give?

Thosesummernights · 12/09/2023 16:58

Hilarious. The ‘entitlement’ of the managers wanting the team to come back into the office. Shocking. We’re back full time and see way, way better productivity. The team were keen to come back and have some routine.

For a moment, how to you think public facing employees manage it? They can’t WFH. Honestly, if you don’t like it leave but you really have nothing to complain about.

Tracker1234 · 12/09/2023 16:57

I used to work primarily a a supplier to government. They spend months and months discussing what they wanted often with different people attending meetings. At one point myself and my colleague attended a meeting and there were 19 of them! They were showing off to each other and trying to all justify why they were there. Months went by and eventually they chose a cheap and cheerful product which was not a great choice.

Dont get me started on the government dept that refused to get off old technology even though it was so old maintenance wasn’t going to be available. Company was on the hook for the upgrade and even then they dug their heels in.

I spent many hours at their sites and it was truly shocking how they were running their ‘business’. Lots of cottage industry type behaviour and any excuse was used to down tools. Technology was blamed a lot by them when it was their inability to change their ways that was slowing everything down.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 12/09/2023 16:52

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 16:37

I really consider working in the office per se to be a really old fashioned concept. Times move on.

It's not that old. The wfh shift is pretty recent.

There aren't many places with no office base at all.

But I agree a lot of people are still hung up on presenteeism.

You don't need to be in the office to see who's responsive and productive and who isn't.

TrashedSofa · 12/09/2023 16:52

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 16:35

What is wrong with people?

'The team's not happy'. Dear God.

Firstly, you are paid to do a job, and it's the employer's prerogative to decide on the conditions of that employment.

Secondly, while the world has changed since Covid, the idea that means no or barely any time on-site is ridiculous. While many aspects of some roles can be done effectively from home, for many more roles, some time in person is needed. This is often for the less-obvious but integral type of work, like getting to know people, collaboration, building trust, troubleshooting, creative working.

Thirdly, 2 days a week is certainly not an imposition. You still have 3 days a week WFH, and colleagues can continue to benefit from savings to a significant extent, compared to pre-Covid times.

In my workplace we WFH 2 days a week. I'm a manager & I can move my own days around if I need but I do my best to stick to a schedule - it's easier for my team, and me. However, it's always subject to business need. If we need staff on-site they must come in, and if I need to attend in person meetings for example, I'll always come on site.

The level of entitlement from some is crazy.

There's a lot wrong with this post.

The employer's prerogative doesn't outweigh the views of the team. The employer can certainly decide that they're not willing to allow employees to work more than a particular amount from home. The response to that, however, isn't up to them. That will depend on whether they're an attractive enough package in general to be able to enforce their preferred office hours, whether with the current employees or replacements. There's also the possibility that any staff they do manage to unwillingly force in are going to be resentful and that's going to be damaging to team culture. These are not things that can be opted out of, they're part of the workplace and recruitment environment now.

It's not ridiculous to think that the changes since covid mean no or barely any time on site. It completely depends. Some roles need to be fully in person, some not at all, some inbetween. The fact that the OP says her manager thinks it'll go down to 1 day a week and they agree there's no value to them being present in person suggests OPs is at the 'not at all/barely any' end of the spectrum.

You're allowed not to think 2 days in the office is an imposition, but for some it will be, and there's no more wrong with those people than there is with you. Those people will either be able to find a different job with terms more to their liking, or they won't- it's simply part of the workings of the market now. Neither employees nor employer are being entitled.

foxxymoron · 12/09/2023 16:51

Throwncrumbs · 12/09/2023 13:37

Council staff all working from home, not actually doing a lot but raking in massive salaries, are now wondering why the organisations they are employed by are all becoming bankrupt. No accountability for any of them. Take the money but not following through on anything. The moneys gone into peoples pockets but not in services. Big issues in lots of places with the same problems. WFH has become the biggest con/ scam ever imo!

I'm not even public sector but this is beyond ignorant.

Council staff all working from home

I mean, that's a lie for a start.

not actually doing a lot but raking in massive salaries

Again, not true. I mean I'm sure it's the case for a few at the top but many of us choose the private sector because it pays better.

The moneys gone into peoples pockets but not in services.

Do....do you not think council workers should be paid a salary?

Big issues in lots of places with the same problems.

Well that's the consequence depletion of budgets, not staff who are apparently, according to you, "all" WFH.

NearlyMonday · 12/09/2023 16:43

Reddog1 · 12/09/2023 16:28

Interesting about HMRC, for whom I worked until last year. They have a newish telephony system, bargain basement. I think they’re happy to let “WFH” take the blame for poor connectivity rather than admit they’ve bought a lemon.

That, and front line staff are leaving in droves. Morale is low and pay is ok but better in the private sector. The person you’re talking to about your tax underpayment, pension contributions and K code is paid less than the person who scanned your potatoes and cheese in Aldi.

I am public sector, we also have a new telephone system - it is dreadful, irrespective of whether you're in the office or at home. A call comes in, and you just can't answer it!!!

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 16:40

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 16:37

I really consider working in the office per se to be a really old fashioned concept. Times move on.

Having no choice at all is probably old-fashioned.

Having some element of in-person connection is certainly not.

People think Teams calls etc can work as effectively - they often can't. The small personal interaction, being able to open up or even just the interpersonal connection - often these are important & needed.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 16:38

If the job can be done as well or better at home,

Aspects of my job can be done well, perhaps better at home. No distractions, control over meetings / interactions and so on.

But even where it seems to be the case, a lack of staff cohesion & personal connection, can be detrimental at a top level. So individual employees might feel they work better at home; as an overall entity the company might be losing out.

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 16:37

I really consider working in the office per se to be a really old fashioned concept. Times move on.

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 16:36

M4J4 · 12/09/2023 16:15

What are their reasons for not wanting to go in?

I can sort of understand if they have a long commute or childcare challenges.

But if you want to work from home purely because you prefer it or don't see the value in working out of the office then these are the types of people our company would try to weed out.

Edited

And these are the sorts of companies I would weed out! How backward can you be! If the job can be done as well or better at home, why would you force people to commute in? My commute costs £50 a day and is 2 hours each way. There’s not a chance in hell I’m going back to that !

Instead, I no longer look for other jobs or push for big pay rises. I do my job far, far better at home. I would leave before going back in.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 16:35

What is wrong with people?

'The team's not happy'. Dear God.

Firstly, you are paid to do a job, and it's the employer's prerogative to decide on the conditions of that employment.

Secondly, while the world has changed since Covid, the idea that means no or barely any time on-site is ridiculous. While many aspects of some roles can be done effectively from home, for many more roles, some time in person is needed. This is often for the less-obvious but integral type of work, like getting to know people, collaboration, building trust, troubleshooting, creative working.

Thirdly, 2 days a week is certainly not an imposition. You still have 3 days a week WFH, and colleagues can continue to benefit from savings to a significant extent, compared to pre-Covid times.

In my workplace we WFH 2 days a week. I'm a manager & I can move my own days around if I need but I do my best to stick to a schedule - it's easier for my team, and me. However, it's always subject to business need. If we need staff on-site they must come in, and if I need to attend in person meetings for example, I'll always come on site.

The level of entitlement from some is crazy.

Fightyouforthatpie · 12/09/2023 16:35

Throwncrumbs · 12/09/2023 13:37

Council staff all working from home, not actually doing a lot but raking in massive salaries, are now wondering why the organisations they are employed by are all becoming bankrupt. No accountability for any of them. Take the money but not following through on anything. The moneys gone into peoples pockets but not in services. Big issues in lots of places with the same problems. WFH has become the biggest con/ scam ever imo!

I have read some ignorant shite on here over the years but that takes the Biscuit

Hiyawotcha · 12/09/2023 16:33

Voted YANBU but expect will be a hybrid that involves office at least twice a week.

Reddog1 · 12/09/2023 16:28

Interesting about HMRC, for whom I worked until last year. They have a newish telephony system, bargain basement. I think they’re happy to let “WFH” take the blame for poor connectivity rather than admit they’ve bought a lemon.

That, and front line staff are leaving in droves. Morale is low and pay is ok but better in the private sector. The person you’re talking to about your tax underpayment, pension contributions and K code is paid less than the person who scanned your potatoes and cheese in Aldi.

ShadyPaws · 12/09/2023 16:27

I'm working in the office today. Can't hear any of my callers as it's so noisy with everyone talking
Rather WFH in peace. Every single thing I do is monitored, I can't be 3 mins late back from my lunch without someone knowing

flipent · 12/09/2023 16:25

I work from the office almost every day. I would miss it if I didn't and I struggle with the amount some colleagues WFH.
I would rather everyone was in the office, but I also appreciate that the world has changed and coming in more often is my choice. But I wouldn't be happy if any of my colleagues were moved to 100% WFH either.

Legale · 12/09/2023 16:25

@M4J4 It's due to issues such as inadequate parking meaning driving around a city trying to find a (likely expensive) space, or relying on very unreliable public transport. One wants all its employees in on the same day and friend can't concentrate with the noise, plus people tend to just use that day to socialise, chat and lunch together, then start serious work again on the WFH days.
I only work from home if I have an appointment or am too unwell to come in but can do some work, at least, in the house. For me it means half an hour to nursery instead of a little over 5, a considerable amount on fuel and sometimes a hassle to find parking (there is literally no public transport to my workplace from my village). It is a job the could be done with 2 or 3 days only in the office, so I am also starting to look at WFH vacancies, or hybrid in favour of more home working, at least.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/09/2023 16:24

sparklefresh · 12/09/2023 15:35

Why aren't they happy?

Because it will cost them four times as much in petrol and no doubt some will now need wraparound care. Plus the time factor of course.

I agree it could have been much worse though.

kitsuneghost · 12/09/2023 16:22

sparklefresh · 12/09/2023 15:35

Why aren't they happy?

Cause it will cost them money

littlegrebe · 12/09/2023 16:17

Throwncrumbs · 12/09/2023 13:37

Council staff all working from home, not actually doing a lot but raking in massive salaries, are now wondering why the organisations they are employed by are all becoming bankrupt. No accountability for any of them. Take the money but not following through on anything. The moneys gone into peoples pockets but not in services. Big issues in lots of places with the same problems. WFH has become the biggest con/ scam ever imo!

@Throwncrumbs Could you elaborate on how me doing the paperwork bits of my job from home where I can concentrate properly has caused historic equal pay claims, central government funding cuts and massive inflation pushing up day to day operational costs please?

Also, and perhaps more importantly, could you ensure my massive salary is forwarded ASAP? I took a pay cut to move to the public sector several years ago and have yet to see any sign of anything remotely resembling a massive salary. Very keen to get this rectified if you wouldn't mind.

NearlyMonday · 12/09/2023 16:16

And just because we all USED to attend 5 days per week, doesn't mean we should necessarily do this now. The world has changed.

M4J4 · 12/09/2023 16:15

Legale · 12/09/2023 16:12

My last job was 3 days out of 5 and literally no-one did it. Not even management. I know of people who are looking to jump ship in certain professions because of a return to the office where other employers in the sector are fully WFH.
I only WFH occasionally and I do get more done. Far too many distractions in the office, unless a client is in it's a bit of work and a lot of chat/procrastination in the absence of any major deadlines.

What are their reasons for not wanting to go in?

I can sort of understand if they have a long commute or childcare challenges.

But if you want to work from home purely because you prefer it or don't see the value in working out of the office then these are the types of people our company would try to weed out.

LakieLady · 12/09/2023 16:13

adriftinadenofvipers · 12/09/2023 14:57

There would be no point in my returning to the office even for a day or two a week, literally.

Our team was always based over five locations. It would be unlikely that everyone in each location would want to come into the office on the same day, and even if they did, we'd have meetings etc and wouldn't probably spend much if any time together in any case.

It's actually freed us up tremendously to work from home. Had this discussion with team manager only yesterday. Where we would previously spend up to 2 hours driving to a meeting and the same back, we can now fit 4 meetings into that day whereas before it would have been that single one. Plus you could have driven all that distance and the bloody meeting last half an hour!!

There are times and situations where we still have to do that but cutting down on travelling times to the extent we have been able to, has been game-changing.

My experience is similar.

I work in welfare rights and (among other things) represent people at appeal tribunals.

When it is a video or telephone hearing, I get on with my other work until a few minutes before the time of the appointment. If they are running late, the clerk rings to let me know, and I carry on with my work. When the appeal has been heard, I carry on with the rest of my work. When the decision arrives in the post, I call the client and explain what it means, how much the arrears payment will be, any implications for their other benefits etc, log my outcomes etc.

When I have face to face appeals, I have to drive to the tribunal venue (half an hour or 1.5 hours travelling, depending on which tribunal office is dealing with the case). If they're running late, we all sit around until they've finished the hearing they're doing, and panic about getting parking tickets if the wait goes on a long time. When we finally get in there, the appeals seem to take a lot longer than they do over the phone. Sometimes, they will say the decision will be sent in the post, but sometimes they want you to wait so they can deliver it in person, which can be another hour. Then the client wants a debrief afterwards, to go through what the impact of the award will be. When I get back, I still have to write everything up.

Doing things remotely is far more efficient, which is why my caseload is double what it was pre-Covid.

Possimpible · 12/09/2023 16:12

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 16:08

If it helps OP, we’re mandated to go in one day a week and I’ve not been in since Feb 2020. Are they keeping a register ?

No, they're expecting their (presumably adult) employees to comply with the terms of their employment... Don't be surprised if you're pulled into a similar meeting shortly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread