Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Meeting: 'Working from home' - your vote needed!

371 replies

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 00:53

Got a meeting invite late tonight titled simply: Working from home'. Scheduled for half an hour. No additional info.

What are they gonna say?

Return to the office full time? Full time WFH???

Your guess is as good as mine. We're currently in once every two weeks.

Results posted in here tomorrow once the meeting has been held.

Yanbu = back to office
Yabu = WFH

OP posts:
NearlyMonday · 12/09/2023 19:13

@CrabbiesGingerBeer i agree that you can’t change the goal posts if someone has been employed on a wfh contract

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 12/09/2023 18:47

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 17:50

As for two days simply not being an imposition, this is nothing more than your value judgement. You can't prove that it isn't, any more than anyone else could prove that it is. It's a personal call. It's also not a good way to approach the issue.

Out of a 5 day working week, 2 days on-site isn't an imposition. How could it be?

Imagine thinking an employee asking their staff to work on-site 2/5 of the time equals an imposition 🤦🏻‍♀️

Well my job has spent the last 3 years recruiting on a full time WFH basis (after saying anyone who didn’t like full time WFH could leave and losing literally half the staff).

If they changed to two days in the office each week then if the two full days were, for example Monday and Tuesday, people would have to fly / drive to the office Sunday night, stay over two nights and probably get home at around midnight on Tuesday.

How could that possibly not be an imposition?

everetting · 12/09/2023 18:47

Every business in my field of employment that does not allow wfh, seems to be struggling to recruit. Again and again on industry online groups someone posts an advert and asks for advice about why they are getting no applicants. I have never seen this with a wfh role.
If you are old fashioned and don't move with the times, you will in many areas of the country struggle to recruit.
My husband hates wfh but also hates office work. There are lots of jobs around for the type of work where you can't work from home.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/09/2023 18:40

From a management perspective, we be also always focused on business need, when explaining rationale for decisions

A balanced way of handling it, and that's why I'm surprised OP hasn't mentioned what they said about reasons

It would after all be the obvious thing to do - unless WFH has caused major productivity issues, in which case it might be understandable if she doesn't want to say

everetting · 12/09/2023 18:39

@fafairyfluf teamwork is very relevant for some jobs and not others. My job is specialised but everyone seems to think they can do it, like being a teacher. In my last job a lot f money was wasted on a team devised project that would normally be my responsibility to do. I kept pointing out the problems but was just seen as negative. It did not work, because in my job detail matters, but no one was willing to look at the detail.
A similar example would be a team planning a wedding by only looking at the fun things like who to have as a band and amazing decorations, but no one wanted to look at details like what food to have and dismissed any of my attempts to get these decisions made.
Teamwork can work well in some jobs. In other cases it is just people with no understanding of your job making idiotic suggestions.

CharlotteBog · 12/09/2023 18:39

Goingsomewhere · 12/09/2023 17:38

I've been wfh the past 2 days and barely spoken to another human. Just sat in front of a screen. Don't get why people like it.

I have been WFH for 8 years or so.

I don't tend to speak to other people when I'm in front of the screen; my work is mostly solitary and I need to focus. I've had 2 hours of (zoom) meetings in the last 2 days with cameras on so we could see each other.

Outside of work I've swum (to be fair, that's not the first thing you'd think of if you want human interaction, but it's exercise and a change of scenery). I've talked to the Click and Collect woman who I see every week. I've been to a circuits class where I have lots of friends.
Today I went for a walk with a friend at lunch time and am meeting friends this evening, after I've been for a solo walk and cleaned up after dinner.
The flexibility and the lack of commute means I can enable my son going to the gym because I can collect him from town (10 min drive away) rather than him having to get the bus home. He can also be spontaneous to a degree if he wants to stay out later.

I do have to be active in ensuring I do see people, and this was harder when my son was younger and I couldn't leave him (lone parent), but right now it's perfect for me.

Well before covid and everyone wfh I acknowledged that it worked for me because I was senior in my position, didn't need daily affirmation, that my kids were older and I was able to work independently.

everetting · 12/09/2023 18:33

I am old enough to remember the introduction of computers to offices. We had the same old fashioned firms complain about that and resist it.
Wfh does not work well if you don't invest in setting it up and managing it properly. But done well it can work well.

PortalooSunset · 12/09/2023 18:31

fairyfluf · 12/09/2023 18:29

That's just weird

Innit tho?! Hoping that one will disappear..

everetting · 12/09/2023 18:30

You can tell the go ahead firms. Those stuck in old fashioned ways will be getting people back into the office, beca6that is how it has always been done.

The only negative in my place from wfh is that new young people in more senior posts than me do flounder a bit more. This is because the managers who are supposed to train and supervise them don't do it properly. So they come to low paid office staff like me for help with things that I am not even expected to know. I have helped because I feel sorry for them. Since wfh I no longer do this.

I wonder sometimes if this is what meant by the learning in the office I.e. passing on your responsibility for training to much lower paid staff.

fairyfluf · 12/09/2023 18:29

PortalooSunset · 12/09/2023 18:25

Totally agree with being less productive in the office! We've also been recently told to return 2 or 3 days minimum to be office based (depends if pt or ft). We've since been told that additionally on our agreed WFH days we have to either start or finish our day in the office Confused

That's just weird

fairyfluf · 12/09/2023 18:29

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 15:28

UPDATE

Meeting has just been held. We have to go in to the office twice per week.

The team are not happy.

Perfectly reasonable. I'd suggest all going in for the same day for one of those days. Otherwise its pointless.

They will expect productivity to drop but it will help improve team work

everetting · 12/09/2023 18:26

Conditions get changed and improved all the time. If you take the approach of some on here, no one should be able to bring an equal pay claim as they knew the salary when taking the job.

PortalooSunset · 12/09/2023 18:25

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 15:48

Re. Team not happy

We've been almost 100% WFH since covid.

Team is not happy because of the commute/traffic, the fact that all the work we do is online, never in person, and they basically don't see what value it adds. Also, we're less productive in the office due to distractions.

Boss has agreed with all of the above. Chance it may get changed to one day per week ( which I think is totally fine)

Totally agree with being less productive in the office! We've also been recently told to return 2 or 3 days minimum to be office based (depends if pt or ft). We've since been told that additionally on our agreed WFH days we have to either start or finish our day in the office Confused

ilovebrie8 · 12/09/2023 18:25

I'm over long commutes, lack of trains and generally so much time tied up in commuting. I'm over working in an office and all that entails...used to be debates about blinds up, blinds down, too cold, too hot etc etc...at stage in my career where I've been there done that and happy to WFH. Collaborative working is the buzzword trotted out but sorry a lot of the time that is nonsense....just a handy buzzword to throw it! Last time I was in the office I sat opposite my boss he was either in meetings or headphones on he did not collaborate with anyone! 🙄

TrashedSofa · 12/09/2023 18:24

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 17:53

it's about whether employer and employees are able to come to a mutually acceptable agreement on working conditions.

With respect, this is wrong.

It's correct to consult, discuss & be open to points made by employees.

No workplace is based on reaching a 'mutually acceptable agreement'. That's nonsense. How would you have a 'mutually acceptable' situation that suited all employees?

It's for this reason there are rules of employment. It's correct to have latitude where possible (eg we have flexi time) but it's not parity.

All contracts are mutually acceptable agreements on working conditions, otherwise there is no employment contract.

It's not necessarily about suiting all employees either, because some people have no choice but to take work and accept conditions that do not suit them. Just as some employers have no choice but to take employees and accept conditions that do not suit them. Whether something suits a person or organisation and whether they accept it are not the same question.

TrashedSofa · 12/09/2023 18:20

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 17:48

The employer gets to decide what terms and conditions they'll offer to employees, the employees get to decide whether to stay or not, and then for new recruits whether to apply/accept a role. There are two separate sets of decisions here and neither one can override the other.

That's factually untrue though.

The employer gets to decide what the T&C of employment are. At that point in time, in the vast majority of cases, the employee has to accept it.

It at least temporarily does override the employee's wishes!

In time, if the employee really doesn't want to work in that way, they can look for another job, hand in their notice & leave. This isn't possible for everyone - so it's not an absolute choice. It also isn't immediate & not always straightforward.

There's just not an equivalence.

This is full of generalisations. If you're going to make claims like vast majority, that needs backing up.

You appear to be arguing that if an employer changes the terms and the employee quits as a consequence, the employee still has to go into work until they work their notice? This is wrong. People can and do take accrued annual leave, call in sick or simply not work the notice. The employer at best might be able to pursue them for damages if they do the latter, which is difficult, but what they cannot do is oblige the employee to adhere to the new conditions. The employee's wish not to work in the office in that scenario overrides the employer's wish to have them there. There is no ultimate decision. Your post is wrong.

AllyCart · 12/09/2023 18:10

That kind of arrangement seems totally pointless!

Not if you look at how half of MN sees "working" from home.

There's a lot of 'just' putting a wash on, 'just' walking the dog, 'just' looking after a child that should be in nursery and isn't.

Redbrickrebel · 12/09/2023 18:09

Wfh is not just one solid concept.

It means different things in different departments of organisations, never mind organisations themselves.

At the end of the day , if a hybrid or predominantly wfh policy works for both department and employee, it's nobody else's business.

When WFH I do my job differently, but equally effectively. I also get 2 .5 hrs of commuting time back. It is a brilliant addition to the workplace, and it is narrow mindness and ignorance to call it 'nonsense' .

TenderDandelions · 12/09/2023 18:04

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 15:48

Re. Team not happy

We've been almost 100% WFH since covid.

Team is not happy because of the commute/traffic, the fact that all the work we do is online, never in person, and they basically don't see what value it adds. Also, we're less productive in the office due to distractions.

Boss has agreed with all of the above. Chance it may get changed to one day per week ( which I think is totally fine)

My team work a 5 day fortnight. 3 days in the office one week, 2 the next. Works well for us. A lot of the team are still training, so massively benefit from the 1:1 time they get with the manager.

On the flip side, my friend has to go in one day a week where she sits at a hot desk and still had the same Zoom calls with her team as she does when she's at home because she works for their London office and the rest of her team are either in Scotland or India! Her manager isn't in the office on the same day as her either, so she has to pay for commuting costs to get in to the office and do the same as she does at home. The only benefit she's had from it in the last week has been the air conditioning! That kind of arrangement seems totally pointless!

AnxiousAnniee · 12/09/2023 18:02

I think it depends on what you're used to. It will be a bit of a shock to those who WFH completely (and prefer it) and can understand why they aren't happy. However for myself I work from the office three days a week and going down to two would be amazing! I'd be happy with that

CharlotteStreetW1 · 12/09/2023 18:00

Ginmonkeyagain · 12/09/2023 15:54

@coxesorangepippin Well of course you never do work in person if you have all been 100% WFH for three years!

Is that the whole organisations - it's like coming across those Japanese soldiers who still think the war is going on! A lot of workpaces have been back in the office at least a couple of days a week since late 2021.

We've been five days back in the office since the end of the first lockdown! And I only wfh then because we were "vulnerable".

(I got shitloads done working at home but a poor colleague in the office had to do the physical side of my job that couldn't be done remotely. I hated wfh but I do understand if people prefer it.)

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 17:59

@Coffeesnob11

That is a good idea, regarding the business case.

From a management perspective, we be also always focused on business need, when explaining rationale for decisions.

Wolfpa · 12/09/2023 17:58

I often wonder about the argument about working from home as there is no need to go into an office. To me this is like giving the company you work for an excuse to say “well if this job can be done from anywhere why are we paying high salaries we will now only hire people from cheaper places”

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 17:57

garlictwist · 12/09/2023 17:47

My employer recently made everyone return back 50% of their working week. I must admit at first I was quite annoyed about it but now I think it's 100% the right decision.

I have a much better working relationship with my team, I don't get sick of the sight of my own four walls and I feel more involved in the goings on of the business.

That said, my "commute" is a 17 minute walk so I might feel differently if it were expensive and long. But I do think there is a good case for a hybrid approach.

Agree with this.

We worked 2 days on-site, 3 days from home for quite a long while, then it reversed.

I found the initial 'extra' day on-site quite hard, tiring & I felt initially, unnecessary. Now it feels like the right balance.

Like I sat, the type of work I do means f2f connection is very valuable. But it's also the small things, like a quick chat before an in-person meeting to advance something. That can't happen on Teams; it's an ad hoc point of connection.

Coffeesnob11 · 12/09/2023 17:57

This happened to us but 4 days a week in the office. Rather than just complain we made a business case for 3 max. The presentation included what our clients were doing, reasons why it was better to be more flexible including health, environment etc and quotes from recruitment agents on what top candidates were looking for. It was so well received they used it for the whole global policy. Its fine to say you are not happy and no but I always find its better to give business reasons why.