Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Meeting: 'Working from home' - your vote needed!

371 replies

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 00:53

Got a meeting invite late tonight titled simply: Working from home'. Scheduled for half an hour. No additional info.

What are they gonna say?

Return to the office full time? Full time WFH???

Your guess is as good as mine. We're currently in once every two weeks.

Results posted in here tomorrow once the meeting has been held.

Yanbu = back to office
Yabu = WFH

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 12/09/2023 21:29

How long does it take for WFH to become part of t&cs even if the original contract was office based? Have there been industrial tribunals yet?

Employers can't now claim it is still an emergency situation.

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 21:22

We’re moving towards a 4 day a week trial soon. Same pay, less hours. Most of us wfh. It’s MN’s idea of hell!

It keeps me very loyal to my company and I am very experienced and good at my job and could jump ship for more money, but wfh is worth thousands to me.

I get the work done. The nature of my work means I can spread it out. So I walk the dog twice for 20 mins. He sleeps the entire rest of the time and doesn’t even need toilet breaks (greyhound!). And 3x a week I take a longer lunch and swim - and extend my day where needed . This is important as I work with vulnerable people and I need to look after myself. I didn’t do this in the office well enough and with commute on top and ended up on medication. I’m off it now.

I work longer where needed and shorter when it’s quieter. It’s smart working and it makes me much better at my job and also so much happier - I am autistic and working in an office was not a happy experience for me. My job is people based so I talk all day on the phone - but I don’t need to see colleagues or socialise with them- happy to have meetings remotely.

Full WFH should be an option where possible. It enables many people to work smarter quicker and better. It’s not for everyone but neither is or was office work.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/09/2023 21:18

PortalooSunset · 12/09/2023 18:25

Totally agree with being less productive in the office! We've also been recently told to return 2 or 3 days minimum to be office based (depends if pt or ft). We've since been told that additionally on our agreed WFH days we have to either start or finish our day in the office Confused

Agree this sounds ridiculous on the face of it, but i can't help wondering if the start/finish of the day thing is an attempt to stop school drop offs/pick ups turning into hours of non-availability

In fairness it doesn't much matter if the work can be done at oher times - providing it is done - but it's not much use if there are clients waiting or some other time sensitive issue

Blanketpolicy · 12/09/2023 20:57

To all those who wfh saying just get rid of the ones who aren't performing...

Or maybe find out what makes them tick and engage, motivate and inspire them instead?

I do agree young children should not be at home if there is no other parent to supervise them and parents should not be disappearing to drop/pick them up from school unless an emergency. They should also be available to go into the office if /when required during during normal working hours with just a days notice. Pets are fine as everyone needs a break from their desk, but they should have care readily available if they need to go in office - I kept my dog walker throughout covid/WFH. If I wasn't WFH my work would not have had me available 8am to 8pm today for various calls over different time zones.

Nothing is black and white and it is time everyone grew up and realised each situation should be assesed in its own context.

Meowandthen · 12/09/2023 20:56

Viviennemary · 12/09/2023 06:52

About time this wfh nonsense was stopped.

Ridiculous comment of the day.

Starwind74 · 12/09/2023 20:55

Oh sorry just realised I think you mean the meeting was scheduled to last half an hour. Still find it strange that they told you about it late at night.

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 12/09/2023 20:53

Lol. After all this time why did they choose now - going into winter - with covid and flu etc?
Do they want you all to be off work with sickness?

MajesticWhine · 12/09/2023 20:53

I think she meant that 1/2 hour was allocated for the duration of the meeting

Starwind74 · 12/09/2023 20:49

Missing the point of the thread, but you posted at 0.53 saying the meeting was in half an hour. So meeting in the middle of the night? or perhaps you are not in UK. I agree though that once a fortnight sounds like a very small amount of time to spend in the office.

Dumbndumber · 12/09/2023 20:41

To all those who wfh saying just get rid of the ones who aren't performing....It's not so easy to sack people just because they're lazy, especially if they've been employed for more than 2 years. If you try, it's a long drawn out process, with lots of chances, and often just being lazy isn't a good enough reason to sack someone as it has to be quantifiable. They'd have to be really bad, and you have to keep giving them chances to improve.If all those who don't like being made to go back, blame the lazy fuckers who are causing productivity to decline, not the businesses.Also, unless your contract says you can wfh, you're being unreasonable, and your employer has been good to let you continue past covid until now, so count your blessings. People are so entitled nowadays it's unbelievable. Also, if you're WFH, your dc and any pets should still be in child care or doggy care, as they would've been when you were in the office.There's no way you can be just as efficient if you've kids at home needing attention and pets needing letting out/walking multiple times a day.Anyone working from home should still have to have their dc in childcare away from their home, even in the school holidays.

SoAndSoSaidSo · 12/09/2023 20:15

Summering23 · 12/09/2023 17:27

I guess at least it's only 2 days. My place forces us in 3 days a week. We can't all do the same 3 days so often I'm sat there on my own all day.

We all have different days in bar 1, sometimes it's like a ghost town.

LlynTegid · 12/09/2023 20:06

Hope OP that one day a week is what happens in the end. Planned well you will get the benefits without too many of the drawbacks.

NearlyMonday · 12/09/2023 19:50

My current job before covid, a good chunk of my work time was spent listening to my bosses gossip and useless meetings. Every time I go back into the office I can't believe how little work I actually get done even though I am not doing anything I should not be.

I totally get this. With hindsight, I now realise how much time I used to spend doing non-productive things. But even now, when I’m having an office day, it’s quite possible to have a busy day but accomplish very little. Which is why WFH is so good for productivity.

everetting · 12/09/2023 19:49

And employers can not just change
contracts as they wish. There is law around this that has to be followed. It can lead to the employee opting for redundancy including redundancy money.

TrashedSofa · 12/09/2023 19:46

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 19:28

All contracts are mutually acceptable agreements on working conditions, otherwise there is no employment contract.

God I really hope you don't work in HR or employment law

The initial contract is offered, and perhaps can be negotiated (not commonly) & then accepted.

Thereafter specific working arrangements (which is what we are discussing) are at the discretion of the employer.

It's not necessarily about suiting all employees either, because some people have no choice but to take work and accept conditions that do not suit them

That's the exact point! You can't suit all employees. So the employer decides, ultimately.

Nothing you have written here, even the bits that are correct and that you haven't made up, negates what I have written.

All employment contracts are mutually accepted, or there won't be an employer and employee relationship. Makes no odds whether the initial offer was agreed or whether they negotiated, This is the case initially, and it's also the case thereafter where specific working arrangements will only exist because both the employer and employee have accepted and continue to accept them. By definition.

And no, it's not exactly your point. You can't suit all employees or employers, and this fact has no bearing on the reality that the both make a decision and there is no 'ultimate'.

everetting · 12/09/2023 19:46

@EaEarringsandLipstick I have worked in lots of places. There is usually plenty of private space for better paid staff to have private zoom calls, but not lower paid staff. Unless you are lower paid you probably have no idea how virtually all forms treat us differently.
Before covid, I struggled on phone calls to call centres as there was often so much background noise. It is way easier now many are working from home.

TrashedSofa · 12/09/2023 19:40

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 19:25

You appear to be arguing that if an employer changes the terms

But they aren't changing the terms! For most organisations, the contract of employment hasn't changed since pre-Covid. The place of work is still the office, but WFH was facilitated. It's entirely the employer's prerogative if & when they want to revert.

(If an employee has a specific contract to WFH, that would of course be different)

the employee still has to go into work until they work their notice? This is wrong. People can and do take accrued annual leave, call in sick or simply not work the notice

Rare, and not germane to my point (which, yet again, was that there is not an equivalence between the employer & employees positions, as you seem determined to argue).

The employee's wish not to work in the office in that scenario overrides the employer's wish to have them there.I

😂😂😂

Nope! Sadly you're still wrong.

The employer's decision stands. As it's employment not slavery, if the employee doesn't like it, they can leave, with all the change that means to the employee. Some employees will be fine with this. Many would be deeply upset (read many MN posts along this line!). Either way the employer is not changing & will recruit a replacement as needed. The employee is the one that needs to agree or make the changes that will affect them.

You're the one who mentioned changing terms and conditions, not me. You can't therefore say this isn't a case of changing them, especially as OP hasn't confirmed it either way. I specifically didn't say that because we don't have enough information, particularly not given the possibility of an implied change due to custom and practice. It doesn't much matter to my point anyway.

You initially said it's the employer's prerogative to decide on the terms of OPs employment. This is wrong, because all they decide is what basis they are willing to employ people on. This is not the same thing. You clearly get this because you're now trying to say that because you've decided something is 'rare' (prove your claim) that somehow means anything.

Also, you don't actually know whether the employer will recruit a replacement as needed, whether their decision stands (the manager seems to think otherwise) or whether they'll change it. These are all assumptions.

GoryBory · 12/09/2023 19:33

If the role was office based before covid then it was always possible to need to go back into the office.

I actually don’t know many people who are still WFH now, especially not FT.

I don’t get why the team are so annoyed that they potentially have to go back to doing the job that they applied for.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 19:32

everetting · 12/09/2023 19:22

I have never worked anywhere with enough meeting rooms to do private zoom calls.
Last place I worked introduced hot decking so you were often sat next to people you didn't really know and whose work was irrelevant to yours.
My current job before covid, a good chunk of my work time was spent listening to my bosses gossip and useless meetings. Every time I go back into the office I can't believe how little work I actually get done even though I am not doing anything I should not be.

Again, you've been unfortunate to work in very poorly structured and resourced organisations.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 19:31

@CrabbiesGingerBeer

That's entirely different.

Your company has intentionally recruited on a WFH basis, and employees accepted as such.

Of course it's not fair to then decide that they must spend time on-site. (And contractually it wouldn't hold up anyway).

That's not OP's situation or what we are discussing.

43ontherocksporfavor · 12/09/2023 19:30

I’m in school every day. Would hate to be wfh every day.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 19:28

All contracts are mutually acceptable agreements on working conditions, otherwise there is no employment contract.

God I really hope you don't work in HR or employment law

The initial contract is offered, and perhaps can be negotiated (not commonly) & then accepted.

Thereafter specific working arrangements (which is what we are discussing) are at the discretion of the employer.

It's not necessarily about suiting all employees either, because some people have no choice but to take work and accept conditions that do not suit them

That's the exact point! You can't suit all employees. So the employer decides, ultimately.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2023 19:25

You appear to be arguing that if an employer changes the terms

But they aren't changing the terms! For most organisations, the contract of employment hasn't changed since pre-Covid. The place of work is still the office, but WFH was facilitated. It's entirely the employer's prerogative if & when they want to revert.

(If an employee has a specific contract to WFH, that would of course be different)

the employee still has to go into work until they work their notice? This is wrong. People can and do take accrued annual leave, call in sick or simply not work the notice

Rare, and not germane to my point (which, yet again, was that there is not an equivalence between the employer & employees positions, as you seem determined to argue).

The employee's wish not to work in the office in that scenario overrides the employer's wish to have them there.I

😂😂😂

Nope! Sadly you're still wrong.

The employer's decision stands. As it's employment not slavery, if the employee doesn't like it, they can leave, with all the change that means to the employee. Some employees will be fine with this. Many would be deeply upset (read many MN posts along this line!). Either way the employer is not changing & will recruit a replacement as needed. The employee is the one that needs to agree or make the changes that will affect them.

everetting · 12/09/2023 19:22

I have never worked anywhere with enough meeting rooms to do private zoom calls.
Last place I worked introduced hot decking so you were often sat next to people you didn't really know and whose work was irrelevant to yours.
My current job before covid, a good chunk of my work time was spent listening to my bosses gossip and useless meetings. Every time I go back into the office I can't believe how little work I actually get done even though I am not doing anything I should not be.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 12/09/2023 19:16

Possimpible · 12/09/2023 13:52

@WomanStanleyWoman2 If someone who was planning on training to be a nurse suddenly decides to chuck it in because they could work from home as an accounting assistant, I’m glad they’re not going to be a nurse

Nursing is a job, like any other. Candidates will weigh up the pros and cons of entering any job role before they apply. It's not fair or right to expect people to be Florence Nightingale. When the work culture in the UK has now swung towards flexibility, WFH, late starts to walk the kids to school, why would anyone get up at 5.45am, work nightshifts, weekends, Christmas etc? People will drop nursing for more flexible roles, and it is not your place to be making moral judgements about that. You are right that they need to make these roles more attractive to recruit but that's just not going to happen - they're getting worse as staff realise the above and leave in droves.

@iamwhatiam23 I don't agree! I don't think its anything to do with wfh! It's because the pay and working conditions in these jobs are shit! Im an ex NHS worker.

WFH would come under working conditions... I am current NHS staff and fully agree with the PP you quoted. Nursing pay is not 'shit', but it is unacceptable remuneration for the responsibility and conditions.

Also here to say that full-time WFH is likely having a negative social impact - yes someone will be along to tell me how they have so much energy to throw dinner parties now that they don't have to commute, but in general I notice people are becoming very insular and reluctant to go out, and I think WFH has a role in that. People get too used to being in their own space all the time. I know 'office culture' is much mocked, but learning to get along with and work alongside people you wouldn't normally socialise with is really important.

I don’t know who you think you are to tell me it’s “not my place” to make these judgements, but in any case, you’re wrong about nursing being like any other job. It simply isn’t, and anyone going into that profession has to accept that.

The idea that more people WFH will cause a mass exodus from the nursing profession is absurd. You make it sound as if current and potential nurses will have only twigged in the last three years that their chosen job means shifts and more unsociable hours. It’s always been like this. Office jobs were always fixed hours as standard, Monday to Friday. Why are legions of nurses suddenly going to be up in arms about this now that the commute factor has been removed for some? Office jobs have always had more flexibility than nursing, yet people have continued to train to do it for longer than living memory.

In any case, what’s your actual point? Are you suggesting that we have to falsely maintain a downside to other jobs just in case someone who MIGHT have considered nursing decides they’d rather do that job instead?

Swipe left for the next trending thread