Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Meeting: 'Working from home' - your vote needed!

371 replies

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 00:53

Got a meeting invite late tonight titled simply: Working from home'. Scheduled for half an hour. No additional info.

What are they gonna say?

Return to the office full time? Full time WFH???

Your guess is as good as mine. We're currently in once every two weeks.

Results posted in here tomorrow once the meeting has been held.

Yanbu = back to office
Yabu = WFH

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TrashedSofa · 22/09/2023 06:59

coxesorangepippin · 21/09/2023 19:28

QUICK UPDATE

Just an update for anyone interested.

There's has been huge criticism of the twice per week return, so it has been reduced to once per week, to be reviewed.

We were in the office yesterday and it turns out that a lot of the (large 100+ people) teams we work with are now permanently WFH. But not us, were still on hybrid.

Boss has basically said if we can go in once a week, fine, if not he'll turn a blind eye.

Haha I thought that might happen!

NearlyMonday · 21/09/2023 21:57

Sounds like a result then!

Abracadabra12345 · 21/09/2023 19:31

Boss has basically said if we can go in once a week, fine, if not he'll turn a blind eye.

In other words, you're all back to full wfh so all this drama for nothing

coxesorangepippin · 21/09/2023 19:28

QUICK UPDATE

Just an update for anyone interested.

There's has been huge criticism of the twice per week return, so it has been reduced to once per week, to be reviewed.

We were in the office yesterday and it turns out that a lot of the (large 100+ people) teams we work with are now permanently WFH. But not us, were still on hybrid.

Boss has basically said if we can go in once a week, fine, if not he'll turn a blind eye.

OP posts:
chasemeridien · 13/09/2023 20:17

In the office once a week minimum.

NearlyMonday · 13/09/2023 19:55

We used to have much more autonomy with how we set out our days, and I'd often do a heap of client visits one day then the following day do all the paperwork/follow up. That's not allowed anymore.
There's been a fairly recent change of leadership so they're marking territory I assume. I'm kind of towing the line at the moment but I'm pretty certain given time things will go back to how they were.
But yep, I've colleagues who have contracted hours to start early or finish late, and have basically been told they have to come in to an empty office which is fucking nuts 😂

@PortalooSunset if this continues I expect your employer will struggle to retain staff. Your suggestion about lots of client meetings one day followed by a paperwork day sounds perfectly sensible, and a good use of time. My employer (public sector) also has one eye on green issues and unnecessary travelling is frowned upon, we’re not supposed to do part-days in the office. And pre-covid we had a massive car parking problem, and as we’re all doing 2 days per week in the office, this problem has now disappeared

BitOutOfPractice · 13/09/2023 18:40

That sounds utterly infuriating! I'm glad I work for myself! If this is the modern workplace, I think I'm unemployable!

PortalooSunset · 13/09/2023 18:34

And thanks for the love for my name @BitOutOfPractice Flowers

PortalooSunset · 13/09/2023 18:33

NearlyMonday · 13/09/2023 11:33

So if you're on a WFH day, you have to present yourself at 8.30am (just to say hello) and then drive back home and start working? Seriously?? Apologies if I've misunderstood, but it sounds mad.

It's not quite as ridiculous as that it absolutely is - there's an expectation we meet with a certain number of clients a week and a lot of this needs to be face to face due to the nature of the role. So we go in, say hello, visit a client then head home.
We used to have much more autonomy with how we set out our days, and I'd often do a heap of client visits one day then the following day do all the paperwork/follow up. That's not allowed anymore.
There's been a fairly recent change of leadership so they're marking territory I assume. I'm kind of towing the line at the moment but I'm pretty certain given time things will go back to how they were.
But yep, I've colleagues who have contracted hours to start early or finish late, and have basically been told they have to come in to an empty office which is fucking nuts 😂

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 13/09/2023 12:50

NearlyMonday · 13/09/2023 11:33

So if you're on a WFH day, you have to present yourself at 8.30am (just to say hello) and then drive back home and start working? Seriously?? Apologies if I've misunderstood, but it sounds mad.

Agree - that is just bonkers.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/09/2023 12:48

NearlyMonday · 13/09/2023 11:33

So if you're on a WFH day, you have to present yourself at 8.30am (just to say hello) and then drive back home and start working? Seriously?? Apologies if I've misunderstood, but it sounds mad.

Again, though, I have to wonder the reasons are for this - OP hasn't said, just as she hasn't said what reasons they've given for wanting employees back two days at all

They may or may not be good reasons - we simply don't know, despite the usual pile-on and assumptions - but it would be good to know what they are

NearlyMonday · 13/09/2023 11:33

BitOutOfPractice · 13/09/2023 09:56

We've since been told that additionally on our agreed WFH days we have to either start or finish our day in the office

What the hell @PortalooSunset (brilliant name!) is the point of that buggery bollocks? I'd be pushing back on that!

So if you're on a WFH day, you have to present yourself at 8.30am (just to say hello) and then drive back home and start working? Seriously?? Apologies if I've misunderstood, but it sounds mad.

TrashedSofa · 13/09/2023 11:09

GnomeDePlume · 13/09/2023 10:53

Absolutely 'it depends'. So far as I am aware there is no absolute definition of 'reasonable'. This is often tested in industrial tribunals.

Employers are often very definite that changes to custom and practice are reasonable when it suits them.

Aren't they just!

GnomeDePlume · 13/09/2023 10:53

Absolutely 'it depends'. So far as I am aware there is no absolute definition of 'reasonable'. This is often tested in industrial tribunals.

Employers are often very definite that changes to custom and practice are reasonable when it suits them.

BitOutOfPractice · 13/09/2023 09:56

We've since been told that additionally on our agreed WFH days we have to either start or finish our day in the office

What the hell @PortalooSunset (brilliant name!) is the point of that buggery bollocks? I'd be pushing back on that!

TrashedSofa · 13/09/2023 09:28

GnomeDePlume · 13/09/2023 08:40

Employers insisting employees attend the office with no real justification other than 'bums on seats' are demonstrating to employees that they aren't valued as individuals. Some will vote with their feet.

That may not matter if there is a large pool of suitable potential employees to recruit from and the terms and conditions on offer are comparable with the market.

If the Ts&Cs lag behind the market (as they often do when employees have been in place for a while) then the employer can end up paying a high price for insisting on presenteeism.

Employers often undervalue current employees.

Agree, and this is why people's individual barometers of what's reasonable, entitled etc just aren't much use here. Employers and employees can both have such wildly varying levels of leverage. Some people can demand much more than others, as can some employers. There's no point in generalising or making assumptions. The answer is that it depends.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 13/09/2023 09:12

You're the one who mentioned changing terms and conditions, not me. You can't therefore say this isn't a case of changing them, especially as OP hasn't confirmed it either way. I specifically didn't say that because we don't have enough information, particularly not given the possibility of an implied change due to custom and practice. It doesn't much matter to my point anyway.

I’m glad someone has mentioned Custom and Practice. As another poster said, the OP’s employer has long since lost the chance to argue that this was a purely emergency situation. For over two years now there’s been the option to say “restrictions are over; get back to the office”. They haven’t taken that option - which to me suggests that WFH was adopted as a long-term “norm”, even if not specified in the contract.

“In order for an entitlement to become established by custom and practice, it must be long-standing, uninterrupted, automatically received, expected and well-known.”

From the TUC website. I’m no lawyer, but I’d argue that two years plus of uninterrupted majority WFH (discounting the prior period when restrictions were in place) with no expectation that this had to be specifically agreed or negotiated in advance would qualify…

SeptemberSuns · 13/09/2023 09:07

Perfectly reasonable to expect you in the office 2 days a week. More than reasonable in fact.

GnomeDePlume · 13/09/2023 08:40

Employers insisting employees attend the office with no real justification other than 'bums on seats' are demonstrating to employees that they aren't valued as individuals. Some will vote with their feet.

That may not matter if there is a large pool of suitable potential employees to recruit from and the terms and conditions on offer are comparable with the market.

If the Ts&Cs lag behind the market (as they often do when employees have been in place for a while) then the employer can end up paying a high price for insisting on presenteeism.

Employers often undervalue current employees.

Taylorscat · 13/09/2023 06:20

SurprisedWithAHorse · 12/09/2023 22:35

The point, as it so often is, is to satisfy a sense of presenteeism and force staff to prove their devotion by coming in even when it's pointless because nobody else is there.

I could see the point in set office days for all (two out of five doesn't seem draconian to me although every other Wednesday seemed to work fine for you) so you have a chance to meet up in person, build team relationships etc etc. When the rule is literally "doesn't matter when or who else is there, you just have to get your bum on an office seat", then it's clearly purely performative.

But senior management is largely performative. The people in charge have no idea what they're doing and they need to look busy and as if they're doing something, anything.

Too many managers and too many shit managers.

Completely agree with this. I’d accept a team day when the entire team is in, or dept. But that’s not usually what happens.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 12/09/2023 22:35

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 22:11

Perfectly reasonable. I'd suggest all going in for the same day for one of those days. Otherwise its pointless.

^

Sorry for potential drop feed but this is exactly what's been suggested (and what we currently do, bi weekly, Wednesdays).

So you'd be in on a Wednesday with all the team and then pick your own day of your choice, and then the second week you'd pick any two days that suits you.

Which leads me to think you could potentially only see the team once every two weeks on a Wednesday anyway.... so what's the point in the extra 3 days??

🤔

The point, as it so often is, is to satisfy a sense of presenteeism and force staff to prove their devotion by coming in even when it's pointless because nobody else is there.

I could see the point in set office days for all (two out of five doesn't seem draconian to me although every other Wednesday seemed to work fine for you) so you have a chance to meet up in person, build team relationships etc etc. When the rule is literally "doesn't matter when or who else is there, you just have to get your bum on an office seat", then it's clearly purely performative.

But senior management is largely performative. The people in charge have no idea what they're doing and they need to look busy and as if they're doing something, anything.

Too many managers and too many shit managers.

coxesorangepippin · 12/09/2023 22:11

Perfectly reasonable. I'd suggest all going in for the same day for one of those days. Otherwise its pointless.

^

Sorry for potential drop feed but this is exactly what's been suggested (and what we currently do, bi weekly, Wednesdays).

So you'd be in on a Wednesday with all the team and then pick your own day of your choice, and then the second week you'd pick any two days that suits you.

Which leads me to think you could potentially only see the team once every two weeks on a Wednesday anyway.... so what's the point in the extra 3 days??

🤔

OP posts:
Pammela2 · 12/09/2023 22:02

Except that productivity in the UK is currently awful. Most research supports that it’s usually due to poorly skilled managers and thus the lack in camaraderie in teams as well as being able to utilise individuals effectively.
So although you might think you’re managing your own work well, there’s clearly a huge issue which links to the wider needs of companies to allow and sustain any growth.

Possimpible · 12/09/2023 21:52

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 12/09/2023 19:16

I don’t know who you think you are to tell me it’s “not my place” to make these judgements, but in any case, you’re wrong about nursing being like any other job. It simply isn’t, and anyone going into that profession has to accept that.

The idea that more people WFH will cause a mass exodus from the nursing profession is absurd. You make it sound as if current and potential nurses will have only twigged in the last three years that their chosen job means shifts and more unsociable hours. It’s always been like this. Office jobs were always fixed hours as standard, Monday to Friday. Why are legions of nurses suddenly going to be up in arms about this now that the commute factor has been removed for some? Office jobs have always had more flexibility than nursing, yet people have continued to train to do it for longer than living memory.

In any case, what’s your actual point? Are you suggesting that we have to falsely maintain a downside to other jobs just in case someone who MIGHT have considered nursing decides they’d rather do that job instead?

My point is that nurses are humans, and that weighing up pros and cons of working as a nurse versus working as an accounting assistant doesn't make them an awful person, or indeed nurse if that's what they decide to do. You seemed to be implying that nursing is a calling, a vocation, and that people should just do it for the love of it. Just because you want to be a nurse doesn't mean you don't also value a work life balance.

And actually the last three years has caused a mass exodus from nursing, not sure if you've missed that? Obviously it's not just that lots of other workers' conditions have improved (WFH), it's that NHS working conditions have worsened - wearing uncomfortable PPE, worsening staff to patient ratios, not getting breaks, more unpaid overtime, sicker patients, busier wards. And actually I'd argue that previously shift work had potentially more flexibility than office work - you could go to the bank on a Tuesday for example. Now people who WFH can pop out and do life admin, start later, finish earlier etc.

With regards to your final paragraph, my point was basically what you said originally - they need to make 'keyworker' roles more attractive (higher pay for example) or nobody will train or work in those roles. If you think those going into nursing just have to accept it's not like other jobs and put up with it, I hope you're prepared to accept no nurses in the workforce in 30 years. Wards are already propped up with agency staff and nurses in their 50s riding it out to their pension.

tianabiscuit · 12/09/2023 21:34

"Also, if you're WFH, your dc and any pets should still be in child care or doggy care, as they would've been when you were in the office.There's no way you can be just as efficient if you've kids at home needing attention and pets needing letting out/walking multiple times a day.Anyone working from home should still have to have their dc in childcare away from their home, even in the school holidays."

I agree entirely that children of an age where they need on the spot attention should be in some sort of childcare as if their parents were actually on their business premises. I know some of my colleagues flout this and it's fairly obvious, they try to hide it but give themselves away regularly.

Pets I disagree with. We have a dog who usually curls up under my or DH's desk for much of the day, have a chew on hand to occupy her if mooching around and a meeting needs full concentration, she has a short run round the park at lunchtime, as well as longer walks before and after work because we don't have a commute to worry about and she usually goes out for a wee when one of us sticks the kettle on. In this hot weather the back door has been open for her to come and go as she pleases anyway. I can't think that our dog is unique in her lack of working time consumption. And everyone needs to get up and stretch their legs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread