Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s utter hell working with extroverted people when you’re introverted?

91 replies

beeonmybonnett · 11/09/2023 17:34

I work in an office and I really am the most introverted person there. I always have been quiet and shy. Don’t get me wrong, I am pleasant and will always try to make conversation with others, even if they aren’t talking to me.

There is one person in particular who I would say is very extroverted. She’s always chatting away to everyone and never shuts up, she’s always laughing and giggling and making jokes with everyone. She’s the type of person who everybody knows because she’s very much “out there” and is very popular.

I know that second paragraph makes me sound very jealous of her, but honestly I’m not. Despite how I’ve described her, we do get on very well and have never had any conflict but she is a bit full of her own self importance at times, it’s so cringey when she’s sitting making jokes and thinks she’s a comedian.

I just find it so uncomfortable. I’m just a quiet person, I always have been, that’s just me and that’s how I am which I’m not ashamed of. It’s not that I’m rude and never speak to anyone, because I do. I just find it more difficult to come out of my shell.

I always seek to contribute to group conversations, I don’t want to be some kind of oddball who just sits there and doesn’t contribute to any conversations, but she’s constantly talking and it’s actually very difficult to get a word in edgeways sometimes.

I don’t begrudge her for being extroverted, that’s fine, that’s just the way she is, just like I’m introverted and that’s also fine but I just find it so uncomfortable because I never have much to talk about and I look incredibly boring and they’re probably thinking I don’t have much of a life outside of work!

Can anyone relate to me and agree that this feels like hell at times? If you have any tips, please do share!

OP posts:
MindPalace · 12/09/2023 07:46

Your colleague sounds rude, unfunny and annoying if she’s not giving others a chance to contribute. There will be many extroverts who are polite and let others speak.

On balance I am probably slightly extroverted in that I enjoy speaking to people (although I also like hiding away and having quiet time by myself) but I would like to think I am polite and let others talk too.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 12/09/2023 07:39

Some posts in this thread make me wonder whether the words introvert and extrovert are starting to be used in the way that so many other words are these days - to forge an identity on which to hang a whole load of feelings about not being properly valued or 'seen' and/or to forge a way of pigeon-holing other people in order to make them at fault in relation to the negative effects they have on you. In other words: to insist on respect for oneself while simultaneously disrespecting other people.

They are pretty insubstantial words in reality. They weren't coined to capture the whole of a person but just to get clear about how people vary along a single dimension, deliberately isolated from many other features of personality for the sake of the conceptual clarity needed in research.
It sounds like the annoying person spoken of in the OP probably is extroverted. But that wouldn't remotely be enough to explain her behavour. You'd need to bring many other personality concepts into play as well.

Curiosity101 · 12/09/2023 07:10

I also think you're projecting your insecurities. She may well be annoying but you have no evidence she's an extrovert.

I suspect you attribute being quiet, shy and socially anxious with being an introvert (given how many times you've repeatedly said that the opposite of that is an extrovert). And that actually you would rather be louder (not loud/rude), confident and socially adept (wouldn't we all!).

Your colleague does sound like they might be annoying, and if that is the case then get some noise cancelling ear phones and crack on.

But I suspect she'll still take up headspace... Because there are qualities about her that you wish you had even if maybe she over does it a bit. I think if you follow up on counselling or even coaching you might find a huge benefit to yourself.

And just to reiterate again what others have said. You're using introvert and extrovert wrong. I'm an introvert, hate socialising and talking to people. Would actively avoid them and am drained at the end of a day around people. But a big part of my job is networking and maintaining relationships, so at work I talk (and listen) a lot. Doesn't make me an extrovert, cause I go home exhausted by it all in a way that I never am when I've worked alone all day. But outwardly you would see a fun, sociable, confident person at work.

Candlelight34 · 12/09/2023 06:57

I like extroverts. They help me take my mind off things by chatting about different topics which makes me relax.

Fairyliz · 12/09/2023 06:53

You actually sound like you are jealous of her that ‘everyone likes her’ and she is popular.
You are annoyed that you can’t get a word in edgeways; surely an introvert would be glad to have the pressure to perform taken off them?

Shortpoet · 12/09/2023 06:52

What’s it like in the office on the days she’s on annual leave? How do you find interacting with your other colleagues on those days?

msmonstera · 12/09/2023 06:43

My workplace has an energy vampire who sounds like this. Big high pitched loud voice. Doesn't shut up, ever. Constant attention seeking behaviour and manufacturing of drama. Dressed like a luminous Christmas tree. Bouncing in her seat and whooping. The noise pollution is exhausting. On days she's not there, there is pleasant chat between everyone else. On the days she's in we all go into ourselves and just put up with the noise. I wear ear plugs to take the edge off. I'm quite introverted myself but this person is also an insensitive, rude, crude moron and I wouldn't be in the room with her if we weren't forced, introvert or not.

LovingMyLiver · 12/09/2023 06:22

I would loathe your colleague and probably really like you

Mangofandangoo · 12/09/2023 06:11

Perhaps she's nervous OP

maddening · 12/09/2023 05:56

Is she always engaging you or is.it simply that she is there with all these character traits that you don't like?

Mble · 12/09/2023 05:48

I have no idea about the introvert/extrovert thing but it just sounds like you find her annoying.

MiddleParking · 12/09/2023 05:25

People are focusing on you not getting the meaning of introvert and extrovert, but it seems you’re also misusing the words like and dislike pretty heavily. Would you say all the things you’ve said about her here to her face? If you did, do you think she’d come away from the conversation concluding that you liked her? No. You don’t like her and you’re pretty unpleasant about her. That’s fine, most of us have annoying colleagues, but she’s not responsible for your character defects or how other people respond or don’t respond to you.

hylian · 12/09/2023 05:05

· I never have much to talk about and I look incredibly boring
· she’s so loud and outgoing whereas I’m more quiet natured and more subdued
· I feel like I’ll be judged if I don’t respond to her jokes
· I just want to get up and run away.
· I’m very shy so yes I do worry about what people think of me!
· I probably do need some counselling to overcome my confidence issues and my social anxiety
· I just feel like people find me boring
· I find it uncomfortable because I struggle in social situations whereas she clearly thrives on them.

OP - These are some phrases you've used in your posts.

This is about you, not her - you're projecting your insecurities onto her (that's not a judgement - it's really common and understandable - but that's what is happening).

You do need to work on your social anxiety and confidence issues. You say it's 'unfair' that she doesn't let you get a word in - but it's not this colleague's fault that she is outgoing and talks a lot - some people are just like that.

You will need to learn some coping mechanisms for that if you want to get on in your life because people like this are everywhere. The best way to do this is to look inside and recognise your own issues that are holding you back, and talk to a counsellor.

mrlistersgelfbride · 11/09/2023 21:35

I think you are getting a hard time too, OP. I know exactly how you feel! I'm introverted. I think I'm interesting and funny when you get to know me but I'm not the sort of person who goes on and on about their kids, how much money their husband makes or some crap that was on TV last night. I used to work with people like this. I tried to comment to join in but they always talked over me. It got really boring! I felt people liked her but it was only because she didn't shut up 😆 she was actually a friend to me, and a nice woman but I felt more relaxed at work after she had left.

I'm starting a new job soon and wary of meeting new people as I don't want this kind of situation to happen again!
Sorry this isn't helpful advice, but solidarity. Don't let it worry you. You don't have to be loud or chatty to be liked and valued. Be yourself. People who are worth knowing will get to know you for you away from this annoying chatter.
For what it's worth, I gravitate towards the quiet people and would prefer someone like you as a friend rather than the non stop chatting woman. I'm sure other people in your office feel the same way too.

XenoBitch · 11/09/2023 21:16

When I'm all peopled out, I shut off or go home. I am most definitely an introvert, but you'd never see that part as I'd have left to recharge elsewhere

Yep, you can't tell if someone is an introvert or extrovert based on how they act around you. I honestly don't think it matters anyway, as how you recharge is a personal thing. I get fed up with the posts on MN misunderstanding it all TBH... and sometimes the posts pitting them against eachother.

FloozingThePlot · 11/09/2023 21:16

I think you're getting a hard time here OP. I completely understand what you're trying to say whether you have used the labels of 'introvert' and 'extrovert' correctly or not... Your colleague, by the sounds of it, is taking up all the 'space' and not leaving any for others who, like you, who might be quieter and more reflective. Good team members aren't just those who do all the talking; they're the ones who are mindful of the strengths and needs of others.

CheesyBeanos · 11/09/2023 21:08

beeonmybonnett · 11/09/2023 18:01

She has to be extroverted, because she’s always with people and talking to people - even when we walk to the canteen, she spends about half an hour talking to people from other departments - people I don’t even know so she obviously does get her energy from being around people whereas I just want to and sit down in a quiet corner by myself!

I don’t mind her being extroverted, I just find it when I feel like everyone’s eyes are on her and I can’t get to say what I want to say

This describes me at work. Most of my colleagues can't understand how I know so many people across the organisation and seemingly everyone wants to say hello or chat. I have been described as giving energy to a room and being good at lifting others up.

I often find quiet and shy people draining and hard work, but make great effort to hide these feelings. Although it's not unusual to find some of these people aren't shy at all. They just can't be bothered interacting with the particular people around them.

When I'm all peopled out, I shut off or go home. I am most definitely an introvert, but you'd never see that part as I'd have left to recharge elsewhere.

XenoBitch · 11/09/2023 20:08

You seem far too focused on attributing your colleagues annoying traits to the fact that she is an extrovert, and you not liking them based on yourself being an introvert.

I can be the life and soul of a gathering... I can yammer on, and I tell bad jokes. I am also an introvert. I need time to recharge after I see people. Other introverts drain me too. I know extroverts who don't speak a peep, but they feel recharged after spending time with people.

Let go of the whole introvert/extrovert thing, as you don't seem to have a grasp on what it actually means anyway. It seems you like some quiet, and your colleague is just a chatterbox.

MistyTrains2 · 11/09/2023 19:13

Introvert here. I've just learned to own my introvertism. I work with people from differnet cultures some of whom are very 'loud'. My specialism is knowing quite niche topics 😂 in depth.

I find people who talk in monologues very draining. As introverts we tend to attract them as we appear to be a listening ear.

AllOfThemWitches · 11/09/2023 19:12

I have no idea what I am...

PonyPatter44 · 11/09/2023 19:11

I'm an extrovert in the sense that I gain energy from being around other people, and I am quite outgoing. However, your colleague sounds like a raging pain in the arse, and I would be very surprised if your other colleagues didn't think so too! They're smiling and nodding for the same reason you are - noone wants to be the office misery and tell her to shut up, and nobody realises that actually everyone else feels the same!

beeonmybonnett · 11/09/2023 19:09

Justaredherring · 11/09/2023 19:03

id find her annoying to be around, OP. If she’s a nice person people will like her for that, but I’d find it exhausting to be around her

That’s it. It’s just an anxiety thing. It’s because she’s so loud and outgoing and I’m not that everyone just thinks I’m an oddball. I’m a very nice and approachable person, I’m just not confident or loud!

OP posts:
beeonmybonnett · 11/09/2023 19:07

Rainbowsandrainclouds1 · 11/09/2023 19:01

@beeonmybonnett

This

"She has to be extroverted, because she’s always with people and talking to people - even when we walk to the canteen, she spends about half an hour talking to people from other departments - people I don’t even know so she obviously does get her energy from being around people whereas I just want to and sit down in a quiet corner by myself!"

Is not necessarily true at all, as the PP was trying to explain.

Introverted is not synonymous with quiet and shy and extrovert it not synonymous with loud and confident.

She doesn't have to be an exteovert at all.

I'm Introverted, I recharge away from people, but, I'm loud, confident, assertive and popular at work and love being around other people.

You sound like you just dont like this woman and are blaming it on your being shy and quiet.

Right, sounds like you’ve already decided for me that I don’t like her.

I do like her, there are some things about her that annoy me, which I’ve already stated and explained.

Im introverted, she’s extroverted. Fine. Yes, we don’t have the same personalities and I find it uncomfortable because I struggle in social situations whereas she clearly thrives on them.

I never said I don’t love being around others, I do like interacting with others but it depends on the situation tbh. I’m more comfortable with some people than others tbh. That’s just me.

But it’s not fair that I can’t get to speak a lot of the time

OP posts:
Justaredherring · 11/09/2023 19:03

id find her annoying to be around, OP. If she’s a nice person people will like her for that, but I’d find it exhausting to be around her

Rainbowsandrainclouds1 · 11/09/2023 19:01

@beeonmybonnett

This

"She has to be extroverted, because she’s always with people and talking to people - even when we walk to the canteen, she spends about half an hour talking to people from other departments - people I don’t even know so she obviously does get her energy from being around people whereas I just want to and sit down in a quiet corner by myself!"

Is not necessarily true at all, as the PP was trying to explain.

Introverted is not synonymous with quiet and shy and extrovert it not synonymous with loud and confident.

She doesn't have to be an exteovert at all.

I'm Introverted, I recharge away from people, but, I'm loud, confident, assertive and popular at work and love being around other people.

You sound like you just dont like this woman and are blaming it on your being shy and quiet.