Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pay 50/50 in joint account bills

37 replies

Daisiesandstuff17 · 11/09/2023 16:27

So neither me or DH earn huge amounts but I earn several £ more per hour, I also work on average 10 hours more per week than he does and I have a small side business that earns me a little extra each month (£50-£100 maybe).

I also have a large amount of savings from inheritance (I never use these savings), and the house we live in was bought in full by me (inheritance and my pre marital savings) so we have no rent/mortgage.

I have a car and I pay all of its upkeep and bills from my personal account. DH doesn’t drive. I use the car for work mostly but we use it for holidays and days out regularly.

When we do jobs in the house, I always pay more, usually quite a bit more but sometimes we go 50:50 on small jobs. For example we had new doors and windows, I paid about 75% of the bill.

All our household bills and food come from the joint account. We each pay in the same amount each month (about £300)

DH has suggested this is unfair given he earns so much less than me and doesn’t have significant savings. I feel it is his choice to only work 20-25 hours per week.

I understand I am financially better off but I feel I have given us the benefit of not having a mortgage or high rent. I don’t live a lavish lifestyle and I save each month. I am happy paying for more of the household tasks like a new kitchen or flooring as I get it doesn’t always need to be 50:50. But I feel I take on enough extra than it is fair we both share equally in our monthly bills.

aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 11/09/2023 21:08

You are being taken for a mug!

Iwasafool · 11/09/2023 21:05

Ponoka7 · 11/09/2023 17:23

I've never seen that when there's been no children. Normally the man expects to not get involved in childcare or housework but wants half the bills paid.
This set up is fair because of the hours he works, I he's chosen his income and thus his disposable income.

We've obviously seen different threads.

SkankingWombat · 11/09/2023 18:16

I think in marriage both should have an equal amount left over after bills for their own spending, but in your case he has essentially taken some of his share as 'free time' rather than 'fun money'. This is how I would be explaining it to him. That doesn't make his a wrong choice necessarily, as we all have differing ideas on work/life balance, but does have the consequence of less spending money in his share.
The discrepancy in your hourly wage is (more than) made up by you paying a greater share of the one-off bills plus all car costs (I know he doesn't drive it, but he benefits from its use on days out & holidays).

billy1966 · 11/09/2023 18:16

Daisiesandstuff17 · 11/09/2023 17:51

he originally went to part time a few years ago as he was depressed. He never really sought any treatment and I wouldn’t describe him as depressed now, I think he’s just got used to part time work. Being frank I’m not sure he was ever depressed; he is just a bleeping misery.

He does do things around the house but I wouldn’t say the majority at all.

his main point is that even if he did full time hours he wouldn’t earn as much as me… Okay but he would have a lot more! He is always complaining he doesn’t have enough money so just work more surely…

I am very aware that whilst I don’t believe he married me for my money, I have made a huge mistake in that respect. I was advised that my savings, as long as never co mingled should stay as mine if we separated. That and a short marriage at present offers me some protection in terms of my home. You live and you learn… 🙈

Kindly meant OP, but stop faffing about and get legal advice and get rid of him.

A lazy, workshy, entitled, misery?

Stop wasting YOUR time.

PaminaMozart · 11/09/2023 18:14

In your shoes I would seek legal advice as a matter of urgency. You want to be sure that he would have no claim on the house or the inheritance if you were to divorce.

pointythings · 11/09/2023 18:08

If he wants more money, he should work full time. Then if he still earns less than you, you put in proportionally according to your respective earnings.

It would be different if you had DC and he were doing most of the caring and housework, but that's not your situation.

Michim · 11/09/2023 18:07

OP you should be paying fully for upkeep / renovations to the house and the car. He doesn't even drive and you will get any growth on the house. I don't think that should earn you any "bonus points"

That being said - he chose to work part time, I would suggest saying you adjust for him having a lower salary (because I would think you would expect the same from him if it was reversed) but not for the hours. Like - of you earn £10 an hour and he earns £9 - then you pay 10/19 = 52% and he pays the remainder

Mr85 · 11/09/2023 18:07

I think the fact he is choosing to work less is an issue.

For part of our relationship my wife left a good paying job to do a less stressful but minimum wage job. During that time I covered a greater proportion of the outgoings as it was worth the money to see her happy.

Now she earns slightly more than me we split things 50:50. She saves the difference so that we hopefully end up with similar pensions/savings at retirement.

I guess it depends whether you think he could increase his hours without affecting your relationship and what he wants to do with the money.

SpamFrittersYouSay · 11/09/2023 18:03

Sadly, OP, your husband is representing a growing trend of people who value their work life balance ( ie working part time) but still want the benefits of a full time salary. Mental well-being is often quoted but, as in your case, it seems that laziness/cba is the driving force.

It's not an attractive trait and it would put me off.
He's benefiting from your largesse.
He needs to shape up or ship out.

This is your decision to make.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 11/09/2023 18:01

Oh gosh OP, if he wants more money in his pocket then he needs to work more. Do not have children with this man unless he grows up considerably.

ScarlettSunset · 11/09/2023 17:56

If you think your marriage was a mistake, get legal advice asap and get out as soon as you can. A shorter marriage is likely to have far less impact on your finances than a longer one, especially as you don't have children.
I made a mistake like this too, but because my marriage was short, the financial side eventually just got resolved by just putting us back as we would have been had we never married (even though we did have a child).

Daisiesandstuff17 · 11/09/2023 17:51

he originally went to part time a few years ago as he was depressed. He never really sought any treatment and I wouldn’t describe him as depressed now, I think he’s just got used to part time work. Being frank I’m not sure he was ever depressed; he is just a bleeping misery.

He does do things around the house but I wouldn’t say the majority at all.

his main point is that even if he did full time hours he wouldn’t earn as much as me… Okay but he would have a lot more! He is always complaining he doesn’t have enough money so just work more surely…

I am very aware that whilst I don’t believe he married me for my money, I have made a huge mistake in that respect. I was advised that my savings, as long as never co mingled should stay as mine if we separated. That and a short marriage at present offers me some protection in terms of my home. You live and you learn… 🙈

OP posts:
SpamFrittersYouSay · 11/09/2023 17:38

This could be expensive for you were you to end it with him.
I'd be looking for some legal advice.

If you don't intend to split then you need to have a serious conversation.

trevthecat · 11/09/2023 17:36

Why does he only work part time?
Is the house ring fenced?

AgnesX · 11/09/2023 17:32

I was going to say it should be in proportion to your income eg 60/40 but then I saw that he only works part time?

Unless there's a particularly good reason that he can't work full time, you're paying more as it is.

PizzaPastaWine · 11/09/2023 17:32

Please don't have children with this guy OP. It has disaster written all over it.

TeachesOfPeaches · 11/09/2023 17:29

I'll marry you OP

billy1966 · 11/09/2023 17:28

I would be very wary of him and his part time job.

Stick to 50/50 particularly if you decide to have children.

You will need it.

He sounds work shy.

Does he do his share in the house considering he has a part time job?

CarpetSlipper · 11/09/2023 17:25

From what you have said YANBU. You have already bought the house so he has no mortgage/rent (is this in his name aswell?), so this is the equivalent of you paying the whole mortgage/rent on top of 50% of all other costs.
However, can he afford his half? What are his reasons for not working more? Are there health reasons or does he just not want to? Does he do more around the house? Was it a joint decision for him to work less or did he decide on his own? Does he have a particularly stressful job?

If you’re a partnership, you should support each other and pool resources. I wouldn’t want to be barely surviving while my partner had shitloads in savings and it’s not always easy to get better paying work but it sounds like you’re contributing far more than 50% and he’s not working full time so he’s in the wrong to complain.

44PumpLane · 11/09/2023 17:23

OP if he's choosing to work part time this is the consequence, he has less money.

If there is a drop feed that he's got a very good reason for the part time working then maybe I'd have a different opinion. But with the info given it seems he's living very cheaply because of your money!

Is he lovely in all other respects? Because if you have niggling thoughts about him I'd suggest getting out sooner rather than later.

Inheritance that's not been added to the family pot will be most likely ringfenced in a divorce, and if you've not been married for ages the argument for giving him a share of the house won't be there as it's an asset you came in to the marriage with.

Ponoka7 · 11/09/2023 17:23

Iwasafool · 11/09/2023 17:16

I've seen so many theads like this where it is the husband earning more and the answer always seems to be "it's family money" "all goes in joint account".

I've been married 40 years and we don't do joint account, he probably pays more for bills and stuff than I do as he has a higher income. If I want something done in the house e.g. new bathroom, I might pay as I want it. Currently having some work done and I'm paying about two thirds, I'm quite pleased he offered to pay some as he didn't actually want it done.

I don't think there is one right way but what I do think is if you work fulltime, and more, and he works 20 hrs then he should be doing the bulk of housework/cooking etc.

I've never seen that when there's been no children. Normally the man expects to not get involved in childcare or housework but wants half the bills paid.
This set up is fair because of the hours he works, I he's chosen his income and thus his disposable income.

44PumpLane · 11/09/2023 17:20

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz OP states no children.

Iwasafool · 11/09/2023 17:16

I've seen so many theads like this where it is the husband earning more and the answer always seems to be "it's family money" "all goes in joint account".

I've been married 40 years and we don't do joint account, he probably pays more for bills and stuff than I do as he has a higher income. If I want something done in the house e.g. new bathroom, I might pay as I want it. Currently having some work done and I'm paying about two thirds, I'm quite pleased he offered to pay some as he didn't actually want it done.

I don't think there is one right way but what I do think is if you work fulltime, and more, and he works 20 hrs then he should be doing the bulk of housework/cooking etc.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 11/09/2023 17:15

Does he work fewer hours to do childcare?

PinkRoses1245 · 11/09/2023 17:14

He needs to work more hours then. And you need to make sure your assets are protected in case of divorce

Swipe left for the next trending thread