Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I just as bad?

114 replies

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:35

Guys I need your help. STBXH and me are splitting up - we want different things. I totally accept this from our perspective, but we have a teenage son and this will devastate him.

STBXH is keen to move out asap and get on with his new life (he has dates lined up apparently). I can't really criticise although wish he could have gone about it better and waited until we had at least divorced, but I don't want to make a fuss as I don't want to do any patching up.

The thing I do take issue with, however, is that he is not willing to wait a couple of years until DS is of adult age. I'm being pretty critical about this and so are some of the people I'm confiding in too. I am claiming he is abandoning his child. However really he isn't he's just leaving me.

Withouth speaking to me he has gone ahead and assumed that we would sell the house and both stay local. From there he would obviously be able to see DS. But, due to my circumstances (I don't have family here and I don't really like the town where we are), I am planning on leaving the area and moving a couple of hours' drive away.

So, am I being a bit of a hipocrite? I am not instigating the divorce or separation as it seems his need to be free is greater than mine although I can't really hold that against him. This means he is responsible for breaking up our family whist DS is still at home.

However, I feel like my decision is the biggest thing that will really separate us, to the point where DS will hardly ever see his dad. I can't really take the moral high ground and claim that H is the one breaking up the family, can I?

I could stay around and live a lesser quality life for the couple of years left and be financially worse off and keep DS and H within visiting distance. But, I will not be happy.

Please help me sort out this moral dilemma as don't want to be seen as reeking revenge on H and making him feel bad for putting himself first now when under different circumstances I am prepared to put my feelings first when it suits me.

Let me know please.

YABU - and are as bad as H
YANBU - your reasons are not on the same scale of selfish - or something like that

OP posts:
Disloyal · 11/09/2023 16:48

Your tone is really odd.

i think you need to process the split and then think about future options.

My kids would have hated to lose their ‘history’ and start sixth form somewhere completely new. Does your son have mo roots or friends at all?

Vinrouge4 · 11/09/2023 16:42

I think if your son is happy to move after his exams then go for it. He will be 16 and will be old enough to get a train by himself to visit his dad. Your stbx is already mapping out his life without you and you deserve some happiness too.

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:40

i think i'm a bit fucked up mentally tbh - this has only just happened and I'm getting really mixed up and focusing on all the wrong things. i don't know what i'm doing.

OP posts:
GingerIsBest · 11/09/2023 16:34

Why are you so fixated on blame? You're blaming your H for splitting up your family and you really really want to be able to do that. And so you're concerned that if you're also to blame, then you can't blame him for leaving?

Stop thinking about blame. start thinking about what is definitely going to happen and what might happen. On the might happen list, consider what is best for you and your DS.

So, moving to be closer to his extended maternal family, a new (better?) school and an area he will like more (if that's truly how he'll feel) does not necessarily mean a destroyed relationship with his dad, especially at this age. An additional factor to consider is whether or not his dad will be that interested or involved even if you stay close - it is implied that in fact, that would NOT be the case in which case moving away is arguably a better choice.

In many cases, as lots of PP have pointed out, moving away WOULD be a bad idea and would limit the child's relationships with dad, other family, friends etc. But the way you describe it, that seems less likely.

itsmyp4rty · 11/09/2023 16:33

You say splitting up will devastate your son - but moving him 2 hours away from his dad to somewhere where he knows no one and has to start a new school will be fine by him?

Nottodaty · 11/09/2023 16:28

Have you properly had a conversation with your son. I think it’s such an important age even post GCSE’s he will be quite isolated.

My friends moved away when their son was 16 post GCSE. Thinking he’d make friends with new people at college. He lasted just under a year,dropped out of college, moved back to his older sister house (living in her shed basically) and just re-started a year behind but at the same college as his friends. He was very unhappy :( He has seen his parents twice since June. They only live 2 hours away.

financialcareerstuff · 11/09/2023 16:27

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:53

Yeah, but as you say he is leaving me and not our son. I am not sure I can claim he's abandoning his DS and that that will ruin him and then take him far away on my account. If my priority was truely with DS then I'd stay local in order to keep them within distance. Moving away is for me.

Why would you want to claim he's abandoning DS?

You seem to have a strong need to be the victim/ for your husband to be the bad guy... yet you don't seem bothered that he's leaving- and don't want to patch it up.... sounds like it was a pretty mutually bad relationship?

How would it feel for you to reframe - accept it mutually hasn't worked, and that the two of you now will work together to give your son Consistency and make sure his relationship to both his parents is maintained?

3luckystars · 11/09/2023 16:26

You think your husband leaving is disruptive, well moving hours away at age 15 will be even more disruptive! I know you are upset but I don’t think you are thinking straight.

Do you think children are happier when their parents are married? If so then that’s only when the parents were HAPPY and not the way you describe it. It sounds awful.

if you think your husband should be able to wait a few years then so should you.

I don’t think you should move, no. I think you should stay in the house you are in until your son is 18.

cruffinsmuffin · 11/09/2023 16:22

I think when your DS is older, if this move doesn't go as swimmingly as you're imagining it (it'll be hard potentially to break into established friendship groups in college, and he'll never have the history they have with older friends) he might resent you for it.

If my mum had moved me away for college, several hours away from my friends + where I grew up, I'd probably be quite miffed - especially if I was able to make new friends / continue on with life as normal.

It would potentially be an easy blame situation too if he doesn't see much of his dad or end up with a good relationship with him - it's easy to focus on you being the one to move him away and potentially isolating him from the life he has now, especially if him or his father are bad at LDR.

If it's 2+ hours each way it's not an easy day trip to spend time together, you're creating a situation where it will always have to be planned visits / cost a fair bit of money in transport and it removed that opportunity for them to have an easier relationship, if you're local there's the chance to just grab tea together or go do something together on the spur of the moment, even pop round for a chat about things. All of a sudden that's not a possibility due to a decision you would be making now. So yes putting a several hour journey between your son and his dad could be seen to be to blame for their lack of relationship. I know I feel that way about my mum sometimes when she made a similar decision with my dad!

PerfectMatch · 11/09/2023 16:21

The reason that posters are fixating on the school is that they're thinking of it from your DS's point of view which is the really important thing here. If he's really happy to move schools and leave his friends and not see his dad as often, then that's fine and I don't think you should worry too much about your STBXH's opinion on whether or not you're doing the right thing. But are you sure DS won't mind?

ButterflyOil · 11/09/2023 16:21

Your son is almost 16, it’s only a couple of hours, surely they can keep in touch electronically and have regular visits?! It’s not like he’s a toddler. And as for socialising - well you can both do that, your son will be in sixth form before you know it.

Im honestly not sure what you want from this thread - it’s not about blame and who is worse surely, it’s about attempting to co-parent and support your son as life changes post divorce.

LivingNextDoorToNorma · 11/09/2023 16:19

The issue is with H and if by moving him I'm as culpible as H is for severing the relationship between them and DS having an absent father.

Surely that goes without saying? The main thing preventing your son from having a physically close relationship with his dad will be the distance between them. Now obviously people have very successful relationships despite large distances between them, but being 2 hours apart will limit how active his dad can be in his life.

My parents divorced when I was young, and by 16 I didn’t often sleep over at my dad’s anymore. But I would quite often pop round for tea after college, or he’d meet me on my lunch break from my weekend job. That wouldn’t have been possible with a 4 hour round trip.

CalistoNoSolo · 11/09/2023 16:12

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:55

I would never do this. Please see previous response. I am planning it so he can finish up here and then start a new life with new friends in a new town nearer other family.

So you wouldn't dream of making him move 2hrs away at 15, but at 16 it will be fine and make no difference to him? You're delusional. If you really wanted to do the right thing for your child you would stay put until he goes to university.

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:07

sandyhappypeople · 11/09/2023 16:04

I think you need to consider what your DS future plans are, you say moving away would make you happy, but at 16 you DS could choose to live with his dad to stay near his friends, would YOU then be happy still? And happy travelling 2 hours to visit him?

He may be perfectly happy to move with you, but it’s not a guarantee and you should be focusing on his happiness as much as your own.

I think you should stay in the area, transition through through the separation then decide in a few years

No I wouldn't be happy and I wouldn't leave him.

OP posts:
Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:05

OK this isn't quite going the way I was hoping as there is too much fixation on the school. The issue is not really about DS's school. He doesn't go to a great school and he doesn't like it and we would only go after GCSEs are finished anyway. He'd love going to a new college in a new town with new people in a smaller community. We live in the M25 corridor where there are gangs and stuff and I'm pretty sure he'd love to get away from it. The break between GCSE and A-level would be a great opportunity and he'd also get to know kids where his mum ends up living. It's a sensible plan.

Obvioulsy, however, the status quo is status quo and he won't miss what doesn't change if we stayed around.

The issue is with H and if by moving him I'm as culpible as H is for severing the relationship between them and DS having an absent father.

That's it. Not the school, or the place. Just the dad.

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 11/09/2023 16:04

I think you need to consider what your DS future plans are, you say moving away would make you happy, but at 16 you DS could choose to live with his dad to stay near his friends, would YOU then be happy still? And happy travelling 2 hours to visit him?

He may be perfectly happy to move with you, but it’s not a guarantee and you should be focusing on his happiness as much as your own.

I think you should stay in the area, transition through through the separation then decide in a few years

PerfectMatch · 11/09/2023 16:02

I think the most important thing here is try and move away from words like "abandoning his child" and "responsible for breaking up the family". It's less about blame here, and more about accepting that this is the situation and communicating with DS and STBXH to find a way forward that works for all of you.

PerfectMatch · 11/09/2023 16:00

Sorry x post OP

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:59

PerfectMatch · 11/09/2023 15:57

In my opinion:

YABU and unrealistic to think that your STBXH should wait till DS is 18 before dating anyone.

YANBU to want to move away but you need to tread carefully here. When? Ideally not now as DS is presumably in his GCSE year, and not mid A levels either (although you have a window of opportunity next summer). Will DS mind? I imagine he'll be pretty upset?

I will leave after his GCSEs next summer so he can start a new sixth form

OP posts:
AuroraForever · 11/09/2023 15:59

You've both decided to split up but he’s wanting to go sooner than you’d like, he’s not really breaking your family up he just wants to get gone sooner rather than later.

In fairness it’s usually worse to stay together until any DC reach 18. He may already have an inkling as to what’s going on. Have either of you spoken to him about it yet?

What’s the plan regarding your son’s schooling if you’re moving a few hours drive away?

GentrifiedLDN · 11/09/2023 15:59

I do not think you are being a hypocrite in many ways you are being hard on yourself

However, moving so far away when he is in his GCSE years, new school new friends - you could put your kid in a position where he ends up choosing to live with his dad

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:59

For a bit more context - there's no way H will want any custody as his new life involves lots of socialising and doing the exact opposite of any parenting. In fact, he doesn't seem bothered at all about the kids and just wants to go. However, he'd love to be a part time parent and drop in when it suits him. There's also no way DS would choose him over me although I'd give him the choice and if he really wanted to stay with his current school then I'd have to accommodate.

OP posts:
PerfectMatch · 11/09/2023 15:57

In my opinion:

YABU and unrealistic to think that your STBXH should wait till DS is 18 before dating anyone.

YANBU to want to move away but you need to tread carefully here. When? Ideally not now as DS is presumably in his GCSE year, and not mid A levels either (although you have a window of opportunity next summer). Will DS mind? I imagine he'll be pretty upset?

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:56

Oh no, I left out an important part and now the entire focus is on me ripping him out of school when that's not what I'm going to do at all. I will move him when he's 16 and left school.

OP posts:
blueluce85 · 11/09/2023 15:56

Again, that's a good idea in principle, but he may want to go to sixth form with his friends, and unfortunately, you wouldn't be able to prevent him from remaining with his dad at that age.

That's a risk I personally wouldn't want to take with my child. I like that I live 20mins from my ex, despite the fact that if I moved away I could buy something instead of being stuck renting!