Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I just as bad?

114 replies

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:35

Guys I need your help. STBXH and me are splitting up - we want different things. I totally accept this from our perspective, but we have a teenage son and this will devastate him.

STBXH is keen to move out asap and get on with his new life (he has dates lined up apparently). I can't really criticise although wish he could have gone about it better and waited until we had at least divorced, but I don't want to make a fuss as I don't want to do any patching up.

The thing I do take issue with, however, is that he is not willing to wait a couple of years until DS is of adult age. I'm being pretty critical about this and so are some of the people I'm confiding in too. I am claiming he is abandoning his child. However really he isn't he's just leaving me.

Withouth speaking to me he has gone ahead and assumed that we would sell the house and both stay local. From there he would obviously be able to see DS. But, due to my circumstances (I don't have family here and I don't really like the town where we are), I am planning on leaving the area and moving a couple of hours' drive away.

So, am I being a bit of a hipocrite? I am not instigating the divorce or separation as it seems his need to be free is greater than mine although I can't really hold that against him. This means he is responsible for breaking up our family whist DS is still at home.

However, I feel like my decision is the biggest thing that will really separate us, to the point where DS will hardly ever see his dad. I can't really take the moral high ground and claim that H is the one breaking up the family, can I?

I could stay around and live a lesser quality life for the couple of years left and be financially worse off and keep DS and H within visiting distance. But, I will not be happy.

Please help me sort out this moral dilemma as don't want to be seen as reeking revenge on H and making him feel bad for putting himself first now when under different circumstances I am prepared to put my feelings first when it suits me.

Let me know please.

YABU - and are as bad as H
YANBU - your reasons are not on the same scale of selfish - or something like that

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 11/09/2023 17:38

You sound punch drunk OP. That is totally understandable given the circumstances, but it's probably not the best time to make any life changing decisions. Hang on for the minute, until you can wrap your head around everything.

ManateeFair · 11/09/2023 17:37

I don't think your ex is doing anything wrong by wanting to separate if he is unhappy and I don't think it's reasonable to ask anyone to stay in a relationship that makes them miserable for another two or three years because their teenager isn't an adult yet. I wouldn't expect that of a woman and I wouldn't expect that of a man either.

Equally, I don't think it's unreasonable that you'd like to move to a different town a couple of hours away, if you hate where you currently live and moving would put you closer to your own family. Your ex shouldn't be 'expecting' you to remain local - he could, if he was worried about not seeing enough of DS, ultimately move to the same town as you to be near him.

Presumably, though, a move to somewhere 2 hours away will also mean uprooting DS from school and his friends, which is quite a big deal for a 15-year-old at any time, let alone when he's already dealing with his parents' divorce. Will he have completed his GCSEs by the time you move?

I think that in terms of the impact on your DS, you're probably about equal. But I also think that trying to assess who is the most at fault and who is going to cause the most damage is futile.

BygoneDays · 11/09/2023 17:35

It’s his fault. You deserve so much better.

Moveoverdarlin · 11/09/2023 17:34

Personally I’d wait. Wait till he’s uni age and then move. Wait till he can drive himself between the two homes.

Cupcakekiller · 11/09/2023 17:33

It doesn't matter what's best for you, it's about what's best for your son. You need to reframe your entire thinking.

GoryBory · 11/09/2023 17:33

Who broke up with who?

I can’t help thinking that there is some tit for tat going on.

He’s already saying that’s he going to go and shag a load of women that are lining up for him and now you want to move away.

I think YABU to want him to wait years before he can move on with his life.

If you’ve separated then what’s the point in dragging it out.

But YANBU to move on with your life and if that means moving to your support system then that’s fine but it would be your responsibility to be the one who takes your son back to this area to see his dad if needed, although he’s old enough to get a train anyway.

I would just take it one day at a time though.
There’s no need to tell your DS or exDH about moving in a years time as you may get a job opportunity elsewhere or start a new relationship etc.

Bluevelvetsofa · 11/09/2023 17:31

I think you should focus on your son and how you can support him during his important GCSE year, before you make any definitive decisions.

It was your ex’s decision to separate and yours to consider moving away, so there is an element of hypocrisy. Presumably, you can stay where you are for at least this academic year, so your son can finish year 11. Things may be clearer after that.

ColloidalSliver · 11/09/2023 17:31

Nanny0gg · 11/09/2023 17:21

Surely your DS has just started his GCSE years?

Why move schools and him away from his friends?

I sat my O levels when I was still 15 (31st August birthday)...

ColloidalSliver · 11/09/2023 17:29

If my priority was truely with DS then I'd stay local in order to keep them within distance. Moving away is for me

Well, that's your answer. If your priority is DS, then you won't move.

Divorce is shit. The best way you can get through this (and I sympathise, as mine is still rumbling on 8 years after the event) is to stop blaming and start working out a way to help your son to navigate his new reality with as little other upheaval as possible. Your STBX needs to work with you on this. If he is such a dick that he won't do it, I'm afraid you're going to have to do the donkey work because someone has to be advocating for your son. He will thank you for it in the longer term.

UsingChangeofName · 11/09/2023 17:26

I haven't voted, as the vote / question doesn't really make sense to me.

UsingChangeofName · 11/09/2023 17:26

I agree with most.
If you are splitting up, then it is right to do it now.
You've both agreed, so get on with the practicalities.

But I also agree with everyone else in terms of you seemingly dismissing your ds in all of this, and what his feeling are.
Yes, if he were 6, I would expect him to have to suck it up and move away from all his friends, but at 16 that is a very different story. Like most, I think you'd have to be prepared for him to choose to stay with his Dad, if you move after his GCSEs.

Nam3chang384 · 11/09/2023 17:25

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:53

Please don't be mean. I have had no sleep for days and no one to talk to so I am relying on MN to help me sort through issues. I just need some guidance as to what decisions need to be made and when. I don't want to look back in a few years and see that I got things wrong, like moving DS away when it's only for my benefit and not his.

I agree with the PP that you need to reframe your thinking on this, however, I can see you feel conflicted. You blame your STBXH for ending the status quo whilst your DS is still at school but you are worried that you will ultimately feel / look like the 'bad guy' if you move away (as a consequence of STBXH ending the marriage) and that feels unfair to you.

I think you need to really try to not think about things in terms of who is 'at fault'. Can you discuss your feelings with your STBXH about wanting to move away for a better lifestyle? Would he consider letting you stay in the house until your DS is 18? I don't know anything about your broader situation but that is often settled upon in divorce hearings - might you be entitled to that as part of a settlement? I would suggest speaking to a solicitor to get a feel for what might be deemed reasonable.

IVFfirsttimer91 · 11/09/2023 17:25

Having read this post and as you have said - completely disregarding any school stuff, I think yes, you would be just as culpable if not more so than exH for severing the relationship if you move away - KNOWING that if you did so, he wouldn’t have a relationship with his dad. Stick around for a couple of years, then move.

Nanny0gg · 11/09/2023 17:24

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:50

thank you - this is so messed up. H is moving on coz he wants to get on with his life. Fair enough. But I surely deserve to as well I don't know why I think I have to carry all the responsibility and put my needs on hold and be the sole carer of our son. I keep forgetting that H needs to do his bit. It's like, oh okay then go and shag other people whilst I am at home keeping the status quo going for everyone's benefit by my own.

If I stay then H will need to do his share of childcare responsbility - and arrangement needs to be made. If he forces me to sell family home which he wants to do asap, then I don't have any choice but to move after DS exams as won't be able to afford to live here, unless H pays maintenance. H wants to sell the house asap so he can get the equity. When I think about it this is soooooo complicated - if we are to part it everything is fair.
1.

You need to get legal advice before you're railroaded into anything.

Just because he wants the equity doesn't mean he'll get it right this minute

Nanny0gg · 11/09/2023 17:21

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 15:47

DS is 15. Oh I am aware and think that he may have been a philanderer and a bit of a perve all the time we've been together. But I don't want to go there as would probs be too horrific. He hasn't the back bone and is far too lazy to take action against me. He'll be too distracted anyway with his 'new life'.

Surely your DS has just started his GCSE years?

Why move schools and him away from his friends?

CaroleSinger · 11/09/2023 17:18

He isn't abandoning his son. Why the fixation on that? You're just splitting up and your son will still have 2 parents. Moving hours away is of course going to be a challenge with contact. But I think you know that already and moving that distance isn't just for a better life. I think you also want to put distance between you and your ex, that's understandable but don't use your son for leverage here it isn't fair. Stop telling your friends he is abandoning his son.

CrackedChina · 11/09/2023 17:13

I think after telling the children about the split, I would ask them if they want to stay local and finish their schooling there or if they like the idea of moving to your home place. I would respect their decision and if they wanted to stay and postpone moving away until the youngest was in college. Your ex's views wouldn't concern me. Your children and yourself are a family unit now and need to make a decision together on where you live. They may well like the idea of a new start elsewhere. Or not.

TeachesOfPeaches · 11/09/2023 17:10

I wouldn't tell your husband about moving away as he could apply for a prohibited steps order to stop you.

StressBless · 11/09/2023 17:10

I don’t think apportioning culpability is helpful to anyone, there are 2 separate issues:

  1. You and your DH separating
  2. Where you live after you separate

I think you also need to accept your DS will have an opinion on where he wants to live and you can’t necessary assume it’ll be with you. He’s almost an adult, you need to include him in the discussions so he’s not just presented with a decision on his future with no say on it.

Hufflepods · 11/09/2023 17:04

It’s selfish to threaten him with ‘barely seeing his son’ if he separates with you because you will move several hours away. It’s not only selfish but blackmail.

RedHelenB · 11/09/2023 17:01

CalistoNoSolo · 11/09/2023 15:53

I think moving your 15yo 2hrs from his friends and school during the first year of gcse's is beyond shitty. You say its not OK for his father to move out, but what you're proposing has the potential to really fuck him over.

This. You need to stay local at least until the end of gcses.

PerfectMatch · 11/09/2023 16:54

OP it's early days for you - it's not surprising that your head is all over the place. Before you finalise anything with your ex, maybe you should go to counselling for yourself to talk all this through with someone.

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:53

Disloyal · 11/09/2023 16:48

Your tone is really odd.

i think you need to process the split and then think about future options.

My kids would have hated to lose their ‘history’ and start sixth form somewhere completely new. Does your son have mo roots or friends at all?

Please don't be mean. I have had no sleep for days and no one to talk to so I am relying on MN to help me sort through issues. I just need some guidance as to what decisions need to be made and when. I don't want to look back in a few years and see that I got things wrong, like moving DS away when it's only for my benefit and not his.

OP posts:
BrokenBonesStixStones · 11/09/2023 16:51

In this whole process DS must be puts first and above both you & your STBXH’s wants. As parents we someday have to sacrifice

that said I do understand how hard it must be for you in this situation, (I would feel the exact same as you in this situation) you have my sympathies and best wishes for the future

Optomystic · 11/09/2023 16:50

Vinrouge4 · 11/09/2023 16:42

I think if your son is happy to move after his exams then go for it. He will be 16 and will be old enough to get a train by himself to visit his dad. Your stbx is already mapping out his life without you and you deserve some happiness too.

thank you - this is so messed up. H is moving on coz he wants to get on with his life. Fair enough. But I surely deserve to as well I don't know why I think I have to carry all the responsibility and put my needs on hold and be the sole carer of our son. I keep forgetting that H needs to do his bit. It's like, oh okay then go and shag other people whilst I am at home keeping the status quo going for everyone's benefit by my own.

If I stay then H will need to do his share of childcare responsbility - and arrangement needs to be made. If he forces me to sell family home which he wants to do asap, then I don't have any choice but to move after DS exams as won't be able to afford to live here, unless H pays maintenance. H wants to sell the house asap so he can get the equity. When I think about it this is soooooo complicated - if we are to part it everything is fair.
1.

OP posts: