Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently you can no longer call the GP to book a GP appointment.

342 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 11/09/2023 15:26

You now HAVE to book online, and it HAS to be through the website and NOT the app.

I found that out the hard way today when I tried to book an appointment for my son, the app said none available so I rang up and waited half an hour on the phone to get through to reception, who told me I had to book it online.

You make a request and they’ll get back you within 48 hours.

AIBU to think that’s bloody ridiculous?!

OP posts:
Lifeomars · 11/09/2023 17:40

And the expense, my Wifi is realtively cheap as £22 a month, but for some people that will be a big expense and then if the practice is not using the phone app any more you will need to have a lap top so that is more expense. There is a bit of me that is now totally sick of everysingle bloody thing being either on an app or online only and I say that as someone who is very computer literate. I was almost reduced to tears by the Uber app recently when changing my debit card details as it is set up for US zip codes and of course when I entered my post code I kept putting a space between the two sets of characters. So of course I had to Google a video of how to do it and problem solved. However many people do not have the equipment or the skills to negotiate the idiosyncracies of certain systems and I think many will just give up as a consequence. It is going to similar to shutting ticket offices at stations in a sense, we have to consider the needs of vulnerable and excluded groups.

JustKen · 11/09/2023 17:37

On the phone message when you ring up you are told to book an appointment on the NHS App. But on the app it says, "Not appointments can be booked at this time". I have tried waiting in the queue to talk to The Gatekeeper (Receptionist) and she'll answer the phone then cut you off. So I walk down there from my flat (10 minutes) and they refuse to make an appointment because they don't want to see patients in the surgery unless a GP says it's ok. (A hangover from the pandemic)

I'm looking for a new GP.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 11/09/2023 17:36

My mum is 84 and does use the NHS app but finds the e-consult awkward to use and prefers the phone. There will be lots of 84 year olds who can't cope with technology, not because they don't know how to use it but because they don't have the manual dexterity anymore, can't see well enough, or don't have the cognitive ability anymore.

And not everyone has friends or family nearby to help.

If we paid for GP appointments all this might be better, although given levels of customer service in other areas maybe not.

juniper111 · 11/09/2023 17:34

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 11/09/2023 17:12

@juniper111 no I don't think the receptionist made the rule.

Would have thought it would made more sense if she could send a message to the GP saying YP has something that needs looking at and GP could have authorised a face to face appointment, which would have saved us both some time and freed up a telephone appointment for someone who could be dealt with by phone.

If I'd done an e-consult form online, the GP would have read it in their non-appointment time and I'd probably have been asked to make a face to face appointment. I'm not allowed to use the e-consult form as I've got a long term chronic illness, so if I answer the questions honestly it tells me I need to ring the surgery and speak to someone, even though the skin growth is nothing to do with my chronic illness which is currently well managed.

Can you imagine sending a message for the over 200 patients who ring everyday. "Doctor KP needs an appt" x 200. It wouldn't work. It needs to go into a slot and then the doctor can triage and put in the appropriate a lot. A lot of people think the doctors are just there for themselves. Not the 4000+ patients.

Spiderysummer · 11/09/2023 17:32

I liked e- consult which my surgery used to use but now you have to phone up and they put you on a waiting list for a phone call from the GP. From what I have heard, this can take 2-4 weeks and you have no control of timings.
Our surgery sends say they no longer can treat emergencies on the day appointments and so people are sent to urgent care centres miles away for things like bad ear infections. I have been advised to go to A&E on a number of occasions when it simply isn't suitable. I worry about my family needing quick, simple medical care.

MarilynSays · 11/09/2023 17:30

Oh my goodness the world has gone mad. I'm dreading this happening to our surgery x

Stroopwaffels · 11/09/2023 17:29

MANY people who are 75+ now would have been in their late 50s/early 60s (or older) when computers first started being used more, and would have been already retired, or in a job where they never used computers.

This is my mum. She was a primary teacher, took early retirement aged about 50 around 1995 when computers in primary schools were on a trolley and wheeled from class to class. After retiring from full time teaching she did supply as a teacher in school nurseries or with the very youngest classes and never ever had to use the computer in her work. Dad was more interested in computing and the internet, had an email address, used Facebook, online banking, booked holidays online. But he now has dementia, is in a home, and would not manage even to switch the laptop on.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/09/2023 17:29

enchantedsquirrelwood · 11/09/2023 17:24

Yes I agree - I wonder how either GPs or councils meet their obligations under the Equality Act or the public sector equality duty.

And by definition, GPs will be dealing with a lot of disabled people, as well as elderly.

This thought struck me when I was reading through the thread. The Equality Act 2010 mandates reasonable adjustment for those who need it and by not providing an alternative method of booking GPs could well find themselves in breach of it.

juniper111 · 11/09/2023 17:29

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 11/09/2023 16:57

@Viktorella What about those people without the internet? (Many people over 75 don't have it.) Or is this the idea, to exclude and brush off older people who you feel take up too much time? Hmm

As stated in her post she says the digitally impaired can call the surgery and get through easier because the lines aren't jammed and they will fill the form in for them. Or did you choose to ignore that?

MargaretThursday · 11/09/2023 17:27

Otoh I've just walked into our surgery with a non-urgent request for dd. They're phoning me in the next half an hour, and it will be sorted out over the phone, and I can collect the made up prescription in 48 hours from our local surgery.

In the old system I'd be given an appointment (same day normally) and arrive on time, probably have a 20-60 minute wait, then have to take the prescription to the pharmacy and wait while it is made up.

Sometimes the system works better the new way.

Lifeomars · 11/09/2023 17:27

This is fine if you have a computer and can afford to have wifi, so ok for people like me but I like to also think how this impacts people who either can't afford it or do not have the skills to use it. I live in a poor inner city area and I think if the Health Centres here bring this in it will exclude a lot of people.

I remember how many children from less well-off families struggled to access online teaching during lockdown, There were stories of kids taking it in turn to do their work on a parent's phone as that was the only way they could get online. If phone app can no longer be used there are a lot of people who will not be able to access the system. It has not yet been brought in where I live and I hope that there is some thought and consideration given to those who will not have the skills and/or the equipment to do this

moose62 · 11/09/2023 17:26

I filled in the online form trying to return a call that i had from the GP saying she wanted to speak to me ASAP....
Four days later she rang me back asking what I had called for!

Rosscameasdoody · 11/09/2023 17:26

juniper111 · 11/09/2023 17:19

Never heard of needing a letter to set up the NHS app. Who would you send the letter to? What do you do with it?

Both myself and my partner needed to complete a registration with the GP before we could use the online service. We then had to wait for a letter from the surgery which confirmed completion of registration and gave instructions for registering online along with a personal access code.

Winnading · 11/09/2023 17:25

Daffidale · 11/09/2023 15:39

The basic principle is sound - triaging patients according to need, and letting them submit info online rather than sitting on the phone - but the way many GPs are doing this is bonkers. Ours have just switched to “you have to use the online system”. Requested an appointment 3 weeks ago, filled in their infernal form, got a text saying I needed a routine appointment and they’d be in touch. Since then crickets.

at least ours asks for times you aren’t available so you can tell them no to call you during client meetings.

I quite like the basic premise, my 83 yr old neighbour not so keen.
However I've tried to put times when I cant answer the phone and been quite harshly told, the dr will call whenever and if you miss that call, you then have to rebook online again.

Plus the triage bit isnt working. I had an injury a while ago, no sign of it healing at all, so I filled out the econsult for some help with which aid I would be better off with, the practice manager text with go here or here to buy what you need.
Fantastic, but I did not know what I needed. Because I'm not a bloody dr or nurse.
Anyway my new Google medical degree suggested an item. I bought item, still not better, in more pain than ever, have to see dr for decent painkillers. He tells me in that consult that I actually needed x aid not y aid.

Well I fucking asked for help. You chose to fob me off.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 11/09/2023 17:24

nebulae · 11/09/2023 15:54

It doesn't actually impact me as it's not my surgery, but I feel it's exclusionary on the behalf of our population who cannot use the Internet due to no skill, no access or no ability (vulnerable adults). We must always look out for the most vulnerable in our society, one day it will be us and we will be told well it's how it is now

Agree 100%. And it's not just GP appointments. Car parks are increasingly moving to payment via an app, which many people can't do. Some public toilets near me can now only be accessed if you have a contactless debit card (and can afford the 50p charge). It's always the most vulnerable who suffer.

Yes I agree - I wonder how either GPs or councils meet their obligations under the Equality Act or the public sector equality duty.

And by definition, GPs will be dealing with a lot of disabled people, as well as elderly.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/09/2023 17:24

fearfuloffluff · 11/09/2023 16:05

Quite a lot of people are functionally illiterate. You can't just say fuck em, no healthcare for you

And others have gone more or less deaf and blind during that time. Not sure how an 86 year old with WMD and bilateral hearing loss is supposed to manage to book her own appointments when she can't even see or hear a phone.

teaandtoast44 · 11/09/2023 17:22

It's scandalous. How many elderly people must just not bother anymore because they're not computer literate? My grandparent would have no clue. My mother would struggle. It's totally irresponsible and unfair. Offer an online option by all means but consider those who can't or choose not to use a smart phone or the internet ffs.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/09/2023 17:22

TheBarbieEffect · 11/09/2023 16:02

Computers have been around decades. If they don’t know how to use one then they had their chance to learn and chose not to.

Now there are consequences to that decision.

And according to you those consequences should be that they have no access to healthcare ? Just because computers have been around for decades doesn’t mean everyone can use them, and certainly doesn’t mean that we should be forcing people who have trouble with them, for whatever reason, into yet another one size fits all system which will inevitably end in tragedy for someone.

Whichwhatnow · 11/09/2023 17:22

AngeloMysterioso · 11/09/2023 17:08

Well I rang the surgery again, spent another half hour in the queue… and by the time I got through all the remaining appointments were gone and because it was ONE MINUTE PAST FOUR the utterly useless e-consult was closed. An hour and a bit of my life completely wasted.

My surgery does allow calls but only between 8 and 9, and the lengths of the call queues mean you're often cut off promptly at 9 without managing to speak to anyone.

But it's ok apparently, because you can do an eConsult... but only between the hours of 8 and 9!!!. WTF. What if you're regularly at work during that one hour or something?

So frustrating.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 11/09/2023 17:22

@countrygirl99 I couldn't agree more.
There seems to a persistent ignoring of the fact that people lose their abilities as they develop cognitive issues. My dm has, in the last 3 years gone from doing everything on her macbook to just about being able to look at her bank account on a dementia friendly phone. Still manages to live in supported accommodation but can't navigate the digital world.

Topseyt123 · 11/09/2023 17:21

I think this is the sort of thing that could work well for some people but not at all for others.

I could use it myself, I've made online appointments a few times. I'm not aware that our surgery is using this system yet, although I should think they will eventually.

I do think that they will have to operate both systems in tandem for a long time yet. Plenty of people could have problems with online or computer based systems.

My 88 year old mother would be in this category. She does have broadband, but no smartphone or computer, only her Alexa which she uses for audio books or to listen to the radio. Even if she had the inclination to learn to use a computer (she doesn't), she would now never be able to see the screen properly because of severe macular degeneration. I can't do it for her before anyone tries to suggest that as I live a three hour drive away and she would never want to phone me to divulge her issues. The idea would horrify her.

There are many people who would struggle to use a computer for many different reasons. Some may never have learned, some may have disabilities and/or learning difficulties that make it problematic etc. etc. etc. Some on this thread seem to be hinting that they should thus be unable to access GP appointments, which would be really discriminatory.

Ridiculous.

dutysuite · 11/09/2023 17:21

Ours has been like this since the pandemic. We have to book online and describe our symptoms and then sometimes the receptionist will come back and request more information - this backwards and forwards can take two days and then we receive a text to say an appointment has been made, usually a one -two week wait but there’s never a time stipulated we’re expected to be available whenever they call which is an absolute pain. Sometime they close the online booking system for days at a time and they refuse to take calls. The problem I have with this system is there’s absolutely zero confidentiality - when I suffered from anxiety and mild depression the last thing I wanted to do was write about it and then not know who was actually reading it.

Oblomov23 · 11/09/2023 17:19

Ours is a website. Or phone. No app.

juniper111 · 11/09/2023 17:19

Nannyfannybanny · 11/09/2023 16:21

My surgery told me last year to do this. I got up surgery website,did the email user name password. Got email confirming user name. Then when I tried to make an appointment,it comes up "hum there seems to be a problem,you aren't actually registered at this practice, would you like to choose another practice from the list. I've been registered with them 12 years. I finally went into the surgery,put up the surgery website on my phone,showed the receptionist what it said, she had a very quick look, said,"that's not us" although the name of the surgery is blatantly shown at the top,and pushed the phone over the counter to me, turning her back. I left the surgery, tried many times. It suggested I login to NHS site. Tried that,it said I require a letter from the GP confirming I am registered with them. Last week someone rang from the surgery said it had been a year since my last script,so I have to make appointment, almost 3 months wait for a PHONE APPOINTMENT! told her I have the box script was 8/12/22 NOT a year ago. Finally rang spoke to someone else,who said she didn't know why I had even be told this.

Never heard of needing a letter to set up the NHS app. Who would you send the letter to? What do you do with it?

BatshitCrazyWoman · 11/09/2023 17:18

1upmushroom · 11/09/2023 16:35

It's terrible OP. I've filled in two e - consults, and twice missed the telephone call because I'm working or driving. I've had to go into the surgery and speak to the practice manager to insist on a face to face appointment (which of course I now have, and they could have saved all this fuss by booking me in as requested in the first place!)

At the very least, people should be given a reasonable telephone appointment time, i.e between 2 and 2.30 etc so they can arrange to be available. 'Anytime from 12 - 6pm' is crap tbh and I'm not putting up with it anymore. In future it's one e-consult and then off to the practice manager I go. If everyone did this the system would have to change.

I have similar issues. I'm at work, and my phone is locked away apart from lunchtime, except on the day I WFH. So ringing me 'at any time between 12 and 6 pm, within 2 to 4 days' is fuck all use to me.

I've just used private GPs, luckily I can afford it.