Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently you can no longer call the GP to book a GP appointment.

342 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 11/09/2023 15:26

You now HAVE to book online, and it HAS to be through the website and NOT the app.

I found that out the hard way today when I tried to book an appointment for my son, the app said none available so I rang up and waited half an hour on the phone to get through to reception, who told me I had to book it online.

You make a request and they’ll get back you within 48 hours.

AIBU to think that’s bloody ridiculous?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gwendimarco · 17/09/2023 15:32

That is disgusting in my opinion. My great auntie is 95 with macular degeneration and almost blind. She still lives independently with help popping twice a week, but no way in the world would she be able to use this system.

It is indirect discrimination and they should know better. I am disgusted and if I were in your shoes I would be contacting the local paper to encourage them to do a piece on it. I might even go so far as to seek out some elderly / infirm / impoverished people for interview about how they have been cut off from vital services.

ItcanbeDone · 17/09/2023 15:26

I think for the massive underfunding by a certain govt they do the very best they can. My daughter has DS and my husband has MS, and both need a lot of appointments atm, and we can use the app or ring up or we could just go straight to the surgery. I cannot fault them.

Parker231 · 17/09/2023 12:51

Xenia · 17/09/2023 12:46

18m more people in the UK than when I was born and 1.2 immigration a year now (600k net immigration) is having an effect although Labour and Tories seem to have no problem with that.

Luckily I have only had 2 GP appointments in about 20 years. I call them my £100k a time 7 minute appointments! I would rather be allowed to opt out and keep my cash.

The NHS is significantly staffed by those not from the UK. The Uk also has a labour shortage so immigration is good and necessary.

Xenia · 17/09/2023 12:46

18m more people in the UK than when I was born and 1.2 immigration a year now (600k net immigration) is having an effect although Labour and Tories seem to have no problem with that.

Luckily I have only had 2 GP appointments in about 20 years. I call them my £100k a time 7 minute appointments! I would rather be allowed to opt out and keep my cash.

Parker231 · 17/09/2023 12:31

Herecomesthemoon · 16/09/2023 14:57

Last time I used e-consult it told me I need to see someone urgently instead of using it though I knew it was a non urgent issue so I gave up and made a routine appointment.
Now, if you ask for an appointment reasonably soon, you will get a phone consultation with a pharmacist or, if it is for joint pain, a physio. There are no face-to-face or GP appointments.
I had a phone call, blood tests, prescription, then another phone call and prescription in early July. I have just now seen a GP and been referred to hospital. There is a shorter wait for hospital outpatient clinics and procedures than to see a GP, which is ridiculous.
Since covid asthma reviews are by phone with a pharmacist. They are not allowed to check peak flow or inhaler technique.
I used to always stick up for the NHS but I think the complete unavailability of GPs is scary.

Why do you think there isn’t sufficient GP appointments?
Its very basic - more people want appointments than there are available.

MimiGC · 16/09/2023 19:28

And the elderly without smartphones or computers are supposed to do what? Or those with learning disabilities? Poor literacy skills? Poor English? Not everyone can do things online.

Herecomesthemoon · 16/09/2023 14:57

Last time I used e-consult it told me I need to see someone urgently instead of using it though I knew it was a non urgent issue so I gave up and made a routine appointment.
Now, if you ask for an appointment reasonably soon, you will get a phone consultation with a pharmacist or, if it is for joint pain, a physio. There are no face-to-face or GP appointments.
I had a phone call, blood tests, prescription, then another phone call and prescription in early July. I have just now seen a GP and been referred to hospital. There is a shorter wait for hospital outpatient clinics and procedures than to see a GP, which is ridiculous.
Since covid asthma reviews are by phone with a pharmacist. They are not allowed to check peak flow or inhaler technique.
I used to always stick up for the NHS but I think the complete unavailability of GPs is scary.

JenniferBooth · 16/09/2023 14:23

I used Anime back in May Im still waiting for a reply

Solonge · 16/09/2023 08:21

I read this thread when it was posted. Yesterday my practice texted to say from now on all appointments are to be booked via Anime sounds like a Japanese cartoon site. It states there will now be same day appointments, I think thats highly inlikely as the present wait time is 4 weeks. Someone will be missing out, I suspect the elderly, poor and non techie.

justasking111 · 15/09/2023 12:31

After six days of it I think the poison was gone, I had no pain the last four days. She did say phone this morning if I'm worried. I was having awful gas even in my sleep 🤭 but that's stopped now. I've actually been out to the co-op for some broth. Managed to shower, dress, make the bed and hoover the bedroom as well as nip to the local shop. I'm on the mend.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 15/09/2023 07:30

pigsDOfly · 14/09/2023 14:58

Really bad advice given from the reception to take Imodium under your circumstances. Under no circumstances should they be handing out ill informed medical advice.

When you're feeling better might be an idea to speak to the practice manager and tell him/her that this person is overstepping their remit.

I agree with a PP, that's appalling advice. If you have food poisoning, your body needs to get rid of the 'poison', not bunging it up with immodium! Definitely complain.

Winnading · 14/09/2023 20:50

TigerRag · 14/09/2023 15:11

"E consult asks "what outcome do you want?""

And it doesn't let you submit the form without filling this in. I often end up writing that I have no idea because I don't know and don't want to make it sound like I've googled my symptoms.

I usually put along the lines of, dr Google suggests, or
With my new doctorate via Google I think I should have...

But then I can be a sarcastic cow.

sthisbest · 14/09/2023 15:40

TigerRag · 14/09/2023 15:11

"E consult asks "what outcome do you want?""

And it doesn't let you submit the form without filling this in. I often end up writing that I have no idea because I don't know and don't want to make it sound like I've googled my symptoms.

The NHS website is actually very good on symptoms so it is worth having a look beforehand. I think the question makes the satisfaction levels for the service go up, as it is directly asking what you want the doctor to do and then it is up to them to refuse this or go along it, knowing this is the outcome you would like. Best play the game I think. They can't fob you off so easily if you have researched in advance.
You could just put that you would like 'appropriate diagnosis' and throw the ball back in their court lol.

TigerRag · 14/09/2023 15:11

"E consult asks "what outcome do you want?""

And it doesn't let you submit the form without filling this in. I often end up writing that I have no idea because I don't know and don't want to make it sound like I've googled my symptoms.

AlwaysUnreasonablyFabulous · 14/09/2023 15:08

justasking111 · 14/09/2023 14:23

Had a lovely chat with receptionist this morning for advice. Six days into D&v I'm feeling somewhat weak. Did have a reasonable day on Tuesday but it returned on Wednesday. There's a lot of bugs going around she said so advised I see a pharmacy for immodium. I'm too wobbly to drive so OH has picked some up from the supermarket. Receptionist said if they don't work then ring at 8am tomorrow to try and get an appointment.

Went for a birthday lunch on Friday, had whitebait which was cold, undercooked so it might be food poisoning.

We don't have e consult unfortunately.

Wish me luck.

This is part of the problem, untrained receptionists dishing out medical advice, completely unacceptable

sthisbest · 14/09/2023 15:06

justasking111 · 14/09/2023 14:23

Had a lovely chat with receptionist this morning for advice. Six days into D&v I'm feeling somewhat weak. Did have a reasonable day on Tuesday but it returned on Wednesday. There's a lot of bugs going around she said so advised I see a pharmacy for immodium. I'm too wobbly to drive so OH has picked some up from the supermarket. Receptionist said if they don't work then ring at 8am tomorrow to try and get an appointment.

Went for a birthday lunch on Friday, had whitebait which was cold, undercooked so it might be food poisoning.

We don't have e consult unfortunately.

Wish me luck.

Being a fan of E Consult, I am not very impressed by what has happened for you there. It may be an okay course of action but since you have already been trying to deal with it alone for several days, I would be miffed at being told to see the pharmacist on the day that I had finally decided I wanted the NHS to help me. Are you confident that the receptionist referred to someone medically qualified before giving you this fob off?
You would hope that had you done an E Consult, whoever had triaged it, would have thought you maybe needed more re food poisoning and feeling weak...I don't know a blood test maybe given that it has been a week already?
I think we have already reached the point where the reality tv series 'GPs behind closed doors' no longer corresponds to reality in any shape or form.
The pandemic caused GPs to lock down and they have never recovered to normal 'face to face' service levels. The practice I go to already had E-Consult and Advanced Nurse Practitioners pre-pandemic and was using it sensibly with fast response times.
So although the technology can help provide more targetted care, there is still a real risk of conditions going untreated for far too long. To some extent we are all being turned into the managers of our own care as E Consult asks 'what outcome do you want?'. If you have googled, you can make suggestions, could it be X?
I am not saying this is a good thing but it seems to be the reality post-covid. How long before everyone has a 'wearable' to check blood pressure, ECG etc which feeds back to an App at the GPs? Would this be a positive?

Hope you feel better soon and that the immodium works.

pigsDOfly · 14/09/2023 14:58

justasking111 · 14/09/2023 14:23

Had a lovely chat with receptionist this morning for advice. Six days into D&v I'm feeling somewhat weak. Did have a reasonable day on Tuesday but it returned on Wednesday. There's a lot of bugs going around she said so advised I see a pharmacy for immodium. I'm too wobbly to drive so OH has picked some up from the supermarket. Receptionist said if they don't work then ring at 8am tomorrow to try and get an appointment.

Went for a birthday lunch on Friday, had whitebait which was cold, undercooked so it might be food poisoning.

We don't have e consult unfortunately.

Wish me luck.

Really bad advice given from the reception to take Imodium under your circumstances. Under no circumstances should they be handing out ill informed medical advice.

When you're feeling better might be an idea to speak to the practice manager and tell him/her that this person is overstepping their remit.

justasking111 · 14/09/2023 14:23

Had a lovely chat with receptionist this morning for advice. Six days into D&v I'm feeling somewhat weak. Did have a reasonable day on Tuesday but it returned on Wednesday. There's a lot of bugs going around she said so advised I see a pharmacy for immodium. I'm too wobbly to drive so OH has picked some up from the supermarket. Receptionist said if they don't work then ring at 8am tomorrow to try and get an appointment.

Went for a birthday lunch on Friday, had whitebait which was cold, undercooked so it might be food poisoning.

We don't have e consult unfortunately.

Wish me luck.

Quisquam · 14/09/2023 09:26

I can assure anyone that the reason is that make sure that the people who actually need to be seen are seen. This is not to stop elderly or people with other difficulties from seeking their GPs.

People who know how to game the system will still be seen, while some of those who don’t, won’t! All they need to know are the key phrases to get medical attention!

Agnes12 · 14/09/2023 06:31

In my case there was just an on screen message on the practice website saying they were at capacity and to try again the next day so not sure how this would be counted? I wonder whether the feedback you have received is a bit self selecting - it’s the people who have used it/can use it and like it. I don’t like the fact that once they are at capacity you can’t book any sort of appointment, at any time, in the future. You are left with an on screen message saying try again tomorrow. For someone who might be worried and stressed about their health i personally don’t think it’s terribly helpful to just see this on a screen with the feeling that they might never get an appointment- what if it’s “at capacity” the next day too?

amarante · 14/09/2023 05:04

Also, if patients turn up the practice should complete the form on their behalf. The idea is that all requests are enter on the platform.

Would also like to say that by using this platforms, we GP practices will have data to present to our NHS local teams and prove that demand for a GP service.
If there is nothing in place and you book the appointment like before - telephone or online- once all the appointments are gone there is nothing to show or prove the number of people who called or tried to get an appointment and did not get because they were all gone.
In this case we can show that indeed the number of GPs available is not sufficient so more pressure will be made on policy makers.

amarante · 14/09/2023 04:58

Underminer · 13/09/2023 22:47

@amarante So with this system, when my son calls for an appointment, what would you do? He has autism and can’t fill out forms himself, and because he has problems communicating, he would struggle with anyone saying he can’t have an appointment unless he fills out the form, and wouldn’t argue that he needs help. Can notes be put on records to flag where people like him need additional support?

Absolutely. All practice systems have a facility to add alerts. So when we search-for the patient details to check their age and whether they are in any group which may need more assistance an alert will pop count stating that such patient needs help with the form. Patients in groups which will need the form to be completed on their behalf will not be asked appt show questions as well. Reception ask what is the issue or reason for the appointment and will complete the form as such.
I can assure anyone that the reason is that make sure that the people who actually need to be seen are seen. This is not to stop elderly or people with other difficulties from seeking their GPs.
People would be shocked to find out how many people come to see the GP without needing one or even twice a week. But because they either queue of are on the phone system by 7.59am they get an appointment.

Underminer · 13/09/2023 22:47

@amarante So with this system, when my son calls for an appointment, what would you do? He has autism and can’t fill out forms himself, and because he has problems communicating, he would struggle with anyone saying he can’t have an appointment unless he fills out the form, and wouldn’t argue that he needs help. Can notes be put on records to flag where people like him need additional support?

amarante · 13/09/2023 21:42

I am a practice manager and we recently implemented this. The feedback from patients has been great. It stops people who would be queuing outside from 7.30 am every week to book an appointment for trivial things or use the GP as an agony auntie can to be given to patients who really need them.
The idea is to signpost and book patients with other clinical staff which previously would insist on a GP appointment and the receptionist would need to oblige. Also
There are not enough GPs for all hence making sure that we use their time wisely and to prioritise each clinical case.
Our patients who do not have computers or are not IT savvy can ring and the receptionist will complete the form on their behalf though so that there is no discrimination and once we explain the rationale people do accept the service.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/09/2023 21:36

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 13/09/2023 20:40

Yep exactly! As I and many others have said, some people cannot use the internet, and some people cannot get access to it. As another poster said, are 'poorer' people mean to ask a more affluent neighbour if they can use their internet? They would be so embarrassed and ashamed! Sad

I love the way people are just expected to spend money. Using my uncle as an example he'd have to buy a smart phone or tablet and pay for broadband or data. Why should anyone have to do that just to get a doctors appointment? He wouldn't need it for anything else.

In DM's case she wouldn't have been physically able to do it but she could use a telephone. Yes I could have done it for her but why should anyone have to tell a family member their medical information?